How well are police serving the public?
Discussion
With recent videos (photographer in Gloucester being told he was lucky not to have been knocked out by a Police Officer and a fracking protest photographer suffering a dubious, at the very least, arrest for failing to provide) showing shocking Police behaviour what do PHers think of this (scroll towards the end for the interesting piece).
http://youtu.be/VUptcBBhsAo
It appears to be an outrageous overreaction by both Officers - what is the problem with UK Police, are we placing awesome power and discretion in the hands of people who are unable to handle either one of those things let alone both?
http://youtu.be/VUptcBBhsAo
It appears to be an outrageous overreaction by both Officers - what is the problem with UK Police, are we placing awesome power and discretion in the hands of people who are unable to handle either one of those things let alone both?
adamfawsitt said:
With recent videos (photographer in Gloucester being told he was lucky not to have been knocked out by a Police Officer and a fracking protest photographer suffering a dubious, at the very least, arrest for failing to provide) showing shocking Police behaviour what do PHers think of this (scroll towards the end for the interesting piece).
http://youtu.be/VUptcBBhsAo
It appears to be an outrageous overreaction by both Officers - what is the problem with UK Police, are we placing awesome power and discretion in the hands of people who are unable to handle either one of those things let alone both?
Did you really have to dig up such an old video?http://youtu.be/VUptcBBhsAo
It appears to be an outrageous overreaction by both Officers - what is the problem with UK Police, are we placing awesome power and discretion in the hands of people who are unable to handle either one of those things let alone both?
A video that has been argued over again and again.In fact its not even the full one that may have made you view it differently.
grumbledoak said:
Is this that welsh 'tard in the range rover driving off and getting his windscreen smashed? Compo all round and generally a pity the copper didn't t
t the old fool while he was at it IIRC.
Yes, this is that really old video of the "poor old pensioner" who failed to stop. You know the chap, the one with an arrest sheet as long as your arm who, IIRC has been stopped numerous times for traffic offenses such as no insurance, no tax etc. etc. etc. etc.
t the old fool while he was at it IIRC.Is the behaviour that bad, or are an extreme minority of events heavily reported fuelling this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Availability_heuristi... ?
Since the formation of ACPO which in effect is a political police body, but makes big money for it's members, I have lost a lot of respect for the Police. On top of this there seem to be too many incidents with officers acting illegally, which fires the distrust.
When I was a kid the local bobby used to give one a clip around the ear and take one home, if one had been caught doing anything naughty. Damn sight more effective as one might have also got a thrashing at home......
Of course the world has got so socialist liberal namby pamby, so we waste billions every year, giving kids a slap on the wrist through the courts, or giving proven terrorists their human rights to stay........ This makes the police and justice system the laughing stock.
BUT the majority of the hardworking BiB still no doubt do a hard and mostly thankless job!
When I was a kid the local bobby used to give one a clip around the ear and take one home, if one had been caught doing anything naughty. Damn sight more effective as one might have also got a thrashing at home......
Of course the world has got so socialist liberal namby pamby, so we waste billions every year, giving kids a slap on the wrist through the courts, or giving proven terrorists their human rights to stay........ This makes the police and justice system the laughing stock.
BUT the majority of the hardworking BiB still no doubt do a hard and mostly thankless job!
I think in general they do a good job, I certainly feel safe and believe they will respond to a 999 call in good time. However they are let down by a bad attitude towards the general public, I have no faith that if I have to talk to them for any reason that I'll be talked to with respect, told about my rights and that they will assume guilt before innocence.
La Liga said:
Is the behaviour that bad, or are an extreme minority of events heavily reported fuelling this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Availability_heuristi... ?
Frankly, your post smacks of desperation.Isn't some of this perhaps due to them lowering standards in their selection procedure? I know when I house shared with some young coppers when I first left home, the selection process was quite strict regarding fitness, height, intelligence etc. These days that appears to have gone out the window.
REALIST123 said:
La Liga said:
Is the behaviour that bad, or are an extreme minority of events heavily reported fuelling this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Availability_heuristi... ?
Frankly, your post smacks of desperation.
I've introduced objective forms of data analysis from internal and external measurements around perception, trust and confidence, that don't support the "things are so bad / getting worse" - but then what chance does any objective data and argument have against confirmation bias?
JMGS4 said:
When I was a kid the local bobby used to give one a clip around the ear and take one home, if one had been caught doing anything naughty. Damn sight more effective as one might have also got a thrashing at home......
Of course the world has got so socialist liberal namby pamby
BUT the majority of the hardworking BiB still no doubt do a hard and mostly thankless job!
This and the fact it would have been the same local cop. In my case he was known as Wingnut and was feared and respected. Of course the world has got so socialist liberal namby pamby
BUT the majority of the hardworking BiB still no doubt do a hard and mostly thankless job!
