Failing to Stop and Exchange - Private Car Park
Failing to Stop and Exchange - Private Car Park
Author
Discussion

shakotan

Original Poster:

10,862 posts

227 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
To precursor this matter, firstly I only heard about this last night, so am relying solely on what I'm being told, and secondly, my partner is currently undergoing treatment from a Psychologist, and takes medication for, Anxiety issues.

On the 17th January, my partner was involved in a very low speed collision in the Arndale Shopping Centre in Luton. She allegedly failed to note a Give Way marker on the floor and collided with another vehicle that was coming down the ramp from the floor above. My partner exited her vehicle to speak to the driver of the other car and exchange details, but the other driver was very confrontational and this triggered an anxiety attack. I'm told these attacks do not happen very often, and it is usually stressful social interactions that cause them. Due to the anxiety attack, my partner decided to get back in her vehicle and leave the scene.

Later, once home and the anxiety issue had subsided, she took the poor decision of burying her head in the sand about the whole matter and hoped it would go away.

A couple of days ago, she received a telephone call from her insurance company regarding the accident. Obviously the third-party had noted her registration and reported the matter to their insurance company. My partner admitted that a collision had taken place but did not admit liability, and the insurance are dealing with it.

Unfortunately yesterday she received a letter from the Camera, Tickets and Collision Unit of Bedford and Herts Police, requesting details of the driver at the time of the accident, and noting that they are alleged to have caused the offences of: Failing to Report an Accident, Fail to Stop and Give Name and Address, and Driving Without Due Care and Attention.

I have posted a copy of the letter below. My partner is now terrified that she will lose her license, which she depends upon for her work (she is self-employed in a care profession that takes her all over London and the surrounding counties).

I'd really like to know the professionals opinion on what happens next. The form asks for explanation from the driver about the offences, but at this stage is she best just confirming her details until she knows whether they will press ahead with any charges?

If it does go to Court, what sentence can she expect. Can you even be charged with Driving Without Due Care on private property?

She knows she been stupid, there are some mitigating circumstances regarding the anxiety attacks, however she should have later reported the accident and not buried her head in the sand. Any advise is much appreciated.


Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
shakotan said:
To precursor this matter, firstly I only heard about this last night, so am relying solely on what I'm being told, and secondly, my partner is currently undergoing treatment from a Psychologist, and takes medication for, Anxiety issues.

On the 17th January, my partner was involved in a very low speed collision in the Arndale Shopping Centre in Luton. She allegedly failed to note a Give Way marker on the floor and collided with another vehicle that was coming down the ramp from the floor above. My partner exited her vehicle to speak to the driver of the other car and exchange details, but the other driver was very confrontational and this triggered an anxiety attack. I'm told these attacks do not happen very often, and it is usually stressful social interactions that cause them. Due to the anxiety attack, my partner decided to get back in her vehicle and leave the scene.

Later, once home and the anxiety issue had subsided, she took the poor decision of burying her head in the sand about the whole matter and hoped it would go away.

A couple of days ago, she received a telephone call from her insurance company regarding the accident. Obviously the third-party had noted her registration and reported the matter to their insurance company. My partner admitted that a collision had taken place but did not admit liability, and the insurance are dealing with it.

Unfortunately yesterday she received a letter from the Camera, Tickets and Collision Unit of Bedford and Herts Police, requesting details of the driver at the time of the accident, and noting that they are alleged to have caused the offences of: Failing to Report an Accident, Fail to Stop and Give Name and Address, and Driving Without Due Care and Attention.

I have posted a copy of the letter below. My partner is now terrified that she will lose her license, which she depends upon for her work (she is self-employed in a care profession that takes her all over London and the surrounding counties).

I'd really like to know the professionals opinion on what happens next. The form asks for explanation from the driver about the offences, but at this stage is she best just confirming her details until she knows whether they will press ahead with any charges?

If it does go to Court, what sentence can she expect. Can you even be charged with Driving Without Due Care on private property?

