Discussion
williredale said:
And you can drive to a pre-booked MOT.
Has to be provably pre-booked......of which a copper could easily check out. So as long as you have test/fail slip on your person and can show that you are directly en-route home, or to a place to have defects remedied, then one is not in contravention of the law.williredale said:
And you can drive to a pre-booked MOT.
Yes, you can do that without an MOT certificate at all. But the point of my question is: Will having an MOT fail even though the previous MOT certificate was still valid be automatically alerted to officers using the ANPR system?Any police who use ANPR-equipped cars and can tell me the answer to this?
Recent fail before it expired, garage says it is logged as a fail so I will get a tug from plod if they feel the need. Reason being I took it away was they wanted to charge me 80 quid more for the exhaust than the decent local tyre and exhaust centre and I had to take it away before the retest.
So, as I understand it. It still had a valid MOT but it failed on the early retest for a blowing exhaust (small holes, not audible yet) however if the police pull you because the new system says there is a fail and ANPR flags it up, then if the car is unroadworthy then you will still get done for that unroadworthy bit.
Look at it this way, depends what is wrong and how bad but you have just painted a target on yourself until it has passed the MOT.
So, as I understand it. It still had a valid MOT but it failed on the early retest for a blowing exhaust (small holes, not audible yet) however if the police pull you because the new system says there is a fail and ANPR flags it up, then if the car is unroadworthy then you will still get done for that unroadworthy bit.
Look at it this way, depends what is wrong and how bad but you have just painted a target on yourself until it has passed the MOT.
Raize said:
williredale said:
And you can drive to a pre-booked MOT.
Yes, you can do that without an MOT certificate at all. But the point of my question is: Will having an MOT fail even though the previous MOT certificate was still valid be automatically alerted to officers using the ANPR system?Any police who use ANPR-equipped cars and can tell me the answer to this?
I thought you never got a fail but 'A refusal to issues a Pass'. One way to find out the official status may be by going to the website below and entering the VRN and the V5c document number. https://www.gov.uk/check-mot-status
Raize said:
Parsnip said:
How do they determine road worthiness?
My 350Z failed an MOT recently on emissions (needed and Italian tune up and a sympathetic tester to pass it) - after the fail, was I wrong to drive it, or is emissions just an MOT fail, but the car is still roadworthy?
Road worthiness is based on the Construction and Use regulations. I doubt emissions would cause a problem there.My 350Z failed an MOT recently on emissions (needed and Italian tune up and a sympathetic tester to pass it) - after the fail, was I wrong to drive it, or is emissions just an MOT fail, but the car is still roadworthy?
I checked MOT status for my car using the link and got the following:
Link said:
Your MOT details
Registration Mark:
XXXXXX
Make of the vehicle:
XXXXX
Model of the vehicle:
XXXXX
Test Result:
Certificate Issued (Pass)
Colour of the vehicle:
XXXXX
Date of test:
XX/04/2013
Expiry date:
XX/04/2014
Odometer Reading:
XXXXX Miles
VTS undertaking the test:
XXXXXX
VTS telephone number:
XXXXXX
There are later tests for this vehicle that are either test failures or abandoned tests.
Further details are available via the History Check.
Not sure if that would cause a flag on ANPR or not.Registration Mark:
XXXXXX
Make of the vehicle:
XXXXX
Model of the vehicle:
XXXXX
Test Result:
Certificate Issued (Pass)
Colour of the vehicle:
XXXXX
Date of test:
XX/04/2013
Expiry date:
XX/04/2014
Odometer Reading:
XXXXX Miles
VTS undertaking the test:
XXXXXX
VTS telephone number:
XXXXXX
There are later tests for this vehicle that are either test failures or abandoned tests.
Further details are available via the History Check.
Edited by Raize on Saturday 8th March 16:09
Someone on a Merc forum I visit just said he drove for 6mths without an MOT due to some kind of confusion / forgetfulness and never got stopped, but who knows if that's just chance or if ANPR really doesn't show MOT status?
