Court summons-speeding-trade car
Discussion
Okay everyone, one of my cars in the trade was caught speeding doing 58 in a 50 zone in December. It was driven by a driver whom we've since sacked due to negligence. I got a NIP 7 days after he'd been caught speeding & sent them a letter back with his details.
Today I get the police on my door questioning me why I've not responded regarding the issue & apparently they're wanting to take me to court. I've given them the drivers details & phone number (which is now disconnected)...I'm just wondering if I'm liable for anything? I don't think I am but I'd like a second opinion
Thanks in advance
Today I get the police on my door questioning me why I've not responded regarding the issue & apparently they're wanting to take me to court. I've given them the drivers details & phone number (which is now disconnected)...I'm just wondering if I'm liable for anything? I don't think I am but I'd like a second opinion
Thanks in advance
If you didnt fill the rear of the form in with the details it asks at the section which is relevant then Yes,you are liable as you have not complied with the Section 172 request. By writing it on a seperate piece of paper is not good enough,if you did not return it within the 28 days as it says you should then you could /will get summonsed for failing to furnish details,which is a totally seperate offence.
Stefluc
Stefluc
Stefluc said:
If you didnt fill the rear of the form in with the details it asks at the section which is relevant then Yes,you are liable as you have not complied with the Section 172 request. By writing it on a seperate piece of paper is not good enough..
As long as any such letter contains all of the information required by the s.172 request, then it's a perfectly acceptable method of responding.Stefluc said:
... By writing it on a seperate piece of paper is not good enough, ...
I'm a little confused here. Are you saying writing it on a separate piece of paper is deemed a failure to furnish? SS2. later suggests otherwise, and I recognise SS2. as being well informed from past performance.Could you clarify please and provide a citation?
SM
What I am saying is if you do not fill in the rear of the form and sign and date it as per the requirement of the form,then you have not fulfilled the requirement.
This is an old trick by people writing the details on a seperate piece of paper and sending it back with a blank 172.
I have been at two trials where this was tried by solicitors and the District Judge upheld the Prosecution side for failing to comply with the form.
Its quite simple really the form asks and provides a place for the details to be filled in,why would you then fill in a blank piece of paper and send it back.
This is an old trick by people writing the details on a seperate piece of paper and sending it back with a blank 172.
I have been at two trials where this was tried by solicitors and the District Judge upheld the Prosecution side for failing to comply with the form.
Its quite simple really the form asks and provides a place for the details to be filled in,why would you then fill in a blank piece of paper and send it back.
Stefluc said:
What I am saying is if you do not fill in the rear of the form and sign and date it as per the requirement of the form,then you have not fulfilled the requirement.
This is an old trick by people writing the details on a seperate piece of paper and sending it back with a blank 172.
It's not a trick, nor is it an automatic failure to fulfil the requirement.This is an old trick by people writing the details on a seperate piece of paper and sending it back with a blank 172.
As long as the substance of the s.172 request is complied with in full, there's no problem (at all) in providing the information in letter form.
Stefluc said:
I have been at two trials where this was tried by solicitors and the District Judge upheld the Prosecution side for failing to comply with the form..
I suspect there's rather more to that story than defendants who simply provided the s.172 information by letter rather than using the form provided.supermono said:
I'm a little confused here. Are you saying writing it on a separate piece of paper is deemed a failure to furnish? SS2. later suggests otherwise, and I recognise SS2. as being well informed from past performance.
Could you clarify please and provide a citation ?
I'd be interested in this also..Could you clarify please and provide a citation ?
Jones v DPP [2004] is a well established case whch supports the view that a letter is acceptable...
Jones v DPP said:
5. Dr Jones received this (s.172) notice and he returned it. He did not complete and sign the form itself but in the part where he was required to give the name of the driver, if it was not he, he wrote the words: "Please see covering letter enclosed". The letter was dated 12th February. It was headed with the registration number of the vehicle and was in these terms:
"Thank you for the notice dated 11/02/02 relating to this vehicle. I confirm that I am the owner. It is one of six vehicles in my practice fleet. For several months it has been based in Cardiff and driven with my consent by a number of qualified drivers of approved age.
