Over officious steward at a roller disco
Discussion
Evening chaps and chapesses
My nimble brain has been churning over since Saturday when I took the Mac tribe to a local fortnightly roller disco. It was my first visit and Mrs Mac and Miss Mac's second time. Mrs and Miss were skating together and as a reasonably good skater I followed them around taking a video with my mobile.
A recently post pubescent twunt in a hi-viz vest literally ran in between me and my kinfolk preventing me from following them and requesting my name, address, telephone number and postcode. I asked him why this information was required and he said "for the protection of children".
I retorted with "How will YOU having my details protect children?". His response "I have to take these details for the protection of children".
I might have called him a moron, and/or told him to go away. He didn't get my details.
Notwithstanding the fact I was with my family and had I been of dubious character probably wouldn't go 'perving' children where there is 100% parental chaperoning. There was no advance notice that this information must be provided should we wish to photograph/video at this event.
As I said, I have mulled over the situation and cannot resolve the "protection of children" stance, especially as I was filming my child/wife at the time. Was I just being an arse? Should I maintain my stance on the inevitable recurrence or give up my details to be stored who knows where and sold to who knows who?
Ta peeps
Mac
My nimble brain has been churning over since Saturday when I took the Mac tribe to a local fortnightly roller disco. It was my first visit and Mrs Mac and Miss Mac's second time. Mrs and Miss were skating together and as a reasonably good skater I followed them around taking a video with my mobile.
A recently post pubescent twunt in a hi-viz vest literally ran in between me and my kinfolk preventing me from following them and requesting my name, address, telephone number and postcode. I asked him why this information was required and he said "for the protection of children".
I retorted with "How will YOU having my details protect children?". His response "I have to take these details for the protection of children".
I might have called him a moron, and/or told him to go away. He didn't get my details.
Notwithstanding the fact I was with my family and had I been of dubious character probably wouldn't go 'perving' children where there is 100% parental chaperoning. There was no advance notice that this information must be provided should we wish to photograph/video at this event.
As I said, I have mulled over the situation and cannot resolve the "protection of children" stance, especially as I was filming my child/wife at the time. Was I just being an arse? Should I maintain my stance on the inevitable recurrence or give up my details to be stored who knows where and sold to who knows who?
Ta peeps
Mac
Mac
If it were a paid entrance event on private premises they can put up signs saying no photography, OR request you to stop if seen if there are no signs
ie its their 'home' and they make the rules
However what they cannot do is
detain you
Ask for any personal details ( only a policeman can do that)
Take the camera/phone from you ( could constitute assault)
Demand you delete the images
Demand the SD card etc
now this is where the law gets really interesting AND can cause the PC brigade to go apoplectic
In General
You need permission of the landowner if you are on their property and wish to take photgraphs, as above
IF you are on public property (( areas where members of the public are allowed to walk without let or hindrence,)shopping malls etc do not come under this definition) you can take pictures of anybody or anything at anytime, without asking their permission.(unless refused by an officer of the law or someone duly authorised) BUT not one of the trained bouncers/security guards/people in hi-vis vests etc
you can also take pictures of people who are ON private property IF you can see them from an area where the public have access and can view them with the naked eye,without taking undue steps or actions in doing so ( hope that makes sense)
eg You can take pictures inside T5 at Heathrow, but not where security sensitive sections are, so takig a pic of an aircraft is ok but not the customs area
IANAL, but a active amateur photgrapher
If it were a paid entrance event on private premises they can put up signs saying no photography, OR request you to stop if seen if there are no signs
ie its their 'home' and they make the rules
However what they cannot do is
detain you
Ask for any personal details ( only a policeman can do that)
Take the camera/phone from you ( could constitute assault)
Demand you delete the images
Demand the SD card etc
now this is where the law gets really interesting AND can cause the PC brigade to go apoplectic
In General
You need permission of the landowner if you are on their property and wish to take photgraphs, as above
IF you are on public property (( areas where members of the public are allowed to walk without let or hindrence,)shopping malls etc do not come under this definition) you can take pictures of anybody or anything at anytime, without asking their permission.(unless refused by an officer of the law or someone duly authorised) BUT not one of the trained bouncers/security guards/people in hi-vis vests etc
you can also take pictures of people who are ON private property IF you can see them from an area where the public have access and can view them with the naked eye,without taking undue steps or actions in doing so ( hope that makes sense)
eg You can take pictures inside T5 at Heathrow, but not where security sensitive sections are, so takig a pic of an aircraft is ok but not the customs area
IANAL, but a active amateur photgrapher
silverfoxcc said:
IF you are on public property (( areas where members of the public are allowed to walk without let or hindrence,)shopping malls etc do not come under this definition) you can take pictures of anybody or anything at anytime, without asking their permission.(unless refused by an officer of the law or someone duly authorised)
When can a Police officer refuse you permission to film / photograph in a public place -- where it isn't an offence to do so (such as a designated secure no photography area etc).OP, you did the right thing not giving your details and for resisting telling him to do one. Consider writing to the management.
