Murder trial - astounded
Discussion
I was astounded to see a recent murder trial where the killer freely admitted to committing the act but got off totally free on the grounds of self defense. The jury returned a verdict of not guilt and that was that.
Surely there should have been the lesser charge of manslaughter to answer to ?
It was a somewhat complicated case with joint defendants and elements still ongoing in relation to an incident of perjury so I have to be careful what I say.
Henry
Surely there should have been the lesser charge of manslaughter to answer to ?
It was a somewhat complicated case with joint defendants and elements still ongoing in relation to an incident of perjury so I have to be careful what I say.
Henry

(Voluntary) Manslaughter requires someone to carry out an unlawful act. If, for example, you punch someone then that is an unlawful act. If the punch is ruled as self defence then there is no unlawful act and no manslaughter.
In the case you are writing about (which seems to be about self defence and not loss of control, diminished responsibility), if this persons actions were in self defence then they haven't committed any unlawful acts and were fully justified (as the law allows) in their actions. Therefore if you are found NG of Murder then you couldn't possibly be found guilty of (voluntary) manslaughter.
In the case you are writing about (which seems to be about self defence and not loss of control, diminished responsibility), if this persons actions were in self defence then they haven't committed any unlawful acts and were fully justified (as the law allows) in their actions. Therefore if you are found NG of Murder then you couldn't possibly be found guilty of (voluntary) manslaughter.
TheBear said:
(Voluntary) Manslaughter requires someone to carry out an unlawful act. If, for example, you punch someone then that is an unlawful act. If the punch is ruled as self defence then there is no unlawful act and no manslaughter.
In the case you are writing about (which seems to be about self defence and not loss of control, diminished responsibility), if this persons actions were in self defence then they haven't committed any unlawful acts and were fully justified (as the law allows) in their actions. Therefore if you are found NG of Murder then you couldn't possibly be found guilty of (voluntary) manslaughter.
Well probably a bit of everything. Loss of control, diminished responsibility - there were drugs found at the scene, a bit of a mentalist and this wasn't the first person the accused had killed.In the case you are writing about (which seems to be about self defence and not loss of control, diminished responsibility), if this persons actions were in self defence then they haven't committed any unlawful acts and were fully justified (as the law allows) in their actions. Therefore if you are found NG of Murder then you couldn't possibly be found guilty of (voluntary) manslaughter.
H.
Henry-F said:
I was astounded to see a recent murder trial where the killer freely admitted to committing the act but got off totally free on the grounds of self defence. The jury returned a verdict of not guilt and that was that.
Self defence is a complete defence - I'm reasonably sure that the vast majority of people know this. Henry-F said:
TheBear said:
(Voluntary) Manslaughter requires someone to carry out an unlawful act. If, for example, you punch someone then that is an unlawful act. If the punch is ruled as self defence then there is no unlawful act and no manslaughter.
In the case you are writing about (which seems to be about self defence and not loss of control, diminished responsibility), if this persons actions were in self defence then they haven't committed any unlawful acts and were fully justified (as the law allows) in their actions. Therefore if you are found NG of Murder then you couldn't possibly be found guilty of (voluntary) manslaughter.
Well probably a bit of everything. Loss of control, diminished responsibility - there were drugs found at the scene, a bit of a mentalist and this wasn't the first person the accused had killed.In the case you are writing about (which seems to be about self defence and not loss of control, diminished responsibility), if this persons actions were in self defence then they haven't committed any unlawful acts and were fully justified (as the law allows) in their actions. Therefore if you are found NG of Murder then you couldn't possibly be found guilty of (voluntary) manslaughter.
H.
Are past offences taken into account in these situations?
They may be admissible as to character or credibility, but they have no bearing on whether or not a particular act is actually self-defence.
If you go around beating people up for fun, you still have the same right to defend yourself as a victim. Of course you might be less believable as to whether you really were the victim in any particular incident.
If you go around beating people up for fun, you still have the same right to defend yourself as a victim. Of course you might be less believable as to whether you really were the victim in any particular incident.
My friend was a juror in a case when two particularly nasty drug dealers got into a fight. One attacked the other (plenty of witnesses) and ended up being killed with his own knife. Not guilty & the guy walked free. It was decided that the survivor had a very credible fear for his own life and acted in a way that could be deemed as 'reasonable' given the circumstances.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


