Advice on potentially heavy handed cops....
Discussion
I am getting info on this second hand, but taking it on face value for now.
We live in a village - an urban village really part of a bigger city. For years, and I have lived here since I was a kid, youngsters have used the local school playground out of hours for things like football, roller skating and basketball.
All fairly innocent stuff. The school yard is unlocked, ungated and open.
Its a good location as it is safe, no traffic and it keeps kids from playing ball in streets, roller skating along pavements, etc.
All nice and unofficial
By kids, I am not talking about chavs or teenagers prone to damage stuff, more nice ordinary kids aged 10-13 ish.
Yesterday evening, two police rock up, and tell the kids to bugger off out of there claiming it is trespass.
Like good kids, they do as they are told.
One mum called the school today. The school's position is the same as it ever was. the grounds are not officially open, no-one has permission but we are not going to stop anyone by calling the police etc.
They have to not give official permission I guess for insurance reasons.
I am not a Dad, just a local who as a kid used the yard like kids before me and since.
Trespass where there is no break in is not criminal. Am I right. The property owner has not complained to the police, so officers wading in I believe have no right to do this.
Is this correct?
I ask as some of the parents plan to take their kids back there and if the BiB turn up, send them on their way with a flea in their ears.
This is a community where there is very low crime, and most crime is "imported" as the place is a destination - a seaside village. We are not talking anti-police here, far from it.
Any advice appreciated.
We live in a village - an urban village really part of a bigger city. For years, and I have lived here since I was a kid, youngsters have used the local school playground out of hours for things like football, roller skating and basketball.
All fairly innocent stuff. The school yard is unlocked, ungated and open.
Its a good location as it is safe, no traffic and it keeps kids from playing ball in streets, roller skating along pavements, etc.
All nice and unofficial
By kids, I am not talking about chavs or teenagers prone to damage stuff, more nice ordinary kids aged 10-13 ish.
Yesterday evening, two police rock up, and tell the kids to bugger off out of there claiming it is trespass.
Like good kids, they do as they are told.
One mum called the school today. The school's position is the same as it ever was. the grounds are not officially open, no-one has permission but we are not going to stop anyone by calling the police etc.
They have to not give official permission I guess for insurance reasons.
I am not a Dad, just a local who as a kid used the yard like kids before me and since.
Trespass where there is no break in is not criminal. Am I right. The property owner has not complained to the police, so officers wading in I believe have no right to do this.
Is this correct?
I ask as some of the parents plan to take their kids back there and if the BiB turn up, send them on their way with a flea in their ears.
This is a community where there is very low crime, and most crime is "imported" as the place is a destination - a seaside village. We are not talking anti-police here, far from it.
Any advice appreciated.
Do you have a bobby who liaises with the community? Most villages do, and If so worth a chat.
Was very surprised a few years ago when ours popped round as he'd seen our address pop up a few times. We'd had a couple of cars mildly vandalised at home, and then broken into away from home...
Was very surprised a few years ago when ours popped round as he'd seen our address pop up a few times. We'd had a couple of cars mildly vandalised at home, and then broken into away from home...
Pound to a penny there's been a complaint from someone.
Although given the attitude that parents will send the Police away with a flea in their ear then its no surprise they have perhaps taken the harder line if that's the locals attitude towards the cops and hardly a good example to set to their children.
Although given the attitude that parents will send the Police away with a flea in their ear then its no surprise they have perhaps taken the harder line if that's the locals attitude towards the cops and hardly a good example to set to their children.
Mk3Spitfire said:
I can't wait to see the way this thread will go.
"Ordinary" trespass is not a criminal offence, and only becomes so where there are aggravating factors. Maybe there was more to it? Maybe the officers had complaints from neighbours re noise etc? Maybe they were just in a bad mood?
Indeed. It is not a crime to wander across someone's back garden, unless intent can be proved, or there is damage, and then that damage has to be intentional and not accidental. "Ordinary" trespass is not a criminal offence, and only becomes so where there are aggravating factors. Maybe there was more to it? Maybe the officers had complaints from neighbours re noise etc? Maybe they were just in a bad mood?
Problem for the school is that when my ball goes onto the roof, what do I do ? I climb up, I fall off, I sue them for making it easy for me to climb up.
Back in 1978 to about 1983, I would play football with my mates HERE : http://goo.gl/maps/xhrXL note the fence is a recent addition. I did climb onto the roof more than a few times.
