Hiring a solicitor
Author
Discussion

Kinjak

Original Poster:

18 posts

231 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
Hi guys,

I am after some advice about employing a solicitor.

I was hit from behind while stationary in early December. My car claim is settled.

Now while i'm sure some of you will scoff, i did suffer neck pains for the following month.

After much consideration i decided to pursue an injury claim.

I contacted a solicitor recommended by friend and I am reading the agreement and I am hoping for some advice before signing it.

The solicitor I contacted before Christmas has contacted me, and I asked him about the documentation he sent me.Most of it i understand and sounds reasonable, the part i am questioning is the fees, specifically "the success fee". In the schedule attached this is explained as 100% of the basic charges. I contacted the solicitor and he explained it as follows.

They operate on a no-win no-fee basis. Assuming a win, they claim costs. This was around £1300 but was recently reduced to £500, (I believe he quoted government changes).
So to balance out, they need to claim a success fee, which can be up to 100% of costs (£500) or 25% of the total compensation (I think he said whichever is greater but i didn't note this down during the conversation). He explained that section is written according to guidelines set out by by a higher power (i believe he may have said Law society) and essentially blamed them for it containing confusing language.

Now assuming this is normal practice (which hopefully it is) that's fine. Speaking to to the solicitor however didn't exactly exactly leave me feeling reassured, i felt i was speaking to a salesman. Which i suppose is understandable given the how much competition there is. It just made me want to fact check hence my post.

I could post the page from the contract referring to the success fee if anyone wants it, however i'm not sure that whether that is acceptable. Let me know if it is or i'll PM it if anyone asks. Any and all comments appreciated.

This was supposed to be a quick question, if it's turned into a wall of text, apologies.

TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
Kinjak said:
Hi guys,

I am after some advice about employing a solicitor.

I was hit from behind while stationary in early December. My car claim is settled.

Now while i'm sure some of you will scoff, i did suffer neck pains for the following month.

After much consideration i decided to pursue an injury claim.

I contacted a solicitor recommended by friend and I am reading the agreement and I am hoping for some advice before signing it.
You suffered a sore neck for a month.

So did you suffer any financial loss as a result?

I also was hit from behind and suffered a sore neck for a few months.I got on with life and did not claim.

Pobolycwm

330 posts

211 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
I got whacked from behind by a Range Rover, wrote the car off , did I claim ? No

My daughters have both run into the back of vehicles, did the other drivers claim ? No

You got a pain in the neck ..........

mattshiz

461 posts

172 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
if you haven't got anything nice to say then don't say anything at all. Nobody really cares that you didn't claim, what did you want a medal? The o/p has every right to pursue legal advice, unfortunately i can't help with that matter.

Zeeky

2,954 posts

243 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
OP, it is normal practice. Prior to the recent changes in the law the success fee was added to the solicitor's costs and paid by the losing party.

This is no longer the case and the solicitor is only entitled to charge you the fee. You cannot be charged more than £500 but if this figure is greater than 25% of your award for damages the fee will be reduced accordingly.

TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
mattshiz said:
if you haven't got anything nice to say then don't say anything at all. Nobody really cares that you didn't claim, what did you want a medal? The o/p has every right to pursue legal advice, unfortunately i can't help with that matter.
It's not exactly a nasty reply is it?
In fact your reply about a medal could be seen as not being a nice reply.

Either way I do not care what you think.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
The solicitor that you spoke to probably was a sales person, and may not even have been a solicitor (ie he or she may have been an employee of a law firm who is not a solicitor). At the level of the market that you are dealing with, the operators are mostly just concerned with churning files. In general, the rule is that you can have a cheap lawyer, or you can have a good lawyer, but you can't have both. A lawyer who cannot produce a clear contract and explain it to a client is not a good lawyer. It is unlikely that you will find any solicitor operating in that market sector who will fill you with confidence, but you can look for another one if you wish.

You won't care what I think about your opportunistic whiplash claim, but I think it's cheesy.

PurpleMoonlight

22,362 posts

188 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
And of course you are not obliged to use a solicitor at all .....