First they removed all the local police houses, then the small local police stations and now the main Police stations have been removed and replaced by these large central stations. The few police stations that do remain have opening hours that render them useless anyhow. Hardly a move in the right direction for local policing or building relations with the public
REALIST123 said:
It's hard to see how one could consider that we are well served given the almost daily reports of corruption and wrongdoing.
Isn't it odd that none of these stories get much air time:http://www.polfed.org/events/police_bravery_awards...
I accept that there's a difference between being better than most and being good, but I do wonder which other police forces around the world serve their country better.
Whilst the IPCC and the whole complaints procedure system comes in for repeated criticism, I know of no other force that has anything that comes close.
PACE and CoPs govern the conduct of police in the way they deal with prisoners. Other countries have brought in similar systems but up until 2003 none were as tightly controlled as England/Wales.
Most police officer welcomed, and indeed wanted, the CCTV systems in cell blocks. Prisoners are filmed the moment they arrive on police property and on any interview are audio recorded.
Prisoners are no longer questioned in the sense of interrogation, certainly not as they used to be for the first 15-20 years I was in the job. Police officers can no longer 'trick' you without serious consequences.
Prisoners have the right to legal advice. In my old force we had lay visitors who would come into the cell block at any time of the day or night to ensure that systems were complied with and prisoners were dealt with properly.
Whilst, quite correctly, we have criticism of the police for accepting bribes and telling lies – that's not in court – when you compare the England/Wales record on bribes, we hardly struggle in comparison with other forces, and that includes other Western forces, even other EU forces.
Consider too the pay of police officers. For the service you get it is a bargain. Check how much the French set-up costs.
We have criticism of the way public order is policed in this country. Get a life.
Remember that traffic wardens were vilified in the media before they were privatised. They were seen as jobsworths. Prefer them now, do you? You didn't know when you were well off and the same goes for the police.
The police in this country are the best that they have ever been. The talk of the 'good old days' when police could used violence against kids, is rather farcical. Whilst I can see the logic and the efficacy of the police acting in loco parentis, it led to a culture of violence when dealing with all people regardless of age.
I know a woman, I worked with her, whose partner was murdered in France. She said that there was no incident room, no major enquiry and it was clear that they were not bothered. She made a fuss and was threatened. So her boyfriend had been killed and that, it seemed, was it.
What odds would you give that Maddie McCann's murderer would be behind bars now if it had happened in England?
One thing: when a unit of mine dealt with robberies against teenage foreign students, we used CCTV. We would have video of the offenders using violence to steal from kids yet, when approached by police, these kids would sometimes deny being a victim.
The lads had to say that everything was on CCTV and then, when these kids attended the station, they would be nervous. The lads couldn't understand it. It would appear that some EU countries had police officers who did not like being bothered by crime reports.
The England/Welsh forces are criticised for lack of interest in turning up to report crimes but that ignores the fact that you get policing on the cheap. Officers go from job to job, from report to report, and if at the end of the shift they have been unable to deal with all the incidents, then they are handed over onto the oncoming shift. Something has to give so some jobs have to be sleeved.
And that was ten years ago. Nowadays the situation is much worse. Moan all you want but it is a bit like buying a Smart car and then complaining about the lack of rear space.
The police have a workload that cannot be controlled. They are demand led.
Foreign forces came to this country to see the workings of PACE and some could not believe that English/Welsh forces welcomed the changes. It was the same with CCTV in the cell block.
Ask yourself one question: if you were to be arrested for an offence, one that you have done or one that you were innocent of, which country would you prefer that to be in?
So you are entitled to ask if the police to a good job, and you are permitted to suggest:
Whilst the IPCC and the whole complaints procedure system comes in for repeated criticism, I know of no other force that has anything that comes close.
PACE and CoPs govern the conduct of police in the way they deal with prisoners. Other countries have brought in similar systems but up until 2003 none were as tightly controlled as England/Wales.
Most police officer welcomed, and indeed wanted, the CCTV systems in cell blocks. Prisoners are filmed the moment they arrive on police property and on any interview are audio recorded.
Prisoners are no longer questioned in the sense of interrogation, certainly not as they used to be for the first 15-20 years I was in the job. Police officers can no longer 'trick' you without serious consequences.
Prisoners have the right to legal advice. In my old force we had lay visitors who would come into the cell block at any time of the day or night to ensure that systems were complied with and prisoners were dealt with properly.
Whilst, quite correctly, we have criticism of the police for accepting bribes and telling lies – that's not in court – when you compare the England/Wales record on bribes, we hardly struggle in comparison with other forces, and that includes other Western forces, even other EU forces.
Consider too the pay of police officers. For the service you get it is a bargain. Check how much the French set-up costs.
We have criticism of the way public order is policed in this country. Get a life.