The Police concerned know the actual law, but they also know that because they are in uniform they can treat teenagers in a patronising and obnoxious and unfair manner. And hey nice kids grow up hating anyone in a uniform. Great PR? Not.
New POD said:
but they also know that because they are in uniform they can treat teenagers in a patronising and obnoxious and unfair manner. And hey nice kids grow up hating anyone in a uniform. Great PR? Not.
PLEASE do not tar all officers with this brush. I thought from your previous posts that you were BIB? Or am I mistaken? Either way, I don't know many officers who are like that unnecessarily. Unfortunately, there are some yoofs who don't listen all that intently to the nicey nicey approach! New POD said:
Indeed. It is not a crime to wander across someone's back garden, unless intent can be proved, or there is damage, and then that damage has to be intentional and not accidental.
Intent is required for most criminal offences but as you mentioned criminal damage - intent is not always required (recklessness will suffice) 
On the subject of being found in someones back garden - it depends on the circs, see the offence of Found on Enclosed Premises (Vagrancy Act). Intent is required for that offence though.
Edited by Red 4 on Tuesday 28th January 20:59
[quote=New pod
The Police concerned know the actual law, but they also know that because they are in uniform they can treat teenagers in a patronising and obnoxious and unfair manner. And hey nice kids grow up hating anyone in a uniform. Great PR? Not.
[/quote]
and of course teenagers just do exactly as they are told and are polite and compliant all the time when spoken to by Police.
what an idiotic statement but i suppose in your line of work you've not had to deal with a breed of teenager pissed and ready to take on the world when they are in a safety in numbers scenario.
The Police concerned know the actual law, but they also know that because they are in uniform they can treat teenagers in a patronising and obnoxious and unfair manner. And hey nice kids grow up hating anyone in a uniform. Great PR? Not.
[/quote]
and of course teenagers just do exactly as they are told and are polite and compliant all the time when spoken to by Police.
what an idiotic statement but i suppose in your line of work you've not had to deal with a breed of teenager pissed and ready to take on the world when they are in a safety in numbers scenario.
I understand if the school is concerned. That is why they won't call the police. I played there in 1983, it is an old Victorian school and Imagine kids have been playing there after hours since the 19th century.
The attitude of parents is generally good towards the police. It is a nice place, people are very community centred.
The key here - and what I was trying to get definition on - trespass is a civil matter. No breaking and entering, no criminal damage, no section five swearing not drinking just kids playing sport in a school yard as they have done for over a century.
The land owner - it is a private school - gives tacit approval - ie you are not here with permission, but we are not going to call the cops.
If the police are responding to a complaint from a neighbour then I can't see what it would be. We are talking early evening - 4pm at this time of year. In the summer, we used to play there till about 9PM.
It ticks all the boxes, kids out having fun, not hanging round street corners in gangs, but involved in healthy sport.
My neighbour does want to send the cops away on their toes if they are involving themselves in something that they have no jurisdiction over.
My fear, is that these two sill police - probably not local to the area and used to the area and used to dealing with scummy chavs, have taken it upon themselves to get involved. If complaints are made, the school will withdraw its tacit approval because it will have to come down on one side or the other. The risk averse nature of the world these days would suggest they will come down on the side of caution for fear of being sued etc.
What the neighbours want to do, is to get the cops to jog on, and not create a formal fuss.
A case of it aint broke......
The attitude of parents is generally good towards the police. It is a nice place, people are very community centred.
The key here - and what I was trying to get definition on - trespass is a civil matter. No breaking and entering, no criminal damage, no section five swearing not drinking just kids playing sport in a school yard as they have done for over a century.
The land owner - it is a private school - gives tacit approval - ie you are not here with permission, but we are not going to call the cops.
If the police are responding to a complaint from a neighbour then I can't see what it would be. We are talking early evening - 4pm at this time of year. In the summer, we used to play there till about 9PM.
It ticks all the boxes, kids out having fun, not hanging round street corners in gangs, but involved in healthy sport.
My neighbour does want to send the cops away on their toes if they are involving themselves in something that they have no jurisdiction over.
My fear, is that these two sill police - probably not local to the area and used to the area and used to dealing with scummy chavs, have taken it upon themselves to get involved. If complaints are made, the school will withdraw its tacit approval because it will have to come down on one side or the other. The risk averse nature of the world these days would suggest they will come down on the side of caution for fear of being sued etc.
