Driver on trial for killing two toddlers in Leicester
Driver on trial for killing two toddlers in Leicester
Author
Discussion

outnumbered

Original Poster:

4,894 posts

265 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
I read this story in the paper this morning, and thought it was a) tragic but b) interesting from a legal point of view.

The driver's being prosecuted for causing death by dangerous driving. The prosecution say she was on the phone (but it was handsfree, which is entirely legal afaik), and also speeding (36mph). But the main cause of the accident seems to be that another driver crossed a red light, hit the accused, which caused her to crash into the pedestrians. The other driver has since died.

I suppose the contention is that she should have looked and been aware of the person crossing the red light, and been able to avoid the collision, but that's a technique that I'd say most drivers don't follow [as a motorcyclist I'm a bit more attuned to it].

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-ord...



Edited by outnumbered on Wednesday 5th March 11:28

kiethton

14,668 posts

211 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
As sad as this case it it should have never reached court or even a ticket...

Strikes me as the relatives of the fatalities (either kids or other driver) trying to lay the blame elsewhere

ikarl

4,082 posts

230 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
That seems a strange case.
I assume she is only being charged due to the speeding..?

I wonder if she would've been charged if she was doing 31/32/33mph etc

HTP99

25,426 posts

171 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
I didn't know the ins and outs of this story as I just read the headline this morning online however if it is the case that someone ran the redlight causing this woman to crash into the pedestrians then why on earth is it her being prosecuted, it sounds as though she was just in the wrong place at the wrong time and it is all the fault of the other, now deceased driver, it is tragic all round but if those are the facts I think I feel more sorry for the woman.

It seems they are focusing on her speeding more than anything else, what about the car that went through a red?

Edited by HTP99 on Wednesday 5th March 11:42

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
On first viewing it crazy.

But, do we know how long the lights had been red or green.
In some way has her speeding put her into the path of someone who jumped the red at the last moment.

Granted - I'd be looking at the delay on the lights too if this is the case.

But I just wonder if there is something more here.

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
outnumbered said:
The prosecution say she was on the phone (but it was handsfree, which is entirely legal afaik)...
Not if it distracts you to the point of causing you to drive badly. It's the driving badly which is illegal of course, but the use of the phone may be relevant if it offers an explanation of why you were driving badly.

The case basically boils down to whether a competent, careful driver (maybe one who was driving a bit more slowly and paying a bit more attention) would have seem the other car approaching and avoided the collision. That would depend on a lot of things - the layout of the junction, the speed the other car approached at etc. The fact that the light was green helps her case but doesn't automatically mean she's not blameworthy - you don't stop watching the road ahead just because there's a green light do you? It's ultimately a matter for the jury to decide - if after they've heard all the evidence they take the same view as the people on this thread so far she'll be acquitted, but I suspect there's more to be said about the accident than is in a brief newspaper report.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
I'm surprised the charge is DD. Would have thought at the most careless in this case as she wasn't the main contributory factor in the crash? I don't think she should even be in court tbh, tragic as the case is.

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
From the details of the story, that she's being tried seems quite reasonable to me.

Someone else's mistake need not result in an accident. The chance of avoiding that accident obviously increases and decreases with the circumstances, but the mere fact that someone has errored may not excuse you of everything that happens as a result. Apparently the CPS think that she fell below the required competency and duty of care, which also seems quite possible.

berlintaxi

8,535 posts

204 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
kiethton said:
As sad as this case it it should have never reached court or even a ticket...

Strikes me as the relatives of the fatalities (either kids or other driver) trying to lay the blame elsewhere
Seriously?

Try reading the article, the other drivers death had nothing to do with the accident.

I am guessing if the other driver was still alive he would also be on trial.

"It is the prosecution's case the children's death was as a result of the driving of Mr Andrews and Mistry with both their driving falling below the standard of a competent and careful driver."

Rob_T

1,916 posts

282 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
how can they tell that she was doing 36 exactly, unless she was also coincidentally in a speed trap at the time.

either way extremely sad for all involved

liner33

10,861 posts

233 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Read it yesterday , seemed very harsh to me. My wife often calls me on the way home from work , handfree bluetooth she doesnt need to touch or even look at her phone but knowing that you could be held accountably for an accident if you are on the phone seems wrong.

Ok accountable only if you arent a police special and hit a biker

A900ss

3,314 posts

183 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Rob_T said:
how can they tell that she was doing 36 exactly, unless she was also coincidentally in a speed trap at the time.

either way extremely sad for all involved
I'm guessing Tachograph as commercial vehicle.

NPI

1,310 posts

155 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
A900ss said:
I'm guessing Tachograph as commercial vehicle.
BMW commercial vehicle?

Some interesting quotes in the article:
"It is the prosecution's case the children's death was as a result of the driving of Mr Andrews and Mistry with both their driving falling below the standard of a competent and careful driver."

Dangerous driving calls for driving falling FAR below the usual standard.

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
NPI said:
Dangerous driving calls for driving falling FAR below the usual standard.
Perhaps they have an expectation of death by dangerous being reduced to death by careless, rather than going in with the latter and having it reduced to nothing.

williamp

20,468 posts

304 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Maybe cctv could work out the speed? Aso, maybe it shows that the driver swerved towards he unfortunate parent and children, rather then away from then?

V8forweekends

2,506 posts

155 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Article says she was travelling "in excess of 36 mph" not exactly. Perhaps they deduced this from measuring impacts, distance travelled on CCTV, maybe she owned up to it (as if).

If the quality of the spelling and grammar in that article is anything to go by, I wouldn't want to stake anything on the accuracy of the reporting.

Tyre Tread

10,697 posts

247 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Direct quote from |The Telegraph: ' "She did not break or take any action.

"She then crossed in excess of 36mph. She was then struck by the Mini - only after the collision did she apply the breaks - but it was too late."

Horrendous!

NPI

1,310 posts

155 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
trashbat said:
erhaps they have an expectation of death by dangerous being reduced to death by careless, rather than going in with the latter and having it reduced to nothing.
I'm sure there's a 'revenge' element coming from somebody that has resulted in the case going forward.

On the face of it, it seems ridiculous. Perhaps the other driver had made "she came out of nowhere" type of comments in his statement?

kiethton

14,668 posts

211 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
berlintaxi said:
kiethton said:
As sad as this case it it should have never reached court or even a ticket...

Strikes me as the relatives of the fatalities (either kids or other driver) trying to lay the blame elsewhere
Seriously?

Try reading the article, the other drivers death had nothing to do with the accident.

I am guessing if the other driver was still alive he would also be on trial.

"It is the prosecution's case the children's death was as a result of the driving of Mr Andrews and Mistry with both their driving falling below the standard of a competent and careful driver."
The basis and majority of my post is correct IMO - I read an earlier draft in the Daily Fail yesterday where the latter wasn't mentioned.

Correct the other drive would also be on trial but it is the liability of the other driver turning across the path of the BMW that caused the accident...after a collision it is often hard to control the car initially, especially when people/things are close by.

speedking31

3,964 posts

167 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
telegraph said:
"She did not break or take any action.

"She then crossed in excess of 36mph. She was then struck by the Mini - only after the collision did she apply the breaks - but it was too late."
FFS this is a broadsheet.

I suppose if she was going slower she would have had less momentum and possibly pulled up before the collision with the pushchair. That would be a difficult angle to argue. If guilty, then anyone using the phone would automatically be guilty of dangerous driving. The roads could become quite empty soon.