Data protection Act question.
Data protection Act question.
Author
Discussion

s3fella

Original Poster:

10,524 posts

218 months

Wednesday 26th February 2014
quotequote all
Long story sorry and just interested from a legal perspective.

I left and energy supplier in November and settled up my final bill (took ages) at first of Feb.

All good, no issues. Until yesterday, when I get a letter from debt collectors for the final bill plus 30 quid.

I call energy company and they say 'ignore the letter it's an error' but later on the debt collectors call me on my mobile, a number that's not public and on TpS.

I explain it's an error and they need to call supplier, but they won't. I then get an email from them and another call.

I call the energy supplier and have a moan! I point out I'm not happy at the debt collectors having my info, name address, email, phone number and even, who I bank with.
Supplier accepts it is an error, speaks to debt collectors about deleting my data and are told they can only delete my phone number, they need to keep name address, account number and bank for 'internal purposes'.

I'm not getting out of my pram about it, but as I've given private info to supplier and they've passed it on due to an error, is this a breach of data protection act? Supplier says no, as it was an accident, but I've said it's not, it's negligent. Does it matter?

Can I insist my data is deleted? If so ( and I know it doesn't warrant it) but how is that enforced?

Company also accepts it breached its own Ts and Cs which state they need to write certain warning letters to me, which they didn't as I'd paid, but if they had have done would have shown the error before any damage was done. But they say as I am no longer a customer, their Ts and Cs don't apply!!!

I mentioned a concern about it affecting credit score, they said an unequivocally 'no' but when I ask them to put in writing that if it transpires to show as a black mark on me, they would undertake to do the donkey work to correct it, (not compensate me, just to sort it out which can take ages) they refused to do so! Surprise surprise.

Again, I know it isn't crime of the century, but I'm interested as I think they've breached data protection and TPS rules as well as their own ts and cs. They say they've not done any if that.

Budding Ph lawyers! Appreciate any opinions! Cheers

voyds9

8,490 posts

314 months

Wednesday 26th February 2014
quotequote all
Have they broken their data protection policy, well it depends on what their policy says. After all you read and agreed to it when you signed up.

They are also entitled to keep your data as long as it is relevant. If they delete it how can they prove you owe them nothing.

I have a requirement to keep data at least 7 years and in some cases up to 25 years.


TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Wednesday 26th February 2014
quotequote all
The energy company's DPA registration will allow them to pass your details on, for legitimate business purposes. They believed they were doing so.

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Wednesday 26th February 2014
quotequote all
IANAL, but perhaps a letter to original company stating that you have proof ( you paid by ?? and got receipt ).
First step might be to write ( using sign on receipt service), referring to phone calls and the reply that "this was just an error", and ask for proof that it was "just an error", and all action would cease .
Then ask for explanation for passing your data on to debt collection agency, as you need this reply before proceeding to pass a breach of DPA to the ICO. State that you dispute this debt, and as this matter is formally in dispute, the debt collectors are in breach of the law . Plenty of templates/advice etc on Consumer Action group. Some legal beagles on here might add more.

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Wednesday 26th February 2014
quotequote all
Debt collection company (or NHS or Local Authority or anyone who uses personal data) also has a duty under DPA to keep the personal data for only as long as it is needed and then delete it, including regular culls of information it no longer has a use for...

wink

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Wednesday 26th February 2014
quotequote all
s3fella said:
I explain it's an error and they need to call supplier, but they won't. I then get an email from them and another call.
Rule number 1.

Never EVER engage with a DCA on the phone. Tell them to put it writing. Then write back saying the debt is disputed/paid (whichever applies) and they must refer it back to the creditor. Any further communication from them is a clear breach of OFT Guidelines (see paragraph o. page 26). If they persist report them.

For example Roxburghe have got into serious trouble over this and the OFT are minded to refuse to renew their credit licence.

Rule number 2.

Remember rule number 1. smile

s3fella said:
I call the energy supplier and have a moan! I point out I'm not happy at the debt collectors having my info, name address, email, phone number and even, who I bank with.
Supplier accepts it is an error, speaks to debt collectors about deleting my data and are told they can only delete my phone number, they need to keep name address, account number and bank for 'internal purposes'.

I'm not getting out of my pram about it, but as I've given private info to supplier and they've passed it on due to an error, is this a breach of data protection act? Supplier says no, as it was an accident, but I've said it's not, it's negligent. Does it matter?

Can I insist my data is deleted? If so ( and I know it doesn't warrant it) but how is that enforced?
See Data Protection Principles 3 and 5. You might want to contact the ICO for clarification as to whether it is appropriate for your information to be held (and if so, for how long) by the DCA given that the supplier censored up and the debt never existed in the first place.

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Wednesday 26th February 2014
quotequote all
RD- clap

Reason I posted was that I'd had something similar from a high street bank. I'd cancelled a standing order before it was due. Bank failed to stop it and as a result charged me a fee. I disputed and extra charges accrued. It got to debt agency ,but when I challenged debt agency , I got a reply with a copy of my bank statements. I wrote to bank asking why they could send out my bank data to a debt collection agency ,prior to a DPA complaint to ICO.

s3fella

Original Poster:

10,524 posts

218 months

Thursday 27th February 2014
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
The energy company's DPA registration will allow them to pass your details on, for legitimate business purposes. They believed they were doing so.
But they've admitted they made an error and that they shouldn't have as there was no debt. The ts and cs say they can pass to acollections agency in order to help collect an outstanding debt. But there wasn't one, so they shouldn't have done so. Which appears to be a breach of their policy to me. But is it against the law?

They've also breached their ts and cs regarding the letters they should have sent prior to passing on this info, which of course they didn't do as there was no reason to, there was no debt.

For the prior poster, I have no issue with the energy supplier holding the details, it's the collection agency that shouldn't have them in the first place.

s3fella

Original Poster:

10,524 posts

218 months

Thursday 27th February 2014
quotequote all
[quote=Who me ?]IANAL, but perhaps a letter to original company stating that you have proof ( you paid by ?? and got receipt ).
First step might be to write ( using sign on receipt service), referring to phone calls and the reply that "this was just an error", and ask for proof that it was "just an error", and all action would cease .
Then ask for explanation for passing your data on to debt collection agency, as you need this reply before proceeding to pass a breach of DPA to the ICO. State that you dispute this debt, and as this matter is formally in dispute, the debt collectors are in breach of the law . Plenty of templates/advice etc on Consumer Action group. Some legal beagles on here might add more.
[/quote]
They've admitted I've paid and that it is an error and they will put this in writing. I just want to know is a breach of their dpa policy a breach of the law?

s3fella

Original Poster:

10,524 posts

218 months

Thursday 27th February 2014
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
s3fella said:
I explain it's an error and they need to call supplier, but they won't. I then get an email from them and another call.
Rule number 1.

Never EVER engage with a DCA on the phone. Tell them to put it writing. Then write back saying the debt is disputed/paid (whichever applies) and they must refer it back to the creditor. Any further communication from them is a clear breach of OFT Guidelines (see paragraph o. page 26). If they persist report them.

For example Roxburghe have got into serious trouble over this and the OFT are minded to refuse to renew their credit licence.

Rule number 2.

Remember rule number 1. smile



s3fella said:
I call the energy supplier and have a moan! I point out I'm not happy at the debt collectors having my info, name address, email, phone number and even, who I bank with.
Supplier accepts it is an error, speaks to debt collectors about deleting my data and are told they can only delete my phone number, they need to keep name address, account number and bank for 'internal purposes'.

I'm not getting out of my pram about it, but as I've given private info to supplier and they've passed it on due to an error, is this a breach of data protection act? Supplier says no, as it was an accident, but I've said it's not, it's negligent. Does it matter?

Can I insist my data is deleted? If so ( and I know it doesn't warrant it) but how is that enforced?
See Data Protection Principles 3 and 5. You might want to contact the ICO for clarification as to whether it is appropriate for your information to be held (and if so, for how long) by the DCA given that the supplier censored up and the debt never existed in the first place.
Cheers for all responses.
I didn't have a lot of option on rule number one as they called me and it was an 'unknown number'. So I had to say something, and they'd already written to me and I'd received the letter that day.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Thursday 27th February 2014
quotequote all
s3fella said:
Cheers for all responses.
I didn't have a lot of option on rule number one as they called me and it was an 'unknown number'. So I had to say something, and they'd already written to me and I'd received the letter that day.
Actually you did. smile They would have had to identify themselves. This would then match up to the letter you had already received. So you wouldn't need to tell them to write. Just say all future communication will be conducted in writing and they are not to telephone you again. Then terminate the call (or leave the phone on while you go and do something else: they will soon get fed up with shouting into thin air). If they refuse to identify themselves (i.e. the company they represent) that too is a fundamental breach of the OFT Guidance.

Persistent such callers can be stopped by Anonymous Caller Rejection. Ask your phone provider how you can activate it. There is normally a small monthly fee but the cost is well worth it. It's the best way to stop the telemarketing/survey pests as well.

23rdian

387 posts

194 months

Thursday 27th February 2014
quotequote all
I'm all for redress usually, but in this case surely its not worth the hassle? Energy company used DCA prematurely. Forget it and move on? Or just switch supplier?

Siscar

6,315 posts

160 months

Thursday 27th February 2014
quotequote all
s3fella said:
They've admitted I've paid and that it is an error and they will put this in writing. I just want to know is a breach of their dpa policy a breach of the law?
Their breach of DPA, if that's what it proved to be, might be enough - if you try hard enough - to get the ICO to say to them something along the lines of 'tut, tut, you shouldn't have done that'.

Any true sanction would come through a court and that is only going to happen if significant loss occurred as a result of the alleged breach.

s3fella

Original Poster:

10,524 posts

218 months

Thursday 27th February 2014
quotequote all
Cheers. No it was just them saying unequivocally that they'd not broken the law and that the ts and cs don't apply as I am an ex customer made me think it's not as simple as that.

It's a shame as during my time as a customer, they were very nice, but I feel this fk up and their blasé attitude to it do them a disservice.