Advice please on 'Conditional offer' fixed penalty
Discussion
Good Evening folks,
Hoped I'd never need to ask the legal eagles in here for advice but sadly it seems after 13 'lucky' years I've come across a pc who was having a bad day/needed the paperwork/was making a point etc..
Late on the 3rd of January I was making my way home in a loan car from a garage that is rebuilding an engine for me.
It was 22.00 and I was the only car on the road just around the corner from my house, after going straight on at a round about a panda car (that I'd observed a long way before) pulled out behind me.
Knowing that one of the headlights on the car had gone I anticipated his lights coming on and had already planned a road about 100 yards ahead that I would pull into to avoid stopping on a main-ish road.
As the police man came up to the side of my car it soon became apparent that he was on a mission to get as many points possible from this 'pull'. As I was getting out of the car he immediately started to speak down to me about how I was clearly speeding and how he hates people that speed in residential (30) areas. I knew I hadn't been speeding, I had seen him from the other side of the roundabout and had gone past him and carried on at 30. Handily it turned out he had no speed measuring equipment on him anyway so he would let me off that. I remained calm, polite and direct with him through out.
He soon established the car was not mine, but that it was a garage loan car. Whilst I was giving over my details he asked for proof of insurance. I advised him that I am insured on the car under the garages policy - "no you're not, I've never heard of a policy like that" "I think we've got enough here to give you 12 points on your licence" etc etc
Meanwhile his colleague had been instructed by him to go round the car and check everything that he could find.
After checking my driving licence details and the vehicle details on the radio he came back to say he could find no record of me being insured on the car. He then read me my rights, arrested and put me in the back of his car. Whereby he gave me a producer for documents needed to drive the car. A 'fix it' notice which meant I had to take the car to an MOT station within the week with the issues sorted and he would leave it that. He would, however, give me a £100 fine for non display of the tax disc. Incidentaly the b/s that this guy spoke was really something, I didn't pick him up on any of it or disagree with him but he was coming out with some corkers such as doing me for driving without due care when I said "I don't think I was" in reply to his allegation of speeding.
So, I got the failed headlight and the two rear tyres sorted and legal. Took the car to an MOT station and then the stamped documents along with V5, MOT and copy of proof of insurance to the police station. Thinking that the most I'd hear of this now would be the £100 tax disc fine.
Fast forward to today I have 3 letters from the 'Cameras, tickets and collisions dept.
Letter 1; Conditional fixed penalty of £50 for 1 headlight out
Letter 2; Conditional fixed penalty of £100 for non display of tax disc
Letter 3; Conditional offer of fixed penalty of £100 and 3 points for low rear tyre tread.
Now, I really don't feel that this is fair bearing in mind it was not my vehicle and I sorted the above faults within a week and took all paper work to the station immediately.
I currently have a clean licence with 13 years experience and have had 3 points for speeding 9 years ago.
Should I appeal and take it to court to fight my case? Or should I take it on the chin and think of all the times I've dealt with nice coppers?
Many thanks for the advice.
Hoped I'd never need to ask the legal eagles in here for advice but sadly it seems after 13 'lucky' years I've come across a pc who was having a bad day/needed the paperwork/was making a point etc..
Late on the 3rd of January I was making my way home in a loan car from a garage that is rebuilding an engine for me.
It was 22.00 and I was the only car on the road just around the corner from my house, after going straight on at a round about a panda car (that I'd observed a long way before) pulled out behind me.
Knowing that one of the headlights on the car had gone I anticipated his lights coming on and had already planned a road about 100 yards ahead that I would pull into to avoid stopping on a main-ish road.
As the police man came up to the side of my car it soon became apparent that he was on a mission to get as many points possible from this 'pull'. As I was getting out of the car he immediately started to speak down to me about how I was clearly speeding and how he hates people that speed in residential (30) areas. I knew I hadn't been speeding, I had seen him from the other side of the roundabout and had gone past him and carried on at 30. Handily it turned out he had no speed measuring equipment on him anyway so he would let me off that. I remained calm, polite and direct with him through out.
He soon established the car was not mine, but that it was a garage loan car. Whilst I was giving over my details he asked for proof of insurance. I advised him that I am insured on the car under the garages policy - "no you're not, I've never heard of a policy like that" "I think we've got enough here to give you 12 points on your licence" etc etc
Meanwhile his colleague had been instructed by him to go round the car and check everything that he could find.
After checking my driving licence details and the vehicle details on the radio he came back to say he could find no record of me being insured on the car. He then read me my rights, arrested and put me in the back of his car. Whereby he gave me a producer for documents needed to drive the car. A 'fix it' notice which meant I had to take the car to an MOT station within the week with the issues sorted and he would leave it that. He would, however, give me a £100 fine for non display of the tax disc. Incidentaly the b/s that this guy spoke was really something, I didn't pick him up on any of it or disagree with him but he was coming out with some corkers such as doing me for driving without due care when I said "I don't think I was" in reply to his allegation of speeding.
So, I got the failed headlight and the two rear tyres sorted and legal. Took the car to an MOT station and then the stamped documents along with V5, MOT and copy of proof of insurance to the police station. Thinking that the most I'd hear of this now would be the £100 tax disc fine.
Fast forward to today I have 3 letters from the 'Cameras, tickets and collisions dept.
Letter 1; Conditional fixed penalty of £50 for 1 headlight out
Letter 2; Conditional fixed penalty of £100 for non display of tax disc
Letter 3; Conditional offer of fixed penalty of £100 and 3 points for low rear tyre tread.
Now, I really don't feel that this is fair bearing in mind it was not my vehicle and I sorted the above faults within a week and took all paper work to the station immediately.
I currently have a clean licence with 13 years experience and have had 3 points for speeding 9 years ago.
Should I appeal and take it to court to fight my case? Or should I take it on the chin and think of all the times I've dealt with nice coppers?
Many thanks for the advice.
Sounds like he may have been a bit of a jobsworth.
HOWEVER....regardless of who actually owns the car, you the driver, are automatically the user and so you have no defence over the tyres, and the fact you even admit that you knew the light was out?! Its your duty to check the roadworthiness of the car and choose to ask for another one or that one to be fixed before you use it on the road. That being said, the garage are also liable for causing/permitting the vehicle to be used in that condition.
And arrested???? Are you sure you were arrested? You can be cautioned (read your rights) without being under arrest. I can't imagine you were actually arrested in these circa?
HOWEVER....regardless of who actually owns the car, you the driver, are automatically the user and so you have no defence over the tyres, and the fact you even admit that you knew the light was out?! Its your duty to check the roadworthiness of the car and choose to ask for another one or that one to be fixed before you use it on the road. That being said, the garage are also liable for causing/permitting the vehicle to be used in that condition.
And arrested???? Are you sure you were arrested? You can be cautioned (read your rights) without being under arrest. I can't imagine you were actually arrested in these circa?
Were you given an official "Vehicle Defect Rectification Notice" in relation to the headlight and tyres or was it an unofficial "get them fixed ASAP"? If you were given a VDRN then that states that no further action will be taken in relation to the offences if the Notice is complied with (I.e. problems sorted, stamped at MOT station & returned to Police within 14 days).
Therefore you shouldn't be prosecuted for the headlight & tyre offences if the VDRN was complied with fully. Did you keep the original or a copy after you returned it to the police station? If you have a copy then it should have the MOT stamp & the station stamp from when you produced it with the insurance. If you do have it then you would appear to have a case for the prosecution relating to the headlight & tyres to be dropped.
Individual forces procedures differ, in some places when a VDRN is returned a copy is sent to the Central Ticket Office to be registered & they then forward it to the cop who then does the paperwork themselves. If it goes missing in the post during any one of these journeys the cop won't know you've complied and so will raise the summons. It could well be that you are just a victim of circumstance like this.
Therefore you shouldn't be prosecuted for the headlight & tyre offences if the VDRN was complied with fully. Did you keep the original or a copy after you returned it to the police station? If you have a copy then it should have the MOT stamp & the station stamp from when you produced it with the insurance. If you do have it then you would appear to have a case for the prosecution relating to the headlight & tyres to be dropped.
Individual forces procedures differ, in some places when a VDRN is returned a copy is sent to the Central Ticket Office to be registered & they then forward it to the cop who then does the paperwork themselves. If it goes missing in the post during any one of these journeys the cop won't know you've complied and so will raise the summons. It could well be that you are just a victim of circumstance like this.
Edited by Juliet1981 on Saturday 8th February 18:35
Thank you for your replies.
Yes, he was a jobsworth. A jobsworth that was full of lies and threats. I appreciate you guys only have my side of the story but I promise you I was smiley, helpful, to the point and honest with him the entire 30 mins.
I knew the light was out because it had come up on the cars computer. It was something I didn't fix the same day it happened. In the eyes of the law clearly I should have. But - there is usually some leniency on this. Plus the copper actually stated he would only fine me for the non display of tax disc!
The extra fines and points on my licence I did not expect.

Juliet1981 - Thank you so much for the advice! Yes, I was given a Vehicle Defect Rectification Notice which I complied with within 7 days.
I have kept photocopies of everything along with the badge number of the officer and time / date I handed it all to.
So - should I go to court or is there another way?