The fail / expiry thing seems to a grey area now. It was perfectly clear in the old days that the Certificate was valid until it expired (despite people often saying the contrary).
However with computerised MOTs they say the certificate isn't a certificate - it's a receipt. And the only way to know the MOT status is to check the computer, which will of course say "Fail".
The slightly boggling thing is the "receipt" says "Certificate" on it!
The fail / expiry thing seems to a grey area now. It was perfectly clear in the old days that the Certificate was valid until it expired (despite people often saying the contrary).
However with computerised MOTs they say the certificate isn't a certificate - it's a receipt. And the only way to know the MOT status is to check the computer, which will of course say "Fail".
The slightly boggling thing is the "receipt" says "Certificate" on it!
Raize said:
Used the history checker however and it shows the failed test. So I guess I am definitely going to get pulled if I keep driving so the real question is if the fail reasons are a breach of C&U.
So the big question is does the issue of a fail or an abandonment of a test negate the original certificate renewal date? Edited by Raize on Saturday 8th March 16:09
ANPR can flag up many things if the filters are set for it. It is one thing for a vehicle to activate the system, another to have a crew to be in a position to stop it.
WeI generally have six crews to Police 500miles of m/way , so I'll leave you to do the maths about what filters are set.
WeI generally have six crews to Police 500miles of m/way , so I'll leave you to do the maths about what filters are set.
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1986/1078/regul...
Nice gray area in section 5. "All reasonable expedition". Is saving up for the repair considered reasonable in the eyes of the law?
Nice gray area in section 5. "All reasonable expedition". Is saving up for the repair considered reasonable in the eyes of the law?
rewc said:
Raize said:
Used the history checker however and it shows the failed test. So I guess I am definitely going to get pulled if I keep driving so the real question is if the fail reasons are a breach of C&U.
So the big question is does the issue of a fail or an abandonment of a test negate the original certificate renewal date? Edited by Raize on Saturday 8th March 16:09
"You can still drive your vehicle if it fails the test and its existing MOT certificate is still valid (ie you got it tested before the expiry date). However, you might be stopped by police and prosecuted if your vehicle is unroadworthy."
That's pretty much set in stone. But the question is if the failed test paints a massive target on you and increases your chance of getting stopped hugely.
Raize said:
But the question is if the failed test paints a massive target on you and increases your chance of getting stopped hugely.
No.This subject has been done to death on here over the years, but here we go again...
1. An MOT certificate is no more than a bit of paper (well, and a computer record these days) that says the vehicle was roadworthy on the date that the tester issued the certificate. It is not a guarantee that the vehicle is still roadworthy even when you drive it off the garage forecourt, let alone a year later.
2. In reality it is not really any sort of "guarantee" even when it is being written out. A cynic might say that all it shows is that the tester didn't spot anything to fail it on, and that in itself doesn't mean there wasn't something he missed.
3. When you leave the garage proudly clutching you new MOT bit of paper, it does two things. Firstly it says that the vehicle has a valid MOT certificate, and secondly it says that it is valid for a year.
4. If. lets say, your MOT expires on April 15th and you take it in to be tested on April 10th and it fails, the car still has a valid MOT certificate. The retest does not invalidate the existing certificate. You still have a valid MOT until April 15th so you cannot be done for failing to have a valid MOT certificate, because you've got a valid MOT certificate. You got it last year and it is still valid. You could of course be done for whatever it is the car failed on (if covered by C&U regs), but you could have been done for that at any time since the fault developed, without going to a testing station to get a refusal note.
5. Finally, take anything a garage mechanic tells you that you can't corroborate immediately with a huge pinch of salt, especially if they take a sharp intake of breath and use the word "illegal" in a sentence. Quite often all they are trying to do is drum up some business. My usual line is "I don't go to my lawyer to ask him to change my tyres, and I don't come here for legal advice"
Shuts 'em up every time

Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


