Insurance excess on 3rd party claim ?
Insurance excess on 3rd party claim ?
Author
Discussion

fastbikes76

Original Poster:

2,450 posts

152 months

Tuesday 10th January 2017
quotequote all
So my young lad rings me telling he nudged a garage wall while reversing at night in an awkward spot. Not even a mark on his bumper but the concrete palisade type wall crumbled and broke one panel. He did the right thing and gave the owner his details who rightly wants it fixed. She has come to him with a price of £550 which doesn't seem unreasonable too me/us.

The question is, If he claims on his insurance for JUST her damaged wall and not his car, does he still pay an excess ? I've gone through his T&C's as best a layman can, and cant see any reference too it. His excess is only £200 so cheaper than the repairs and his premiums are only £600odd so cant see them going up 'that' much .

Regards


drdel

496 posts

158 months

Tuesday 10th January 2017
quotequote all
I think you will find the excess is payable towards any claim.

Fox-

13,575 posts

276 months

Tuesday 10th January 2017
quotequote all
drdel said:
I think you will find the excess is payable towards any claim.
No, generally only for claims for damage, theft or fire to the insured vehicle.

SteveR1979

601 posts

171 months

Tuesday 10th January 2017
quotequote all
drdel said:
I think you will find the excess is payable towards any claim.
I think you'll find its not.

No excess is paid if the 3rd party claims from you.
If you claim then an excess is payable.

fastbikes76

Original Poster:

2,450 posts

152 months

Tuesday 10th January 2017
quotequote all
OK so that kind of sums up my thoughts. My other son crashed a couple of years ago and didn't pay an excess as his car had nothing but a scratch. As they only paid out for the third party and not his car he didn't have to pay an excess. I didn't know if that was the norm or unique to his policy. I couldn't find any reference to this sons policy so wanted to check before calling Ins co.

Many thanks.

Aretnap

1,971 posts

181 months

Tuesday 10th January 2017
quotequote all
For completeness, a very small number of insurers (XS Direct are the only one I know of, as far as personal policies go at least) do apply the excess to both third party and own damage claims. But they're very much the exception - specialist companies at the bottom end of the market. In 99% of cases, and certainly any involving the big household name insurers, the excess is only payable if you claim for damage to your own car.

kiethton

14,656 posts

210 months

Tuesday 10th January 2017
quotequote all
If he's young I'd just pay the £550 - you'd make it back in next year's premium alone, definitely within the next 3 years you'd have to declare it for in any case.

fastbikes76

Original Poster:

2,450 posts

152 months

Wednesday 11th January 2017
quotequote all
In conclusion, I spoke with Ins Co via live chat and they confirmed excess is only payable when claiming for damage to your OWN property. If claiming for damage caused to a 3rd party by yourself but not for your own car there is no excess payable.

He is 21 and pays peanuts for insurance so cant see the increase costing more than the repairs. His policy went down after a total loss claim after his first year driving !

BertBert

21,291 posts

241 months

Wednesday 11th January 2017
quotequote all
That's interesting, why did his ins co talk to you about his ins policy?
Just curious.
fastbikes76 said:
In conclusion, I spoke with Ins Co via live chat and they confirmed excess is only payable when claiming for damage to your OWN property. If claiming for damage caused to a 3rd party by yourself but not for your own car there is no excess payable.

He is 21 and pays peanuts for insurance so cant see the increase costing more than the repairs. His policy went down after a total loss claim after his first year driving !

fastbikes76

Original Poster:

2,450 posts

152 months

Wednesday 11th January 2017
quotequote all
BertBert said:
That's interesting, why did his ins co talk to you about his ins policy?
Just curious.
They didn't speak to me about his specific policy but rather them as a company. I asked them as a generic question, they replied with the info above. From previous experience with our other son, Google and now current Ins Co..this appears to be industry standard that no excess is payable unless claiming for damage to your own insured property/car.