Denmark raises speed limits. Accidents and fatalities fall.
Discussion
The following appeared on AOL's website today:
"A two-year experiment by the Danish road authorities has revealed that the accident rate has fallen on both single carriageway rural roads and motorways, where the speed limit has been raised.
Danish authorities made the decision to raise the speed limit from 80 km/h (50mph) to 90 km/h (56mph) on two-way rural roads two years ago and increase certain sections of the motorway to 130 km/h (80mph) from 110 km/h (68mph) nine years ago.
Results have shown that accidents have decreased on single-carriageway roads due to a reduction in the speed differential between the slowest and fastest cars.
According to authorities, it has also resulted in less overtaking as the slowest drivers have increased their speeds, but the fastest 15 per cent drive one km/h slower on average, despite the higher limit.
The move was initially met with scepticism – much like proposals to increase the motorway speed limits in this country – as police feared motorists would drive even faster, but they have now reportedly changed their minds.
Erik Mather, a senior Danish traffic police officer said: "The police are perhaps a little biased on this issue, but we've had to completely change our view now that the experiment has gone on for two years."
Fatalities have also decreased on the sections of motorway where the speed limit was raised to 130 km/h (80mph).
Brian Gregory, the chairman of the Alliance of British Drivers (ABD) – a group in favour of increased speed limits on UK motorways – said: "These findings vindicate what the ABD has been saying for years, that raising unreasonably low speed limits improves road safety by reducing speed differentials and driver frustration."
He added: "This means reinstating the 85th percentile principle - setting limits that 85 percent of drivers would not wish to exceed.
"Those who have argued that lower speed limits improve safety have been proved wrong.""
http://cars.aol.co.uk/2014/02/24/danish-road-exper...
Not much detail or analysis in the article, but if these findings stand up to scrutinty, it could be an interesting precedent to have an EU neighbour increase limits and not see any resulting increase in fatalities.
"A two-year experiment by the Danish road authorities has revealed that the accident rate has fallen on both single carriageway rural roads and motorways, where the speed limit has been raised.
Danish authorities made the decision to raise the speed limit from 80 km/h (50mph) to 90 km/h (56mph) on two-way rural roads two years ago and increase certain sections of the motorway to 130 km/h (80mph) from 110 km/h (68mph) nine years ago.
Results have shown that accidents have decreased on single-carriageway roads due to a reduction in the speed differential between the slowest and fastest cars.
According to authorities, it has also resulted in less overtaking as the slowest drivers have increased their speeds, but the fastest 15 per cent drive one km/h slower on average, despite the higher limit.
The move was initially met with scepticism – much like proposals to increase the motorway speed limits in this country – as police feared motorists would drive even faster, but they have now reportedly changed their minds.
Erik Mather, a senior Danish traffic police officer said: "The police are perhaps a little biased on this issue, but we've had to completely change our view now that the experiment has gone on for two years."
Fatalities have also decreased on the sections of motorway where the speed limit was raised to 130 km/h (80mph).
Brian Gregory, the chairman of the Alliance of British Drivers (ABD) – a group in favour of increased speed limits on UK motorways – said: "These findings vindicate what the ABD has been saying for years, that raising unreasonably low speed limits improves road safety by reducing speed differentials and driver frustration."
He added: "This means reinstating the 85th percentile principle - setting limits that 85 percent of drivers would not wish to exceed.
"Those who have argued that lower speed limits improve safety have been proved wrong.""
http://cars.aol.co.uk/2014/02/24/danish-road-exper...
Not much detail or analysis in the article, but if these findings stand up to scrutinty, it could be an interesting precedent to have an EU neighbour increase limits and not see any resulting increase in fatalities.
It is interesting for sure. I am annoyed with the fact that the speed limit is not a limit as such. In clear conditions with low traffic volume there is no problem doing 90 mph, apart from the 70 limit. But on other occasions 70 mph is way too fast.
I feel that on the motorway network the time has come to introduce an absolute limit of say 100, rigidly enforced. Then have variable limits which lower it to as low as 50 in times of high traffic volume or poor weather. The technology is there & it would be a vote winner despite what the lefty BBC would have to say about it.
As it is 95% of motorway users break the law, and that makes a mockery of limits when off the motorway where they ARE needed.
I feel that on the motorway network the time has come to introduce an absolute limit of say 100, rigidly enforced. Then have variable limits which lower it to as low as 50 in times of high traffic volume or poor weather. The technology is there & it would be a vote winner despite what the lefty BBC would have to say about it.
As it is 95% of motorway users break the law, and that makes a mockery of limits when off the motorway where they ARE needed.
It makes sense, however I can see all the anticar groups mulling over the figures and declaring them wrong. When Swindon switched of their cameras, it would be carnage I seem to recall. After two years when there was no increase in accidents The road safety lobby then declared two years was not long enough to see.
It is common sense to most and there has been examples of this around the world, yet in the UK we have councils jumping on the 20mph is plenty bandwagon and reducing perfectly reasonable limits to ones where they are now stupid.
It is common sense to most and there has been examples of this around the world, yet in the UK we have councils jumping on the 20mph is plenty bandwagon and reducing perfectly reasonable limits to ones where they are now stupid.
redstu said:
They probably drive slower as they won't have been held up as much.
