Landslip and the railway - who's fault is it?
Landslip and the railway - who's fault is it?
Author
Discussion

Paul O

Original Poster:

3,184 posts

214 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
hi all,

Just after a bit of direction from any legal bods on here.

The land at the back of my flat slopes away steeply at the end of the garden and at the bottom of this slope is the railway lines.

The land on the slope has a lot of trees on there and over the years the trees have been chopped by the railway.

A slip-circle has developed on the garden area at the top of the slope which needs further investigation. A guestimation would be that as the roots have died from the felled trees, this has upset the balance of the land - we've got a surveyor looking into it.

We have now found out that the land where the trees are, including the slope down to the railway line is owned by our property - and the railway have never had permission from us to chop down the trees.

They have said that, as the slip isn't close enough to the railway lines (and the land is not owned by them) that they are not interested.

They are due to do more tree work at the weekend. I have told them they must not continue as this might make the slip circle worse.

Legally, where do I stand? I suspect I'll have to prove it via a surveyor, undertake remedial work and then sue the railway for the damage (assuming that roots are indeed the cause). Is this right, or should I be doing something else at the same time?

Cheers,

Paul.

Edited by Paul O on Tuesday 18th February 19:18

matchmaker

9,091 posts

231 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
This is PH - obviously the answer is Labour/Tony Blair/Gordon Brown wink

speedking31

3,964 posts

167 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Paul O said:
They have said that, as the slip isn't close enough to the railway lines (and the land is owned by them) that they are not interested.
Should that be "and the land is not owned by them"?

Chopping down stuff on your property and causing damage = trespass? Although there is no doubt some complication where they have a duty to keep the line clear of debris.

Where is the fence line?

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
If you kick off about this, are you prepared for them to insist you maintain the bank and trees to a suitable level to keep the railway safe in the future?

Obviously the issue of potential landslip/subsidence on your land needs sorting but I'd be approaching it with a view to working with them rather than against them.

Muncher

12,235 posts

280 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
There is wide ranging railway legislation which allows them to come onto your land in order to maintain and safegaurd the railways despite the fact that the land and trees are owned by you. I would be weary of chasing them expecting them to pick up all of the bill at the end of it...

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Paul O said:
We have now found out that the land where the trees are, including the slope down to the railway line is owned by our property
Did your solicitor not sit you down with the Land Registry plan of your plot and get you to confirm the boundaries were what you thought they were?

What does the LR plan say?

[quote]and the railway have never had permission from us to chop down the trees.
I'd lay odds on there being a covenant allowing them to. Again, did your solicitor not point that out to you?

A couple of quid on the LR website will show you the exact score.

Paul O

Original Poster:

3,184 posts

214 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies.

I'm not a legal type, so am going to quickly run out of talent on describing this, but here it is in laymans terms...

The land is leasehold to the properties but the freehold is owned by the management company (which we all own - it isn't a third party). The freehold originally looked like it owned the flats, the parking and the gardens, but there is a separate land registry number which shows that remainder also belongs to us. None of the residents are aware that we owned this extra piece of land.

So, great news that we have just doubled the size of the estate, but not so great that we can't use it for anything.

I'm not too fussed about who missed what from a legal/conveyancing angle with when buying as it is largely irrelevant. I have been working closely with the railway (not against them) as mentioned above, but when they discovered we owned the land, the conversation dropped like a stone.

There is mention of a covernance in the land registry doc which I have yet to get hold of - this I expect will mention authority for the railway chopping down the trees.

So next step is to get the surveyor to look into it and remedy the problem but its going to be extremeley expensive (thousands, if not tens of thousands) so was looking at it from a legal perspective - that being, irrespective of who owns the land, if the railway chopped down the trees which caused the subsidence on our land are they legally responsible to contribute to the remedial costs?

Thanks chaps!

W124Bob

1,863 posts

206 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
I can't comment on your particular problem but as a train driver all I can is that there is a massive amount of tree clearance going on at the moment, colleagues and have commented on this issue arising.I have always assumed that a certain amount of vegetation was a good thing, NR seems to have adopted real slash and cut mentality at the moment. The worst aspect of this is the failing machine, looks like a mini tornado has been by. I hope you do get some justice from NR if they have contributed to your problem.

rs1952

5,247 posts

290 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
In terms of the length of time that railways have been around (getting on for 200 years now in some cases, and over 150 years in many more) this practice of allowing cuttings and embankments to get overgrown is quite a new thing. It started in the early 1970s when some bright spark (pun intended) sussed out that they no longer needed to keep the trackside clear of vegetation as they did in the days of steam, because sparks from the chimney would catch the lot on fire if they didn’t.