7db said:
When can a Police officer refuse you permission to film / photograph in a public place -- where it isn't an offence to do so (such as a designated secure no photography area etc).
The police can't really "refuse permission" in a public place (or private, for that matter). If the photography were for terrorism / sexual offences / contained evidence the camera could be seized. But these are rare circumstances. It always seems they stop the wrong people and let the knobs carry on.
Sorry I don't really know how to explain myself, but when you see the videos of those horrible creatures sticking a camera in a Policemans face and acting all smug, knowing they are well within their rights do do so. I don't agree with that at all. But this scenario is just silly and over the top!
Sorry I don't really know how to explain myself, but when you see the videos of those horrible creatures sticking a camera in a Policemans face and acting all smug, knowing they are well within their rights do do so. I don't agree with that at all. But this scenario is just silly and over the top!
Next time get your wife/girlfriend to video it. I take my kids to a water park and there are often women filming their offspring and taking pictures which is apparently allowed. Men are not allowed to and I have watched a man being surrounded by rather aggressive looking lifeguards when his Mrs handed him the camera to hold.
Dodsy said:
Next time get your wife/girlfriend to video it. I take my kids to a water park and there are often women filming their offspring and taking pictures which is apparently allowed. Men are not allowed to and I have watched a man being surrounded by rather aggressive looking lifeguards when his Mrs handed him the camera to hold.
Thats because no woman has ever been involved with kiddy fiddling.
Dodsy said:
Next time get your wife/girlfriend to video it. I take my kids to a water park and there are often women filming their offspring and taking pictures which is apparently allowed. Men are not allowed to and I have watched a man being surrounded by rather aggressive looking lifeguards when his Mrs handed him the camera to hold.
This is called sexual discrimination and should be called out as such.I leave it to others to decide how far they would take it. Me? I'm a bolshy little sod so likely as far as a few grand would get me.
Interesting this discussion, I think the assumption is always that the only possible explaination is that you are taking photo's of children for sexual reasons. However Child Protection isn't always about that.
Recently at a Junior League football club a parent was taking pictures for that clubs website....
The opposition coach apparently became very agitated with the parent photographer, demanding that they stop, delete the images from the match etc, really quite an angry exchange.
Two of his players (both under 10 years old) had been removed from abusive parents and were in foster care... the coach being aware of that situation acted correctly to prevent those images however unlikely it might be from being seen on the net. (the fact he was way over the top in style was ultimately neither here nor there)
Clearly not relevant in the OP's situation, but because someone asks you to stop photographing doesn't always mean they are accusing you of being a Paedophile
PAULJ5555 said:
Dodsy said:
Next time get your wife/girlfriend to video it. I take my kids to a water park and there are often women filming their offspring and taking pictures which is apparently allowed. Men are not allowed to and I have watched a man being surrounded by rather aggressive looking lifeguards when his Mrs handed him the camera to hold.
Thats because no woman has ever been involved with kiddy fiddling.
Gargamel said:
Interesting this discussion, I think the assumption is always that the only possible explaination is that you are taking photo's of children for sexual reasons. However Child Protection isn't always about that.
Recently at a Junior League football club a parent was taking pictures for that clubs website....
The opposition coach apparently became very agitated with the parent photographer, demanding that they stop, delete the images from the match etc, really quite an angry exchange.
