Can someone please help me understand ?
Discussion
Hi, I've got a query. I watched one of these police type programs the other night where the bib were called to a suspected burglary. As they were driving there they spotted a guy walking down the road so they stopped to question him, turned out when he was searched he had a chisel & other items associated with the trade of breaking in about his person & some items that where later shown to be from the scene of the burglary. He told the police he had found said items just down the road & picked them up. Another policeman then found a bag in a dustbin nearby with more incriminating evidence but the narrator said the police would need evidence to prove this guy actually carried out the crime in order for the CPS to charge him.
I've seen similar to this on other programs where they catch someone with what looks like compelling evidence only to be told at the end or the program that no charges were brought due to lack of evidence.
My question is if they could not find this evidence & link him to the scene there is little they could probably do ( unless he admits it - unlikely ) & even if they did charge him he would likely get off so how come your car can be photographed speeding & as far as I'm aware you are obliged to provided the police with the name of the driver or you'll be charged anyway & more then likely end up with a fine & points even if you may not have been driving.
Why, as it is in the case of the burglar is the onus not on the police to prove who was driving rather than the owner of the vehicle be expected to incriminate himself or whomever was driving ?
Phil.
I've seen similar to this on other programs where they catch someone with what looks like compelling evidence only to be told at the end or the program that no charges were brought due to lack of evidence.
My question is if they could not find this evidence & link him to the scene there is little they could probably do ( unless he admits it - unlikely ) & even if they did charge him he would likely get off so how come your car can be photographed speeding & as far as I'm aware you are obliged to provided the police with the name of the driver or you'll be charged anyway & more then likely end up with a fine & points even if you may not have been driving.
Why, as it is in the case of the burglar is the onus not on the police to prove who was driving rather than the owner of the vehicle be expected to incriminate himself or whomever was driving ?
Phil.
Before I start - I speed regularly and am not a member of BRAKE etc.
Speeding is a way, way more common crime than burglary.
Many speeders and burglars would cheerfully tell any lie rather than own up.
The potential penalties for burglary are much more serious, and it is viewed much more seriously in general.
In practice, if one was allowed to say "you prove who was driving", speed cameras would be rendered pointless as very few people would get convicted.
The coppers can sometimes get DNA and/or fingerprints from burglaries.
Speeding is a way, way more common crime than burglary.
Many speeders and burglars would cheerfully tell any lie rather than own up.
The potential penalties for burglary are much more serious, and it is viewed much more seriously in general.
In practice, if one was allowed to say "you prove who was driving", speed cameras would be rendered pointless as very few people would get convicted.
The coppers can sometimes get DNA and/or fingerprints from burglaries.
Ah, I'm a firm believer that to be found guilty, it has to be beyond reasonably doubt.
The problem with driving offences is that if your name is on the V5 you have a responsibility to KNOW who is driving your car (unless your car was in the care of a garage at the time perhaps).
It is a criminal offence NOT to know. Or perhaps the offence is not to say.
The BURDEN of proof is that the police have to prove that a car was speeding. Not who was driving.
Now we all know cars could get cloned, but if that's your defence and it's a lie, then you'll go down for perverting the course of justice or something like that, once they've shown you getting in your car on CCTV in town and driving past the speed camera on the same road 2 mins later.
If your car was cloned, you'll have an alibi. Probably.
Note: I only know of one issue with cloning, and this was a poor bloke that had armed police get him out of bed, with regards to a number of armed robberies, and he and his car had firm alibis, sometimes in a main dealer, sometimes, in meetings at work, or with customers 200 miles from the robbery, or in a restaurant with a credit card receipt and CCTV records. As he told my mate, one of the police that drove him 200 miles to interview him in their station, if he was going to commit a serious crime, he's not likely do it in his own car would he?
The problem with driving offences is that if your name is on the V5 you have a responsibility to KNOW who is driving your car (unless your car was in the care of a garage at the time perhaps).
It is a criminal offence NOT to know. Or perhaps the offence is not to say.
The BURDEN of proof is that the police have to prove that a car was speeding. Not who was driving.
Now we all know cars could get cloned, but if that's your defence and it's a lie, then you'll go down for perverting the course of justice or something like that, once they've shown you getting in your car on CCTV in town and driving past the speed camera on the same road 2 mins later.
If your car was cloned, you'll have an alibi. Probably.
Note: I only know of one issue with cloning, and this was a poor bloke that had armed police get him out of bed, with regards to a number of armed robberies, and he and his car had firm alibis, sometimes in a main dealer, sometimes, in meetings at work, or with customers 200 miles from the robbery, or in a restaurant with a credit card receipt and CCTV records. As he told my mate, one of the police that drove him 200 miles to interview him in their station, if he was going to commit a serious crime, he's not likely do it in his own car would he?
V8forweekends said:
Before I start - I speed regularly and am not a member of BRAKE etc.
Speeding is a way, way more common crime than burglary.
Many speeders and burglars would cheerfully tell any lie rather than own up.
The potential penalties for burglary are much more serious, and it is viewed much more seriously in general.
