B'ham Council still won't give in
B'ham Council still won't give in
Author
Discussion

covboy

Original Poster:

2,593 posts

205 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
What does it need ?


Council transport bosses are putting up new warning signs at controversial Birmingham bus lanes where thousands of drivers have been fined – but have insisted no penalties will be repaid.

The decision came despite independent adjudicator Stephen Knapp ruling that some signage WAS inadequate after an appeals hearing.

Cabinet member Coun Tahir Ali (Lab, Nechells) told the Mail that new signs would be put up before the weekend in three locations to help drivers understand the road lay out.

He said: “My view has always been that the bus lane signs are legal and that has been confirmed by the adjudicator.

"We do not agree entirely with the adjudicator’s recommendations but we do accept them, and we are making further changes that go beyond his recommendations.”

A Traffic Penalty Tribunal was held in Birmingham two weeks ago to consider some of the 500 appeals it had received from angry motorists. Around 100,000 fines have been issued since the scheme was introduced last September, but there will be no refunds for anyone who has already paid up.

“It is up to the individual to exercise their right to appeal,” said Coun Ali.

“If they have paid, they have waived their right to appeal. If the adjudicator had ruled that the signs were non-compliant we would have refunded people.”

But campaigners and councillors argue the council should hand back the cash to ALL motorists caught out by poor signage.

Sutton Coldfield resident Ben Cheney, who had his £60 fine scrapped this week by the adjudicator, said: “If the signage on Priory Queensway was inadequate for me, it must be inadequate for everyone else.

“I think the council should be obliged to refund people their money. Coun Ali is putting his head in the sand. He ought to admit that he has made a mistake.”

His councillor Rob Pocock (Lab, Sutton Vesey) said: “Clearly, many other drivers have been innocently caught by the same poor signage as Mr Cheney and have the same entitlement to justice as he has received.

"The council has some hard thinking to do now, to accept they got it wrong at this specific site, and make amends as best they can.

“The transportation managers and my good colleague Councillor Ali will need to reflect on their own accountability for letting this unacceptable situation get to this state, and not responding more sympathetically when we all first drew this to their attention last autumn”

And Conservative transport spokesman Coun Timothy Huxtable (Bournville) added: “I accept the adjudicator word completely and feel that anyone who was fined in those three locations should be refunded.

"Even if the city council doesn’t have a legal obligation to do this, it should have a moral obligation to be fair.”


http://www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/midlands-news...


Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
How would it be if someone that had been caught tried their arm at recovering £60 through the Small Claims Court????
dvd

GadgeS3C

4,727 posts

195 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
The same "we're right" attitude by BCC worked so well over equal pay...

Dave Hedgehog

16,374 posts

235 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
GadgeS3C said:
The same "we're right" attitude by BCC worked so well over equal pay...
its just the common governmental attitude, they know whats best for us, they are always right, you will comply


FiF

49,020 posts

282 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
By any chance do we have access to a copy of the actual Traffic Tribunal Adjudication. It would be interesting to read why they think the traffic signs are legal yet suggest changes to the signs. That is assuming Birmingham Council statement that the signs were legal is to be trusted, which is a humongous assumption as I don't trust them further than I could throw Eric Pickles with my little finger before I'd had my Shredded Wheat.

One day, just one day, I would like to see a case of misfeasance in public office be brought against these jokers. It might focus their minds a little more facing a charge with maximum sentence of life. Not that I would suggest life for Birmingham parking department as that would cost taxpayers money; public flogging with a cat o' nine against the wash house wall would see justice.

Administer the punishment Mr Christian!


V8 Fettler

7,019 posts

163 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
FiF said:
By any chance do we have access to a copy of the actual Traffic Tribunal Adjudication. It would be interesting to read why they think the traffic signs are legal yet suggest changes to the signs. That is assuming Birmingham Council statement that the signs were legal is to be trusted, which is a humongous assumption as I don't trust them further than I could throw Eric Pickles with my little finger before I'd had my Shredded Wheat.

One day, just one day, I would like to see a case of misfeasance in public office be brought against these jokers. It might focus their minds a little more facing a charge with maximum sentence of life. Not that I would suggest life for Birmingham parking department as that would cost taxpayers money; public flogging with a cat o' nine against the wash house wall would see justice.

Administer the punishment Mr Christian!

I agree. Needs to be aimed at the CEO of the organisation though.

There is a legal term which rebuts the suggestion that paying a penalty indicates acceptance of one's liability.