Legal/debt collecting options
Legal/debt collecting options
Author
Discussion

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Here's an odd situation and I am a bit flummoxed.
Company A Ltd is a limited company but a one man band who trades from home.
Company B is owed money by company A and has a CCJ for the debt.
Company A claims to have no money and be insolvent yet continues to trade indefinitely, and clearly makes money.
A third party debt order is not an option due to the fact that the bank account being used to trade is unknown, as are the clients.
Baliffs have proved ineffectual as he simply claims that everything in his home, where he trades, belongs to him and his wife and are nothing to do with the Ltd company and will not allow access.
Winding up is an options, but a pointless one as it would cost a lot and the slippery owner of company A will happily allow it to be wound up as his income would be diverted.
Any suggestions?

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
How much is the debt? If it's over £600 forget county court bailiffs. About as useful as a chocolate teapot. Escalate the CCJ to the High Court. The fee is only £60. A HCEO with a writ may well succeed. They are used to slippery types. If the debtor is trying to hide assets or phoenix the company he might have slipped up. A competent HCEO will soon find out.

Google The Sheriffs Are Coming on youtube.

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
A quick call to HMRC. If the limited co has no assets and cannot afford to pay the CCJ how are they paying for their house etc?


Martin4x4

6,506 posts

163 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Trading while insolvent is unlawful under the 1986 Insolvency Act.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wrongful_trading

If you play it right, you can wind up the company and the liquidator can seize any preferential payments to the 'owner' or shadow directors to pay legitimate creditors.

Edited by Martin4x4 on Tuesday 4th March 20:51

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
The debt has to be more than £750 to issue a winding-up petition and the initial cost to the petitioner is just shy of £1400. The OP would be very unwise, imo, to try managing this process himself unless he has some experience in the field. So there will be additional expense in paying someone to do it for him. The debt would need to be a substantial sum to make it worth the investment. A HCEO has a far better chance of getting the debt to the OP settled without the drawn out process of winding-up/bankruptcy proceedings.

L1OFF

3,794 posts

287 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
I can recommend the HCEO route, I struggled to collect £4500 from a building company I had done some design work for. The court ballifs were ineffectual and got fobbed off with the usual wriggling. I used the HCEO's and they paid up pretty quickly.

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
In my post "Bailiff" referred to HCEO.
If someone is in a residential house and refuses entry, any kind of bailiff is completely ineffectual. All they have to do is stand at the door and say "There are no company assets here and you cannot come in" and the HCEO has no more power than you or I.

I guess what I am asking is whether there are any other methods of debt collection than bailiffs/winding up/third party debt orders. All three in this instance are completely ineffectual

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Send the scaffolders round.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
Company A Ltd is a limited company but a one man band who trades from home.
Company B is owed money by company A and has a CCJ for the debt.
Company A claims to have no money and be insolvent yet continues to trade indefinitely, and clearly makes money.
You need to try and obtain evidence of how he is still trading. Maybe get someone you know (who the debtor doesn't) try to do business with him. See if he can obtain a letterhead and details of the bank account (so that he can make payments).

In the meantime, have you explored this as a way of flushing him out? http://www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/c...
Even if it doesn't succeed in getting you your money, it could make his life difficult. He may be able to stall the HCEO over the debt but he won't be able to avoid appearing for examination. By asking the right questions you should be able to find out quite a lot about his finances. If he refuses to attend he will be taking a big risk.

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
In the meantime, have you explored this as a way of flushing him out? http://www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/c...
Even if it doesn't succeed in getting you your money, it could make his life difficult. He may be able to stall the HCEO over the debt but he won't be able to avoid appearing for examination. By asking the right questions you should be able to find out quite a lot about his finances. If he refuses to attend he will be taking a big risk.
Very interesting. I have never heard of that before and I can think of a few cases in the past where that would have been useful at least, as you say, to make their life awkward
Ive read through it and I cant quite understand it's actual purpose? Is it to make him answerable as to why he hasn't paid the debt?

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
Very interesting. I have never heard of that before and I can think of a few cases in the past where that would have been useful at least, as you say, to make their life awkward
Ive read through it and I cant quite understand it's actual purpose? Is it to make him answerable as to why he hasn't paid the debt?
It's to obtain information about the debtor's finances and should reveal things like bank account details (debtors are required to bring bank statements to prove this) and any assets owned by the company. If you apply for an order against the Ltd company (which from your OP is what you should do) you would name the director as the person who would attend for the company.

The information you obtain should then allow you to identify assets and bank accounts that you can enforce your judgment against.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
Very interesting. I have never heard of that before and I can think of a few cases in the past where that would have been useful at least, as you say, to make their life awkward
You're not alone. Until the BBC series first aired, most people knew the sum of censored all about HCEOs. Oral examination is another useful but little known avenue with which to exert pressure. It won't get you your money but, properly handled, will provide a lot of information from which to decide whether you have any realistic chance of obtaining any.

Andy_GSA said:
blindswelledrat said:
Ive read through it and I cant quite understand it's actual purpose? Is it to make him answerable as to why he hasn't paid the debt?
It's to obtain information about the debtor's finances and should reveal things like bank account details (debtors are required to bring bank statements to prove this) and any assets owned by the company. If you apply for an order against the Ltd company (which from your OP is what you should do) you would name the director as the person who would attend for the company.

The information you obtain should then allow you to identify assets and bank accounts that you can enforce your judgment against.
Beaten to it. smile

The standard form for examining a company officer is here - http://www.moneyclaimsuk.co.uk/PDFForms/EX141.pdf

You, or your representative, can attend court and ask additional questions. With a slippery one man band debtor if you have reason to believe he is trying to conceal information (e.g. about assets or trading through one company but paying himself through another) then it is crucial to frame the questions in such a way that it makes them difficult to circumvent. Also, give some thought to any additional documents which you may want him to produce.

http://www.fbdebt.co.uk/2013/09/oral-examination-i...

OP you might find this useful as well before you launch your Exocet - http://uk.practicallaw.com/books/9781847662903/cha...

Edited by Red Devil on Thursday 6th March 15:42

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks all