Are threats like this illegal?
Discussion
Aretnap said:
I wonder... does any sort of threat... say a threat to take legal action when it is not justified also break the law?Mill Wheel said:
I wonder... does any sort of threat... say a threat to take legal action when it is not justified also break the law?
Mostly these are covered by blackmail (theft act) being demands with menaces - which are only fine if the menace is a reasonable way to pursue the demand.If you don't pay me, I'll take you to court. <- reasonable action
If you don't pay me, I'll biff you on the nose.<- not reasonable (might also be public order offence)
If you don't pay me, I'll tell your wife about that affair. <- not reasonable?
Pay me. I'm going to tell your wife about that affair. <- not contingent?
Obviously any threat to commit criminal damage is unlawful. The defence here would, I presume, be that they did not intend that anyone would believe it.
We had one chap who put out cones to stop cars parking outside his house. When it was pointed out that this was unlawful after he complained that they were continually being handed in as found property, he had a number of sticky labels printed which he stuck onto the screens on habitual parkers. The adhesive required some work to remove. A PC got a call to a 'fight', an argument in fact, a bloke had parked his car there and 'loitered' and then confronted the chap, sticky labels in hand. When it was pointed out to the householder that his actions amounted to criminal damage a supervisor was called - me.
Despite repeatedly asking him to destroy said labels and give an undertaking that he would not put them on other cars, he refused and was arrested for a number of offences of threats to commit criminal damage, although all charged as one, and, after what he said in interview, criminal damage to three cars where we had a complainant, the loitering chap being part of an upset group.
He would have been cautioned had he followed his solicitor's advice to agree not to stick labels on cars again. At court he said he would continue to stick said labels on cars and the arresting officer's suggestion to the court that a conditional discharge would be OK if he accepted what he did was wrong, was reluctantly ignored. He got quite heavily fined. I left the division soon after so do not know if my suspicion, that this would escalate into an ECHR case, were correct.
We had one chap who put out cones to stop cars parking outside his house. When it was pointed out that this was unlawful after he complained that they were continually being handed in as found property, he had a number of sticky labels printed which he stuck onto the screens on habitual parkers. The adhesive required some work to remove. A PC got a call to a 'fight', an argument in fact, a bloke had parked his car there and 'loitered' and then confronted the chap, sticky labels in hand. When it was pointed out to the householder that his actions amounted to criminal damage a supervisor was called - me.
Despite repeatedly asking him to destroy said labels and give an undertaking that he would not put them on other cars, he refused and was arrested for a number of offences of threats to commit criminal damage, although all charged as one, and, after what he said in interview, criminal damage to three cars where we had a complainant, the loitering chap being part of an upset group.
He would have been cautioned had he followed his solicitor's advice to agree not to stick labels on cars again. At court he said he would continue to stick said labels on cars and the arresting officer's suggestion to the court that a conditional discharge would be OK if he accepted what he did was wrong, was reluctantly ignored. He got quite heavily fined. I left the division soon after so do not know if my suspicion, that this would escalate into an ECHR case, were correct.
Mill Wheel said:
Aretnap said:
I wonder... does any sort of threat... say a threat to take legal action when it is not justified also break the law?V8RX7 said:
Derek Smith said:
I left the division soon after so do not know if my suspicion, that this would escalate into an ECHR case, were correct.
His Right to stick labels on cars ?I'm unaware of that one.
Although with the EU it's a possibility

His missus stayed in the house, looking out the window. After the arrest I assumed she'd appear, but didn't. Before I drove off I knocked on the door and she appeared, looking totally disinterested. I told her that, in my opinion, we should get him to agree to a caution, but her disagreement with my estimate of the situation was apparent.
The PC sent the brief in, telling him that all we wanted was a straight apology and agreement that he would not do the same again. What could be easier?
I seem to remember a story where a householder got miffed with people using the end of his drive to turn round. So he put some heavy obstructions out, think of concrete cones as a best description. Apparently the local school kids, who hated him for other reasons, got some epoxy super duper adhesive and stuck the things in place.
Derek Smith said:
When it was pointed out to the householder that his actions amounted to criminal damage a supervisor was called - me.
I think calling it criminal damage is absurd and means that every copper who's ever posted a parking ticket has broken the same law.I wonder why you didn't deal with the anti-social parking with such stridence?
Edited by Martin4x4 on Monday 10th February 13:46
Martin4x4 said:
Derek Smith said:
When it was pointed out to the householder that his actions amounted to criminal damage a supervisor was called - me.
I think calling it criminal damage is absurd and means that every copper who's ever posted a parking ticket has broken the same law.I wonder why you didn't deal with the anti-social parking with such stridence?
Edited by Martin4x4 on Monday 10th February 13:46
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




