Challenging an invoice due to poor quality work
Challenging an invoice due to poor quality work
Author
Discussion

Nick M

Original Poster:

3,632 posts

254 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all

To set the scene, a house is being refurbished and the main drain was blocked, so obviously needed unblocking.

My father was given the name of a local(ish) plumber who came and started work investigating the blockage and, eventually, clearing it. Dad then also asked him to install a new toilet and sink in the bathroom.

Now, at no stage did either of them discuss money (first 'fail' by the pair of them) and then the plumber had to come back to repair some leaks which he tried to do with silicone sealant on pvc piping (which screamed 'bodge' to dad and I). When the bill arrived it was for a lot of hours and included descriptions for work which hadn't been done (clearing the rubbish away from site, such as the old sink and loo).

He failed to fix the leaks and dad had lost his patience and told him not to come back, and now the plumber has started demanding immediate payment (no payment terms on his invoice, therefore I'm assuming it's due on presentation of the invoice) and is threatening legal action if we don't pay by this Friday.

The guy is a grade A keyboard warrior (some of his emails did make me LOL though) but he's less sure of himself in person, so I'm trying to get a meeting arranged so we can sort this out. Not sure if he'll agree, but figured it was worth a try.

Dad has photographed everything and documented the time and expense to do the repairs properly, but I have a couple of questions:

- is there a contract if no offer is made which is accepted ? Hourly rates, fixed fees, or any other money related conversation were studiously avoided by both sides... So neither has covered themselves in glory, but the opportunity existed for the plumber to suggest pricing, so by NOT doing so I'm assuming it was to try and maximise his profit on the job. The plumber also said in one of his emails that because price hadn't been discussed then he could charge what he liked, which I'm 99.9% sure is wrong;

- he's not interested in discussing this - we've made an offer to pay for the drain cleaning and loo / sink, but feel the cost of the work to put right his 'repairs' should be netted off against his invoice. But if he doesn't agree to that, is the better option to a) wait for legal action to be initiated by him, and then challenge it, or b) pay in full and then put in a claim for the bit of the invoice we're challenging ?

Thoughts and suggestions welcome.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
There was a contract. The contract can be inferred from the conduct of the parties. A contract does not have to be a document written in blood with KONTRACT written on it in big letters. The contract has no clear stipulation as to price, but the plumber can claim a reasonable amount for the work done. If the work was not done with reasonable care and skill, the amount payable may be reduced and/or the plumber may have a liability to the home owner.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Make an open offer, accompanied by a cheque or other tender of payment, for the amount you think it fair to pay add a bit extra for luck). Stipulate that the cheque is tendered in full and final settlement of the plumber's claim. If the plumber accepts the cheque, he is stymied. If he sues, defend the claim on the basis that a fair payment would be what you offered. Be polite and calm and write every letter with a view to it being read by a Judge.

Pagey

1,372 posts

265 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
From what I recall a colleague telling me a little while back, when he joined the FSB he was advised of the followin:



Did the trader provide you with a right to cancel form along with a quote?

fsb said:
On 1 October 2008, the ‘Cancellation of Contracts Made in a Consumer’s Home or Place of Work etc Regulations 2008’ (the Regulations) came into force. These new regulations extend the existing law on cooling-off periods and cancellation rights for consumers and cover contracts made during both solicited visits made by traders – (i.e. visits made at the consumer's request) - and unsolicited visits by traders.
or if starting wort straight away did he ask you to sign a & Day Cancellation form waiving your
cancellation rights:
Something along the lines of:

fsb said:
Customer agreement to commence work prior to the expiry of the statutory seven day cancellation period











I/we agree that (enter trader’s name & address) ……………………………………

…………………………………………………………………………

…………………………………………………….. may commence

the above work on (enter date here) ……………………..……, before my
cancellation period has expired.


I understand that if I decide to subsequently cancel the contract within the seven days, I will be asked to pay for any work or goods that have been carried out or purchased prior to my cancellation.

Name and Address: ……………………………………………………..

……………………………………………………………………………..

……………………………………………………………………………..

……………………………………………………………………………..

Signed: ……………………………………………………………….

Date: ……………………………………………..
IIRC if the trader hasnt given you either of these, should you go to trading standards they will take action against the trader

Edited by Pagey on Tuesday 4th March 16:47

Who Me

96 posts

153 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
As far as the Law stands this guy carried out work at your property and you are liable to pay for that work.
Not sure how you are going to stand as there was no agreed price, but he also cannot charge the earth or in his words whatever he wants.
If you cannot agree a figure with him and settle, when it goes to court you will need to provide quotes from at least 2 other people for what they would of charged for the work and also, 2 quotes for making good his shoddy work. This will allow a judge to see what the worth is of work carried out.
While this is going on right now, prepare for the worse case of legal action and send clear Emails or letters, do not get into personal insults, Imagine you are a judge who will be hearing this case and what evidence you will see from both sides.

Going to be far less stressful for both sides to settle out of court, and far less costly for the loser. By the sound of things you are in the right..Good Luck

gjf764

1,338 posts

206 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Top barrister replies with pragmatic free advice to resolve the situation, FSB view is to go nuclear and threaten the world for not filling in the right form. I know which one I'd go for

Nick M

Original Poster:

3,632 posts

254 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all

A genuine thanks everyone smile

The advice provided here is pretty much how I was going to try and resolve it, i.e. offer a sensible amount of money and try to seek a reasonable agreement, so nice to know that's a sensible way to go about it. And some useful suggestions regarding getting alternative quotes from other plumbers in case it ends up going further.

As for the form - nope, not even a hint of it. But I'm not going to go down the trading standards route unless the guy ends up being utterly unreasonable.

Off to make a few changes to my letter, but one final question if I can - would it be better to make a payment via a cheque (which he can refuse to cash) or via a bank transfer (which is what the plumber keeps asking for) ?? Is either option OK in terms of a covering letter which states we're making a payment in full and final settlement ? I assume a bank transfer just means he has to tell us that he's not accepting the payment as full and final settlement if he wants to pursue the difference ?

Thanks again.