She knows she been stupid, there are some mitigating circumstances regarding the anxiety attacks, however she should have later reported the accident and not buried her head in the sand. Any advise is much appreciated.

I sympathise with the difficulty but as ever your partner will find the authorities understanding is improved if she makes a proper reply to the paperwork. You need advice from solicitor specialising in motoring offences. Get that advice and follow it. There is a clear dichotomy here in your partner driving the car and being unable to deal with the consequences of her mistake at the time. Honestly and a well presented case should ensure she is not disqualified. From your description it may be the incident was not on a road. Give your lawyer the full details and follow their advice. Best of Luck.

jbsportstech

5,069 posts

210 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Or they may take the view that since she failed to report the accident within 48 hrs to her insurer or the police the panic attack is just a front and she actually is trying to avoid. If she hand contact the police and insurer then fine.

She has failed stop and report the accident, as said get a good solicitor but in my book her excuse ran out after she got home and failed to report the accident.

singlecoil

35,888 posts

277 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
I don't want to sound unsympathetic, but it is a little concerning that your partner is 'driving all over London' and yet can't handle a situation such as the one described. I'm sure you are equally worried about that. Is this a temporary thing, do you think?

theguvernor

629 posts

162 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
If i was you i would also see if you could get a letter from a GP/Psychologist saying she can suffer from anxiety attacks etc if put in a confrontational position like she was. (Make sure it obviously states she's fine to drive though).
I'd imagine it could make the consequences less harsh if there's a better understanding of the situation.
(I'm neither a solicitor nor a police officer).

HorneyMX5

5,809 posts

181 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
As a fellow sufferer of anxiety and panic attacks I can understand why she did what she did and also why she buried her head in the sand. Avoiding triggers is one of the key methods of dealing with anxiety but sometimes you just have to grit your teeth and fight it head on.

I hope it all works out OK for her.

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
singlecoil said:
I don't want to sound unsympathetic, but it is a little concerning that your partner is 'driving all over London' and yet can't handle a situation such as the one described. I'm sure you are equally worried about that. Is this a temporary thing, do you think?
+1

It's tough to varnish ones opinion on this sort of thing. If someone has a serious anxiety problem then they should not be driving, especially around London. That is the brutal truth I'm afraid. Furthermore one would assume that if she is seeing a psychologist for it that it is significant enough that the DVLA would need notifying - as unfortunately they can fine you for undisclosed medical conditions when they become aware of them (e.g. after an accident).

That being said I don't imagine she would be banned, especially if the anxiety factor was mentioned in a statement. Whilst she has been charged with three offences she would expect to receive points for the most significant one, rather than points for each.

HTP99

25,435 posts

171 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
My neighbour popped round with one of those letters last year as he had had an altercation locally; there was a bit of tooing and froing and heated words and the third party drove off without leaving details; my neighbour thought nothing of it and came home and forgot about it.

A week later the letter arrived claiming that someone driving his car had failed to stop at the scene of an accident and could he please fill in the details of the driver; he was worried as it is a pretty stern letter and the crime of failing to stop at the scenic of an accident is quite a bad one.

Anyway he asked me to show my dad to get his advice; my dad is a retired Traffic Officer and still works for the Police in a civilain role, his response was something like this:

"Oh, all they are trying to establish who was driving the vehicle at the time, this info will be used by the insurance company regarding the claim and there is nothing to worry about, it is just a process to get the correct informationm the Police won't be interested they are just following procedure.

My dad was correct, nothing happened to my neighbour, he didn't go to court, he didn't receive any points or lose his licence.

HorneyMX5

5,809 posts

181 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Durzel said:
singlecoil said:
I don't want to sound unsympathetic, but it is a little concerning that your partner is 'driving all over London' and yet can't handle a situation such as the one described. I'm sure you are equally worried about that. Is this a temporary thing, do you think?
+1

It's tough to varnish ones opinion on this sort of thing. If someone has a serious anxiety problem then they should not be driving, especially around London. That is the brutal truth I'm afraid. Furthermore one would assume that if she is seeing a psychologist for it that it is significant enough that the DVLA would need notifying - as unfortunately they can fine you for undisclosed medical conditions when they become aware of them (e.g. after an accident).

