Where would brother stand on ownership?
Discussion
My brother spoke to me tonight about a classic car he wants to buy, but I'm concerned about it.
The car has been stored in a garage for 30 odd years, but the garages have been sold onto developers so it has to come out.The owner of the car left his partner and three children five years ago and disappeared to abroad leaving her with a crippling amount if debt it seems. The partner is selling the car and says she is the owner as she has paid the garage fees for the last five years since he left and the five years prior to that when he was with her. She has to sell the car to put the money towards the debts.
The car has not been registered with the DVLA on their computerised system as it's been off the road for so long, and there's no info on the DVLA website when he checked the registration number. It will therefore still have a buff log book. The woman says she has no log book, so it is either lost or with the bloke. There is a registration number and chassis plate so my brother should be able to get a log book when he's ready to MOT the car.
Where does my brother stand if the bloke comes out of the woodwork in a few years time with the buff log book, realises his ex-partner has sold the car and then reports it stolen? Is it a civil matter between the woman and her ex-partner or does my brother stand a real chance of having the car taken off him as stolen goods?
The car has been stored in a garage for 30 odd years, but the garages have been sold onto developers so it has to come out.The owner of the car left his partner and three children five years ago and disappeared to abroad leaving her with a crippling amount if debt it seems. The partner is selling the car and says she is the owner as she has paid the garage fees for the last five years since he left and the five years prior to that when he was with her. She has to sell the car to put the money towards the debts.
The car has not been registered with the DVLA on their computerised system as it's been off the road for so long, and there's no info on the DVLA website when he checked the registration number. It will therefore still have a buff log book. The woman says she has no log book, so it is either lost or with the bloke. There is a registration number and chassis plate so my brother should be able to get a log book when he's ready to MOT the car.
Where does my brother stand if the bloke comes out of the woodwork in a few years time with the buff log book, realises his ex-partner has sold the car and then reports it stolen? Is it a civil matter between the woman and her ex-partner or does my brother stand a real chance of having the car taken off him as stolen goods?
Edited by kartman24 on Monday 24th February 09:48
Edited by kartman24 on Monday 24th February 09:48
Is the vehicle of significant value?
Registration with DVLA is not the same as ownership, if she claims to be the legal owner she will need to provide a receipt / invoice selling goods and transferring title.
Whether she is the owner or not is difficult to prove if the bloke is not around, is he likely to come back?
Registration with DVLA is not the same as ownership, if she claims to be the legal owner she will need to provide a receipt / invoice selling goods and transferring title.
Whether she is the owner or not is difficult to prove if the bloke is not around, is he likely to come back?
Maz_uk said:
Is the vehicle of significant value?
Registration with DVLA is not the same as ownership, if she claims to be the legal owner she will need to provide a receipt / invoice selling goods and transferring title.
Whether she is the owner or not is difficult to prove if the bloke is not around, is he likely to come back?
Value presently is a couple of grand, but restored possibly 5-10 times that. Registration with DVLA is not the same as ownership, if she claims to be the legal owner she will need to provide a receipt / invoice selling goods and transferring title.
Whether she is the owner or not is difficult to prove if the bloke is not around, is he likely to come back?
The bloke could come back - he has three kids with her so he may resume some kind of relationship with them at some point and find out about the car sale.
You actually MOT the car prior to putting it onto the Swansea computer.
Unless something has changed you will probably be able to retain the original registration number, if this doesn't matter, take the plates off, get proof of build date from owners club, have it re registered with an age related number. This would also help if matey boy comes back from France (although in reality he would have a next to impossible task to grab it back).
Unless something has changed you will probably be able to retain the original registration number, if this doesn't matter, take the plates off, get proof of build date from owners club, have it re registered with an age related number. This would also help if matey boy comes back from France (although in reality he would have a next to impossible task to grab it back).
If the person selling the car does not have title to do so, then the buyer does not obtain title. There are some exceptions to this principle, but on the facts stated the OP's brother would be at risk of losing the car to its real owner if he pops up (assuming the seller not to be the real owner).
There would be no theft as there would be no dishonesty on the part of the purchaser, but the car's owner could make a civil claim to recover the car or its value.
There would be no theft as there would be no dishonesty on the part of the purchaser, but the car's owner could make a civil claim to recover the car or its value.
caziques said:
...
Unless something has changed you will probably be able to retain the original registration number, if this doesn't matter, take the plates off, get proof of build date from owners club, have it re registered with an age related number. This would also help if matey boy comes back from France (although in reality he would have a next to impossible task to grab it back).