I can state absolutely that I was not driving the vehicle on that day. I have no way of stating which authorised driver was actually driving at the time in question on 29.01.02. If there is a camera record, this might assist in identifying the driver if I might have sight of it."
And he gave the name and address of his solicitor in Penarth.
8. The other two questions can be dealt with quite shortly. The first concerned the evidential admissibility of the letter written by Dr Jones, to which I have referred <..snip..>.....
9. It appears that at the trial the question of the admissibility of Dr Jones' letter did feature as a matter for debate and the first part of the case stated by the deputy district judge concerns that question. The deputy district judge refers in the case stated to the decision of the Queen's Bench Division in DPP V Broomfield (2002) EWHC 1962 (Admin) 166 Justice of the Peace 736 as being a well-known authority for the proposition, as he put it, that if the notice is in reasonable form and requires the information to be given in a particular form then that form must be used. The decision of Broomfield and an earlier decision of the Divisional Court called Boss v Measures (1990) RTR 26 each concerned instances, one them under the Road Traffic Act 1988 and the other under a different piece of legislation, where a person was required to give information and where they had done so, they said, orally on the telephone.
10. The essence of the first of those decisions which was followed in the second, was that the legislation was to be construed inferentially as entitling the police seeking the information to stipulate, so far as it was reasonable, the form in which it should be supplied. And the decision in each of those two cases was that the form stipulated was reasonable and that the defendant in attempting to answer orally had not answered in a form which was acceptable and, accordingly, that convictions followed as a result.
11. Judge Wilkie QC, who was the deciding judge in Broomfield, in addition to citing a passage from what Woolf LJ (as he then was) had said in Boss v Measures, also pointed out that a purpose of seeking the information in section 172 of the 1988 Act was to enable proof of certain matters, including the identity of the driver of the vehicle, to be given in summary proceedings and, accordingly, there was an important reason why the information should be given in writing and, as the judge held, in the form in which it had been requested.
12. In my judgment, at least as it has turned out, the question of the admissibility of Dr Jones' letter took on a life of its own, which, as I say, as things have turned out, it did not deserve.
13. In this court there has been no issue but that this letter written by Dr Jones and the fact that it accompanied the nearly-blank form which had been sent to him and the fact that on that form he had written referring to the letter, that all that was without difficulty admissible in evidence before the deputy district judge. I think, however, that it is quite important to express my view that however it may be that the police operating section 172 are entitled to stipulate a written form in which the answers should be given, and however it may be that someone who attempts to answer not in that form but orally, as it might be on the telephone, would not be complying with what is required of them, that somebody who answers in writing in the way in which Dr Jones did in the present case is acting in substance entirely in accordance with the statutory requirement. Yes, he did not fill in the form, but he did provide the form itself, cross referred to his letter. His letter was a document which he had signed and the letter contains all the information in writing which the form had required and indeed more.
14. Accordingly, it does seem to me, first of all, that there was absolutely no respect in which he could properly be criticised for the way in which he had dealt with this matter by means of the letter and, secondly, that so far as it went that the letter was a proper compliance with section 172(2) of the 1988 Act.
"Thank you for the notice dated 11/02/02 relating to this vehicle. I confirm that I am the owner. It is one of six vehicles in my practice fleet. For several months it has been based in Cardiff and driven with my consent by a number of qualified drivers of approved age.
I can state absolutely that I was not driving the vehicle on that day. I have no way of stating which authorised driver was actually driving at the time in question on 29.01.02. If there is a camera record, this might assist in identifying the driver if I might have sight of it."
And he gave the name and address of his solicitor in Penarth.
8. The other two questions can be dealt with quite shortly. The first concerned the evidential admissibility of the letter written by Dr Jones, to which I have referred <..snip..>.....
9. It appears that at the trial the question of the admissibility of Dr Jones' letter did feature as a matter for debate and the first part of the case stated by the deputy district judge concerns that question. The deputy district judge refers in the case stated to the decision of the Queen's Bench Division in DPP V Broomfield (2002) EWHC 1962 (Admin) 166 Justice of the Peace 736 as being a well-known authority for the proposition, as he put it, that if the notice is in reasonable form and requires the information to be given in a particular form then that form must be used. The decision of Broomfield and an earlier decision of the Divisional Court called Boss v Measures (1990) RTR 26 each concerned instances, one them under the Road Traffic Act 1988 and the other under a different piece of legislation, where a person was required to give information and where they had done so, they said, orally on the telephone.
