we really do need retesting at 70
Discussion
julian64 said:
moronic thread OP.
Assuming a twenty year old nicks a car, drives like a t
t and then kills someone, would you say
a) Stick the idiot in jail
b) Ban all twenty year olds from the road.
Woah there sparky, I don't think the OP has suggested anything. His post was a link only and the thread title suggests retesting. Why the insult?Assuming a twenty year old nicks a car, drives like a t
t and then kills someone, would you saya) Stick the idiot in jail
b) Ban all twenty year olds from the road.
One commenter in the newspaper report hits the nail on the head for me, would they be so lenient if it was a driver in their 20's?
1) Retesting at 70 would make no difference to this moronic driver - she is banned but still drives
2) As usual, the reaction to one bad person is to suggest we impose something stupidly expensive and onerous on everyone.
3) There are plenty of people of all ages who shouldn't be driving, and plenty of all ages who are fine.
2) As usual, the reaction to one bad person is to suggest we impose something stupidly expensive and onerous on everyone.
3) There are plenty of people of all ages who shouldn't be driving, and plenty of all ages who are fine.
Hackney said:
julian64 said:
moronic thread OP.
Assuming a twenty year old nicks a car, drives like a t
t and then kills someone, would you say
a) Stick the idiot in jail
b) Ban all twenty year olds from the road.
Woah there sparky, I don't think the OP has suggested anything. His post was a link only and the thread title suggests retesting. Why the insult?Assuming a twenty year old nicks a car, drives like a t
t and then kills someone, would you saya) Stick the idiot in jail
b) Ban all twenty year olds from the road.
One commenter in the newspaper report hits the nail on the head for me, would they be so lenient if it was a driver in their 20's?
Its a logic fail.
1) Woman shouldn't be driving
2) Woman is 70
ergo 70 year olds shouldn't be driving (without further testing).
Its the sort of logic fail that shouldn't really be allowed to pass without comment, because its not even ageist, its just moronic.
Two separate issues here.
Firstly, the woman in the article should have the book thrown at her regardless of age. Although banning her seems to have no affect. What then, prison?
Second and wider issue, if you learn how to pass a driving test at 17 do you remain a good driver until the day you die? Ideally ongoing coaching and retesting should be compulsory but it'd be expensive. So do you just enforce a retest? If you fail - depending on the severity of the fail - are you banned or forced to go back to provisional licence / L plates, maybe P plates, until you've had lessons and passed another test.
I'd be supportive of that. No doubt a number of people would get to a certain age and lose interest anyway.
Being caught driving after failing a test results in a ban.
Firstly, the woman in the article should have the book thrown at her regardless of age. Although banning her seems to have no affect. What then, prison?
Second and wider issue, if you learn how to pass a driving test at 17 do you remain a good driver until the day you die? Ideally ongoing coaching and retesting should be compulsory but it'd be expensive. So do you just enforce a retest? If you fail - depending on the severity of the fail - are you banned or forced to go back to provisional licence / L plates, maybe P plates, until you've had lessons and passed another test.
I'd be supportive of that. No doubt a number of people would get to a certain age and lose interest anyway.
Being caught driving after failing a test results in a ban.
It's OK to keep shouting for re-tests at 70 or every 10 yrs as suggested, but who's going to pay for this lot ?
I have a car, bike, HGV & PSV so I would need to do four separate tests, I don't think so.
Punish the bad or incompetent drivers by all means, but not every one else.
Easier still, 12 penalty points then a re-test for that class of vehicle
I have a car, bike, HGV & PSV so I would need to do four separate tests, I don't think so.
Punish the bad or incompetent drivers by all means, but not every one else.
Easier still, 12 penalty points then a re-test for that class of vehicle
gus607 said:
It's OK to keep shouting for re-tests at 70 or every 10 yrs as suggested, but who's going to pay for this lot ?
I have a car, bike, HGV & PSV so I would need to do four separate tests, I don't think so.
Punish the bad or incompetent drivers by all means, but not every one else.
Easier still, 12 penalty points then a re-test for that class of vehicle
And what for example you are a bus driver and fail your PSV, now your out of a job?I have a car, bike, HGV & PSV so I would need to do four separate tests, I don't think so.
Punish the bad or incompetent drivers by all means, but not every one else.
Easier still, 12 penalty points then a re-test for that class of vehicle
Retesting at intervals really is a non starter. Punish those etc etc as you suggest.
We have a lot of older drivers who are more than competent to drive, and probably an equal amount of younger drivers who are less competent, I met one today.

Edited by Vipers on Wednesday 12th March 17:17
gus607 said:
It's OK to keep shouting for re-tests at 70 or every 10 yrs as suggested, but who's going to pay for this lot ?
I have a car, bike, HGV & PSV so I would need to do four separate tests, I don't think so.
Punish the bad or incompetent drivers by all means, but not every one else.
Easier still, 12 penalty points then a re-test for that class of vehicle
I think a retest would really highlight how many bad or incompetent drivers are out there.I have a car, bike, HGV & PSV so I would need to do four separate tests, I don't think so.
Punish the bad or incompetent drivers by all means, but not every one else.
Easier still, 12 penalty points then a re-test for that class of vehicle
A retest would be paid for by the driver. But, I'd suggest a competency / awareness test rather than full theory (£31) and practical (£62) tests, say £50 in total?
And for those with multiple licences, perhaps the test would be more generic or maybe there's a £50 Driving Competency Test with supplementary HGV, PSV, Motorbike parts at £10 each.
Clearly it would cost some more than others but would the benefits outweigh that both on a total level and a personal level, reduced insurance premiums perhaps?
Much of the infrastructure is in place already and I seem to remember that fewer and fewer kids are taking their driving tests due to the high costs of driving when you're young, so perhaps this would help keep testing offices going.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



