Trial of PC caught Huhning ends - may be retried.
Trial of PC caught Huhning ends - may be retried.
Author
Discussion

Mill Wheel

Original Poster:

6,149 posts

227 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-bristol-26122...

BBC News said:
Portishead PC speed points trial jury discharged
The jury in the trial of a police officer from Portishead who allegedly accepted speeding points for his girlfriend has been discharged.

PC Alex Owen, 31, wrongly claimed to have been driving Nina East's car after she was caught in a speed check, Gloucester Crown Court heard.

The couple, who both work for Avon and Somerset Police, denied conspiracy to pervert the course of justice.

They maintained they had made an honest mistake about who had been driving.

It is alleged PC Owen said he was driving 34-year-old Ms East's car to prevent her losing her licence.

Police are to discuss with the CPS whether to seek a retrial.
More here...
http://www.bristolpost.co.uk/Jury-Bristol-police-s...

Given Vicky Pryce's trial went to a second round after the jury failed to reach a verdict, is there not a precedent for these cases going into extra time with a second jury?

And How much of a majority is considered acceptable for a majority verdict to be brought in?

abc2011

58 posts

183 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Are juries getting more... indecisive? There seem to be an awful lot of juries being discharged recently.

Or maybe I'm just noticing it more after reading threads on here about Jury Service.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
I don't think two examples have much statistical reliability somehow...

GALLARDOGUY

8,160 posts

250 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Genuine mistake about who was driving??

How hard is it??

Do you think he would may such a mistake when pulling you or I over??

Like hell he would.

He's a fking liar.


anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
GALLARDOGUY said:
Do you think he would may such a mistake when pulling you or I over?
Probably not since when pulling you over it'd be quite easy to see who was driving wink

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
From the newspaper report he's plainly & simply lying; claiming to be driving when obviously elsewhere.

It doesn't seem a particularly complicated case.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Best pop down to the Crown Court and tell the jury to "read the news paper report", then biggrin

If only the Judge had thought of that!

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
These cases aren't easy for the jury if all there is to go on is the word of one group against another, particularly when the result is a prison sentence. Remember, the jury have to be SURE the couple are lying, not just think they might be.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
La Liga said:
Best pop down to the Crown Court and tell the jury to "read the news paper report", then biggrin

If only the Judge had thought of that!
Quite.
It's abundantly obvious that the newspapers do so much more research and investigation.
Also their internal standards on truth are much much more stringent than the courts, none of this silly 'reasonable doubt' for them.

If a newspaper says someone is guilty we should save the taxpayers money and just convict based on that.

Oh, but only for police though.
Non police are entitled to a full jury and trial with every bit of evidence reviewed and every comment from a police officer doubted. But obviously police shouldn't have this. They should just be fired, jailed and have their obscene pension stripped from them.

Oh, and made to apologise for Hillsborough too.

Mill Wheel

Original Poster:

6,149 posts

227 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
These cases aren't easy for the jury if all there is to go on is the word of one group against another, particularly when the result is a prison sentence. Remember, the jury have to be SURE the couple are lying, not just think they might be.
Especially since most of the jury wouldn't expect a police officer to lie in court?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Mill Wheel said:
10 Pence Short said:
These cases aren't easy for the jury if all there is to go on is the word of one group against another, particularly when the result is a prison sentence. Remember, the jury have to be SURE the couple are lying, not just think they might be.
Especially since most of the jury wouldn't expect a police officer to lie in court?
Really?

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Mill Wheel said:
Given Vicky Pryce's trial went to a second round after the jury failed to reach a verdict, is there not a precedent for these cases going into extra time with a second jury?
What do you mean by precedent? There are a number of factors to consider in deciding whether to seek a retrial, including the chance of a conviction second time round, the public interest and the availability of witnesses. The fact that someone, somewhere was once retried for a superficially similar offence would not be a major factor in deciding whether to seek a retrial.

