Detained or Arrested.. what is the difference?
Discussion
What is the difference between being detained while enquiries are made, and being arrested?
Just wondering after watching the video on this news article in the Manchester Evening News:
http://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greate...
Just wondering after watching the video on this news article in the Manchester Evening News:
http://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greate...
Not much, really. I am fairly sure that a police officer cannot detain you without arresting you, although someone may know of a particular Statute that allows this. EDIT: some indeed do, and I was wrong.
People can be detained under the Immigration Act 1971, and in that context are detained not arrested.
From a civil law wrongful arrest/false imprisonment point if view, it matters not what the detention/arrest is called. It's the enforced deprivation of liberty without lawful cause that matters. EDIT: I stand by this bit (but not under it! /FOTL-woo-wah-woo).
PS: if the facts are as stated in that article, the chap has a slam dunker claim.
People can be detained under the Immigration Act 1971, and in that context are detained not arrested.
From a civil law wrongful arrest/false imprisonment point if view, it matters not what the detention/arrest is called. It's the enforced deprivation of liberty without lawful cause that matters. EDIT: I stand by this bit (but not under it! /FOTL-woo-wah-woo).
PS: if the facts are as stated in that article, the chap has a slam dunker claim.
Edited by anonymous-user on Thursday 6th February 12:26
Mill Wheel said:
What is the difference between being detained while enquiries are made, and being arrested?
Just wondering after watching the video on this news article in the Manchester Evening News:
http://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greate...
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-25793111Just wondering after watching the video on this news article in the Manchester Evening News:
http://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greate...
Thought it was just a Scottish thing...
"Police detention in Scotland
A suspect can be held forcibly in a police station for a maximum of 24 hours.
Detainees are entitled to have a lawyer give them advice.
Once the period of detention is over, the detainee must be released or arrested and charged.
If arrest has taken place, the accused person can either be released or detained in custody to appear in court.
If a detainee is released they can be charged at a later date - but may not be detained a second time.
While the period of detention is usually limited to 12 hours, a senior police officer can sanction a further period of 12 hours, meaning a total of 24."
Breadvan72 said:
PS: if the facts are as stated in that article, the chap has a slam dunker claim.
Just against the one officer though?If the other officers reasonably think (cos the lying officer said so) this guy has had a couple of drinks and been driving, did they do anything wrong?
You do not have to arrest to detain someone.
A sec 1 PACE search for example, "you are detained for the purpose of a search". You are not under arrest, however to enable the search to take place you are not allowed to leave and will be detained.
You can also be detained to prevent a breach of the peace, used at football fixtures when a group of fans identified as risk are on the rampage. Round them up, detain them and wait for things to calm down before releasing them, for example.
A sec 1 PACE search for example, "you are detained for the purpose of a search". You are not under arrest, however to enable the search to take place you are not allowed to leave and will be detained.
You can also be detained to prevent a breach of the peace, used at football fixtures when a group of fans identified as risk are on the rampage. Round them up, detain them and wait for things to calm down before releasing them, for example.
Liability for the arrest varies according to the context. For example, if a police officer arrests you for being drunk and disorderly, and it later transpires that you were not D and D, then because of the nature of the offence the officer can be liable, regardless of his/her belief. In other cases, the reasonable belief of the officer may afford a defence.
The Chief Constable is usually sued as vicariously liable for the wrongdoing of an officer, and it is the force that usually pays out, rather than the officer, if the case is settled or the claimant wins at trial.
The Chief Constable is usually sued as vicariously liable for the wrongdoing of an officer, and it is the force that usually pays out, rather than the officer, if the case is settled or the claimant wins at trial.
He's also a freeman cretin.
rohrl said:
The guy in the video is a "Freeman on the Land" type. I just copied this from a thread on reddit about this video :
From the description on the YouTube video uploaded by Steve Spy:
Lawful Observer is assaulted by 9986 and then his colleage lies in order to carry out unlawful arrest of Lawful observer whilst filming police assaults at protest against Fracking on Barton Moss Road, Irlam, Salford on 14/1/14. After the camera was turned off, 08076 David Kehoe breaks camera strap in order to seize camera from lawful observer. Because of advanced storage technology, the video data was stored by the device to be recovered when the camera was eventually returned on 31st January 2014. Uniformed hired thug for IGAS David Kehoe blatantly lies about what is said, even though there is a camera pointed at him recording his lies.
Transcript of court case 28/1/14:
Usher - "can you stand at the end"
Freeman - "I claim common law jurisdiction, I do not consent and I wave the
benefits"
Magistrate - "Can you repeat that"
Freeman - "I claim common law jurisdiction, I do not consent and I wave the
benefits"
Magistrate (to other two magistrates) - "I don't think we have had that before"
Clerk - "Are you Steven Spy?"
Freeman - "I am Steven of the family Spy"
Clerk - " Are you Steven Spy?"