Two of his players (both under 10 years old) had been removed from abusive parents and were in foster care... the coach being aware of that situation acted correctly to prevent those images however unlikely it might be from being seen on the net. (the fact he was way over the top in style was ultimately neither here nor there)
Clearly not relevant in the OP's situation, but because someone asks you to stop photographing doesn't always mean they are accusing you of being a Paedophile
We got a similar situation at a local school. One of the children is "at risk" (not sure of what the situation is) and therefore we are asked not to put pictures of events/plays etc up on Facebook in case the child in question is recognised. Don't know which child it is, but parents are requested/warned about photography and filming before every school event.Recently at a Junior League football club a parent was taking pictures for that clubs website....
The opposition coach apparently became very agitated with the parent photographer, demanding that they stop, delete the images from the match etc, really quite an angry exchange.
Two of his players (both under 10 years old) had been removed from abusive parents and were in foster care... the coach being aware of that situation acted correctly to prevent those images however unlikely it might be from being seen on the net. (the fact he was way over the top in style was ultimately neither here nor there)
Clearly not relevant in the OP's situation, but because someone asks you to stop photographing doesn't always mean they are accusing you of being a Paedophile
Photography laws in the UK are a mess.
They are pragmatic to the point of being useless.
Anyone can photograph pretty much anything and there's no way to stop them.
The only way to stop them is to use other laws.
Harassment, threatening behaviour, voyeurism, child protection.
There are many suggestions for alternative laws, but what we have now gives all the power to the photographer.
One just needs to hope that a polite chat will stop any issues - but unfortunately there are just as many a
holes with cameras as there are in any other area of life.
They are pragmatic to the point of being useless.
Anyone can photograph pretty much anything and there's no way to stop them.
The only way to stop them is to use other laws.
Harassment, threatening behaviour, voyeurism, child protection.
There are many suggestions for alternative laws, but what we have now gives all the power to the photographer.
One just needs to hope that a polite chat will stop any issues - but unfortunately there are just as many a
holes with cameras as there are in any other area of life.boyse7en said:
We got a similar situation at a local school. One of the children is "at risk" (not sure of what the situation is) and therefore we are asked not to put pictures of events/plays etc up on Facebook in case the child in question is recognised. Don't know which child it is, but parents are requested/warned about photography and filming before every school event.
That is sensible in such instances, if a little annoying.We had a parent at my nephew's birthday party who was all "Think of the children" over pictures being taken. We left it to her to explain why her two were the only ones not in any of the group photos or those that were sent to all the parents a few days after.
Dave Hedgehog said:
PAULJ5555 said:
Dodsy said:
Next time get your wife/girlfriend to video it. I take my kids to a water park and there are often women filming their offspring and taking pictures which is apparently allowed. Men are not allowed to and I have watched a man being surrounded by rather aggressive looking lifeguards when his Mrs handed him the camera to hold.
Thats because no woman has ever been involved with kiddy fiddling.
boyse7en said:
We got a similar situation at a local school. One of the children is "at risk" (not sure of what the situation is) and therefore we are asked not to put pictures of events/plays etc up on Facebook in case the child in question is recognised. Don't know which child it is, but parents are requested/warned about photography and filming before every school event.
possibly some BS they have made up to stop all filming future generations are going to have a great time, they will never be hugged or touched and all the faces of their school friends will be pixelated out, sports day pics should be interesting lol
Dr Jekyll said:
Snowboy said:
Photography laws in the UK are a mess.
They are pragmatic to the point of being useless.
Anyone can photograph pretty much anything and there's no way to stop them.
What would you prefer?They are pragmatic to the point of being useless.
Anyone can photograph pretty much anything and there's no way to stop them.
I fully realise these won't ever become law; I'm just answering your question.

A photographer should not take a 'direct' photo of someone without their permission unless they are clearly performing.
People in the background is a different situation.
If a person asks a tog to stop photographing them then continuing to do so is illegal and punishable.
Although the copyright is held by the tog, the person who is the main focus of the photo should have a veto over the photos use unless they have signed a release.
Dave Hedgehog said:
boyse7en said:
We got a similar situation at a local school. One of the children is "at risk" (not sure of what the situation is) and therefore we are asked not to put pictures of events/plays etc up on Facebook in case the child in question is recognised. Don't know which child it is, but parents are requested/warned about photography and filming before every school event.
possibly some BS they have made up to stop all filming future generations are going to have a great time, they will never be hugged or touched and all the faces of their school friends will be pixelated out, sports day pics should be interesting lol
there has been at least one case in basildon where kids where tracked down by sports day pics posted to facebook.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