What the neighbours want to do, is to get the cops to jog on, and not create a formal fuss.
A case of it aint broke......
Mk3Spitfire said:
New POD said:
but they also know that because they are in uniform they can treat teenagers in a patronising and obnoxious and unfair manner. And hey nice kids grow up hating anyone in a uniform. Great PR? Not.
PLEASE do not tar all officers with this brush. I thought from your previous posts that you were BIB? Or am I mistaken? Either way, I don't know many officers who are like that unnecessarily. Unfortunately, there are some yoofs who don't listen all that intently to the nicey nicey approach!
t, not an gram of empathy, just a bullying obnoxious approach. Given what my kids say about the police in the same area, nothing much has changed. Unfortunately I think the poor hardworking BIB (and I do sympathise), are shell shocked by said "yoofs" who are t
ts, and somehow think that they can save time by missing out the nicey nicey approach. They most likely spend 80% of the time dealing with nasty people, and so it's understandable. All I wonder is, would they talk to their mother in the same way as they talk to an unknown 13 year old who is erm sitting on a bench SV8Predator said:
Mk3Spitfire said:
I thought from your previous posts that you were BIB? Or am I mistaken?
That's the problem, there are some on here that purport to being BIB, (not aimed at Mk3Spitfire by the way), 'of_the_trousers' is one, for example.wildcat45 said:
If the police are responding to a complaint from a neighbour then I can't see what it would be. We are talking early evening - 4pm at this time of year. In the summer, we used to play there till about 9PM.
Really? That's exactly what some old grumpy b
d would complain about. Do you know of any PH'ers living opposite the school? 
New POD said:
Mk3Spitfire said:
New POD said:
but they also know that because they are in uniform they can treat teenagers in a patronising and obnoxious and unfair manner. And hey nice kids grow up hating anyone in a uniform. Great PR? Not.
PLEASE do not tar all officers with this brush. I thought from your previous posts that you were BIB? Or am I mistaken? Either way, I don't know many officers who are like that unnecessarily. Unfortunately, there are some yoofs who don't listen all that intently to the nicey nicey approach!
t, not an gram of empathy, just a bullying obnoxious approach. Given what my kids say about the police in the same area, nothing much has changed. Unfortunately I think the poor hardworking BIB (and I do sympathise), are shell shocked by said "yoofs" who are t
ts, and somehow think that they can save time by missing out the nicey nicey approach. They most likely spend 80% of the time dealing with nasty people, and so it's understandable. All I wonder is, would they talk to their mother in the same way as they talk to an unknown 13 year old who is erm sitting on a bench Mk3Spitfire said:
Believe me. People complain. You wouldn't believe how many times I have been called to "kids playing football in the street" for example. I really wouldn't rule out some misery phoning to complain.
I could understand if it was football in the street. That would be annoying and potentially damaging to property.it is because it is a nice area where kids don't kick balls in the street that they play in the playground.
I am not a father, and generally I am unsympathetic towards kids and teenagers. I however hate injustice. There is no-where else safe for them to play where ball games are allowed. This is an indication of how nice the kids are, there is a big public grassed area in the village which is unused. Just grass and signs saying no ball games. It is a pice of land about as big as a stadium football pitch. The kids don't play there because the signs tell them not to.
Other kids in other places would probably nick the signs for scrap money and play ball terrorising any resident who challenged them.
I think what someone said above is true. Cops treating middle class kids like s
t because they are used to the scummers on sink estates. I can see the local press getting in on this one.
[quote=Mk3Spitfire]
Was being a teenager some time ago now? Attitudes do change. Unfortunately, there is an increasing trend for the younger generation to have no respect for authority
quote]
No s
t Sherlock 
I was told to "f
k off" by a 6 year old once - for no reason other than being a police officer driving past him.
His parent's response was "He's only 6" (no apologies, etc). Go figure...
Was being a teenager some time ago now? Attitudes do change. Unfortunately, there is an increasing trend for the younger generation to have no respect for authority
quote]
No s
t Sherlock 
I was told to "f
k off" by a 6 year old once - for no reason other than being a police officer driving past him.His parent's response was "He's only 6" (no apologies, etc). Go figure...
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


