British expat hiring a car in the UK: which licence to use?
British expat hiring a car in the UK: which licence to use?
Author
Discussion

mwyatt82

Original Poster:

102 posts

153 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
Hi,
I'm a British expat who has lived in Wisconsin USA for the last two and a half years. I have a British and U.S licence. My plod/legal question is this. If I have hired a car using my U.S licence and trigger a camera or were stopped am I obliged to declare that I am also a valid UK licence holder? Would plod even be able to find out roadside or check me out on that? My theory is that I would rather take the fine and dodge points using my American licence and keep my UK one clean as it has been for the last 15 years. Not sure if anyone has faced similar.

caziques

2,847 posts

198 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
I always use my NZ licence in the UK, so I would suggest you use your US one. It could help, and it certainly won't hinder.

If you travelled to any other country, use your UK one - again it could help.

I showed the local highway patrol in upstate New York my UK paper licence a few years ago, "slow down sir" was his suggestion.

daytona355

825 posts

229 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
Use the US one, unlikely to bother trying to track anything, the ticket generators don't use any brains when trying to track down perps. However, as you are giving the hire company a credit card number, remember the fines may well be paid by them and taken on your card with a nice admin fee, as plod won't care about the points so long as they get paid. Therefore, you should keep a clean licence, but it may cost a few quid.

In the US, I've had plenty of fines, but obviously never any points ended up on my UK licence for stuff that would be banning levels , and it's also managed to get me fines instead of a few days in the hole too (according to cops that stopped me). However, I always make sure I pay them, as I don't want to get arrested on the way into the country one day, or even worse, to be refused entry for a few dollars in unpaid fines

bridgdav

4,805 posts

278 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
I Always use the US one..
I flew into LHR yesterday and have a car from Budget/Avis. No issues with using my NC license.

I was also charged a £75 holding charge on my Credit card.. For incidentals, they said... Fuel, fines, tolls.
They said if the car was returned OK, then my card wouldn't be charged.

My question to them was that if I did get a NIP, I would be long gone back to the US by the time it turned up. He just said that it was normal policy now and couldn't offer an answer. I'm not sure if they can charge your card days/weeks after you have settled your account with them when returning the car.

Edited by bridgdav on Saturday 27th February 08:48

Dibble

13,284 posts

270 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
If you still have a valid UK licence it's very easy to check at the roadside. Any pints etc would be recorded against the UK licence, so you could feasibly rack up 12 points and get yourself a totting up ban. Having a US licence wouldn't negate that.

shirt

25,481 posts

231 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
Use your US licence. You can only be fined then if it's a roadside stop for which (I think) they'll process you at the station. You're supposed to surrender your licence once you become non resident so not sure what would happen if bib discovered you still have it.

HD Adam

5,155 posts

214 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
Dibble said:
If you still have a valid UK licence it's very easy to check at the roadside. Any pints etc would be recorded against the UK licence, so you could feasibly rack up 12 points and get yourself a totting up ban. Having a US licence wouldn't negate that.
Really?

So if I flew back to the UK, rented a car using my US Licence and gave my US address, then you stopped me and I showed you that using my utterly convincing Texas y'all accent, you would suspect me of being British and check to see if I had a UK licence?

CABC

6,304 posts

131 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
is the UK Licence technically valid??
Within EU/EEA you're supposed to swap your licence after a period of time from being a resident elsewhere, typically 6 or 12 months.
Fines in your new country, though dvla may not care.

Anyway, in reality you can use either i'm sure without problem

Roo

11,504 posts

237 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
HD Adam said:
Dibble said:
If you still have a valid UK licence it's very easy to check at the roadside. Any pints etc would be recorded against the UK licence, so you could feasibly rack up 12 points and get yourself a totting up ban. Having a US licence wouldn't negate that.
Really?

