Given a ticket whilst queuing on a bus stop
Given a ticket whilst queuing on a bus stop
Author
Discussion

rewc

Original Poster:

2,187 posts

264 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
A motorist who was waiting in a queue of traffic in Bradford has been handed a parking ticket.
Victor Hankins's car was filmed by a mobile traffic enforcement vehicle in a bus stop - while he was in a queue at a red traffic light.
The Council rescinded the notice after Mr Hawkins said he would see them in court.
A motorist who was waiting in a queue of traffic in Bradford has been handed a parking ticket.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leeds-2607451...

Pablo68

910 posts

166 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
scamming council spokesman said:
"When we find out that we have issued a penalty notice in error we cancel it and refund as appropriate.
What they mean is when they are caught out illegally trying to extort money and are threatened with court they back down.

Funny how they wouldn't uphold the blokes appeal against the ticket until he threatened to take them to court and would call the camera operator to court...all of a sudden they "realise" they made a mistake. It's pretty obvious from the camera film evidence he is waiting in a queue of traffic...begs the question how many acts of knowingly extorting money do councils get away with daily?

evilmunkey

1,377 posts

190 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
I had issues with Bradford last year. We were going to the Museum of film and photography. the sign showing directions took me up a road that suddenly became a bus lane with no where else to go but forward into it. No signs to warn of this anywhere and the bus lane was only about 30 foot in length. got a ticket in the post. disputed it and said i will go to court..... case dropped and new signage put up.

covboy

2,593 posts

205 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
evilmunkey said:
I had issues with Bradford last year. We were going to the Museum of film and photography. the sign showing directions took me up a road that suddenly became a bus lane with no where else to go but forward into it. No signs to warn of this anywhere and the bus lane was only about 30 foot in length. got a ticket in the post. disputed it and said i will go to court..... case dropped and new signage put up.
You were lucky



http://www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/midlands-news...

Nimby

5,745 posts

181 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
covboy said:
How do you "secretly" put up road signs? Are they draped in invisibility cloaks?

Mutley

3,178 posts

290 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
Nimby said:
covboy said:
How do you "secretly" put up road signs? Are they draped in invisibility cloaks?
You do it in the wee hours of the night when the majority of roads are empty

g3org3y

22,523 posts

222 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
Pablo68 said:
scamming council spokesman said:
"When we find out that we have issued a penalty notice in error we cancel it and refund as appropriate.
What they mean is when they are caught out illegally trying to extort money and are threatened with court they back down.

Funny how they wouldn't uphold the blokes appeal against the ticket until he threatened to take them to court and would call the camera operator to court...all of a sudden they "realise" they made a mistake. It's pretty obvious from the camera film evidence he is waiting in a queue of traffic...begs the question how many acts of knowingly extorting money do councils get away with daily?
Indeed. Quite scandalous imo.

Edit to add, the recent thread with the chap accused of throwing litter out of his car is very much an example of this frankly outrageous attitude towards the public.


Edited by g3org3y on Friday 7th February 15:21

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
We shouldn't be too quick to blame an entire authority for the over zealous actions of individuals, of course.

I've worked in Bradford for the past 16 months (not any more, hooray!). On my first day at work the pay and display ticket fell off my dash as I slammed the door shut and I duly got a PCN. I sent a digital photo of my ticket to the council, who immediately cancelled the PCN and sent me a little plastic ticket holder to go on the windscreen.


herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
Pablo68 said:
scamming council spokesman said:
"When we find out that we have issued a penalty notice in error we cancel it and refund as appropriate.
What they mean is when they are caught out illegally trying to extort money and are threatened with court they back down.

Funny how they wouldn't uphold the blokes appeal against the ticket until he threatened to take them to court and would call the camera operator to court...all of a sudden they "realise" they made a mistake. It's pretty obvious from the camera film evidence he is waiting in a queue of traffic...begs the question how many acts of knowingly extorting money do councils get away with daily?
Does it say they wouldn't uphold his appeal?