Freeman - "I am Steven of the family Spy"
Clerk - "Where do you live?"
Freeman - "I live on the land"
Clerk - "Can you confirm your date of birth"
Freeman - "I believe that would be hearsay evidence, your honour"
Clerk - "If you honour is satisfied we have identified the defendant, we can
continue".
Prosecution - "The prosecution is not satisfied that there is sufficient
evidence to substantiate the charge, therefore we withdraw the case"
Clerk - " Do you understand that the prosecution is withdrawing its case"
Freeman - "No I do not understand, but I do comprehend"
Magistrate - "Whether you understand or comprehend, the prosecution is
withdrawing its case, so the case is dismissed and you are free to go"
Freeman - "Thank you, your honour".
From the description on the YouTube video uploaded by Steve Spy:
Lawful Observer is assaulted by 9986 and then his colleage lies in order to carry out unlawful arrest of Lawful observer whilst filming police assaults at protest against Fracking on Barton Moss Road, Irlam, Salford on 14/1/14. After the camera was turned off, 08076 David Kehoe breaks camera strap in order to seize camera from lawful observer. Because of advanced storage technology, the video data was stored by the device to be recovered when the camera was eventually returned on 31st January 2014. Uniformed hired thug for IGAS David Kehoe blatantly lies about what is said, even though there is a camera pointed at him recording his lies.
Transcript of court case 28/1/14:
Usher - "can you stand at the end"
Freeman - "I claim common law jurisdiction, I do not consent and I wave the
benefits"
Magistrate - "Can you repeat that"
Freeman - "I claim common law jurisdiction, I do not consent and I wave the
benefits"
Magistrate (to other two magistrates) - "I don't think we have had that before"
Clerk - "Are you Steven Spy?"
Freeman - "I am Steven of the family Spy"
Clerk - " Are you Steven Spy?"
Freeman - "I am Steven of the family Spy"
Clerk - "Where do you live?"
Freeman - "I live on the land"
Clerk - "Can you confirm your date of birth"
Freeman - "I believe that would be hearsay evidence, your honour"
Clerk - "If you honour is satisfied we have identified the defendant, we can
continue".
Prosecution - "The prosecution is not satisfied that there is sufficient
evidence to substantiate the charge, therefore we withdraw the case"
Clerk - " Do you understand that the prosecution is withdrawing its case"
Freeman - "No I do not understand, but I do comprehend"
Magistrate - "Whether you understand or comprehend, the prosecution is
withdrawing its case, so the case is dismissed and you are free to go"
Freeman - "Thank you, your honour".
You can be "detained" for a matter of seconds for the purpose of a drugs, or PACE search for example. You may not even leave the area for the search to be conducted. You're not under arrest. You can also be "detained" under the Mental Health Act for example, whereby you might be taken to a place of safety which can be a police station, and this could be up to 72 hours. You're still not under arrest. an officer can detain using force if necessary though.
It is very annoying that the bloke is a FOTLer. Partly because they are always annoying, but party because he may well win his case, as being a loon and pain in the butt is no excuse for unlawful police action, if that is what occurred here.
Of course, the irony and hypocrisy inherent in using the so called bogus corporate Maritime law civil justice system to collect damages will likely escape the FOTLer.
Of course, the irony and hypocrisy inherent in using the so called bogus corporate Maritime law civil justice system to collect damages will likely escape the FOTLer.
Breadvan72 said:
It is very annoying that the bloke is a FOTLer. Partly because they are always annoying, but party because he may well win his case, as being a loon and pain in the butt is no excuse for unlawful police action, if that is what occurred here.
Of course, the irony and hypocrisy inherent in using the so called bogus corporate Maritime law civil justice system to collect damages will likely escape the FOTLer.
When he's holding a pile of taxpayers' cash in his mitt I doubt he'll care much.Of course, the irony and hypocrisy inherent in using the so called bogus corporate Maritime law civil justice system to collect damages will likely escape the FOTLer.
Breadvan72 said:
Yup. Annoying, isn't it? Still, if Plod does badness, we must pay.
Quite.It's somewhat annoying though that in the original encounter (and many others) the police are required to maintain order yet lack the authority too, so end up doing stuff like this.
It's the proverbial 'clip round the ear' or 'bugger off' that cops used to have but don't have any more.
Sheesh Snowboy, I didn't have you down as one of those "everything was better in the 1950s/1850s/1750s/440000BC" types. The notion of friendly coppers giving friendly bops on the head to maintain order amongst the cheerful, smiling and deferential populace is as absurd as it is historically inaccurate.
Meanwhile, back on Planet Now....
http://www.googlefight.com/index.php?lang=en_GB&am...
Meanwhile, back on Planet Now....
http://www.googlefight.com/index.php?lang=en_GB&am...
Breadvan72 said:
546 to one in favour of the crusty.Fairly conclusive.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



