Was it "smart motorway operator training" evening yesterday?
Was it "smart motorway operator training" evening yesterday?
Author
Discussion

BertBert

Original Poster:

21,267 posts

240 months

Wednesday 20th March 2019
quotequote all
So on my way down the M1 yesterday evening and around the M25 to the south, I went through 7 pointless short speed reductions. So 4-5 gantries.. Down to 60, 50 or 40, then clear. Light traffic, no accidents, nothing to see at all. Yes it can be when the problem clears, if you come through at the end, you miss what happened. Or if you come in at the start of the lane closures, you might not see what's about to happen. But 7 times? Must have been training manoeuvres. Kind of like Dad's Army, but less well organised, less professional and more self-important.

Bert

Eddieslofart

1,328 posts

112 months

Wednesday 20th March 2019
quotequote all
Laziness, operator too lazy to turn their neck to look at screen and see hazard has cleared.

Have you seen the slobs on tv that work in South Mimms ?

Repel_Max

1,860 posts

145 months

Wednesday 20th March 2019
quotequote all
BertBert said:
So on my way down the M1 yesterday evening and around the M25 to the south, I went through 7 pointless short speed reductions. So 4-5 gantries.. Down to 60, 50 or 40, then clear. Light traffic, no accidents, nothing to see at all. Yes it can be when the problem clears, if you come through at the end, you miss what happened. Or if you come in at the start of the lane closures, you might not see what's about to happen. But 7 times? Must have been training manoeuvres. Kind of like Dad's Army, but less well organised, less professional and more self-important.

Bert
Can’t see the point of your comment.

Drivers don’t need to seek out the reason a speed limit is set, they just need to observe the set limit.

It seems the “self-importance” is all yours.

Pericoloso

44,044 posts

192 months

Wednesday 20th March 2019
quotequote all
Repel_Max said:
Can’t see the point of your comment.

Drivers don’t need to seek out the reason a speed limit is set, they just need to observe the set limit.

It seems the “self-importance” is all yours.
It was a sad day when PH scrapped the "speed matters initiation test" about 7 years ago.......frown

they let anybody in nowadays.

CoolHands

23,465 posts

224 months

Wednesday 20th March 2019
quotequote all
Someone on here works for them and will tell you it’s not possible etc even though we’ve all experienced similar, and if you actually suddenly slowed to 40 for the errant sign you would get rear-ended. It’s ste

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

284 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
Repel_Max said:
BertBert said:
So on my way down the M1 yesterday evening and around the M25 to the south, I went through 7 pointless short speed reductions. So 4-5 gantries.. Down to 60, 50 or 40, then clear. Light traffic, no accidents, nothing to see at all. Yes it can be when the problem clears, if you come through at the end, you miss what happened. Or if you come in at the start of the lane closures, you might not see what's about to happen. But 7 times? Must have been training manoeuvres. Kind of like Dad's Army, but less well organised, less professional and more self-important.

Bert
Can’t see the point of your comment.

Drivers don’t need to seek out the reason a speed limit is set, they just need to observe the set limit.

It seems the “self-importance” is all yours.
Idiotic Post Of The Year to date.

You'd be wise to research your subject before spouting sanctimonious guff like that.

A good starter to research would be the apology by Highways England that they've screwed up the software that gives us, for example, a 40 limit at 03.00 with no traffic in sight on either carriageway.

Eddieslofart

1,328 posts

112 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
Pericoloso said:
Repel_Max said:
Can’t see the point of your comment.

Drivers don’t need to seek out the reason a speed limit is set, they just need to observe the set limit.

It seems the “self-importance” is all yours.
It was a sad day when PH scrapped the "speed matters initiation test" about 7 years ago.......frown

they let anybody in nowadays.
Snowflake Brake generation.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

284 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
Eddieslofart said:
My real name is...


smile

syl

693 posts

104 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
Repel_Max said:
Drivers don’t need to seek out the reason a speed limit is set, they just need to observe the set limit.

It seems the “self-importance” is all yours.
It’s my life - I’m unashamedly far and away the most important person in it.

Davidonly

1,080 posts

222 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
Repel_Max said:
BertBert said:
So on my way down the M1 yesterday evening and around the M25 to the south, I went through 7 pointless short speed reductions. So 4-5 gantries.. Down to 60, 50 or 40, then clear. Light traffic, no accidents, nothing to see at all. Yes it can be when the problem clears, if you come through at the end, you miss what happened. Or if you come in at the start of the lane closures, you might not see what's about to happen. But 7 times? Must have been training manoeuvres. Kind of like Dad's Army, but less well organised, less professional and more self-important.

Bert
Can’t see the point of your comment.

Drivers don’t need to seek out the reason a speed limit is set, they just need to observe the set limit.

It seems the “self-importance” is all yours.
Blindly following rules eh...... Who else has done that and what was the result.. ?

Pit Pony

11,317 posts

150 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
Pericoloso said:
Repel_Max said:
Can’t see the point of your comment.

