need some advice from a conveyancing solicitor - stamp duty
need some advice from a conveyancing solicitor - stamp duty
Author
Discussion

broken biscuit

Original Poster:

1,633 posts

232 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Hoping someone can clear this up for me, as I am getting various opinions...

I am buying a house from a relative. The agreed purchase price (ie what I am paying him) is under the stamp duty threshold. The property itself is worth £145k market value, so £20k over the stamp limit. The difference is theoretical gifted equity which forms my deposit. The mortgage company have no issue with this, and my mortgage is agreed.

The solicitor I have instructed is now saying that the figures that need to go on the regitry etc are for £145k therefore I need to pay stamp duty. This is different to what I have been told by other solicitors when obtaining conveyancing quotes, and what the mortgage advisor has told me.

Any conveyancing solicitors confirm whether stamp duty is payable or not please?

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
So you're paying him £124,999 for the house plus £20,000 as a totally and utterly unrelated gift at the same time?
Or is it as a deposit? Because the deposit is part of the purchase price.

Don't take this the wrong way, but do you think HMRC are stupid...?

Vixpy1

42,699 posts

295 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
broken biscuit said:
The solicitor I have instructed is now saying that the figures that need to go on the regitry etc are for £145k therefore I need to pay stamp duty.
He is correct and stamp duty is payable.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Finance Act 2003 Schedule 4 Paragraph 1 said:
Stamp duty land tax: chargeable consideration

1(1) The chargeable consideration for a transaction is, except as otherwise expressly provided, any consideration in money or money’s worth given for the subject-matter of the transaction, directly or indirectly, by the purchaser or a person connected with him.
So the question is whether an equity 'gift' of £20k should (or should not) form part of the chargeable consideration. My first thought was not..

Sounds like one for HMRC or a tax specialist, of which I am neither..

Finance Act 2003

3Dee

3,206 posts

252 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Hang on!
This is the simple view...

So if I am right, The house was up for sale for 145k, correct?

BUT your seller agreed to sell it to you for £120k - which I believe they are entitled to, as nothing I know of forces a seller to sell at the market or advertised price? Provided there are no other parties, surely the seller can sell for whatever they like!

If that is the case, then provided the paperwork reflects the purchase price, then I can't see how Stamp Duty can come into the equation.

BUT - if the seller is notionally selling at 145k, and they gift a proportion of that selling price to you (20k) is a recorded fact, then I can see this will muddy the water somewhat!

Suppose the trick is not to document the 20k?

waterwonder

1,002 posts

207 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
I don't think you can have it both ways.

Either the house is being sold for £125k in which case you have no deposit nor equity. In which case the mortgage co would have a problem because they only value the house at the lesser of purchase price or market value. However you will be below the threshold so no stamp duty

Or

It's being sold at £145k however you will only need to provide £125k of funds because your relative is gifting you the rest. In which case HMRC will want their stamp duty but the mortgage company will be happy, assuming their actual valuation doesn't change the LTV ratio.

Edited by waterwonder on Thursday 6th February 14:33

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
broken biscuit said:
Hoping someone can clear this up for me, as I am getting various opinions...

Any conveyancing solicitors confirm whether stamp duty is payable or not please?
How much money passes from buyer to seller (including everything)?

If it's over the SD limit then SD is payable. Simple.

surveyor

18,707 posts

215 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
broken biscuit said:
Hoping someone can clear this up for me, as I am getting various opinions...

Any conveyancing solicitors confirm whether stamp duty is payable or not please?
How much money passes from buyer to seller (including everything)?

If it's over the SD limit then SD is payable. Simple.
Nothing Government lead is that simple.

In certain circumstances the SDLT can be based on the Market Value of something rather than price paid.

Vaud

60,033 posts

186 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
surveyor said:
Nothing Government lead is that simple.

In certain circumstances the SDLT can be based on the Market Value of something rather than price paid.
Presumably to stop this kind of tax approach?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Vaud said:
Presumably to stop this kind of tax approach?
Yes, to stop this kind of tax evasion.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
That's why I said 'how much paid including everything'

NPI

1,310 posts

155 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
waterwonder said:
I don't think you can have it both ways.