Obtaining information from a club and changing the registration would have no impact on ownership, and if the true owner does claim the car his task would be far from impossible. Unless something has changed you will probably be able to retain the original registration number, if this doesn't matter, take the plates off, get proof of build date from owners club, have it re registered with an age related number. This would also help if matey boy comes back from France (although in reality he would have a next to impossible task to grab it back).
Edited by anonymous-user on Monday 24th February 06:47
Did I not read on here,a while back, that if a car had been left at a garage for some work, and for whatever reason not collected, after a certain time limit the garage could sell the car to recover storage costs ? As the wife has been paying the same for some time, does that not have some away in her being able to dispose of it ?
rigga said:
Did I not read on here,a while back, that if a car had been left at a garage for some work, and for whatever reason not collected, after a certain time limit the garage could sell the car to recover storage costs ? As the wife has been paying the same for some time, does that not have some away in her being able to dispose of it ?
Thanks for all your help so far everyone.I'm not sure whether recovery of storage costs just applies to car businesses? Also she's not his wife, so will that have any bearing on anything? I would have thought it would in some way as the car is not a marital asset.
I came across something similar a while back with something else. In that case, the family had sold the person's car while he was 'away for a few years' as the garage it was in was being demolished by the council. When he returned he reported it stolen, and the police investigated but in the end said it was a civil matter as they were family. Whether or not he sued his family or they just handed across the money paid for it I don't know, but in that case I believe the new owner got to keep the car, but he was a very worried man for a long time.
These two aren't family though.
Edited by kartman24 on Monday 24th February 09:47
Edited by kartman24 on Monday 24th February 09:49
The ex girlfriend does not appear to be the bailee (ie non owner in possession) of the car because it is, if I read the OP correctly, stored with a garage for a fee. Paying the garage fees does not give her a right to sell the car.
If she is or becomes the bailee, she may be able to sell the car by following the procedure set out in section 12 of and Schedule I to the Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977. NB those provisions do not apply in Scotland.
If she is or becomes the bailee, she may be able to sell the car by following the procedure set out in section 12 of and Schedule I to the Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977. NB those provisions do not apply in Scotland.
Edited by anonymous-user on Monday 24th February 18:46
Breadvan72 said:
The ex girlfriend does not appear to be the bailee (ie non owner in possession) of the car because it is, if I read the OP correctly, stored with a garage for a fee. Paying the garage fees does not give her a right to sell the car.
If she is or becomes the bailee, she may be ale to sell the car by following the procedure set out in section 12 of and Schedule I to the Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977. NB those provisions do not apply in Scotland.
I had a look online about bailment and found this on the site of a solicitor's firmIf she is or becomes the bailee, she may be ale to sell the car by following the procedure set out in section 12 of and Schedule I to the Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977. NB those provisions do not apply in Scotland.
"Abandoned Property
If a bailment agreement is set for a fixed term and the bailor fails to claim the property at the end of the term, he may be deemed to have abandoned the property. Alternatively, the voluntary bailment be converted into an involuntary bailment. However, if there's no clear term of bailment agreed upon, the bailor won't be deemed to have abandoned the property unless the bailee gives him notice that he no longer wishes to possess and protect the property."
The last sentence applies here.
The question I guess is what is the risk associated with him a) returning and b) taking action to recover his car if she has/cannot contact him.
EDITED TO ADD: damn, the website i found that on was american. I'll see if i can find a UK equivalent.
Edited by kartman24 on Monday 24th February 10:19
Devil2575 said:
Assuming the story is true then I think it highly unlikely the husband would return and demand his car back. If he did return he would likely have bigger issues than worrying about an old car.
I'm thinking if he does return, it's a dispute between the bailor (him) and the bailee (her if she becomes it) so bro' shouldn't be involved. If they failed to set up an agreement before he left, if she failed to tell him she was selling it, it has to be between them? He may have family in this country she knows about where a letter could be sent to pass on to him etc etc. If he does try it on with brother at a later date, a well constructed solicitor's letter at the time might just see him off.
Edited by kartman24 on Monday 24th February 10:42
I would be guided by BV on this.
One question that occurs to me is that if matey comes back, tracks car and brother down and wants car back, what value is attributed to asset?
If car is professionally valued by 3 people next week at an average of 2k then bro spends 10k turning it into a 20k car before matey comes knocking is matey entitled to car, 20k, or 2k. My best GUESS is 2k as more would be betterment which is not something the courts are keen on. I do not know the answer but basic maths says to me that it would be worth the 'gamble' if those are the figures in play.
