Self Parking Cars
Author
Discussion

Mr Tidy

Original Poster:

31,768 posts

158 months

Friday 13th February 2015
quotequote all
Sorry if this has been raised before, but now these are getting more common does anyone know if they can be used for the parallel park in the driving test?
And should there be another category of driving licence that stops people with these cars driving ones that don't have that feature, like if you pass in an automatic you can't drive a manual?
Actually given that this is PH shouldn't we just give such people a railcard or a bus ticket?rolleyes
Saying that I see plenty of people all the time who I assume have a driving licence but have no driving ability whatsoever so I suppose it's not a new thing really.

Jasandjules

72,662 posts

260 months

Friday 13th February 2015
quotequote all
Logic would suggest if the car parks you don't pass that part of the test....

leefee

637 posts

160 months

Friday 13th February 2015
quotequote all
In my experience you would need to be the sttest of st parkers for the car to be better than you at it... Im sures with time it will improve but for now..

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Saturday 14th February 2015
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
Sorry if this has been raised before, but now these are getting more common does anyone know if they can be used for the parallel park in the driving test?.......
Really?......C'mon now.............Take a wild guess! wink




COMING UP NEXT WEEK:

With all this talk of self driving cars in the future:


SHOULD SELF DRIVING CARS HAVE TO PASS A DRIVING TEST BEFORE BEING ALLOWED ON THE PUBLIC HIGHWAY?

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Saturday 14th February 2015
quotequote all
There is nothing specifically against them, and if you did not take your hands of the wheel I'm not sure the examiner is going to really necessarily know it self parked, but if you fully took your hands off the wheel they might say you failed to maintain control of the vehicle, in fact if you had not already discussed with them that you were going to use self park, they might feel they need intervene which is an instant fail.
There is certainly no specific licence restrictions, I don't really see what the big deal is, they are moving the focus away from the manovers anyway, being able to control a car to within a few inches at slow speed is not what is important, it is observation and control moving with a bit of speed that is. The automatic licence restrictions have seemed fairly pointless to me for a while. Every car has a sycromesh on every gear and the anti stalling of modern cars makes them almost impossible to stall unless something is faulty.

7mike

3,215 posts

224 months

Saturday 14th February 2015
quotequote all
The last time I had a go at a self parking car it had to assess the distance between two parked cars first.
The reverse park for the driving test requires only one vehicle, examiners don't use two.

So, something of an irrelevant post wink

TwigtheWonderkid

49,211 posts

181 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
leefee said:
In my experience you would need to be the sttest of st parkers for the car to be better than you at it... Im sures with time it will improve but for now..
I've only used it on a Hyundai on the fleet at work, and it parks absolutely perfectly. No one could possibly better it, because as I said, it's a perfect parallel park.

chriscpritchard

284 posts

196 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
Have to be switched off!

DT1 said:
If any vehicle fitted with a 'self-parking' feature is presented for test the test should
be conducted in the normal way, however, vehicles fitted with these electronic
devices must be capable of being switched off/de-activated when carrying out
manoeuvres. Candidates must complete their manoeuvres manually. Vehicles
with parking distance sensors are acceptable as this is merely a safety feature.
https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/371399/dvsa-dt1-standard-operating-procedure.pdf

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
I've only used it on a Hyundai on the fleet at work, and it parks absolutely perfectly. No one could possibly better it, because as I said, it's a perfect parallel park.
My brother in Law spent over 10 years living in London driving and parking an old Sherpa van all around the city.

He's left London now and drives a big old FIAT Stilo estate, but he can park it in spaces that a self parking car would never even consider!

I kid you not, if he finds a space 1" longer than the car, he'll park in it, in one go and without touching either car front or rear, without batting an eyelid!

I've been in the car with him, assessed the space he's looking at and thought to Myself: "No chance! - Don't even try it!", meanwhile, he's stopped alongside the front car, selected reverse, gets the back end in, squares the front end up and we're done! (It amazes Me every time!)



