is my contract with LTD company or an individual ?
Discussion
Just wonderign if anyone can advise on the right course of action here -
I recently submittedpaperwork to small calims court against someone for work done at my home. The defendant submitted a defence on the last day he was able to do so claiming that the case should never have been brought against himself and that contract was with his LTD company and should suffer no damage to his credit history due to this.
I was advised by local trading standards that indeed his comapny had been LTD since 2009, despite thte fact that none of his glossy brochures or business cards (which I still have) have anything about his company being LTD written on them nor is there any reference to LTD on the hand written reciept I was given at the time of payment. All his paperwork has his company name and address on it but no mention of being LTD or a company number etc which i was advised was a break of companies house regulations.
Trading standards advised that I resubmit my small claims paperwork requesting a change in the defendants name to that of the LTDcompany name which would costy me an additional £45 ad it would have to in front of the district judge to be confirmed within 6 weeks.
So today I get a letter from the courts telling me that the district judge has deferred my application stating
"the claimant must clarify whether he agrees that his contract was with the ltd company or whether he does not"
Anyone know the best way forward?
I had assumed that I HAD to change the details to that of his
LTD company or face the case being thrown out of court due to me statimng his company name on the original paperwork without mention of it being LTD.
Leghally I just dont know where I stand and seem to be getting conflicting advice from trading standards each time I speak to them.
I recently submittedpaperwork to small calims court against someone for work done at my home. The defendant submitted a defence on the last day he was able to do so claiming that the case should never have been brought against himself and that contract was with his LTD company and should suffer no damage to his credit history due to this.
I was advised by local trading standards that indeed his comapny had been LTD since 2009, despite thte fact that none of his glossy brochures or business cards (which I still have) have anything about his company being LTD written on them nor is there any reference to LTD on the hand written reciept I was given at the time of payment. All his paperwork has his company name and address on it but no mention of being LTD or a company number etc which i was advised was a break of companies house regulations.
Trading standards advised that I resubmit my small claims paperwork requesting a change in the defendants name to that of the LTDcompany name which would costy me an additional £45 ad it would have to in front of the district judge to be confirmed within 6 weeks.
So today I get a letter from the courts telling me that the district judge has deferred my application stating
"the claimant must clarify whether he agrees that his contract was with the ltd company or whether he does not"
Anyone know the best way forward?
I had assumed that I HAD to change the details to that of his
LTD company or face the case being thrown out of court due to me statimng his company name on the original paperwork without mention of it being LTD.
Leghally I just dont know where I stand and seem to be getting conflicting advice from trading standards each time I speak to them.
ORD said:
If it were me, I would have both the individual and the company as Defendants and refer to the documents and other evidence suggesting that the contract was with the individual.
(This is not legal advice and is not to be relied upon as such.)
As far as I am aware you arent allowed to do that.(This is not legal advice and is not to be relied upon as such.)
I submitted my paper work against him personally purely as he was the single point of contact I had originally had and was at no time made aware that his company was a LTD entity.
PurpleMoonlight said:
Poor advice from CAB if you ask me.
All the documentation you have is as a sole trader not a Ltd. Stick with your claim against him personally and don't let him try to hide behind a Ltd.
this is what I had originally thought, I dealt with him directly and never had anything other than the peper work he gave me which i still have ,but on checking his website the final contact page does NOW have Limited after the company name and a companies house number.All the documentation you have is as a sole trader not a Ltd. Stick with your claim against him personally and don't let him try to hide behind a Ltd.
I am just nervous about letting the case go to court and the judge throw it out due to the case being brought against the wrong party. All the paperwork does have his company name and the same address, but definately no mention of the company being LTD.
The courts refuse to give any advice and I have alreayy stated what trading standards last advised. I did think that if the case against his company failed taht I would be able to persue him directly due to this but it will just drag on for months and months and may not even be the case, so I really need to decide which is the more likely to succeed in the face of a judge. I have been advised that the district judge certainly wont like him using this as his defence.
He can try to defend the claim on the basis that he personally did not undertake any work, but he would need to satisfy the Judge that was true. Based on what evidence you have I would say he will struggle.
Seems like a liability avoidance scam to me, do the work as a sole trader and if anything goes wrong claim you are a Ltd.
When was the Ltd established and has it filed previous accounts?
Seems like a liability avoidance scam to me, do the work as a sole trader and if anything goes wrong claim you are a Ltd.
When was the Ltd established and has it filed previous accounts?
PurpleMoonlight said:
He can try to defend the claim on the basis that he personally did not undertake any work, but he would need to satisfy the Judge that was true. Based on what evidence you have I would say he will struggle.