Either the house is being sold for £125k in which case you have no deposit nor equity. In which case the mortgage co would have a problem because they only value the house at the lesser of purchase price or market value. However you will be below the threshold so no stamp duty

Or

It's being sold at £145k however you will only need to provide £125k of funds because your relative is gifting you the rest. In which case HMRC will want their stamp duty but the mortgage company will be happy, assuming their actual valuation doesn't change the LTV ratio.
I think that has to be the right answer - OP is trying to have his cake and eat it.

It wouldn't a problem to only pay £125K for the house if he only needed to borrow, say, 75% of that.

Starfighter

5,352 posts

209 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Isn't ths simialar to the old £125k for the house and £20k for fixtures / fittings trick for years back? I thought that this was stamped on by HMRC.

broken biscuit

Original Poster:

1,633 posts

232 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
The house is being sold for under £125k. It was bought by my relative for this price 12 months ago as a trashed repossession. I renovated the property, and moved in. The idea was for me to do the work over a year to increase the value, then the increased value is my equity for mortgage so I didn't have to find a £20k cash deposit. Now, 12 months on, the house has a market value (for mortgage + compared to similar properties) of £145k, and I owe my relative under £125k for it.

Obviously if I must pay stamp duty on it, I will, however, if I can avoid it (legally) then I shall.

blundey

23 posts

159 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
I did exactly this. Even with the gifted equity of 20k. I paid stamp duty for the amount Im paying for the house not including the gifted equity. On a 170,000 house, i paid 1500 stamp duty as 20,000 was gifted deposit.

I have a letter from my solicitor explaining this if you want me to forward it to you...

message me your email if interested.

caziques

2,849 posts

199 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
IANAL

To me the house is being sold under stamp duty threshold, therefore nothing to pay - as that is the amount of money changing hands. As this arrangement is not tax evasion (in my opinion) HMRC should be OK (no intent to avoid tax by having an artificial value)

The OP could of course trash the place again to ensure there was nothing to pay.

Mr GrimNasty

8,172 posts

201 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
broken biscuit said:
The house is being sold for under £125k. It was bought by my relative for this price 12 months ago as a trashed repossession. I renovated the property, and moved in. The idea was for me to do the work over a year to increase the value, then the increased value is my equity for mortgage so I didn't have to find a £20k cash deposit. Now, 12 months on, the house has a market value (for mortgage + compared to similar properties) of £145k, and I owe my relative under £125k for it.

Obviously if I must pay stamp duty on it, I will, however, if I can avoid it (legally) then I shall.
I think you've wandered into an iffy area because SDLT is assessed on the whole consideration paid for the property, that will include cash (possibly from mortgage) and other types of payment. So effectively you've paid £125K + a year's work valued at £20K (or whatever). If it was just a genuine £20K gift/discount I don't think you'd have a problem. It probably comes down to how you dress it up/how scrupulously honest you want to be.

NPI

1,310 posts

155 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
caziques said:
IANAL

To me the house is being sold under stamp duty threshold, therefore nothing to pay - as that is the amount of money changing hands. As this arrangement is not tax evasion (in my opinion) HMRC should be OK (no intent to avoid tax by having an artificial value)

The OP could of course trash the place again to ensure there was nothing to pay.
But for the mortgage deal he wants he needs his lender to value the property at £145K. Which they have, hence his solicitor has got the willies.

broken biscuit

Original Poster:

1,633 posts

232 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
blundey said:
I did exactly this. Even with the gifted equity of 20k. I paid stamp duty for the amount Im paying for the house not including the gifted equity. On a 170,000 house, i paid 1500 stamp duty as 20,000 was gifted deposit.

I have a letter from my solicitor explaining this if you want me to forward it to you...

message me your email if interested.
You have email. Cheers

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
surveyor said:
Nothing Government lead is that simple.

In certain circumstances the SDLT can be based on the Market Value of something rather than price paid.
Are there examples of what "certain circumstances" are? Be interested to know.

Also, if I want to give my house to someone (related or otherwise), will the govt. want them to pay stamp duty on the "value" (determined by whom?) of the property?