Drivers don’t need to seek out the reason a speed limit is set, they just need to observe the set limit.

It seems the “self-importance” is all yours.
It was a sad day when PH scrapped the "speed matters initiation test" about 7 years ago.......frown

they let anybody in nowadays.
Indeed i have reported his post. Totally unacceptable.
Why though?
The yesterday on the newly opened m6 j19 to 16 smart motorway there was suddenly a sign saying queue ahead with a 40 speed limit.
Nothing. Then 60. Now technically the speed limit starts at the sign so, if it's controlled by average speed cameras you can not afford to accelerate before the sign despite that you can see ahead and can see there is no issues.
Last summer I drove from Bradford to Derby a few times and even when the traffic was light in the middle of the day or in the evening, there was a 60 mph limit for no reason for 40 miles. Someone suggested air polution, but i call custard on that.
What this does is "Peter cry wolf"
It creates distrust, and it bunches up traffic and creates more third lane morons. Like mlm but worse.

Repel_Max

1,860 posts

145 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
Pit Pony said:
Pericoloso said:
Repel_Max said:
Can’t see the point of your comment.

Drivers don’t need to seek out the reason a speed limit is set, they just need to observe the set limit.

It seems the “self-importance” is all yours.
It was a sad day when PH scrapped the "speed matters initiation test" about 7 years ago.......frown

they let anybody in nowadays.
Indeed i have reported his post. Totally unacceptable.
Why though?
The yesterday on the newly opened m6 j19 to 16 smart motorway there was suddenly a sign saying queue ahead with a 40 speed limit.
Nothing. Then 60. Now technically the speed limit starts at the sign so, if it's controlled by average speed cameras you can not afford to accelerate before the sign despite that you can see ahead and can see there is no issues.
Last summer I drove from Bradford to Derby a few times and even when the traffic was light in the middle of the day or in the evening, there was a 60 mph limit for no reason for 40 miles. Someone suggested air polution, but i call custard on that.
What this does is "Peter cry wolf"
It creates distrust, and it bunches up traffic and creates more third lane morons. Like mlm but worse.
Imagine just a few minutes before, lets say 2 minutes before, there was queuing traffic that had just cleared. you would be more than 2 miles away and when you happen upon the lower limit, set as a result of but that limit had eased the congestion, you see nothing.
I suppose they could change the sign for you from "Queuing Traffic" to "Queuing Traffic Just Cleared, Bear With Us, Hope You Are Not Inconvenienced".

Riley Blue

23,205 posts

255 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
Could be 'emissions control'.

Andy S15

399 posts

156 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
I was on a speed awareness course recently and the instructor told me that if a section of smart motorway is set to 60 but with the hard shoulder still closed, this is for emissions reduction rather than traffic.

Camelot1971

2,852 posts

195 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
Pericoloso said:
It was a sad day when PH scrapped the "speed matters initiation test" about 7 years ago.......frown

they let anybody in nowadays.
If they let you in, they have to let everyone in.

mcdjl

5,756 posts

224 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
Pit Pony said:
Indeed i have reported his post. Totally unacceptable.
Why though?
The yesterday on the newly opened m6 j19 to 16 smart motorway there was suddenly a sign saying queue ahead with a 40 speed limit.
Nothing. Then 60. Now technically the speed limit starts at the sign so, if it's controlled by average speed cameras you can not afford to accelerate before the sign despite that you can see ahead and can see there is no issues.
Last summer I drove from Bradford to Derby a few times and even when the traffic was light in the middle of the day or in the evening, there was a 60 mph limit for no reason for 40 miles. Someone suggested air polution, but i call custard on that.
What this does is "Peter cry wolf"
It creates distrust, and it bunches up traffic and creates more third lane morons. Like mlm but worse.
The one just north of Nottingham definitely is emissions related. They did consider reducing it full time there.
I'd love there to be a public log of why the limit was reduced. I get that if the system actually works properly we never see what caused it, but I'd love to know why I had to slow to 40mph on an apparently clear motorway. That data exists so why not tell us?

Cold

16,707 posts

119 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
It's for your own safety. You don't have to know why, you just have to comply.
Citizen.

BertBert

Original Poster:

21,267 posts

240 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
Repel_Max said:
Can’t see the point of your comment.

Drivers don’t need to seek out the reason a speed limit is set, they just need to observe the set limit.

It seems the “self-importance” is all yours.
I'll take that as a yes then.
Bert

reglard

111 posts

97 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
I am sure they do it through the M6 in Birmingham because the toll road is actually slower when M6 clear, because they built the toll road in the wrong place.

Nigel_O

3,854 posts

248 months

Thursday 21st March 2019
quotequote all
Surely the emissions excuse is a bit far-fetched. Slowing vehicles will obviously reduce emissions in that immediate location, but a few gantries away when the NSL is resumed, emissions will be far higher as everyone accelerates again. Far more fuel efficient (and thus emissions-friendly) to let everyone carry on cruising through at the same speed