10. The essence of the first of those decisions which was followed in the second, was that the legislation was to be construed inferentially as entitling the police seeking the information to stipulate, so far as it was reasonable, the form in which it should be supplied. And the decision in each of those two cases was that the form stipulated was reasonable and that the defendant in attempting to answer orally had not answered in a form which was acceptable and, accordingly, that convictions followed as a result.
11. Judge Wilkie QC, who was the deciding judge in Broomfield, in addition to citing a passage from what Woolf LJ (as he then was) had said in Boss v Measures, also pointed out that a purpose of seeking the information in section 172 of the 1988 Act was to enable proof of certain matters, including the identity of the driver of the vehicle, to be given in summary proceedings and, accordingly, there was an important reason why the information should be given in writing and, as the judge held, in the form in which it had been requested.
12. In my judgment, at least as it has turned out, the question of the admissibility of Dr Jones' letter took on a life of its own, which, as I say, as things have turned out, it did not deserve.
13. In this court there has been no issue but that this letter written by Dr Jones and the fact that it accompanied the nearly-blank form which had been sent to him and the fact that on that form he had written referring to the letter, that all that was without difficulty admissible in evidence before the deputy district judge. I think, however, that it is quite important to express my view that however it may be that the police operating section 172 are entitled to stipulate a written form in which the answers should be given, and however it may be that someone who attempts to answer not in that form but orally, as it might be on the telephone, would not be complying with what is required of them, that somebody who answers in writing in the way in which Dr Jones did in the present case is acting in substance entirely in accordance with the statutory requirement. Yes, he did not fill in the form, but he did provide the form itself, cross referred to his letter. His letter was a document which he had signed and the letter contains all the information in writing which the form had required and indeed more.
14. Accordingly, it does seem to me, first of all, that there was absolutely no respect in which he could properly be criticised for the way in which he had dealt with this matter by means of the letter and, secondly, that so far as it went that the letter was a proper compliance with section 172(2) of the 1988 Act.
Edited by SS2. on Thursday 20th February 07:56
The High Court thought that a letter was capable of being a perfectly adequate reply.
http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Admin/2004/236...
http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Admin/2004/236...
Lord Justice May said:
In this court there has been no issue but that this letter written by Dr Jones and the fact that it accompanied the nearly-blank form which had been sent to him and the fact that on that form he had written referring to the letter, that all that was without difficulty admissible in evidence before the deputy district judge. I think, however, that it is quite important to express my view that however it may be that the police operating section 172 are entitled to stipulate a written form in which the answers should be given, and however it may be that someone who attempts to answer not in that form but orally, as it might be on the telephone, would not be complying with what is required of them, that somebody who answers in writing in the way in which Dr Jones did in the present case is acting in substance entirely in accordance with the statutory requirement. Yes, he did not fill in the form, but he did provide the form itself, cross referred to his letter. His letter was a document which he had signed and the letter contains all the information in writing which the form had required and indeed more.
Accordingly, it does seem to me, first of all, that there was absolutely no respect in which he could properly be criticised for the way in which he had dealt with this matter by means of the letter and, secondly, that so far as it went that the letter was a proper compliance with section 172(2) of the 1988 Act.
It would be different if the letter didn't comply with the substance of the requirement, eg if you attempted to make it inadmissible by failing to sign it.Accordingly, it does seem to me, first of all, that there was absolutely no respect in which he could properly be criticised for the way in which he had dealt with this matter by means of the letter and, secondly, that so far as it went that the letter was a proper compliance with section 172(2) of the 1988 Act.
pork911 said:
Slightly OT and just idle curiosity but if the registered keeper is a company and you make no response to correspondence and court documents what are the possible outcomes? No points and just a fine for the company?
The company may be prosecuted. No points, just a fine. A company will often get a warning if the reply is carefully worded.Update on the situation. The enquiry officer believes that the information i supplied to her was false & that I'm making the person up!