That being said I don't imagine she would be banned, especially if the anxiety factor was mentioned in a statement. Whilst she has been charged with three offences she would expect to receive points for the most significant one, rather than points for each.
Rubbish. That would only be the case if driving caused the attacks. I suffer badly with anxiety and painic attacks but driving my cars is one of the things for me that relieves the symtpoms and allows me to gt my head straight. After a bad a few days with it there's no greater leveler for me than taking the car out for a spin.

singlecoil

35,888 posts

277 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
HorneyMX5 said:
Durzel said:
singlecoil said:
I don't want to sound unsympathetic, but it is a little concerning that your partner is 'driving all over London' and yet can't handle a situation such as the one described. I'm sure you are equally worried about that. Is this a temporary thing, do you think?
+1

It's tough to varnish ones opinion on this sort of thing. If someone has a serious anxiety problem then they should not be driving, especially around London. That is the brutal truth I'm afraid. Furthermore one would assume that if she is seeing a psychologist for it that it is significant enough that the DVLA would need notifying - as unfortunately they can fine you for undisclosed medical conditions when they become aware of them (e.g. after an accident).

That being said I don't imagine she would be banned, especially if the anxiety factor was mentioned in a statement. Whilst she has been charged with three offences she would expect to receive points for the most significant one, rather than points for each.
Rubbish. That would only be the case if driving caused the attacks. I suffer badly with anxiety and painic attacks but driving my cars is one of the things for me that relieves the symtpoms and allows me to gt my head straight. After a bad a few days with it there's no greater leveler for me than taking the car out for a spin.
It sounds like rubbish to you because you have missed the point.

The point is that she cannot rely on not having to face such situations. Cars are not insulated metal boxes in which one can and should feel safe, and go about in a relaxed and stress free environment, there are consequences to be faced especially when accidents or other unexpected events occur.

Hol

9,316 posts

231 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all

Been on the other side of this, where the car was parked, but we knew who had damaged it.

All the Police were interested in, was getting the other parties insurance details over to me/my insurer.
I don't think they prosecuted them (I was never called as a witness, nor was the neighbour who saw it), but strangely enough, they did not contest the accident at all.



TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
shakotan said:
To precursor this matter, firstly I only heard about this last night, so am relying solely on what I'm being told, and secondly, my partner is currently undergoing treatment from a Psychologist, and takes medication for, Anxiety issues.

On the 17th January, my partner was involved in a very low speed collision in the Arndale Shopping Centre in Luton. She allegedly failed to note a Give Way marker on the floor and collided with another vehicle that was coming down the ramp from the floor above.

A couple of days ago, she received a telephone call from her insurance company regarding the accident. Obviously the third-party had noted her registration and reported the matter to their insurance company. My partner admitted that a collision had taken place but did not admit liability, and the insurance are dealing with it.

Unfortunately yesterday she received a letter from the Camera, Tickets and Collision Unit of Bedford and Herts Police, requesting details of the driver at the time of the accident, and noting that they are alleged to have caused the offences of: Failing to Report an Accident, Fail to Stop and Give Name and Address, and Driving Without Due Care and Attention.

If it does go to Court, what sentence can she expect. Can you even be charged with Driving Without Due Care on private property?
Ok firstly,the car park is not private as it has public access so the road traffic act will more than likely apply.

Secondly,was there a give way marking or not?
If there was then why on earth is she telling her insurance company she is not to blame?
If you do not know then go and check.

This is being handled very badly so far.

HorneyMX5

5,809 posts

181 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
singlecoil said:
HorneyMX5 said:
Durzel said:
singlecoil said:
I don't want to sound unsympathetic, but it is a little concerning that your partner is 'driving all over London' and yet can't handle a situation such as the one described. I'm sure you are equally worried about that. Is this a temporary thing, do you think?
+1

It's tough to varnish ones opinion on this sort of thing. If someone has a serious anxiety problem then they should not be driving, especially around London. That is the brutal truth I'm afraid. Furthermore one would assume that if she is seeing a psychologist for it that it is significant enough that the DVLA would need notifying - as unfortunately they can fine you for undisclosed medical conditions when they become aware of them (e.g. after an accident).