Mill Wheel said:
And How much of a majority is considered acceptable for a majority verdict to be brought in?
10-2

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
It is simple really. They were accused of perverting the course of justice and the prosecution couldn't satisfy the jury for them to find guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

I do not see how the prosecution could prove the case without some real evidence as they had in the Huhne case. Two people claim they thought they gave the correct information when filling out the S172, how do you prove they were not simply mistaken but were attempting to pervert the course of justice?

If they both stick to their story then very difficult to prove.

Dave Hedgehog

16,375 posts

235 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
GALLARDOGUY said:
Genuine mistake about who was driving??

How hard is it??
me and my OH drive each others cars all the time, i wouldn't have a clue who was driving what when after a few weeks


Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
La Liga said:
If only the Judge had thought of that!
The judge is probably a very smart cookie- it's juries that can be a bit dumb sometimes.

As I said, it seems uncomplicated: he said he was driving, there either is or isn't proof that he was elsewhere.

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
As I said, it seems uncomplicated: he said he was driving, there either is or isn't proof that he was elsewhere.
There's also the little matter of proving intent.

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
The judge is probably a very smart cookie- it's juries that can be a bit dumb sometimes.

As I said, it seems uncomplicated: he said he was driving, there either is or isn't proof that he was elsewhere.
It does not matter if there is subsequent proof that he was elsewhere. When you fill in the S172 it is your belief of the events under investigation. I am sure that the jury are not dumb but I am sure that the prosecution couldn't prove to them beyond reasonable doubt that it was not a mistaken belief but an attempt to pervert the course of justice.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Aretnap said:
There's also the little matter of proving intent.
GPWM

jbsportstech

5,069 posts

210 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Mill Wheel said:
More here...
http://www.bristolpost.co.uk/Jury-Bristol-police-s...

Given Vicky Pryce's trial went to a second round after the jury failed to reach a verdict, is there not a precedent for these cases going into extra time with a second jury?

And How much of a majority is considered acceptable for a majority verdict to be brought in?
Honestly avon and somerset have a culture of cops who bend the rules big style. Some of their officers really do think they are god. Fidling speeding tickets for each other is not uncommon. The previous CC signed them up to southwest one partnership of which he was a board director for all their procurment not thinking it was a conflict of interest. He then got his wife a consulants job for the council part of the contract and she was paid £300k for 3 months work bent as a nine bob note nwas colin port he knew his days were numbered when pcc came in a resigned within hours of hearing the news she had won. They have had numerous cases of not following the law and had cases thrown out because of the way evidence was obtained and the cc has defied a court order before now when they are caught out.

Need a big culture change which hopefully will come with pcc and new cc.


Edited by jbsportstech on Tuesday 11th February 11:07

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
rewc said:
It is simple really. They were accused of perverting the course of justice and the prosecution couldn't satisfy the jury for them to find guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

I do not see how the prosecution could prove the case without some real evidence as they had in the Huhne case. Two people claim they thought they gave the correct information when filling out the S172, how do you prove they were not simply mistaken but were attempting to pervert the course of justice?

If they both stick to their story then very difficult to prove.
To play the Devil's advocate. Perhaps this wouldn't have even seen a court room had it not been a police officer. Perhaps sending flimsy, unrealistic trials to court where it wouldn't have been sent it if were not a police officer does little to help the perception of justice.

rewc said:
Rovinghawk said:
The judge is probably a very smart cookie- it's juries that can be a bit dumb sometimes.

As I said, it seems uncomplicated: he said he was driving, there either is or isn't proof that he was elsewhere.
It does not matter if there is subsequent proof that he was elsewhere. When you fill in the S172 it is your belief of the events under investigation. I am sure that the jury are not dumb but I am sure that the prosecution couldn't prove to them beyond reasonable doubt that it was not a mistaken belief but an attempt to pervert the course of justice.
They're dumb because they've not given the result he wants, the result that MUST be correct based off the newspaper article.

Deflecting like this is really common. It allows us to blame others and retain our bias. We do not have to consider our viewpoint and that we may be wrong.

jbsportstech said:
Honestly avon and somerset have a culture of cops who bend the rules big style. Some of their officers really do think they are god. Fidling speeding tickets for each other is not uncommon.
So that makes it common, then? Where's the evidence that's the case?