Seems like a liability avoidance scam to me, do the work as a sole trader and if anything goes wrong claim you are a Ltd.
When was the Ltd established and has it filed previous accounts?
it certainly wreaks of avoidance to me also.Seems like a liability avoidance scam to me, do the work as a sole trader and if anything goes wrong claim you are a Ltd.
When was the Ltd established and has it filed previous accounts?
On checking with companies house his company was
LTD in 2009 and has submitted last years acounts without issue.
Although he came out , measured up and sold the product to me and was the only one that I contacted it was a bunch of subcontractors in a plain white old transit that came and completed the installation and collected the final payment.
He is also the one that has ignored my calls and occasionally come out to give excuses for not complying with the guarantee or refund as previously agreed.
Andy_GSA said:
If your understanding, supported by your evidence, is that you were dealing with the individual rather then a company then it is the individual you pursue.
this was my initial thought, but my confidence in this thought was severly damaged by trading standards advice on the situation.Is it enough to have evidence in the form of business cards and glossy brochure to prove I was not made aware of his LTD company status.
And is the district judges deferring the case a hint that they believe that I should continue with the case against the sole individual?
Edited by hedgefinder on Monday 17th February 15:02
hedgefinder said:
this was my initial thought, but my confidence in this thought was severly damaged by trading standards advice on the situation.
Is it enough to have evidence in the form of business cards and glossy brochure to prove I was not made aware of his LTD company status??
Trading standards is not the court. Their advice would be good if your literature and invoices made it clear that the defendant was trading with you as a limited company, but if that's not the case then their advice is not good. Is it enough to have evidence in the form of business cards and glossy brochure to prove I was not made aware of his LTD company status??
If you decide to stick with the defendant as an individual then when you write back to the court you can state your reasons for believing you were trading with an individual.
hedgefinder said:
And is the district judges deferring the case a hint that they believe that I should continue with the case against the sole individual?
You edited your post whilst I was composing my reply.Edited by hedgefinder on Monday 17th February 15:02
District Judges don't give 'hints' as such. They review the paperwork and try to manage cases to their conclusion as quickly as possible. Where one side's defence is that the claimant has sued the wrong person then it's in everyone's interest to clear that up as soon as possible.
If the matter went to a final hearing and the defendant showed that you'd sued the wrong person then the claim would be dismissed, likewise if you have sued the correct person then the defence as it stands (if that is all it says) is not a defence that could succeed so a Judge might want to order an amended defence be filed before it goes to trial.
hmm, so it would seem based on the paperwork that I have here that I should just opush on and claim against him as an individual?
I should mention that the business card also lists his brother as a contact, but I have never to my knowledge had any contact with him. I do not know whether this has any bearing?
I should mention that the business card also lists his brother as a contact, but I have never to my knowledge had any contact with him. I do not know whether this has any bearing?
hedgefinder said:
hmm, so it would seem based on the paperwork that I have here that I should just opush on and claim against him as an individual?
I should mention that the business card also lists his brother as a contact, but I have never to my knowledge had any contact with him. I do not know whether this has any bearing?
The question you need to ask yourself (and the question the Judge would ask) is do you have any evidence (e.g. documents) that show you were dealing with a ltd company. If not then the claim is against the individual.I should mention that the business card also lists his brother as a contact, but I have never to my knowledge had any contact with him. I do not know whether this has any bearing?
If you confirm your claim is against the individual the matter may get listed for a short hearing to deal with who should be the correct defendant, possibly combined with a hearing to allocate the matter to a track.
Timsta said:
I think the most important thing is whether you have a company number or PLC on any of the paperwork.
nope, definately not, as witnessed by a trading standards safety officer and several others,althugh on checking his website online does have LTDon the contact page with a company number. But I never had any reason to look at his website or check with companies house until after he submitted this as his defence.hedgefinder said:
Timsta said:
I think the most important thing is whether you have a company number or PLC on any of the paperwork.
nope, definately not, as witnessed by a trading standards safety officer and several others,althugh on checking his website online does have LTDon the contact page with a company number. But I never had any reason to look at his website or check with companies house until after he submitted this as his defence.I was under the impression that this is the reason why all documentation should have the company number on it.
my worry is that he is going to produce forged paperwork, such as an invoice on his letter headed paperwork or something of this nature...which I have never recieved and never originally existed - all I recieved was a hand written reciept from the installers working for him as I wouldnt give them the cash without some form of evidence that they had been paid. He is also in trouble for not producing a lot of other paperwork to comply with current law on their installation which is another matter, but he doesnt seem at all concerned about it.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