This has led to a number of problems because now, when the overhanging trees are scraping the paint off passing trains (I’m thinking especially of the Truro to Falmouth line here, but there are many others) and NR send of gangs to clear it, the “greenies” all start to shout about valuable habitats being destroyed. The fact those “valuable habitats” weren’t there 40 years ago and the ancestors of the little buggers who live there now used to live somewhere else, probably doesn’t enter their heads or their perceptions rolleyes

Clearly we haven’t yet been told the section of line that the OP is talking about. However, if we assume that the line has been there for at least 100 years, and for 60 of those years there probably weren’t any trees there anyway (see above) then logic would suggest that the land used to be stable without them – it might even be that the vegetation has caused the instability (I’m thinking sandy soil, steep gradient, add a bit of wind and rain to the mix together with a few tons of trees pulling on it and Hey Presto! Things can start shifting.

The OP clearly needs to work with NR to resolve this problem, but shouldn’t get too wound up about the trees themselves. At the end of the day they are just so much firewood. Somehow I doubt that NR are going to put their hands in their pockets to pay towards any remedial work if they don’t own the land. To put the boot on the other foot, would you as an adjoining landowner put your hand in your pocket to help out Network Rail if they owned the land?

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Paul O said:
The land at the back of my flat slopes away steeply at the end of the garden and at the bottom of this slope is the railway lines.
I'm a little unclear from your description of the topography, but my reading is that the slope you are describing that begins at the end of your garden is the side of a cutting through which the railway tracks run. By law all railway land in the UK has to be fenced off to prevent incursion by the public onto the tracks (it costs Network Rail a kings ransom every year to repair the damage caused by vandals breaking them down). I have never come across a situation where the boundary fence is anywhere other than at the top of the cutting. So where exactly is it in your case?

Paul O said:
The land on the slope has a lot of trees on there and over the years the trees have been chopped by the railway.

A slip-circle has developed on the garden area at the top of the slope which needs further investigation. A guestimation would be that as the roots have died from the felled trees, this has upset the balance of the land - we've got a surveyor looking into it.

We have now found out that the land where the trees are, including the slope down to the railway line is owned by our property - and the railway have never had permission from us to chop down the trees.

They have said that, as the slip isn't close enough to the railway lines (and the land is not owned by them) that they are not interested.

They are due to do more tree work at the weekend. I have told them they must not continue as this might make the slip circle worse.

Legally, where do I stand? I suspect I'll have to prove it via a surveyor, undertake remedial work and then sue the railway for the damage (assuming that roots are indeed the cause). Is this right, or should I be doing something else at the same time?
Maybe I have misunderstood your description, but the position of the fence is normally significant in determining who owns what. If the trees are the railway side of the fence I very much doubt it is your land that they are on. Even if it is yours Network Rail has the power to enter and carry out remedial work under Section 14 of the Railway Regulation Act 1842. While it would be polite to seek it in the interests of good relations, NR does not actually need your consent. It doesn't work the other way round btw. Entering railway land without consent is a criminal offence (so if you are refused entry to a station or requested to leave and don't comply you could be in deep censored). See section 55 of the British Transport Commission Act 1949.

The issue of their work having caused damage on your side of the fence is something else. In many cases railways are a special case as far as the law is concerned. I reckon you will need specialist professional advice on liability.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Have you had much rain recently and could that be the cause?

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Paul O said:
The land is leasehold to the properties but the freehold is owned by the management company (which we all own - it isn't a third party).
Ah, right. Yes, that makes a difference - not least because gawd knows who was responsible for doing the paperwork when the place was bought.

[quote]None of the residents are aware that we owned this extra piece of land.
Bit of a due diligence failure on the part of the directors of the management company, though.

[quote]if the railway chopped down the trees which caused the subsidence on our land are they legally responsible to contribute to the remedial costs?
Nope, wouldn't expect so. They have the right to cut them down solely to prevent them interfering with the operation of the railway - same as power companies have the right to if the trees may interfere with power lines. It's down to the landowner to manage their own land in line with reasonable expectations _including_ the railway's covenant.

spikeyhead

20,646 posts

228 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
I blame gravity, and possibly that Isaac Newton bloke.