Accidents have probably fallen as drivers are probably looking through the windscreen rather than continually checking that they haven't strayed over the limit by a few mph.
According to the news reports, the reason for the reduction is down to reduced speed differential resulting in less overtaking.Accidents have probably fallen as drivers are probably looking through the windscreen rather than continually checking that they haven't strayed over the limit by a few mph.
More homogeneous traffic
The slowest drivers have increased their speeds, but the fastest 15 percent drive one km/h slower on average, despite the limit increasing from 80 to 90 km/h. While the average speed remains similar to before, the speeds are more fluid and homogeneous on the roads in question.
”It was what we were hoping for,” Hollen said. “It looks like we’ve found the appropriate speed on those stretches of road, so we will reduce the speed differentials and consequently decrease the number of people overtaking.”
A final report will be published in 2015, after which the Vejdirektoratet experiment is due to end.
So it would seem that the view, based on what has been reported, is that 56 mph is the appropriate speed for single carriageway roads. Would people support that in the UK?
Personally I'd like to see the final report once the experiment is complete. The reporting of this story lacks any actual links to data, possibly because the experiment isn't yet complete.
http://cphpost.dk/news/higher-speed-limits-reducin...
It wouldn't work in the UK, just like 'cafe culture' results in half naked Newcastle girls vomiting in the middle of a road at 3:30 in the morning and 'nice' lads randomly smashing each other in the face, increased speed limits would bring out more self-appointed policemen trying to slow everyone down, and boy racers going mentally fast and overtaking everything.
I was regularly doing a fair number of km on Danish motorways when that change came in.
Nice to see the report confirms my experiences. Overall speeds didn't increase and it's as we've said on various threads over the years. Increase the UK limits and it would be an improvement without a free for all flat out blast.
Nice to see the report confirms my experiences. Overall speeds didn't increase and it's as we've said on various threads over the years. Increase the UK limits and it would be an improvement without a free for all flat out blast.
Devil2575 said:
So it would seem that the view, based on what has been reported, is that 56 mph is the appropriate speed for single carriageway roads. Would people support that in the UK?
I suspect you're being deliberately obtuse. Clearly speeds on different stretches of rural single carriageway will vary, so if you want to make speeds more homogenous, you need to take account of those prior speeds when setting the limit for that stretch of road. The ABD and others have been advocating the use of the 85th percentile speed for this reason for years. I don't think anyone is suggesting that 56mph is the magic number. Indeed, it is precisely the universal one-size-fits-all approach to extra-urban speed limits that appears to be causing unnecessary fatalities, by increasing differentials between the cars obeying the speed limit and those exceeding it.
Lil'RedGTO said:
.....AOL....
I thought they had disappeared few years ago - I haven't had a CD from they for ages!But on a serous note:
redstu said:
Accidents have probably fallen as drivers are probably looking through the windscreen rather than continually checking that they haven't strayed over the limit by a few mph.
I got done by a camera van last year (35 in a 30 that was a 50 than a 40 now a 30) and now I find myself looking more at my speed than the road or just going very slowly with other cars on my bumper.I used to modulate my speed to the road conditions or the width of the road or if it was a road through a built up area. Now I have to think and drive differently.
spaximus said:
It makes sense, however I can see all the anticar groups mulling over the figures and declaring them wrong. When Swindon switched of their cameras, it would be carnage I seem to recall. After two years when there was no increase in accidents The road safety lobby then declared two years was not long enough to see.
It is common sense to most and there has been examples of this around the world, yet in the UK we have councils jumping on the 20mph is plenty bandwagon and reducing perfectly reasonable limits to ones where they are now stupid.
Thats because we have road safety groups here, these people getting paid £40,000 a year have to justify their jobs and look like their doing somthing.It is common sense to most and there has been examples of this around the world, yet in the UK we have councils jumping on the 20mph is plenty bandwagon and reducing perfectly reasonable limits to ones where they are now stupid.
All they can do is reduce roads to 20, 40, 50. put in speed humps, chianes, and more pedestrian crossings, mostly with a lack of common sense.
Lil'RedGTO said:
Devil2575 said:
So it would seem that the view, based on what has been reported, is that 56 mph is the appropriate speed for single carriageway roads. Would people support that in the UK?
I suspect you're being deliberately obtuse. Clearly speeds on different stretches of rural single carriageway will vary, so if you want to make speeds more homogenous, you need to take account of those prior speeds when setting the limit for that stretch of road. The ABD and others have been advocating the use of the 85th percentile speed for this reason for years. I don't think anyone is suggesting that 56mph is the magic number. Indeed, it is precisely the universal one-size-fits-all approach to extra-urban speed limits that appears to be causing unnecessary fatalities, by increasing differentials between the cars obeying the speed limit and those exceeding it.
There is nothing in the Danish example that supports your view that a one size fits all approach is the cause of fatalities.
All the Danish example appears to be showing, is that the single carriageway speed limit was set too low. Not forgetting of course that this is a news report about a study that has yet to be completed let alone formally reported on.