That being said I don't imagine she would be banned, especially if the anxiety factor was mentioned in a statement. Whilst she has been charged with three offences she would expect to receive points for the most significant one, rather than points for each.
Rubbish. That would only be the case if driving caused the attacks. I suffer badly with anxiety and painic attacks but driving my cars is one of the things for me that relieves the symtpoms and allows me to gt my head straight. After a bad a few days with it there's no greater leveler for me than taking the car out for a spin.
It sounds like rubbish to you because you have missed the point.

The point is that she cannot rely on not having to face such situations. Cars are not insulated metal boxes in which one can and should feel safe, and go about in a relaxed and stress free environment, there are consequences to be faced especially when accidents or other unexpected events occur.
And this is why people with mental health issues often keep it to themselves for fear of being labeled as someone who cannot cope with life's challenges.

Do you or anyone close to you suffer from anxiety? I suspect not. It's a complex problem and sufferers vary hugely with how it effects them and how they deal with it. It makes me angry that people assume you can't cope with situations, it's one of the reasons my employer does not know becuase I have a high stress job and I don't want them to think it's an issue as it's not.

Sometimes you never know what will trigger it and it catches you by surprise. After I oopened up about being a sufferer with my friends I was amazed to find that many people I had know for many years were also sufferes and confided in me. Some were getting treatment and others now do because I "came out" and they felt they weren't alone. Some of these people are proffesional drivers and two are club racers who have to undergo a medical as part of getting your MSA photo card.

Edited by HorneyMX5 on Wednesday 5th February 11:46

swisstoni

24,249 posts

310 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Need to emphasise that this matter would have been cleared up immediately had it not been for the frightening demeanour of the other party. As you say, your partner stopped and did all the right things initially but met with someone who scared to her sufficiently for her to just want to get away from them.

swisstoni

24,249 posts

310 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
The 'poor driver' lost all sympathy from me when they couldn't calm down and exchange details like a civil human being.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Personally i'd forget all about the panic attack and just appologise. Get your partner to explain that she drove off because the other driver was aggressive and that she then forgot to do anything about it later. I'm sure she won't be banned.

singlecoil

35,888 posts

277 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
swisstoni said:
Need to emphasise that this matter would have been cleared up immediately had it not been for the frightening demeanour of the other party. As you say, your partner stopped and did all the right things initially but met with someone who scared to her sufficiently for her to just want to get away from them.
That would seem unfair to the other driver unless a propensity to get scared in such situations was mentioned as well, otherwise it might seem that the other driver was behaving in a manner that anyone would find threatening.

TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
swisstoni said:
The 'poor driver' lost all sympathy from me when they couldn't calm down and exchange details like a civil human being.
Strange that isn't it.

The other driver was angry/confrontational after a crash.

It's called shock and anger after what has just happened.

I can see why she drove off though.


However,did she tell the op what happened when she got home?
If so why did he not accompany her to the police station?
If she did not tell him,is there no visable damage to the car?


My view so far.......

Failing to stop and exchange or report within 24 hours to police.
Failing to stop at giveway could be driving without due care and attention.

The op needs to visit the scene and check for a giveway.
If there is one they need to inform the insurance company and decide where to go from there.


NPI

1,310 posts

155 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
How does anxiety/panic manifest itself?

Surely anyone who suffers an accident (never mind causes one) would suffer some degree of anxiety/panic?

Edited by NPI on Wednesday 5th February 13:07

shakotan

Original Poster:

10,862 posts

227 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
TPS said:
If there was then why on earth is she telling her insurance company she is not to blame?
At no point did I say she has told her insurance company she is not to blame. I said she had not admitted liability. Those are two completely different things. The first thing ANY insurance company tells you is NEVER admit liability to an accident. That's what insurance assessors are for.