So if I flew back to the UK, rented a car using my US Licence and gave my US address, then you stopped me and I showed you that using my utterly convincing Texas y'all accent, you would suspect me of being British and check to see if I had a UK licence?
I would guess a quick PNC check, if they had reason to suspect you, would quite probably throw up a few questions.

wibble cb

4,162 posts

237 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
swapped my UK licence for a Canadian one years ago, always use it when back in the UK for car hire (I could mess with their heads when they ask for a passport and show my UK one, but I don't !) Never had an issue with it, but then as far as I know, I am generally mindful of speed limits/parking when here, as I don't want to have to deal with any issues once I am back in Canada.

mwyatt82

Original Poster:

102 posts

153 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
Thanks for the interesting replies! My current UK licence runs till 2019, I know I can't renew it after that point as I must have a UK address which obviously I now don't. I had no idea I had to physically surrender and send it back.

mph1977

12,467 posts

198 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
mwyatt82 said:
Thanks for the interesting replies! My current UK licence runs till 2019, I know I can't renew it after that point as I must have a UK address which obviously I now don't. I had no idea I had to physically surrender and send it back.
Your UK licence is currently invalid even if your entitlement to drive isn't.

duckwhistle

277 posts

181 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
Why not just drive legally while you are here ? It's not difficult and saves a lot of hassle.

Landshark

2,117 posts

211 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
Simple answer; show your US licence you'll have to pay upfront at roadside, checks will more than likely show your old UK licence, if not a ghost licence will get created linked to your US one and the points added.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

285 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
If you're hiring a car and your US licence is x years old and the hire company requires it to be x + n years old, they won't let you drive one of their cars, unless you use your UK licence.

Happened to someone I know a couple of months ago. He'd left his UK licence in the States, so didn't get to drive.

Don't know what the time requirement was.

HD Adam

5,155 posts

214 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
Roo said:
HD Adam said:
Dibble said:
If you still have a valid UK licence it's very easy to check at the roadside. Any pints etc would be recorded against the UK licence, so you could feasibly rack up 12 points and get yourself a totting up ban. Having a US licence wouldn't negate that.
Really?

So if I flew back to the UK, rented a car using my US Licence and gave my US address, then you stopped me and I showed you that using my utterly convincing Texas y'all accent, you would suspect me of being British and check to see if I had a UK licence?
I would guess a quick PNC check, if they had reason to suspect you, would quite probably throw up a few questions.
In what way? I have no convictions for anything, ever.

I'm sure if you typed my name in, it would throw up hundreds if not thousands of people with the same name.

Still not convinced although the tin foil hat is on standby.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

247 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
HD Adam said:
Roo said:
HD Adam said:
Dibble said:
If you still have a valid UK licence it's very easy to check at the roadside. Any pints etc would be recorded against the UK licence, so you could feasibly rack up 12 points and get yourself a totting up ban. Having a US licence wouldn't negate that.
Really?

So if I flew back to the UK, rented a car using my US Licence and gave my US address, then you stopped me and I showed you that using my utterly convincing Texas y'all accent, you would suspect me of being British and check to see if I had a UK licence?
I would guess a quick PNC check, if they had reason to suspect you, would quite probably throw up a few questions.
In what way? I have no convictions for anything, ever.

I'm sure if you typed my name in, it would throw up hundreds if not thousands of people with the same name.

Still not convinced although the tin foil hat is on standby.
Through the PNC the Police have access to all vehicle records & all driving licences (not just criminal records). A check on your details will reveal your UK licence. If they think you are fibbing about it, they'll just want to dig more to find out why.

mwyatt82

Original Poster:

102 posts

153 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
duckwhistle said:
Why not just drive legally while you are here ? It's not difficult and saves a lot of hassle.
That's the intention, I don't have any points or endorsements in 15 years of driving over several countries. Just two parking tickets. I raised the question in the event anything happens, a momentary lapse of concentration is all it can take.

HD Adam

5,155 posts

214 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
Ok Von, I'm intrigued.

How will showing a US license & address show up a link to a Uk licence?

Cat

3,134 posts

299 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
HD Adam said:
In what way? I have no convictions for anything, ever.

I'm sure if you typed my name in, it would throw up hundreds if not thousands of people with the same name.

Still not convinced although the tin foil hat is on standby.
Hundreds or thousands of people with the same name, including any middle names? With the same date of birth? Same place of birth?

From experience it is unusual to get more than one person matching all of those criteria.

Cat