The ABD comments are irrellevant. People should wait till the report is published before claiming what the experiment has shown.
Edited by Devil2575 on Tuesday 25th February 09:09
ozzuk said:
Could just be another example of someone reading statistics and coming to a headline grabbing conclusion.
Indeed.As I said, we need to wait for the proper report showing the stats etc.
At the moment this is just an unsubstantiated news report containing very little information.
Mr GrimNasty said:
It wouldn't work in the UK, just like 'cafe culture' results in half naked Newcastle girls vomiting in the middle of a road at 3:30 in the morning and 'nice' lads randomly smashing each other in the face, increased speed limits would bring out more self-appointed policemen trying to slow everyone down, and boy racers going mentally fast and overtaking everything.
I agree. There are some great things in other countries that work well but if you transport them to the UK, our culture means that they will probably fail. I've often though how nice the rest of Europe is with bars staying open well into the night. There's no mad taxi queue punch up at closing time, people are more socialble by going out to eat and having drinks much later, coming home in dribs and drabs when they are done. In reality, our yoof would just go out and drink to the point of death or total loss of control and our NHS would be even more stretched. In my opinion, those who want to drive at 150 leptons would only use increased motorway limits as an excuse to the police for excessive speed. "I was only 20mph over instead of 50mph when we had the old 70mph limit officer."
Oh and as a Geordie I take offense at your comments about our women. I've had many a successful night out taking advantage of drunk Newcastle girls vomiting in the street at 3:30am. Obviously, I don't kiss them.

Devil2575 said:
I don't understand your point. You appear to be using this Danish example as a reason why increasing the speed limit can make roads safer yet you seem to be ignoring some aspects.
There is nothing in the Danish example that supports your view that a one size fits all approach is the cause of fatalities.
All the Danish example appears to be showing, is that the single carriageway speed limit was set too low. Not forgetting of course that this is a news report about a study that has yet to be completed let alone formally reported on.
The ABD comments are irrellevant. People should wait till the report is published before claiming what the experiment has shown.
I was simply objecting to the fact that you chose to take from a story about an increase in speed limits reducing accidents the implication that the speed limit on all UK rural roads ought to be reduced to 56mph. There is nothing in the Danish example that supports your view that a one size fits all approach is the cause of fatalities.
All the Danish example appears to be showing, is that the single carriageway speed limit was set too low. Not forgetting of course that this is a news report about a study that has yet to be completed let alone formally reported on.
The ABD comments are irrellevant. People should wait till the report is published before claiming what the experiment has shown.
The Danish experience appears to show that increasing the speed limit does not necessarily lead to an increase in accidents or fatalities (as some would suggest) and indeed can reduce them. The suggested reason for the reduction in accidents is the reduction in speed differentials between those observing the (previously very low) speed limit and those disobeying it. That seems to suggest that it is important to set the speed limit by reference to the speeds that a cross section of drivers select for a particular stretch of road, and that imposing an artificially low or universal number will not work.
That is one of the principles behind the 85th percentile approach advocated by the ABD, the aim of which is to reduce the spread of speed distribution without criminalising the actions of the ordinary prudent motorist. Hence why I mentioned it.
Lil'RedGTO said:
I was simply objecting to the fact that you chose to take from a story about an increase in speed limits reducing accidents the implication that the speed limit on all UK rural roads ought to be reduced to 56mph.
The Danish experience appears to show that increasing the speed limit does not necessarily lead to an increase in accidents or fatalities (as some would suggest) and indeed can reduce them. The suggested reason for the reduction in accidents is the reduction in speed differentials between those observing the (previously very low) speed limit and those disobeying it. That seems to suggest that it is important to set the speed limit by reference to the speeds that a cross section of drivers select for a particular stretch of road, and that imposing an artificially low or universal number will not work.
That is one of the principles behind the 85th percentile approach advocated by the ABD, the aim of which is to reduce the spread of speed distribution without criminalising the actions of the ordinary prudent motorist. Hence why I mentioned it.
I wasn't suggesting it should be dropped to 56 mph. I was simply raising a point made in one of the few actual quotes from the news story.The Danish experience appears to show that increasing the speed limit does not necessarily lead to an increase in accidents or fatalities (as some would suggest) and indeed can reduce them. The suggested reason for the reduction in accidents is the reduction in speed differentials between those observing the (previously very low) speed limit and those disobeying it. That seems to suggest that it is important to set the speed limit by reference to the speeds that a cross section of drivers select for a particular stretch of road, and that imposing an artificially low or universal number will not work.
That is one of the principles behind the 85th percentile approach advocated by the ABD, the aim of which is to reduce the spread of speed distribution without criminalising the actions of the ordinary prudent motorist. Hence why I mentioned it.
The story makes no comment on the universality of speed limits.
It would appear that what they have done is move their single carriageway limit to closer to what ours generally is i.e 60 mph.
It's also worth noting that we no longer seem to have a universal limit with many roads now having 50 and 40 limits instread of the previous NSL.
I'd also be interested to see what the accident rate on these roads is like compared to the UK.
However first i'd like to see the actual report when the experiment is finished before drawing any conclusions.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