Slidingpillar

761 posts

167 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
ging84 said:
Every car has a sycromesh on every gear...
Let me introduce you to my vintage car... wink

Mopar440

410 posts

143 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
ging84 said:
Every car has a sycromesh on every gear and the anti stalling of modern cars makes them almost impossible to stall unless something is faulty.
Syncromesh on every gear?

Anti stalling? You haven't driven a modern Ford diesel then.


ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
I meant to say every modern car. I have a 2003 ford diesel been driving it for couple of months and I've never managed to stall it, it's a mondeo estate and even loaded with stuff you can can pull away purely simply bringing the clutch up slowly.
It is a different world driving a modern manual compared to something from the 70s

Mopar440

410 posts

143 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
ging84 said:
I meant to say every modern car. I have a 2003 ford diesel been driving it for couple of months and I've never managed to stall it, it's a mondeo estate and even loaded with stuff you can can pull away purely simply bringing the clutch up slowly.
It is a different world driving a modern manual compared to something from the 70s
The Mondeo's one of the worst, so you must be a very good driver. How does the anti stalling system you've mentioned work on your Ford then?

Sheepshanks

41,279 posts

150 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
I've only used it on a Hyundai on the fleet at work, and it parks absolutely perfectly. No one could possibly better it, because as I said, it's a perfect parallel park.
Wonder who would pay if this system caused the car to mash its alloys on the kerb? Or does it give them such a wide berth there's no chance of that happening?

cptsideways

13,891 posts

283 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
Old skool diesels have antistall by design, eg tddi

R8VXF

6,794 posts

146 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
cptsideways said:
Old skool diesels have antistall by design, eg tddi
I can still stall an e46 diesel smile

R_U_LOCAL

2,708 posts

239 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
4rephill said:
I've been in the car with him, assessed the space he's looking at and thought to Myself: "No chance! - Don't even try it!", meanwhile, he's stopped alongside the front car, selected reverse, gets the back end in, squares the front end up and we're done! (It amazes Me every time!)
I could teach you this in about 45 minutes.

Unfortunately, unlike most of the other stuff I write, I've really struggled to write a nice descriptive piece on manoeuvring. I've made a few failed attempts, but nothing worthy of posting.

It's not as hard as you might think, but requires a slightly different mindset.

Maybe I'll have another go this week.

freshkid

199 posts

223 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
Wonder who would pay if this system caused the car to mash its alloys on the kerb? Or does it give them such a wide berth there's no chance of that happening?
Mine did this when I decided to demo the incredible self parking Mercedes to my old man. Couldn't believe it. Low kerbs can catch it out easily.

Sheepshanks

41,279 posts

150 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
freshkid said:
Mine did this when I decided to demo the incredible self parking Mercedes to my old man. Couldn't believe it. Low kerbs can catch it out easily.
Have you broached the subject with your dealer/Mercedes?

TwigtheWonderkid

49,211 posts

181 months

Sunday 15th February 2015
quotequote all
4rephill said:
TwigtheWonderkid said:
I've only used it on a Hyundai on the fleet at work, and it parks absolutely perfectly. No one could possibly better it, because as I said, it's a perfect parallel park.
My brother in Law spent over 10 years living in London driving and parking an old Sherpa van all around the city.

He's left London now and drives a big old FIAT Stilo estate, but he can park it in spaces that a self parking car would never even consider!

I kid you not, if he finds a space 1" longer than the car, he'll park in it, in one go and without touching either car front or rear, without batting an eyelid!

I've been in the car with him, assessed the space he's looking at and thought to Myself: "No chance! - Don't even try it!", meanwhile, he's stopped alongside the front car, selected reverse, gets the back end in, squares the front end up and we're done! (It amazes Me every time!)
Fair enough. I'll revise my comment. Once the system has chosen a space to park in, no human could make a better job of parking in it. I accept a human could park successfully in a space that the system wouldn't consider big enough.