I've never been in trouble with the police before & don't know what to do, she's basically said 'we know that you're lying' (I'm not!!!) and that it'd be easier to accept the 3 points & fine rather than be prosecuted for 'preventing the course of justice' !
Genuinely i'm astounded that it's come to this, im only running a small '1 man band' business as it's efficient for me at the moment & i feel as though this is the reason why they believe i've provided false details!
Any suggestions on what to do before seeking legal advice?
I've never been in trouble with the police before & don't know what to do, she's basically said 'we know that you're lying' (I'm not!!!) and that it'd be easier to accept the 3 points & fine rather than be prosecuted for 'preventing the course of justice' !
Genuinely i'm astounded that it's come to this, im only running a small '1 man band' business as it's efficient for me at the moment & i feel as though this is the reason why they believe i've provided false details!
Any suggestions on what to do before seeking legal advice?
For what it's worth seek legal advice as no amount of posting on here is going to give you the answer you are looking for as we dont have the full fact's.
Also I would hope that the Police will be able to back up their allegation and if they can then I would settle for the least harsh option,as one is a motoring conviction and the other is a criminal conviction.
However if you believe as you are saying that you have done nothing wrong then take it all the way to court.
Also I would hope that the Police will be able to back up their allegation and if they can then I would settle for the least harsh option,as one is a motoring conviction and the other is a criminal conviction.
However if you believe as you are saying that you have done nothing wrong then take it all the way to court.
For what it's worth seek legal advice as no amount of posting on here is going to give you the answer you are looking for as we dont have the full fact's.
Also I would hope that the Police will be able to back up their allegation and if they can then I would settle for the least harsh option,as one is a motoring conviction and the other is a criminal conviction.
However if you believe as you are saying that you have done nothing wrong then take it all the way to court.
Also I would hope that the Police will be able to back up their allegation and if they can then I would settle for the least harsh option,as one is a motoring conviction and the other is a criminal conviction.
However if you believe as you are saying that you have done nothing wrong then take it all the way to court.
dave828 said:
It was driven by a driver whom we've since sacked due to negligence.
dave828 said:
The enquiry officer believes that the information i supplied to her was false & that I'm making the person up!
Presumably, you have employment records of your ex-driver?NS number, copies of payslips, P45 etc ?
dave828 said:
Update on the situation. The enquiry officer believes that the information i supplied to her was false & that I'm making the person up!
I've never been in trouble with the police before & don't know what to do, she's basically said 'we know that you're lying' (I'm not!!!) and that it'd be easier to accept the 3 points & fine rather than be prosecuted for 'preventing the course of justice' !
Genuinely i'm astounded that it's come to this, im only running a small '1 man band' business as it's efficient for me at the moment & i feel as though this is the reason why they believe i've provided false details!
Any suggestions on what to do before seeking legal advice?
Could you provide evidence that said person did exist and employed by your company?I've never been in trouble with the police before & don't know what to do, she's basically said 'we know that you're lying' (I'm not!!!) and that it'd be easier to accept the 3 points & fine rather than be prosecuted for 'preventing the course of justice' !
Genuinely i'm astounded that it's come to this, im only running a small '1 man band' business as it's efficient for me at the moment & i feel as though this is the reason why they believe i've provided false details!
Any suggestions on what to do before seeking legal advice?
I would tell her that by accepting 3 points and fine, then you would actually be perverting the course of justice, as it was not you.
pork911 said:
Slightly OT and just idle curiosity but if the registered keeper is a company and you make no response to correspondence and court documents what are the possible outcomes? No points and just a fine for the company?
I thought SOMEONE had to be named from the company. Usually the Finance Director as he deals with the costs of the insurance. It is within the RK's duty of care to provide and audit and maintain a system whereby the user of the car can be identified, isn't it ? Otherwise in my humble opinion the RK should take the points for being a lackadaisical tardy muppetPuddenchucker said:
Presumably, you have employment records of your ex-driver?
NS NI number, copies of payslips, P45 etc ?
^^This^^Otherwise the OP has been a naughty boy and will be in trouble with HMRC.
R1 Indy said:
I would tell her that by accepting 3 points and fine, then you would actually be perverting the course of justice, as it was not you.
^^And this^^Then follow up by telling the cynical moo where she can shove her disbelief.
Politely of course...

Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


