MOT Advisories
Author
Discussion

motor mad

Original Poster:

474 posts

220 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Afternoon

I'm not sure if this is the right section to post in, so apologies if it's not.

I've just had my wife's car MOT'd. I was given an advisory as the O/S/F tyre is low on tread. When I looked at the report there's 3.97mm tread remaining. Does that sound a bit harsh? The car has only done 3,000 miles since the last MOT and at that rate, I'm more likely to replace the tyres because of perishing than a lack of tread. I wondered if there was a certain tread depth at which point it becomes an advisory? I'm by no means up in arms about it, more curious to know.

Also it was the first time we've had a car MOT'd since the arrival of our first child. I took all the baby related clobber out the boot, but left the car seat in place. This is another advisory as the belt can't be tested. It seems a bit odd to me, but at least next year when the MOT is due, I'll remove the car seat all together.

Thanks

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Irrelevant the MOT states the tyres are worn so what? As to the child seat they can't test the belt and as the rules and common sense prevent them from removing the seat to test the belt they note it.

motor mad

Original Poster:

474 posts

220 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Engineer1 said:
Irrelevant the MOT states the tyres are worn so what? As to the child seat they can't test the belt and as the rules and common sense prevent them from removing the seat to test the belt they note it.
As I said I'm curious to know. If I'd turned round to the MOT tester like I'm sure a percentage of people do and say "change the front tyres then", that's £250+ in their pocket. The reality is the tyres could quite easily last a fair while longer.

Common sense to me says that I wouldn't expect an adult to put their child in a car seat knowing the belt doesn't work. That's a different conversation.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Advisories aren't failures.
They are just advisories.

Don't worry about them.

I expect that one tyre is lower than the others.
This might hint to a problem with tracking or geo, it might be worth looking at.

If you are planning to sell the car it might be worth trying to get a clean not. But if you're keeping it then they are just things you need to be aware of.

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
motor mad said:
Common sense to me says that I wouldn't expect an adult to put their child in a car seat knowing the belt doesn't work. That's a different conversation.
Not really the MOT tester has been presented with a vehicle where one seatbelt can't be checked because it is securing a child seat, if the tester was to remove the seat to test the belt should he then leave the seat un-secured or attempt to re-fit? if he attempts to re-fit how does he know and prove he fitted it correctly?

I've got my daughter's seat in the back of my car and unless I have removed it I assume it is still fitted correctly so give it a basic check incase anything has moved.

motor mad

Original Poster:

474 posts

220 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
Advisories aren't failures.
They are just advisories.

Don't worry about them.

I expect that one tyre is lower than the others.
This might hint to a problem with tracking or geo, it might be worth looking at.

If you are planning to sell the car it might be worth trying to get a clean not. But if you're keeping it then they are just things you need to be aware of.
Thanks, I'm going to get the alignment looked at.

That was my rationale for wanting a clean MOT. I will be looking to sell the car for something with a bigger boot.

John145

2,862 posts

187 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Manufacturer recommendations are to replace tyres at 3mm of tread, so advisory is justified.

motor mad

Original Poster:

474 posts

220 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
John145 said:
Manufacturer recommendations are to replace tyres at 3mm of tread, so advisory is justified.
Thanks

Motorrad

6,811 posts

218 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
John145 said:
Manufacturer recommendations are to replace tyres at 3mm of tread, so advisory is justified.
There was nearly 4mm remaining and the legal limit is 1.6mm.

I'd have asked the tester what his reasoning was and if he'd like to reconsider. Seems to me like the fker was trying to drum up business for whatever mob he's in thrall to.

MGL1986

111 posts

171 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Motorrad said:
There was nearly 4mm remaining and the legal limit is 1.6mm.
So they have advised that there is 2.4mm or tread left, depending on mileage covered etc its quite possible the tyre would be below the legal limit by the next MOT.

SlackBladder

2,655 posts

234 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
MGL1986 said:
So they have advised that there is 2.4mm or tread left, depending on mileage covered etc its quite possible the tyre would be below the legal limit by the next MOT.
Maybe PH should give advisories as well in regard to reading the OP

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
MGL1986 said:
Motorrad said:
There was nearly 4mm remaining and the legal limit is 1.6mm.
So they have advised that there is 2.4mm or tread left, depending on mileage covered etc its quite possible the tyre would be below the legal limit by the next MOT.
Whislt true, it could also be said for brand new tyres (depending on mileage etc.)....

As said above, they're only advisables, I suspect MOT centres are being more forthright in putting these on the computers to help prevent a visit from VOSA. i.e. it "appears" that they are being thorough.

OldJohnnyYen

1,455 posts

180 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
You should be wondering why one tyre is wearing quick than another on the same axle.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
I'd quite like to know where you got a tread gauge that can reliably measure to ten microns...?

Look - it's quite simple. An MOT advisory is something the tester thinks you should be aware of. No more, no less.

JM

3,170 posts

237 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Advisories are just that, things you are being advised about.

At least they didn't fail you.

I was once 'failed' for low tyre tread, when there was over 2mm. The tester then wanted to charge for a full re-test after I had new tyres fitted the same day!


motor mad

Original Poster:

474 posts

220 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all

I'm not arguing the advisories! My question was at what depth of tread does a tyre get an advisory which has now been answered. The car seat was something I'd not really considered until I read the MOT cert.

williredale

2,866 posts

183 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
I normally put the extra rear seats up in my OH's Zafira for its MOT but didn't last time. The boot was full of wheels I was having the tyres taken off. The garage couldn't put them up so I got an advisory for untested belts and a 'sorry that's the rules' from the garage.

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
what sort of tyre was it?
winter tyres the manufacturers usually recommend you change them at 4mm instead of 3mm, they usually come with deep tread to account for this.
so an advisory for less than 4mm on a winter tyre would be sensible
on a summer it would be unnecessary

imagineifyeswill

1,250 posts

197 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
There is no particular limit where the tyre gets an advisory on wear its tester own opinion and just to let you know to keep an eye on it. In the case of the child seat, tester are spcifically told by VOSA on no account to disturb child seats, just advise belt not tested.

V8forweekends

2,506 posts

155 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Advisories are a total load of arse in my not very humble opinion. I've had them mysteriously disappear between MOTS (having not taken any action all) and had a different set every time - or none.

The "no advisories" thing that dealers use to tout their vehicles is meaningless and so very obviously a scam.