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
... or indeed to add to a senseless litigation culture by seeking compensation for having a bit of a sore neck. Perhaps I should see this business as just good economic stuff, as all forms of economic activity generate employment and taxes etc, but I think that the negative impact on society of compo culture may outweigh the economic benefits of keeping the system churning.

Zeeky

2,954 posts

243 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
How badly injured does the victim of another's negligence need to be for a wholly meritorious personal injury claim to be acceptable?


Eclassy

1,201 posts

153 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
... or indeed to add to a senseless litigation culture by seeking compensation for having a bit of a sore neck. Perhaps I should see this business as just good economic stuff, as all forms of economic activity generate employment and taxes etc, but I think that the negative impact on society of compo culture may outweigh the economic benefits of keeping the system churning.
Would seeking compensation from the police for being unlawfully locked up for approximately 9 hours be part of this ''senseless litigation culture''? Reason I ask is I have a friend who I am currently helping put a case together. He just wants to move ahead but I am urging him to do it because the illegality was so blatant. I believe if cases like this are not taken to court, lessons wont be learnt. I feel a bit guilty now.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
That's a tough question, Zeeky. I'm of the opinion that RTA whiplash claims now require legislation to limit their scope, in which case it would also then be a very relevant one. It would have to tread a fine line with regards to Human Rights obligations.

My own view would be that a soft tissue whiplash claim (in the absence of any other injury) should have to impact on the claimants everyday life for a specified period of time before any claim is entertained. It should also be reliant on examination by both the claimant's and defendant's medical expert, the cost of which to be recovered from the value of the claim.

RTA Whiplash as a source of litigation is being abused (professionally in many areas) and has become a special case, as I see it.


anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Eclassy said:
Breadvan72 said:
... or indeed to add to a senseless litigation culture by seeking compensation for having a bit of a sore neck. Perhaps I should see this business as just good economic stuff, as all forms of economic activity generate employment and taxes etc, but I think that the negative impact on society of compo culture may outweigh the economic benefits of keeping the system churning.
Would seeking compensation from the police for being unlawfully locked up for approximately 9 hours be part of this ''senseless litigation culture''? Reason I ask is I have a friend who I am currently helping put a case together. He just wants to move ahead but I am urging him to do it because the illegality was so blatant. I believe if cases like this are not taken to court, lessons wont be learnt. I feel a bit guilty now.
You are doing a good deed. Your friend should sue if he has a case, and can bear the psychological pressure of doing so. Keeping a check on State power is important, and denial of liberty without lawful cause is a serious wrong. A sore neck is not a serious wrong.

I know a bit about wrongful imprisonment cases, so PM me if you want a free steer for your friend.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Bit political, oooh errr: I think that compo culture may be part and parcel of the "let's monetise every aspect of human existence" approach of the Thatcher-Blair-Cameron era.

carinaman

25,297 posts

203 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
Keeping a check on State power is important, and denial of liberty without lawful cause is a serious wrong.
I much prefer that to wailing about The Wail. I'm almost tempted to ask how much a simple solicitor's letter quoting one sentence and responding with a one sentence question may cost.

Eclassy

1,201 posts

153 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
You are doing a good deed. Your friend should sue if he has a case, and can bear the psychological pressure of doing so. Keeping a check on State power is important, and denial of liberty without lawful cause is a serious wrong. A sore neck is not a serious wrong.

I know a bit about wrongful imprisonment cases, so PM me if you want a free steer for your friend.
Thanks for the offer Breadvan and we will surely be taking it up but not for free. I am so sure he'll win I have offered to pay all his costs that he would be able to claim back from the police if he wins. I'll be more than happy to pay you the legal aid rate for some advice when we are ready. I reckon it will take about a month or so to get bit of evidence which although not crucial will stop the police from trying to lie in court. I'll come back to you once he has got this.