Yes, he was a jobsworth. A jobsworth that was full of lies and threats. I appreciate you guys only have my side of the story but I promise you I was smiley, helpful, to the point and honest with him the entire 30 mins.
I knew the light was out because it had come up on the cars computer. It was something I didn't fix the same day it happened. In the eyes of the law clearly I should have. But - there is usually some leniency on this. Plus the copper actually stated he would only fine me for the non display of tax disc!
The extra fines and points on my licence I did not expect.
N Dentressangle said:
You are Andrew Mitchell, AICMFP. 
Pass, will I need to Google that? 

Juliet1981 - Thank you so much for the advice! Yes, I was given a Vehicle Defect Rectification Notice which I complied with within 7 days.
I have kept photocopies of everything along with the badge number of the officer and time / date I handed it all to.
So - should I go to court or is there another way?
I would get in touch with your forces equivalent to the Traffic Process Unit, and explain the whole thing to them. It may well be an admin error. Doesn't excuse the poor condition of the car, but you should t have been told one thing, and then dealt with differently. It helps that you have the original VDRS, so phone the TPU and see what they have to say.
Right - plan of action for Monday will be to follow up the Traffic Unit with the photocopies of the forms.
Thank you again for the advice. I had not seen a Vehicle Rectification Notice before so was not aware of what they meant. As I said the pc had advised I'd only see a fine for lack of tax disc.
Have now Googled the Andrew Mitchell chap, seems he had some sort of driving offence? Not sure I follow still..
Thank you again for the advice. I had not seen a Vehicle Rectification Notice before so was not aware of what they meant. As I said the pc had advised I'd only see a fine for lack of tax disc.
Have now Googled the Andrew Mitchell chap, seems he had some sort of driving offence? Not sure I follow still..
MrMoonyMan said:
Juliet1981 - Thank you so much for the advice! Yes, I was given a Vehicle Defect Rectification Notice which I complied with within 7 days.
I have kept photocopies of everything along with the badge number of the officer and time / date I handed it all to.
So - should I go to court or is there another way?
As you have just received the letter with the offer of fixed penalty then you should have a little while before the end of the offer period so my first step would be to contact the Central Ticket Office (sorry can't remember what dept name yours came from & names seem to get changed to all sorts of things on a regular basis nowadays) and tell them that you were told that you would not be prosecuted if you complied with the notice, that you did so & still have a photocopy after handing the original in at xxxx police station on xxxx date.I have kept photocopies of everything along with the badge number of the officer and time / date I handed it all to.
So - should I go to court or is there another way?
You may find that they check up on this and then rescind the fixed penalty if they realise they've made a mistake. If they do then it's all sorted nice and easily. If they don't rescind the offers then you will have to make the decision about whether to refuse the offer and opt for a Court appearance.
If you do go for a Court appearance then having the copy of the VDRN should stand you in good stead if you have FULLY complied with it conditions. However if the Court decide to convict you then the fine will be greater than that in the fixed penalty offer.
Obviously with only one side of the story it's difficult to say which way a verdict will go, but taking what you have said at face value you are, by your own admission, guilty of the offences but yet took up an offer from the police to fix them and so not be prosecuted! I don't know how legally binding the terms of the Vehicle Defect Rectification Scheme are, it's something that I was always told was a voluntary scheme and so don't think it's terms as they apply in your case have ever been tested in Court so it may or may not be a straight forward fight at Court.
Good plan. They should be best places to guide you.
The VDRS are designed to prevent you being fined/going to court. That's the whole point. It's a way of educating drivers without the need for prosecution, so it sounds like you've been hard done by getting the fines as well.
Don't worry about the Mitchell thing...unless you want to get into a long winded, IMO, quite boring debate about speed and it's relation with safety or otherwise.
The VDRS are designed to prevent you being fined/going to court. That's the whole point. It's a way of educating drivers without the need for prosecution, so it sounds like you've been hard done by getting the fines as well.
Don't worry about the Mitchell thing...unless you want to get into a long winded, IMO, quite boring debate about speed and it's relation with safety or otherwise.
See this thread.
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/53/sectio...
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/53/sectio...
Edited by agtlaw on Saturday 8th February 19:26
With reference to Conditional Offers 1 & 3 I believe the problem is that the VDRS form should have been sent to the CTO or wherever else was specified on it not taken to a Police Station. The CTO forward it to the issuing Officer who then clears it from the system. I expect that the issuing Officer has not been informed of it by the Police Station you took it to as they do not deal with them.
0a said:
Yep, while it keeps happening...
In for a penny....Please show me official statistics that show the average experience of a mop is an admin error and an over zealous police officer.
Ok, that's a tough one. Please show me statistics that the average police experience is a bad one?
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


