Private parking, only payable by mobile phone.
Private parking, only payable by mobile phone.
Author
Discussion

FiF

Original Poster:

49,011 posts

282 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
Saw this the other day.

It was one of these free two hours, then a charge which was a contractual charge for staying over 2 hours up to 24 hours. If not paid then there would be a penalty charge after obtaining details from DVLA etc.

Ignoring the issue that the charges varied between different signs in the same car park, eg stay for 24 hours £10 or £12 or penalty for non payment £105 or £115 dependent upon which sign you read, plus many interpretations of the wording possible, from reading the signs it was only possible to pay by mobile phone.

Agreeing with Justinp1's point on another thread re the Parking Eye case and the judge's point of the appalling wording of the "contract" ad justin's point of "you only had one job" I wondered how this only payable by mobile phone malarkey would stand up.

I know previously in this park one could pay the charge in a shop, but that doesn't seem to be the case currently. I stayed less than 30 minutes so no charge payable by me but just wondering.

Corpulent Tosser

5,468 posts

276 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
Normally I have sympathy for the owners of car parks and do not like the usual "it is an unenforceable speculative invoice so do as you like" attitudes, but when the signage is not clear then the car park owners get no sympathy, how difficult is it to be clear, concise and consistent with the signs.

pherlopolus

2,192 posts

189 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
I only have a work phone which has the 'park by mobile' numbers barred, gets very difficult to park at times...

Usually have to email the company with the details/reg/etc and get them to call/give number so you can ring them normally and pay.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
FiF said:
Agreeing with Justinp1's point on another thread re the Parking Eye case and the judge's point of the appalling wording of the "contract" ad justin's point of "you only had one job" I wondered how this only payable by mobile phone malarkey would stand up.
On the first bit about the signs been contradictory or unclear, the rule is 'contra proferentem', so against the party drawing up the contract, and in the positive interpretation of the parker.

On the mobile phone thing, that's interesting, legally, and from the point of view that this may be PPC MKII.

By that I mean (and in direct relevance to the other thread) that, if Parking Eye or anyone else can get their overhead down, and make taking payments easy, they could say charge £5-10 for parking. Then, should that not be paid, then they could levy another £60 as costs of chasing up the debt. That pulls them out of the legal sticky patch they currently reside in.


With regards to the legality, it's difficult to give a generalisation without seeing what the contract says. My only thought at the moment is that at the point of consideration, the parker may agree to pay £5, but if there was a problem with payment, and with no other way of providing the amount considered, then the £100 or whatever charge would be levied. In that case, it would IMHO be a penalty clause.

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
do they actually say it's a penalty charge
or some convoluted contractual mumbo jumbo that makes what is obviously a penalty charge appear as a legal charge for the fantastic service they will provide you

FiF

Original Poster:

49,011 posts

282 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
Will be a couple of weeks before going back there to have a look. From memory and no longer in first flush of youth these days I don't think they say what it is.

Clearly the £10 or £12 for up to 24 hour parking is a parking charge. That seemed to be clear. Failure to pay will result in a charge also rings a bell.

Could be wrong but seem to think I have seen signs from this outfit also at Trowell services. Bit vague I know, sorry.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
I've experienced a RinGo pay by phone car park at Darlington train station. I can't remember if you could only pay by phone but at the time it was the only option availiable to me. It was a pain in the bloody backside and very stressful when you have a train to catch.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
FiF said:
I know previously in this park one could pay the charge in a shop, but that doesn't seem to be the case currently. I stayed less than 30 minutes so no charge payable by me but just wondering.
If it is this lot www.moto-way.co.uk under govt policy they have to accept cash payments on site, no iffs or butts,
Sec B19 page 18 https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/strateg...

They do also have a full webpage on parking faq's

FiF said:
Will be a couple of weeks before going back there to have a look. From memory and no longer in first flush of youth these days I don't think they say what it is.

Clearly the £10 or £12 for up to 24 hour parking is a parking charge. That seemed to be clear. Failure to pay will result in a charge also rings a bell.

Could be wrong but seem to think I have seen signs from this outfit also at Trowell services. Bit vague I know, sorry.
If it is the same 'outfit' as at Trowell the signage may be quite confusing for "people who prefer not to pay" from what I've seen as they prefer people to not make cash payments.

blank

3,767 posts

219 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
I've experienced a RinGo pay by phone car park at Darlington train station. I can't remember if you could only pay by phone but at the time it was the only option availiable to me. It was a pain in the bloody backside and very stressful when you have a train to catch.
Get the app.

No faffing with change, can pre book parking (e.g. if you're parking over night and charges kick in in the morning), can extend parking if your shopping takes longer than expected.

Works a treat!

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
On street parking. So simple,if you take a leaf out of the ones I see using my local store . They take grand kid out for a trip . Park at shop doors in wide spaces. So , be a good neighbour. Take that old lady who needs to use a stick/crutch/wheelchair ( as long as she's got a blue badge) shopping. No need to pay, just find a stretch of yellow lines ( without a waiting restriction) ,stick badge in window and that's up to three hours for free. And you're being a thoughtful person. Can't be bad ( Now where's that tongue in cheek smilie......)