Item bought not as described - action to take?
Item bought not as described - action to take?
Author
Discussion

task

Original Poster:

418 posts

202 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
I purchased a set of wheels that were advertised as fitting an MGB from a seller on ebay, although I did the purchase outside of ebay.

I sent £50 as a deposit marked as gift through paypal and the rest I paid cash when I met the seller and his mother at a petrol service station.

The wheels themselves are good condition and have obviously never been fitted but they are the wrong bolt pattern for a MGB. Wheels were collected on Thursday and I attempted to fit them to the car on Sunday, I contacted the seller Sunday night and he agreed to call me back yesterday to discuss however I have had no further contact since then. The wheels were also supposed to come with centre caps marked with MG which were not present either.

What, if anything, can I do?

wildoliver

9,324 posts

247 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Trade or private seller?

Ultimately I suspect it may come down to the question of do you want to sue the guy or not?

What are the wheels? I do a lot with Bs so might be able to help.

task

Original Poster:

418 posts

202 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Private seller

The wheels are 14" 6J Minator silver wheels. I'm not sure what they're supposed to fit, the bolt holes are too close together to fit an MGB.

The boxes are marked as having a PCD of 4-100, offset ET33, if the box is to be believed.

stevensdrs

3,265 posts

231 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
As you bought these outside of the ebay system, you have no protection from ebay and no redress against the seller. Caveat Emptor.

deltashad

6,731 posts

228 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
You could try to contact PayPal and tell them what has happened. My be a wasted exercise but why not?

if you have no luck I'd take a wheel to someone who deals with alloys and find out what they're meant to fit.
then sell them on.
you could always go down the route of wheel adapters and make them fit

Riley Blue

23,217 posts

257 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Morris Minor/Riley 1.5 fit by the sound of it. If you bought them cheap you'd probably make a profit if you put them back on Ebay.

RayPike

426 posts

153 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
stevensdrs said:
As you bought these outside of the ebay system, you have no protection from ebay and no redress against the seller. Caveat Emptor.
That's incorrect. The buyer would have absolutely no trouble at all in the small claims court if all is as set out in the OP.

wildoliver

9,324 posts

247 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
For future reference you need 4x114.3

I doubt they are for a minor if they are 4x100 but would fit vw and mx5. Depending how much you paid they would sell well. Indeed had they been 15" I'd have been buying them for my mx5.

Chalk it up to experience I reckon. As above private sale is caveat emptor if the seller clearly stated they were mgb fit then you may have a case to sue against item substantially misrepresented, but for the money involved I doubt it would be worth it. Sell them on and buy the right wheels, as a side note you may regret putting the car on minilite reps anyway, they don't look great these days IMO and are often the wrong offset and upset the handling. A well cleaned up set of original wheels tend to look best.

task

Original Poster:

418 posts

202 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
I paid £250 for 4, I have discovered they were manufactured by a company called SCP and am waiting to call a guy in their classics department to ask about what exactly they would fit. I have already spoken to a different person at SCP who confirmed they made the wheels by the part number on the box.

I hope I can strike some kind of deal with SCP where by they take the old wheels in part ex for a set correct for my car.

The wheels are perfect other than a small scuff on one where it was dropped by the seller prior to my ownership, this didn't bother me as it would be unseen with a tyre fitted and I had planned to get the rims repainted in a different colour anyway.

I'm thinking the best course of action here, if the above fails, it to find out what they fit exactly and then re-list on ebay with a decent advert. At the very least I can make some of my money back although probably not all.

It is very tempting to start legal preceding but most likely time consuming and I don't have a great deal of that at present added to which I would have no idea where to start with such things.

Thanks for all the replies and help so far!

Negative Creep

26,145 posts

258 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
If they're in good condition just put them back up on ebay and move on

task

Original Poster:

418 posts

202 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
for more info this was the advert I used to purchase them;

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/111276954274?ssPageName=...

Clearly stating they were to fit an MGB GT.

task

Original Poster:

418 posts

202 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
wildoliver said:
For future reference you need 4x114.3

I doubt they are for a minor if they are 4x100 but would fit vw and mx5. Depending how much you paid they would sell well. Indeed had they been 15" I'd have been buying them for my mx5.

Chalk it up to experience I reckon. As above private sale is caveat emptor if the seller clearly stated they were mgb fit then you may have a case to sue against item substantially misrepresented, but for the money involved I doubt it would be worth it. Sell them on and buy the right wheels, as a side note you may regret putting the car on minilite reps anyway, they don't look great these days IMO and are often the wrong offset and upset the handling. A well cleaned up set of original wheels tend to look best.
It's a late MGB that I'm fitting a 3.9 V8 to, removed the rubber bumpers to fit sebring front and rear valences. The idea behind the larger wheels was to help a little with traction. Not really aiming for a faithful restoration but more of a fun car that I can use on a fairly regular basis.

wildoliver

9,324 posts

247 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
You probably want to be looking at 15" then IMO.

It wouldn't be a bad idea to look at knock ons as you will very likely decide to hunt out an mgc axle sooner rather than later and most of them are wire wheel axles. The front knock on hubs aren't silly money its a bit of a no brainer to be honest but the cost will increase.


task

Original Poster:

418 posts

202 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
wildoliver said:
You probably want to be looking at 15" then IMO.

It wouldn't be a bad idea to look at knock ons as you will very likely decide to hunt out an mgc axle sooner rather than later and most of them are wire wheel axles. The front knock on hubs aren't silly money its a bit of a no brainer to be honest but the cost will increase.
I've fitted a V8 ratio diff to my later type axle so am OK in that respect, which is what I assume you meant?

Are 15" likely to make an appreciable difference to the handling/feel of the car?

Riley Blue

23,217 posts

257 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
wildoliver said:
For future reference you need 4x114.3

I doubt they are for a minor if they are 4x100 but would fit vw and mx5. Depending how much you paid they would sell well.
You're right, Minor PCD is 101.6mm (4") - my apologies.

maddog993

1,220 posts

271 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
PayPal clearly state that sending money as a gift offers no buyer protection (it's the corollary of waiving the paypal fees normally applied for such a transaction). Equally, you conducted the purchase outside of Ebay and the outstanding balance was paid in cash. As a consequence, neither would be in the slightest bit interested in any dispute between you and the seller.
As someone suggested, just bung them back on Ebay.

wildoliver

9,324 posts

247 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
In that case just go 15" bolt on wheels.

They enable lower profile tyres to be used not essential but a nice upgrade I feel.

RayPike

426 posts

153 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
The Paypal bit is largely a red herring here - as pointed out, there is no recourse there whatsoever. If you take him through the small claims court and you have the basic evidence you should have then you'll steamroller him with no trouble at all. When I did this with someone years ago, they had to refund me, pay the costs and I also got to keep the goods weirdly enough. The judge seemed surprised when I asked when I had to hand back the goods to the seller, now or when they refunded me the money! "Never, the seller committed an offence and is being penalised, not recompensed so they may do the same again to another buyer" were approximately the words used.

mgtony

4,226 posts

221 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
As you met the seller, albeit at a service station, does this mean he is relatively local to you? If you have or can get hold of his address, why not go and knock on his door and see what he has to say.
The centre caps are in the ad, and although the wheels may not fit the B, the caps themselves are worth a few quid:

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/4-x-MG-Alloy-Wheel-Centr...

Go and speak to his mum and let her have a word with him! biggrin

TwistingMyMelon

6,519 posts

236 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Tell his mum you will cry unless he pays you back?

Seriously, thats the risk of second hand goods, especially when you don't have the ebay/paypal guarantee to fall back on which can help in situations like this.