Devious sod sitting next to me, says buy car, do up, sell, buy different car with profit. I'm not comfortable with that idea myself.
One question that occurs to me is that if matey comes back, tracks car and brother down and wants car back, what value is attributed to asset?
If car is professionally valued by 3 people next week at an average of 2k then bro spends 10k turning it into a 20k car before matey comes knocking is matey entitled to car, 20k, or 2k. My best GUESS is 2k as more would be betterment which is not something the courts are keen on. I do not know the answer but basic maths says to me that it would be worth the 'gamble' if those are the figures in play.
Devious sod sitting next to me, says buy car, do up, sell, buy different car with profit. I'm not comfortable with that idea myself.
how much is it worth? and how much will it be worth once fully restored and back on the road?
on property sales when there is doubt over true ownership you can purchase the property with indemnity insurance. No idea if anyone has ever done this with a car, but even if it has not someone has to be the first.
on property sales when there is doubt over true ownership you can purchase the property with indemnity insurance. No idea if anyone has ever done this with a car, but even if it has not someone has to be the first.
Rude-boy said:
I would be guided by BV on this.
One question that occurs to me is that if matey comes back, tracks car and brother down and wants car back, what value is attributed to asset?
If car is professionally valued by 3 people next week at an average of 2k then bro spends 10k turning it into a 20k car before matey comes knocking is matey entitled to car, 20k, or 2k. My best GUESS is 2k as more would be betterment which is not something the courts are keen on. I do not know the answer but basic maths says to me that it would be worth the 'gamble' if those are the figures in play.
Devious sod sitting next to me, says buy car, do up, sell, buy different car with profit. I'm not comfortable with that idea myself.
This is a car bro' wants to keep, although he may not get around to doing it up and end up selling on if he can't get to it in a few years. I have lots of projects I intend to do up, some that have been waiting 30 years ;-) One question that occurs to me is that if matey comes back, tracks car and brother down and wants car back, what value is attributed to asset?
If car is professionally valued by 3 people next week at an average of 2k then bro spends 10k turning it into a 20k car before matey comes knocking is matey entitled to car, 20k, or 2k. My best GUESS is 2k as more would be betterment which is not something the courts are keen on. I do not know the answer but basic maths says to me that it would be worth the 'gamble' if those are the figures in play.
Devious sod sitting next to me, says buy car, do up, sell, buy different car with profit. I'm not comfortable with that idea myself.
Edited by kartman24 on Monday 24th February 12:11
ging84 said:
how much is it worth? and how much will it be worth once fully restored and back on the road?
on property sales when there is doubt over true ownership you can purchase the property with indemnity insurance. No idea if anyone has ever done this with a car, but even if it has not someone has to be the first.
Thank you for the idea. I might just look into that. I've had people ask me about this stuff before but never even thought insurance could cover something like this if it went wrong. I don't think bro' will pay a fortune for insurance every month but if it was a very low cost he might consider it given what the car could be worth when done up.on property sales when there is doubt over true ownership you can purchase the property with indemnity insurance. No idea if anyone has ever done this with a car, but even if it has not someone has to be the first.
Edited by kartman24 on Monday 24th February 12:22
kartman24 said:
Thank you for the idea. I might just look into that. I've had people ask me about this stuff before but never even thought insurance could cover something like this if it went wrong. I don't think bro' will pay a fortune for insurance every month but if it was a very low cost he might consider it given what the car could be worth when done up.
Usually it would be a one-off cost for an indemnity IIRC.Edited by kartman24 on Monday 24th February 12:22
The OP's brother's position here would likely be complicated by the fact that he knows or has reason to believe that the ex girlfriend is not the owner of the car. There are some exceptions to the legal principle "nemo dat quod non habet" (no one can give what they do not have), but those exceptions require that the purchaser act in good faith and without notice of the ownership of the car.
Indeed.
The question is a difficult one and the potential legal ramifications are certainly off putting.
I'm sure if the desire to own that car is strong enough it would be better to track the true owner down if possible and deal with them. You never know how hard g/f has actually tried or if any professional has been involved in finding him. The lure of a few grand might appeal to him.
I would be inclined to find another car though. Not worth the trouble.
The question is a difficult one and the potential legal ramifications are certainly off putting.
I'm sure if the desire to own that car is strong enough it would be better to track the true owner down if possible and deal with them. You never know how hard g/f has actually tried or if any professional has been involved in finding him. The lure of a few grand might appeal to him.
I would be inclined to find another car though. Not worth the trouble.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