In practice, if one was allowed to say "you prove who was driving", speed cameras would be rendered pointless as very few people would get convicted.
The coppers can sometimes get DNA and/or fingerprints from burglaries.
As proven just recently by those two scroats nicking diesel, £75 fine. Now compare that to the much more leniant punishment for speeding which is £100 and 3 points.....hang on a minute, have I got that right, I'm all confused now.Speeding is a way, way more common crime than burglary.
Many speeders and burglars would cheerfully tell any lie rather than own up.
The potential penalties for burglary are much more serious, and it is viewed much more seriously in general.
In practice, if one was allowed to say "you prove who was driving", speed cameras would be rendered pointless as very few people would get convicted.
The coppers can sometimes get DNA and/or fingerprints from burglaries.
NH1 said:
As proven just recently by those two scroats nicking diesel, £75 fine. Now compare that to the much more leniant punishment for speeding which is £100 and 3 points.....hang on a minute, have I got that right, I'm all confused now.
Sad fact is that the diesel scrotes can only just afford 75 quid and the courts know full well you and I can easily afford 100.V8forweekends said:
Before I start - I speed regularly and am not a member of BRAKE etc.
Speeding is a way, way more common crime than burglary.
Many speeders and burglars would cheerfully tell any lie rather than own up.
The potential penalties for burglary are much more serious, and it is viewed much more seriously in general.
In practice, if one was allowed to say "you prove who was driving", speed cameras would be rendered pointless as very few people would get convicted.
The coppers can sometimes get DNA and/or fingerprints from burglaries.
A scrote stole some laptops from the school my wife works at, the police caught him because he left his spliff on the windowsill...Speeding is a way, way more common crime than burglary.
Many speeders and burglars would cheerfully tell any lie rather than own up.
The potential penalties for burglary are much more serious, and it is viewed much more seriously in general.
In practice, if one was allowed to say "you prove who was driving", speed cameras would be rendered pointless as very few people would get convicted.
The coppers can sometimes get DNA and/or fingerprints from burglaries.
It is not an offence not to know who was driving your car.
Also, of you dispute it was you you have the option of going to court and asking the authorities to prove their case.
The standard of proof required would be beyond reasonable doubt.
The s172 is required as without it enforcement would be rendered useless. The ECHR has ruled it is proportionate and consistent with human rights.
Also, of you dispute it was you you have the option of going to court and asking the authorities to prove their case.
The standard of proof required would be beyond reasonable doubt.
The s172 is required as without it enforcement would be rendered useless. The ECHR has ruled it is proportionate and consistent with human rights.
V8forweekends said:
In practice, if one was allowed to say "you prove who was driving", speed cameras would be rendered pointless as very few people would get convicted.
In Sweden the speed cameras are forward facing, they snap a photo of the car and the driver, it is then up to the police to ID and fine the driver, the driver can then choose to go to court, at no point is the RK asked to ID the driver.Innocent until proven guilty.
NH1 said:
I thought this was a simple one, car drivers have money, thieves don't. Until the government start taking TVs as a form of payment it will always be this way.
No, don't be silly.As a car owner you are expected to name who was driving your car. There is no analagous situation with regards to burglary.
New POD said:
.....Now we all know cars could get cloned, but if that's your defence and it's a lie, then you'll go down for perverting the course of justice or something like that, once they've shown you getting in your car on CCTV in town and driving past the speed camera on the same road 2 mins later. ......
If you try and lie your way out of a speeding fine, and later get found guilty of speeding, you get done for speeding, and go to jail for the lie.
If you try and lie your way out of burglary/rape/assault etc (you know serious stuff), and later get found guilty, you get done for the burglary/rape/assault - which may not mean jail, and the lie is forgotten about.
Cat said:
Finlandia said:
Why is the s172 not used for more serious car related crimes?
It is - s172 applies to the vast majority of driving related offences and is often used in cases other than speeding. Cat
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
Finlandia said:
AFAIK Michael Barrymore didn't have to fill in a s172 when he crashed drunk and drugged up?
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
I have no idea whether or not it was used in that case. If it wasn't then it would be the exception rather than the norm.http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
Cat
PS - a 172 request doesn't have to be in writing and "filled in", it can be made and responded to verbally.
Hi, thanks for the replies. Very interesting.
Another scenario for you then, two lads take a car for a joy ride, police chase them but loose then for a few minutes, when they catch up the lads are seen running away from the vehicle, police detain them but cannot say who was driving, it's often said again on these programs that no action was taken as they could not prove who was actually driving the stolen car, as a registered keeper you would be expected to know & name the driver but these low life's get off as they refuse to say ? Why are they not given the chance to either own up or grass on each other or they are both charged with same offence ?
Phil.
Another scenario for you then, two lads take a car for a joy ride, police chase them but loose then for a few minutes, when they catch up the lads are seen running away from the vehicle, police detain them but cannot say who was driving, it's often said again on these programs that no action was taken as they could not prove who was actually driving the stolen car, as a registered keeper you would be expected to know & name the driver but these low life's get off as they refuse to say ? Why are they not given the chance to either own up or grass on each other or they are both charged with same offence ?
Phil.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


