30.1mph in a 30 zone - illegal?
30.1mph in a 30 zone - illegal?
Author
Discussion

AA999

Original Poster:

5,180 posts

248 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
We all hear the 10%+2mph 'rule' given by many police forces, but in actual fact isn't it just a courtesy factor that the police offer to motorists?

If for example a motorist was caught in a speed trap whereby the local so called 'safety camera partnership' hid behind a bush and were determined to keep capture numbers up, that they could legally issue a speeding ticket to a vehicle going 30.1mph in a 30zone?

(If they were able to prove in court that their technical equipment was accurate to that degree?)


Just my random question of the day wink

ED209

6,027 posts

275 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
Yes they could issue a ticket, would anybody issue a ticket - no chance.

jmorgan

36,010 posts

315 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
Brunstrom would if he were still head plod.

Moonhawk

10,730 posts

250 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
Based on the definition of a speed limit in the highway code (being the absolute maximum speed you should travel) - then technically, any amount over it is a breach and could in theory be prosecuted.

The practicalities in detecting and proving it would however, make implementing such a policy highly unlikely.

Exige77

6,523 posts

222 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
AA999 said:
We all hear the 10%+2mph 'rule' given by many police forces, but in actual fact isn't it just a courtesy factor that the police offer to motorists?

If for example a motorist was caught in a speed trap whereby the local so called 'safety camera partnership' hid behind a bush and were determined to keep capture numbers up, that they could legally issue a speeding ticket to a vehicle going 30.1mph in a 30zone?

(If they were able to prove in court that their technical equipment was accurate to that degree?)


Just my random question of the day wink
Don't think it's a "Rule" as such, more of a guideline.

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
The ACPO say that the tolerance of current equipment is +/- 2mph up to 66mph and +/- 3mph above it.

http://www.acpo.police.uk/documents/uniformed/2013...

mel

10,168 posts

306 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
The 10%+"x"mph is purely a guideline for the threshold for prosecution. A guideline issued by the jobs for the boys Limited Company that is the ACPO, so in law it carries no more weight than the guidelines I've just issued saying 200% + 50mph is fine.

hunton69

674 posts

168 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
A few years back a customer bought an American motorhome from a main importer found out it was over 100 inches wide (that's the uk max)when he had to replace the windscreen(approx. 2.5 inches to wide) wanted his money back from dealer. Went all the way to the high court and lost(done about 300 grand)
Judge actually quoted the speed limit law saying you would never get done at 31 in a 30. There is always some tolerance

Centurion07

10,395 posts

278 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
hunton69 said:
A few years back a customer bought an American motorhome from a main importer found out it was over 100 inches wide (that's the uk max)when he had to replace the windscreen(approx. 2.5 inches to wide) wanted his money back from dealer. Went all the way to the high court and lost(done about 300 grand)
Judge actually quoted the speed limit law saying you would never get done at 31 in a 30. There is always some tolerance
Eh?

BMWBen

4,906 posts

232 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
Centurion07 said:
hunton69 said:
A few years back a customer bought an American motorhome from a main importer found out it was over 100 inches wide (that's the uk max)when he had to replace the windscreen(approx. 2.5 inches to wide) wanted his money back from dealer. Went all the way to the high court and lost(done about 300 grand)
Judge actually quoted the speed limit law saying you would never get done at 31 in a 30. There is always some tolerance
Eh?
This one time... at band camp...

IanA2

2,897 posts

193 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
I have some doubts about these guidelines. MrsIanA2 was flashed a few years ago by a camera doing 46 mph in a 40 limit. Ticket came, £60 and 3 points, no offer of any speed awareness course.

ETA: This was Northamptonshire.

mcford

819 posts

205 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
Don't they need a reasonable suspicion of speeding before they check it with their equipment?, if so, someone's got to be good to see a 0.1mph speed difference.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
IanA2 said:
I have some doubts about these guidelines. MrsIanA2 was flashed a few years ago by a camera doing 46 mph in a 40 limit. Ticket came, £60 and 3 points, no offer of any speed awareness course.
Assuming courses were being offered in that area at that time, an invite to attend would have been entirely at the discretion of the local SCP / police, as well as being subject to other pre-qualifying criteria.

TheD

3,144 posts

230 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
Friend of mine got done last week for 44 in a 40. I said nah...he produced the letter.

IanA2

2,897 posts

193 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
SS2. said:
IanA2 said:
I have some doubts about these guidelines. MrsIanA2 was flashed a few years ago by a camera doing 46 mph in a 40 limit. Ticket came, £60 and 3 points, no offer of any speed awareness course.
Assuming courses were being offered in that area at that time, an invite to attend would have been entirely at the discretion of the local SCP / police, as well as being subject to other pre-qualifying criteria.
The main point I was making was about the guidelines; ie if they are as stated, should the camera not have been set at 47 mph?

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
10%+2 refers to the lowest speed you'll be prosecuted for, not the highest you'll get away with, so in a 40 limit the cameras would be set to catch cars doing 46 and above.

BertBert

21,345 posts

242 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
IanA2 said:
The main point I was making was about the guidelines; ie if they are as stated, should the camera not have been set at 47 mph?
That's because you misunderstand the guidelines.

The guidelines started at below 10%+2. So assuming a 1 mph accuracy, at 10%+1 the occifer had discretion on whether to prosecute. At 10%+2 they didn't have discretion. They had to take action.

So fast forward to today...if the guidlines are in force you will get done at 10%+2, but not done at 10%+1.

So being an anally retentive old guy, I set my cruise control to run at 78mph on the motorway.

Bert

jfbrin

415 posts

203 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
TheD said:
Friend of mine got done last week for 44 in a 40. I said nah...he produced the letter.
Interesting. What happened to +10% "allowance"? I thought that was a safety margin one could rely on?

Thought I was hard done by when booked doing 80 in a 70 on M4 in Wales.

tbc

3,017 posts

206 months

Wednesday 12th March 2014
quotequote all
How anyone that sticks to the 30mph limit gets anywhere in the same day is beyond me.

30mph is too slow

QBee

22,545 posts

175 months

Wednesday 12th March 2014
quotequote all
tbc said:
How anyone that sticks to the 30mph limit gets anywhere in the same day is beyond me.

30mph is too slow
Not when you are the pedestrian who trips on a raised manhole while stepping out into the road in a busy town shopping street, momentarily distracted by their grandchild and mobile phone both going off at the same time. Please drive within 20/30 limits and with your brain in gear. It's not all about other vehicle drivers.