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
I'd like to start seeing these pond life behind the CCTV being dragged into court and then sued as individuals by those they're trying to steal from. Maybe when a few of their mates start feeling the bite of the law themselves they'll think again. Maybe then we can revert to motoring laws being designed around safety and enforced as such, rather than being a means of boosting profits.

Ian Geary

5,651 posts

223 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
I agree.

Is there some sort of process of review the footage goes through prior to action I wonder? A FoI to the council about this case would be a good start.

Also, you could ask whether in this case, these checks were done.


Ian

rewc

Original Poster:

2,187 posts

264 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
herewego said:
Does it say they wouldn't uphold his appeal?
I read a local paper report which says the sequence of events was;

Penalty notice issued which driver queried and appealed against.
The appeal was dismissed and a still photo of the car and bus stop markings only issued.
The motorist 'withdrew' the appeal and said he would see them in court.
The penalty was rescinded and apology made.

So yes the initial appeal was refused.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
rewc said:
herewego said:
Does it say they wouldn't uphold his appeal?
I read a local paper report which says the sequence of events was;

Penalty notice issued which driver queried and appealed against.
The appeal was dismissed and a still photo of the car and bus stop markings only issued.
The motorist 'withdrew' the appeal and said he would see them in court.
The penalty was rescinded and apology made.

So yes the initial appeal was refused.
Thanks, makes it clearer.

Terminator X

21,014 posts

235 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
It can't go to Court though can it? Independent arbitrator perhaps ...

TX.

Terminator X

21,014 posts

235 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
We shouldn't be too quick to blame an entire authority for the over zealous actions of individuals, of course.

I've worked in Bradford for the past 16 months (not any more, hooray!). On my first day at work the pay and display ticket fell off my dash as I slammed the door shut and I duly got a PCN. I sent a digital photo of my ticket to the council, who immediately cancelled the PCN and sent me a little plastic ticket holder to go on the windscreen.
You were lucky as the offence is non display of course.

TX.

rewc

Original Poster:

2,187 posts

264 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
Terminator X said:
It can't go to Court though can it? Independent arbitrator perhaps ...

TX.
Traffic Penalty Appeals Tribunal outside London. In London it is PATAS.

In the circumstances I wonder if the driver could have started a civil action against the council if all else failed?

Edited by rewc on Friday 7th February 21:44

Flibble

6,538 posts

212 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
supermono said:
I'd like to start seeing these pond life behind the CCTV being dragged into court and then sued as individuals by those they're trying to steal from. Maybe when a few of their mates start feeling the bite of the law themselves they'll think again. Maybe then we can revert to motoring laws being designed around safety and enforced as such, rather than being a means of boosting profits.
Why would you sue as individuals someone who is just doing their job? Would you like to be individually sued for any faults committed by your company? That could get very expensive and kind of defeats the point of a limited company...

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
Flibble said:
Why would you sue as individuals someone who is just doing their job? Would you like to be individually sued for any faults committed by your company? That could get very expensive and kind of defeats the point of a limited company...
I would expect to be in court if I'd deliberately acted to defraud my clients. Indeed I would also be if I accidentally caused them losses so I'm insured against that. A company director has legal obligations.

If someone is falling below the standard of care necessary and issuing the invoices there are proper real victims here and they should be able to have satisfaction against the perpetrator. We're not talking about someone just doing their job here we're talking about crazed CCTV operators desperately getting their fines in because they love it, and not letting the detail of road markings at the speed camera, slip effect, being stuck at a traffic light or terribly constructed junction get in their way.

Suing them would be an excellent way of stopping this overnight. And you want it stopped surely?

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
Watching the video, all the vehicles in the line appear to be where I'd expect them to be while driving in a lane whereas the one circled appears to be in the gutter.

Pablo68

910 posts

166 months

Sunday 9th February 2014
quotequote all
herewego said:
Watching the video, all the vehicles in the line appear to be where I'd expect them to be while driving in a lane whereas the one circled appears to be in the gutter.
He's not lined up perfectly with the car infront but engine on, lights on driver in seat, sat infront of another car and immediately behind another waiting at a red light who's position clearly indicates he has not driven around the circled car?

Which council traffic enforcement do you work for?