SK425

1,034 posts

180 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Bit surprised at the hostility the OP is receiving for making a claim for a genuine injury. People claiming for injuries that don't exist and even contriving accidents to enable them to do so are evil parasites and I have no problem with treating their fake hurty necks by removing their heads, but the OP isn't one of those (unless he's lying - and nobody here has accused him of that). I have no idea how you are supposed to put a monetary value on an injury that doesn't involve any financial loss, but as a society we've managed it and until that changes, in my view there is nothing dishonourable about making an honest claim for a real injury. We all pay for the right to do that through our car insurance premiums so you'd be a fool not to claim. (We all pay for the parasites too, but that's a different problem).

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Eclassy said:
Breadvan72 said:
You are doing a good deed. Your friend should sue if he has a case, and can bear the psychological pressure of doing so. Keeping a check on State power is important, and denial of liberty without lawful cause is a serious wrong. A sore neck is not a serious wrong.

I know a bit about wrongful imprisonment cases, so PM me if you want a free steer for your friend.
Thanks for the offer Breadvan and we will surely be taking it up but not for free. I am so sure he'll win I have offered to pay all his costs that he would be able to claim back from the police if he wins. I'll be more than happy to pay you the legal aid rate for some advice when we are ready. I reckon it will take about a month or so to get bit of evidence which although not crucial will stop the police from trying to lie in court. I'll come back to you once he has got this.
Legal Aid rate? About 10 pence a year, then; I'd sooner work for nowt! Seriously, though, your offer to consult me professionally is kind, and I do have relevant experience, but I don't come here to drum up business, and you would have to instruct me via a solicitor, cuz that's how we roll.

NB: you never recover full costs. You may get about 80% if you win.

XCP

17,760 posts

259 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
There's an interesting thread on this case already.

Kinjak

Original Poster:

18 posts

231 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the responses guys, i was even hoping for a response from people like Zeeky and Breadvan, so many thanks to all for taking the time to post.

I deliberately left out of my original post some details and the words whiplash in the hopes of avoiding another thread on claim culture and abuse.

In the shower this morning i had a long argument with myself about what to post as a response. I am not going to try to justify why I am consulting a solicitor. I believe myself to be an honest man, and i have thought long and hard before pursuing a claim. I will say I deliberately left out of my original post some details about my incident and the word whiplash in the hopes of avoiding another thread on claim culture and abuse. That obviously worked smile

TPS said:
So did you suffer any financial loss as a result?
Yes.

Zeeky said:
OP, it is normal practice. Prior to the recent changes in the law the success fee was added to the solicitor's costs and paid by the losing party.

This is no longer the case and the solicitor is only entitled to charge you the fee. You cannot be charged more than £500 but if this figure is greater than 25% of your award for damages the fee will be reduced accordingly.
Thanks, exactly what i was looking for, much appreciated.

Breadvan72 said:
The solicitor that you spoke to probably was a sales person, and may not even have been a solicitor (ie he or she may have been an employee of a law firm who is not a solicitor). At the level of the market that you are dealing with, the operators are mostly just concerned with churning files. In general, the rule is that you can have a cheap lawyer, or you can have a good lawyer, but you can't have both. A lawyer who cannot produce a clear contract and explain it to a client is not a good lawyer. It is unlikely that you will find any solicitor operating in that market sector who will fill you with confidence, but you can look for another one if you wish.

You won't care what I think about your opportunistic whiplash claim, but I think it's cheesy.
To be fair to the solicitor, the rest of contract was clear and easily understood. It was the single page i mentioned that was less than clear. I also understand I am always going to be dealing with a certain end of the market due to the nature of my incident. I chose to contact someone recommended by a friend and a small practice.

SK425 said:
Bit surprised at the hostility the OP is receiving for making a claim for a genuine injury. People claiming for injuries that don't exist and even contriving accidents to enable them to do so are evil parasites and I have no problem with treating their fake hurty necks by removing their heads, but the OP isn't one of those (unless he's lying - and nobody here has accused him of that). I have no idea how you are supposed to put a monetary value on an injury that doesn't involve any financial loss, but as a society we've managed it and until that changes, in my view there is nothing dishonourable about making an honest claim for a real injury. We all pay for the right to do that through our car insurance premiums so you'd be a fool not to claim. (We all pay for the parasites too, but that's a different problem).
Thanks for the support.