Yes/No CSA Questions
Author
Discussion

TedMaul

Original Poster:

2,092 posts

244 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
1) Does the benefitting parents salary get taken into consideration at all? It seems not according to the questionaire?

2) The last question in the questionnaire asks about how many nights the kids stay over with the paying parent. Ex has been banging on for ages about having every Sunday, though we split the other 6 days I want it straight 50/50, I suspect her reason is to take it below the 175 nights threshold as this seems to result in a big jump. My way I have them average of 182 nights a year, she gets the same, her way she gets 200 and I get 156. As she is the mum, if I want proper 50/50 I presume i'd have to go to court and probably lose so if the threshold is 174 nights a year, she can give me 173, I pay the extra and then I get some ad-hoc ones now and again which probably dont end up counting unless I count them all up and again, go to court and probably lose.

Beginning to understand all the SWT comments these days...... will be a while before I start a "dating game in your 40s thread"

TIA for any responses, offline until Friday so apologies if I dont respond to any answers or questions

Ted

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
In theory the courts seek fairness for the children in every separation. In practice I think that most children tend to spend more time with their mothers and there is an unwritten bias in favour of the mothers position because of this. I do not think it is a considered bias but I do think that there is one. In consequence you would probably not get your way if the mother objects.

It would be far better to maintain good relations with your ex if you can. She will, after all, always be the children's mother. The less hassle there is the less likely the children are to be affected. I appreciate that some parents seek confrontation but IMO that is a bad idea whatever the reasons. Time is a great healer. Looking forward to your children growing up and making every effort to support them in that process is a much better focus than looking back to the painful days of disputes and separation. I wish you well.

JumboBeef

3,772 posts

208 months

Wednesday 12th March 2014
quotequote all
1) No. She could be earning £200K/pa and be living with a Millionaire. You will still have to pay the same amount, even if she doesn't need it at all and it leaves you with £10 to last to the end of the month.

2) Please don't fall into the trap of "pay per view" children. Only seeing children on certain days just to reduce your payment or from her point of view restricting contact to increase her income. Work out what is best for the children regardless of the financial implications and go with that.

From someone who has (and continues to be) mangled by The CSA and The Family Courts.

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Wednesday 12th March 2014
quotequote all
1) It's not for her, it's for the children (snigger)

2) It goes on the past, so at least for the first few months, it would be based on the 50/50 split.

toddygti

96 posts

169 months

Wednesday 12th March 2014
quotequote all
randlemarcus said:
1) It's not for her, it's for the children (snigger)

2) It goes on the past, so at least for the first few months, it would be based on the 50/50 split.
1) Spot on really

2) It is supposed to be based on the current circustances, however if she lies and says you only have them 1 day a year, they will take this and use it and it is then down to you to prove otherwise over the coming years that you them more often. If you succeed they will reduce the payments down to balance the overpayment. However, convincing them can take years and in the meantime you et caned for the full rate.

S2Mike

3,065 posts

181 months

Wednesday 12th March 2014
quotequote all
They make assumptions about the father, and you are expected to live on the absolute minimum, even if you do have the kids half the time, only seems to be reviewed when someone kicks off.
Make sure you keep a diary of everything, however insignificant it seems at the time, sounds petty but if you can show clear documentation, it seems to have some effect, if and when problems occur.
I speak from bitter experience over 14 years since separating and divorcing, once armed with the diary I found I could confidently give accurate answers with dates and times.
Plus in years to come, you can sit down with the kids and explain what went on and why, which removes the blame game that can happen.

JumboBeef

3,772 posts

208 months

Wednesday 12th March 2014
quotequote all
S2Mike said:
Plus in years to come, you can sit down with the kids and explain what went on and why, which removes the blame game that can happen.
Yep, I had that conversation with my (then) 15 year old daughter a couple of years ago. Her mother had told her I hadn't ever paid a penny. I showed her CSA statements going back over the years showing the many thousands I had paid. Opened her eyes somewhat.

AndyNetwork

1,849 posts

225 months

Wednesday 12th March 2014
quotequote all
Another one to watch out for - "Yes, you can have them for 7* days a week, but I want them back at night." (*Insert appropriate number of days here)

The CSA only take into account the number of overnight stays the children have with the paying parent, not the costly daytime. This is something I have found out to my peril just recently. I have traditionally had my children every other weekend, and even arranged holidays etc, so I am not away for the days I am to have them. However, they have recently started saying they will come during the day, but not stop over. Hey presto, the next thing I know the payments to my ex wife go through the roof, as I don't have them overnight any more.

It still costs me the same as when they did, as I have them during the day. Swimming, food, pictures, treats all cost the same as when I had them overnight, but now I have to find this on top of the additional payment to my ex wife, who when she gets them back at night puts them to bed, and then sends them back to me the following morning, ready for breakfast.

Edited by AndyNetwork on Wednesday 12th March 16:32

TedMaul

Original Poster:

2,092 posts

244 months

Wednesday 12th March 2014
quotequote all
All valuable, thank you.

Its very amicable right now and I have a very good relationship with my kids, 6&8 which I want to keep.

We have agreed absolute 50/50 but I have said i'm happy to pay whats needed and over the odds if required, so just have to see how things go. Like I say, its fine now but she has hinted at asking for money, so based on endless ph tales and friends 1st hand experiance, I hope for the best but plan for the worst

Like the diary idea, may start doing that....

richardrsc

328 posts

166 months

Wednesday 12th March 2014
quotequote all
TedMaul said:
All valuable, thank you.

Its very amicable right now and I have a very good relationship with my kids, 6&8 which I want to keep.

We have agreed absolute 50/50 but I have said i'm happy to pay whats needed and over the odds if required, so just have to see how things go. Like I say, its fine now but she has hinted at asking for money, so based on endless ph tales and friends 1st hand experiance, I hope for the best but plan for the worst

Like the diary idea, may start doing that....
Best of luck, mine's pretty much sorted now, but it's a horrible thing to go though. As a bloke you just get fked over at every turn. Lube well...

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
TedMaul said:
Like the diary idea, may start doing that....
Forget 'may'- for your own sake, do it.

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
TedMaul said:
I hope for the best but plan for the worst

Like the diary idea, WILL may start doing that....
Good plans all.

The diary will also help you answer the questions in your own mind about if you are being reasonable or not when they arise...

shakindog

516 posts

181 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all

Try to keep it amicable it's hard when the ex is trying to shaft you at every turn.

After years of hassle with my ex my son now lives with permanently as a result of his mum's unreasonable behaviour towards him his sisters and me.
Hopefully the other 2 will follow in the nextfew years.

It's a kick in the spuds when you know the money you pay towards your children is used for nights out on the pull.
Just grin and bear it as the long road your travelling will be worth it in the end