Temporary ramps – what requirements?
Temporary ramps – what requirements?
Author
Discussion

speedking31

Original Poster:

3,964 posts

167 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
Some roads are being resurfaced near me. On Thursday night in the dark I hit the transition 'ramp' between an area that had been planed and the pre-existing road surface, causing a puncture.

The speed limit is 40 mph, I estimate I was doing 30 mph.

I went back in daylight, and the ‘ramp’ is approximately 75 mm vertical face. This is formed by the front edge of the planing machine and no attempt has been made to introduce tarmac to make say a 45° slope.

Does anyone know if there are any regulations governing these ramps, i.e. should you be able to maintain the speed limit over the ramp? Is there a defined profile, e.g. no steeper than 30°?

I will write to the council when I know what the bill is. I assume they are responsible. Hopefully if anyone else has also suffered then the council will realise that the profile is not acceptable.

There was a temporary “RAMP” sign next to the ramp, but no advance warning and no lighting.

grumpy52

6,081 posts

197 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
Would you drive over a kerb at 30 mph ?
Just slow down , it's a speed limit not a target !

Vaud

60,024 posts

186 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
grumpy52 said:
Would you drive over a kerb at 30 mph ?
Just slow down , it's a speed limit not a target !
A 7.5cm vertical at the end of roadworks is pretty substantial. Sounds like a job done badly and/or they set the wrong speed limit for the conditions they created.

TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
grumpy52 said:
Would you drive over a kerb at 30 mph ?
Just slow down , it's a speed limit not a target !
Wow,you are just so clever.

What a helpful post too.


herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
When there are both road works and a ramp warning sign it would seem prudent to drive with extra care. I don't think it's reasonable to expect in those circumstances to be able to drive near the speed limit. You'd already dropped into the ground away area so should be aware that there must be rough ground and a ramp to come.

speedking31

Original Poster:

3,964 posts

167 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
I wouldn't drive over a kerb at 30, but wouldn't expect there to be a kerb across a road. As stated the limit is 40, so I had slowed down. With no reduced speed limit signs, one does not expect to have to do walking pace to avoid damage.

BritishRacinGrin

26,708 posts

191 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
Maybe if there was no 'RAMP' sign to warn you, you'd have cause to blame the council..

barker22

1,037 posts

198 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
BritishRacinGrin said:
Maybe if there was no 'RAMP' sign to warn you, you'd have cause to blame the council..
Ah but a ramp is supposed to be a ramp. Not a vertical face.

elwe

192 posts

251 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
The limit is 80mm. There is no requirement to angle the edge to make a ramp, it is allowed to be vertical.

andycaca

472 posts

159 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
80mm is crazy! at that height and being vertical, surely the only way to climb up and down without wheel and tyre damage would be at creeping pace which would bring any traffic in the area to a complete standstill.

i bet some jobsworth is at home this weekend having a right old laugh at all the havoc caused.

edit: doubt i need to say this, but take some photos on the daylight with a ruler to show scale. also signage etc.

topless360

2,763 posts

249 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
I don't know about the regulations but I shattered by front bumper and smashed a near irreplaceable fog lamp in one of those drop down ramp things, there was very limited signage and I was only doing about 20mph from memory.

The point is, you were already doing 10mph below the limit. Even at 20mph you may still have gotten a puncture, with a flat face like that you could argue that you'd need to slow to 5 or 10mph to avoid a puncture. Was there any signage to suggest a specific speed?

In my case, I went straight after the building contractors, the council pointed me in their direction. They ended up paying in full. I took plenty of pictures of the lack of signage, which is a good job as the day after my complaint they put up extra signs, which could be seen as an admission of guilt.

It took a bit of fighting my corner, but it's worth it for the right result. Good luck OP.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
Yes, good luck OP. In this day and age why should we be expected to be responsible for our own actions when it's so easy to get someone else to take the blame?

Stuartggray

7,703 posts

259 months

Sunday 16th February 2014
quotequote all
REALIST123 said:
Yes, good luck OP. In this day and age why should we be expected to be responsible for our own actions when it's so easy to get someone else to take the blame?
Good luck OP and ignore this tt. I had the same problem in the dark, no visible signs. Luckily my V70 on winter 195/65 15s absorbed the punch, but the Mercedes and Audi in front of me did not, and pulled in with damaged low profile alloys. I stopped and offered my services as a witness. I walked back to the offending cut out in the tarmac and saw it was a huge gouge on a road that is a 40 but was a 60 the week before. I wouldn't have taken it at 10 if I was given the chance to see it in daylight with road signs.

speedking31

Original Poster:

3,964 posts

167 months

Sunday 16th February 2014
quotequote all
REALIST123 said:
Yes, good luck OP. In this day and age why should we be expected to be responsible for our own actions when it's so easy to get someone else to take the blame?
I didn't construct a vehicle damaging ramp confused
Here are some pictures:
.
Not quite as vertical as it felt from inside the car, but looks like 45°.
.
You can see the edge of the road is built up, so the nearside tyre was fine.
.
This photo includes a 50p piece to give a sense of scale.

First round has been fired off to the council so we'll see what comes back.


Edited by speedking31 on Sunday 16th February 17:46


Edited by speedking31 on Sunday 16th February 17:47

Stinkfoot

2,245 posts

223 months

Sunday 16th February 2014
quotequote all
Sorry but that is terrible and completely unacceptable for a road serface. I can imagine what that would do to a motobike rider. I would certainly file a claim.

Vaud

60,024 posts

186 months

Sunday 16th February 2014
quotequote all
That would be ok for "very slow - steep RAMP - 10mph" but not in a 40.

The ramp is poor and the signage inappropriate.

Send it to your local free press as well, they love a ready made story with no costs to produce. Might not help or hinder your case, but better than reading about "Local school bench under threat"

EskimoArapaho

5,135 posts

166 months

Sunday 16th February 2014
quotequote all
OK. I can't see the vertical bit! Looks about 50 degrees in the photos.

And surely you knew there was a ramp coming along at some point, as you were driving along a scalped road (and had presumably been down another ramp beforehand)?

the_lone_wolf

2,622 posts

217 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Something doesn't add up here...

Planing 80mm of road surface would leave some pretty brutal raised ironworks, how did the OP maintain such a significant speed through the working area to hit the second ramp at 30mph?

How could such a huge change in surface not be seen in the car headlamps? Especially given the presence of a warning sign...

Surely if you've seen the warning sign and can't see the ramp you're being warned about it might be prudent to slow down in anticipation of the ramp being there? The ramp in the picture is harsher than most, but it's hardly the north face of Everest, it could easily be negotiated by just about any vehicle without damage being caused

speedking31

Original Poster:

3,964 posts

167 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Manholes and the down ramp had had additional tarmac manually pounded into the 'step' giving a much kinder angle of attack. As you can see in the photo the edges of the road had been built up with additional tarmac.

With hindsight obviously walking pace is the correct speed for this 'ramp'. I wish I had slowed further. But in my previous experience the contractors usually make the ramp into a ramp and don't leave a step.

But the question still stands as to whether there are any rules / guidance as to what constitutes a reasonable ramp. Poster above said 80 mm step is acceptable. What is the source for that?

BritishRacinGrin

26,708 posts

191 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Best of luck with it but I don't think the council are likely to entertain your claim. They'll argue that there is signage and that you were travelling at an inappropriate speed.

The ramp looks pretty much as I'd expect, I've certainly seen worse.