Remember that traffic wardens were vilified in the media before they were privatised. They were seen as jobsworths. Prefer them now, do you? You didn't know when you were well off and the same goes for the police.
The police in this country are the best that they have ever been. The talk of the 'good old days' when police could used violence against kids, is rather farcical. Whilst I can see the logic and the efficacy of the police acting in loco parentis, it led to a culture of violence when dealing with all people regardless of age.
I know a woman, I worked with her, whose partner was murdered in France. She said that there was no incident room, no major enquiry and it was clear that they were not bothered. She made a fuss and was threatened. So her boyfriend had been killed and that, it seemed, was it.
What odds would you give that Maddie McCann's murderer would be behind bars now if it had happened in England?
One thing: when a unit of mine dealt with robberies against teenage foreign students, we used CCTV. We would have video of the offenders using violence to steal from kids yet, when approached by police, these kids would sometimes deny being a victim.
The lads had to say that everything was on CCTV and then, when these kids attended the station, they would be nervous. The lads couldn't understand it. It would appear that some EU countries had police officers who did not like being bothered by crime reports.
The England/Welsh forces are criticised for lack of interest in turning up to report crimes but that ignores the fact that you get policing on the cheap. Officers go from job to job, from report to report, and if at the end of the shift they have been unable to deal with all the incidents, then they are handed over onto the oncoming shift. Something has to give so some jobs have to be sleeved.
And that was ten years ago. Nowadays the situation is much worse. Moan all you want but it is a bit like buying a Smart car and then complaining about the lack of rear space.
The police have a workload that cannot be controlled. They are demand led.
Foreign forces came to this country to see the workings of PACE and some could not believe that English/Welsh forces welcomed the changes. It was the same with CCTV in the cell block.
Ask yourself one question: if you were to be arrested for an offence, one that you have done or one that you were innocent of, which country would you prefer that to be in?
So you are entitled to ask if the police to a good job, and you are permitted to suggest:
adamfawsitt said:
With . . . a fracking protest photographer suffering a dubious, at the very least, arrest for failing to provide) showing shocking Police behaviour
but you have to accept that it shows a willingness to criticise an officer when he has acted legally – so rather silly. I am allowed to correct your comment and suggest that it should read:adamfawsitt said:
With . . . a fracking protester arrested for failing to provide a specimen of breath showing that the police officer knew the law and procedure with regards DUI.
The old days were not good. I was dealt with, on occasion, by police officers in my youth who were brilliant, doing a hard job with very little pay and in general, most did a good job. But corruption was rife. I came back one night on the last 'night' (late evening really) bus from the Richardson's pub and the police stopped every black from getting on.As an old codger myself, my personal experience of the police has been overwhelmingly positive.
I am very much an average joe, and have once or twice sailed close to the wind, have been involved with the police in a professional capacity for a short time, and been at the wrong end of an incident or two where police were involved.
IMHO where anyone has power over another, at all levels, there is a temptation to a few to abuse that power, and usually there is previous personal history why that individual strays across the line. That does not make it right though.
Problems like these have been going on time-immemorial. The difference these days is the media. The media with modern technology can and does expose far more than ever before.
Only a small percentage of 'incidents' would have ever surfaced in the public domain years ago. This makes many believe that there are more problems now than there ever were - go talk to Grandad and he will say so.
I have no evidence to say so, but I would take a good guess that there were probably many more misdemeanours by those in power (not just police), per head of population going back 40 years ago, then there ever is today!
As for the UK vs other countries? Go take a year or two out in the US and see how you feel about British bobbies then!
I am very much an average joe, and have once or twice sailed close to the wind, have been involved with the police in a professional capacity for a short time, and been at the wrong end of an incident or two where police were involved.
IMHO where anyone has power over another, at all levels, there is a temptation to a few to abuse that power, and usually there is previous personal history why that individual strays across the line. That does not make it right though.
Problems like these have been going on time-immemorial. The difference these days is the media. The media with modern technology can and does expose far more than ever before.
Only a small percentage of 'incidents' would have ever surfaced in the public domain years ago. This makes many believe that there are more problems now than there ever were - go talk to Grandad and he will say so.
I have no evidence to say so, but I would take a good guess that there were probably many more misdemeanours by those in power (not just police), per head of population going back 40 years ago, then there ever is today!
As for the UK vs other countries? Go take a year or two out in the US and see how you feel about British bobbies then!
adamfawsitt said:
- what is the problem with UK Police
Is there a problem?You have posted one video. I'm not sure how this translates to there being a problem with the UK Police as a whole. I've not watched the video but assuming that it shows behaviour which is not serving the public then it could just indicate that the Police officer had a bad day and got it wrong. Police officers are human after all and subject the the same frailties as the rest of us.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



