S172 for DWDC&A - but not in the area
Discussion
Mornin'
The Mrs received an S172 yesterday, alleges Driving without Due Care in a local car park.
She was in the kitchen texting some mates at the time (she has the log to prove this) and I was with my son at the local pizza van, we walked and it is several miles from where the alleged offence took place.
Quite happy to 'fess up to being the driver if either of us were in the area, but we weren't !
How do you respond to "who was the driver" with "nobody, as we weren't there" ?
Thanks in advance.
N.
The Mrs received an S172 yesterday, alleges Driving without Due Care in a local car park.
She was in the kitchen texting some mates at the time (she has the log to prove this) and I was with my son at the local pizza van, we walked and it is several miles from where the alleged offence took place.
Quite happy to 'fess up to being the driver if either of us were in the area, but we weren't !
How do you respond to "who was the driver" with "nobody, as we weren't there" ?
Thanks in advance.
N.
PurpleMeanie said:
No reason to be there. It is the back of the sports hall/cinema. Shops are nowhere near.
So offense alleged to have happened at the back of some shops, someone cruising and messing around? But why would a cruiser have cloned a car (going back to my previous post)? Interesting, keep us posted, please.civicduty said:
Cloned car, can you ask for photos so that you can point out it isn't actually you or your wife.
While it's not impossible that it's a clone, it's far more likely that an upstanding member of the public has just seen someone back into another car in a car park and drive off... and misread the registration number. There may well be no photos.Aretnap said:
While it's not impossible that it's a clone, it's far more likely that an upstanding member of the public has just seen someone back into another car in a car park and drive off... and misread the registration number. There may well be no photos.
So how would the OP defend themselves against the S172 then?Does your wife remember any kind of incident in that area at any time recently?
The notion that it's a cloned car when it's such a mundane offence and the OP is familiar with the layout of the parking area and has admitted being there before seems fairly outlandish.
That being said if you weren't there at the alleged date/time, you weren't there.
The notion that it's a cloned car when it's such a mundane offence and the OP is familiar with the layout of the parking area and has admitted being there before seems fairly outlandish.
That being said if you weren't there at the alleged date/time, you weren't there.
civicduty said:
Aretnap said:
While it's not impossible that it's a clone, it's far more likely that an upstanding member of the public has just seen someone back into another car in a car park and drive off... and misread the registration number. There may well be no photos.
So how would the OP defend themselves against the S172 then?Durzel said:
Does your wife remember any kind of incident in that area at any time recently?
The notion that it's a cloned car when it's such a mundane offence and the OP is familiar with the layout of the parking area and has admitted being there before seems fairly outlandish.
That being said if you weren't there at the alleged date/time, you weren't there.
No, she doesn't. But it is possible. The notion that it's a cloned car when it's such a mundane offence and the OP is familiar with the layout of the parking area and has admitted being there before seems fairly outlandish.
That being said if you weren't there at the alleged date/time, you weren't there.
I don't think it is a cloned car. It may be a wrong date. Or maybe malicious.
barker22 said:
either way OP, don't fall foul of not filling in the s172 as that is a whole different kettle of fish.
If it is asking for the driver of registration number xxx give them your/your mr's name. Then I would give details of why you don't think the offence is relevant to you.
That is the plan. Explain there could only have been 2 drivers. And why neither of them were there at the time. If it is asking for the driver of registration number xxx give them your/your mr's name. Then I would give details of why you don't think the offence is relevant to you.
And see what happens...

barker22 said:
either way OP, don't fall foul of not filling in the s172 as that is a whole different kettle of fish.
If it is asking for the driver of registration number xxx give them your/your mr's name. Then I would give details of why you don't think the offence is relevant to you.
What do you fill in on the S172 if nobody was driving the car at the time? Their car could have been on their drive or in their garage or a thousand other places but not being driven.If it is asking for the driver of registration number xxx give them your/your mr's name. Then I would give details of why you don't think the offence is relevant to you.
Fill it out truthfully.
The question is:
Who was driving X vehicle at Y location at Z time?
If you cannot say who was driving in those specific conditions say so.
Do not say someone was driving if you don't fully believe it to be true as you are committing an offence and also ruining any defence...
The question is:
Who was driving X vehicle at Y location at Z time?
If you cannot say who was driving in those specific conditions say so.
Do not say someone was driving if you don't fully believe it to be true as you are committing an offence and also ruining any defence...
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



