Signs, parking and clearway regulations
Discussion
Can anyone tell me where to look for what is required of a local authority when siting road signs and introducing clearways?
There's a scheme in my neck of the woods that's causing a lot of people to make a mistake that leads to a parking ticket and, the more I look at it, the more I feel it's been designed to trap the unwary.
If I can establish any criteria not met by the local authority, I reckon I'll be doing a lot of people a favour.
And, before the attack monkeys start, no, I haven't been done...
There's a scheme in my neck of the woods that's causing a lot of people to make a mistake that leads to a parking ticket and, the more I look at it, the more I feel it's been designed to trap the unwary.
If I can establish any criteria not met by the local authority, I reckon I'll be doing a lot of people a favour.
And, before the attack monkeys start, no, I haven't been done...

Road sign siting is in the Traffic Signs Manual - it's the chapter for regulatory signs, Chapter 3
https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploa...
I can't remember what's detailed exactly, but it'll be a good start.
Your local authority should have a traffic management policy available on their website which will (should?) detail site-specific stuff. What County Council are you under?
Eta going by your profile, possibly page 15 of this might be of use? It sounds jargony and full of beauracracy and red tape but don't put too much thought in to it, most of it will be common sense stuff (really!).
http://www.derbyshire.gov.uk/images/Chapter%205_tc...
Any signing clashes won't be deliberate, to make money or catch people out. The guys designing it won't be political or in any way to gain from it. If there's genuine confusion then the engineers won't mind having a look at it to see if anything can be some to clarify the situation.

https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploa...
I can't remember what's detailed exactly, but it'll be a good start.
Your local authority should have a traffic management policy available on their website which will (should?) detail site-specific stuff. What County Council are you under?
Eta going by your profile, possibly page 15 of this might be of use? It sounds jargony and full of beauracracy and red tape but don't put too much thought in to it, most of it will be common sense stuff (really!).
http://www.derbyshire.gov.uk/images/Chapter%205_tc...
Any signing clashes won't be deliberate, to make money or catch people out. The guys designing it won't be political or in any way to gain from it. If there's genuine confusion then the engineers won't mind having a look at it to see if anything can be some to clarify the situation.

Edited by OpulentBob on Wednesday 26th February 23:30
The clearway signs on a side road are allowed to be up to 45 m from the junction. The purpose of the signs is generally to warn drivers in the side road that they are approaching a clearway.
This situation is somewhat different in Sheffield in that both the main road and a short section of the side road are designated urban clearways. The devil will be in the detail of the traffic order.
Far be it from me to defend Sheffield City Council but if it's the situation referenced in your other thread one suspects it's an issue arising from shared road space by vehicles and trams. Vehicle on main road intending to turn into side road is prevented from so doing by parked vehicles. Tram delayed or in worst case unable to stop.
The alternative would be to have yellow lines on each side road with the requisite traffic order. More unsightly but clear for the motorist.
Pretty sure this is not deliberate entrapment.
This situation is somewhat different in Sheffield in that both the main road and a short section of the side road are designated urban clearways. The devil will be in the detail of the traffic order.
Far be it from me to defend Sheffield City Council but if it's the situation referenced in your other thread one suspects it's an issue arising from shared road space by vehicles and trams. Vehicle on main road intending to turn into side road is prevented from so doing by parked vehicles. Tram delayed or in worst case unable to stop.
The alternative would be to have yellow lines on each side road with the requisite traffic order. More unsightly but clear for the motorist.
Pretty sure this is not deliberate entrapment.
FiF said:
Pretty sure this is not deliberate entrapment.
No, I don't supposes it is. However, it ought to be clear to anyone designing such regulations that drivers are going to get caught when they can't reasonably be expected to see certain signs as they turn into a side street, whilst concentrating on scanning for other vehicles and pedestrians. Let's call it entrapment by negligence, eh?

The side road I refer to has a "clearway ends" sign well into the junction and there is no sign on the offside, which would be more noticeable than the existing one on the nearside. In my car, the rear view view mirror completely obscures the sign. Looky here...just turned left into this side road.
It's the grey pole on the left, opposite the "clearway starts" sign on the offside, facing the other way.
At night, vehicles are parked on both sides along the full length of the road.
It's come to my attention that parkers are regularly getting nicked here, within the clearway.
There are other side roads close by, but their "clearway ends" signs are far closer to the junction and can generally be seen before turning into the junction. So the question is why is the sign in the problem road so far from the junction?
As you say, yellow lines would be fair. The existing set up isn't.
Edit...
You said this area is designated an Urban Clearway. It isn't, UCs require signs that say Urban Clearway. This area is covered only by round blue signs, red border, red cross, as in rural clearways. Different animals, aren't they?
Edited by mybrainhurts on Thursday 27th February 19:04
Rural clearways and urban clearways are indeed two completely different animals.
Rural clearways are for inter-urban roads where very few premises require access. Note these are not my words.
Urban clearways have to have different signs. If there is no sign on the other side of the road to the grey pole where are the signs informing drivers they are approaching a clearway?
I reckon it's worth a word to the relevant highway engineer.
For people actually ticketed worth an appeal on the basis that signs are not correct.
Rural clearways are for inter-urban roads where very few premises require access. Note these are not my words.
Urban clearways have to have different signs. If there is no sign on the other side of the road to the grey pole where are the signs informing drivers they are approaching a clearway?
I reckon it's worth a word to the relevant highway engineer.
For people actually ticketed worth an appeal on the basis that signs are not correct.
FiF said:
Rural clearways and urban clearways are indeed two completely different animals.
Rural clearways are for inter-urban roads where very few premises require access. Note these are not my words.
Urban clearways have to have different signs. If there is no sign on the other side of the road to the grey pole where are the signs informing drivers they are approaching a clearway?
The only signs are the blue, round, red border, red cross ones. Rural clearways are for inter-urban roads where very few premises require access. Note these are not my words.
Urban clearways have to have different signs. If there is no sign on the other side of the road to the grey pole where are the signs informing drivers they are approaching a clearway?
Entry to clearway, one sign on the clearway and signs on the side roads before the T junction at which you enter the clearway. The Urban Clearway yellow signs are not present anywhere.
Exit from clearway (on the side roads), the round sign with a plate below it, saying ENDS.
Here's an entry sign that's been thoughtfully twisted through 90 deg by a local scrote..
Here again, this is what you should see as you join the clearway. No other signs present.
No lines on the clearway, just like yer actual rural clearway.
So, are they allowed to put a rural clearway in an urban setting?
The terminology is confusing. It's confusing the hell out of me anyway.
It appears as if the clearway has hours of operation ie not 24/7 then it's called an urban clearway. If it's in effect all the time then it's a clearway. However the traffic signs manual refers to rural and urban clearways.
This is all on phone so no real possibility to research.
It appears as if the clearway has hours of operation ie not 24/7 then it's called an urban clearway. If it's in effect all the time then it's a clearway. However the traffic signs manual refers to rural and urban clearways.
This is all on phone so no real possibility to research.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


