Using a mobile while being towed?
Using a mobile while being towed?
Author
Discussion

Johnnytheboy

Original Poster:

24,499 posts

217 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
First the usual disclaimer to prevent the SPL mob ripping me to shreds. This wasn't me, I wasn't being towed, I don't use my phone while driving, etc. I'm not interested in the rights and wrongs, just what law applies.

Just saw a guy being towed, I believe on a rope, and he was on the phone.

Now I'm guessing this is illegal as he would still count as being in control of the vehicle, right? i.e. he'd be steering and braking.

But where would the line be drawn?

Common sense (which we know has no place in motoring law) would suggest that you are not allowed to use a phone if you were in any way controlling the vehicle, but if you were sat in the driver's seat of a car being towed on a fixed bar, so you weren't doing anything, you could talk to your heart's content.

But is that the case? Or are you considered in charge in the same way as a drunk sleeping in his car is, or is the difference in the ability to drive if you wished?

I'm rambling now. getmecoat

Juliet1981

25 posts

156 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
There is a case where a man disqualified from driving was sitting in the drivers seat of a car being towed and was controlling the brakes/steering. He was found to be the driver because he had control over the vehicle so convicted of driving while disqualified.

The standard that has been developed by the UK Courts is that the essence of driving is the use of the driver’s control in order to direct movement, however that movement is produced.

So if your being towed and use your phone then you do commit the offence of using a mobile phone.

[quote] but if you were sat in the driver's seat of a car being towed on a fixed bar, so you weren't doing anything, you could talk to your heart's content.
[/quote]

If the tow was such that the person in the drivers seat could not control any of the movement of the car then there would be a case for the person not to have committed the offence, but all the rigid towing bars I've seen still need the the towed vehicle to be steered by the person in them.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Johnnytheboy said:
but if you were sat in the driver's seat of a car being towed on a fixed bar, so you weren't doing anything, you could talk to your heart's content.
The phone use wouldn't add anything to the illegality of being there in the first place.

alpha channel

1,400 posts

193 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Pretty much as above, regardless of how the motive force is being applied if brakes and steering are being controlled then the person in the driving seat is in effect driving is liable. If I was doing the towing (on a rope) I'd not be best pleased about the bork potential of the towee running into the back of me because he was distracted by nattering on the phone (I've been towed twice by rope and I've never had to concentrate so hard).

Johnnytheboy

Original Poster:

24,499 posts

217 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
Johnnytheboy said:
but if you were sat in the driver's seat of a car being towed on a fixed bar, so you weren't doing anything, you could talk to your heart's content.
The phone use wouldn't add anything to the illegality of being there in the first place.
Ooh I didn't know that.

carinaman

25,299 posts

203 months