Total stupidity; variable speed limits!!!!!!!!
Total stupidity; variable speed limits!!!!!!!!
Author
Discussion

Turfy

Original Poster:

1,071 posts

210 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
We coming back form Luton yesterday evening in the rain (M1, M25, M3) and there must've been 30 - 40+ different speed limits on the 3 motorways!!!!! Gantry cameras galore continuously changing between 40 - 60mph, average speed zones between 40 -50mph...

It was the most unrelaxing bit of motorway driving I've ever done.

Is this really the future; speed limits changing every 2 - 3 minutes, gantry cameras there to catch you out??

HantsRat

2,409 posts

137 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
Do you have cruise control? If so, set that and relax.

eybic

9,212 posts

203 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
The theory is that if congestion builds up, they will slow approaching traffic in an effort to reduce congestion, whether it works or not is a different matter.

davek_964

11,264 posts

204 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
HantsRat said:
Do you have cruise control? If so, set that and relax.
Unless your cruise control is a lot more clever than mine, not sure how that would have helped the OP.

NDA

25,623 posts

254 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
HantsRat said:
Do you have cruise control? If so, set that and relax.
Does that help when speed limits are constantly changing?

speedking31

3,913 posts

165 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
HantsRat said:
Do you have cruise control? If so, set that and relax.
You're suggesting set cruise control to 40 mph on the motorway, no matter what the gantry says?

ecksjay

360 posts

181 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
Having attended a speed awareness course recently, I learned a lot about smart motorways that I wasnt already aware of. The speed changes are generally for traffic calming, slowing people behind down so you dont run into the back of those in front and end up stopping, causing a wave of traffic that seems to come out of nowhere. Everyones driven down the motorway only to stop without warning for a minute, then off you go again with no evidence of an accident etc. That's what the smart motorways iron out.

That and other things ofcourse but thats the main reason.

AJB88

15,789 posts

200 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
Cruise is no good at all when it goes 70>40>60>70>40>50>60>40 in the matter of 2 miles.

I've driven from MK to Luton airport at 3am many times and seen it set to 60>50>40>70>60 and the road has been absolutely empty.


davek_964

11,264 posts

204 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
Theory:

ecksjay said:
The speed changes are generally for traffic calming, slowing people behind down so you dont run into the back of those in front and end up stopping, causing a wave of traffic that seems to come out of nowhere. Everyones driven down the motorway only to stop without warning for a minute, then off you go again with no evidence of an accident etc. That's what the smart motorways iron out.
Reality:

AJB88 said:
I've driven from MK to Luton airport at 3am many times and seen it set to 60>50>40>70>60 and the road has been absolutely empty.

AJB88

15,789 posts

200 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
Dont know if its just that stretch of the M1 but it always seems to be messed up. Going down to Luton next week at 3am will see how it is then.

Turfy

Original Poster:

1,071 posts

210 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
davek_964 said:
HantsRat said:
Do you have cruise control? If so, set that and relax.
Unless your cruise control is a lot more clever than mine, not sure how that would have helped the OP.
Not at all, unless the cruise control (I retrofit to my car) pays my speeding tickets...


Edited by Turfy on Tuesday 1st October 14:09

eybic

9,212 posts

203 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
AJB88 said:
Cruise is no good at all when it goes 70>40>60>70>40>50>60>40 in the matter of 2 miles.

I've driven from MK to Luton airport at 3am many times and seen it set to 60>50>40>70>60 and the road has been absolutely empty.
Perhaps it's skewed by lots of slow moving vehicles??

HantsRat

2,409 posts

137 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
davek_964 said:
Unless your cruise control is a lot more clever than mine, not sure how that would have helped the OP.
It must be, mine recognises the limits by camera and self adjusts.

nonsequitur

20,083 posts

145 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
Turfy said:
We coming back form Luton yesterday evening in the rain (M1, M25, M3) and there must've been 30 - 40+ different speed limits on the 3 motorways!!!!! Gantry cameras galore continuously changing between 40 - 60mph, average speed zones between 40 -50mph...

It was the most unrelaxing bit of motorway driving I've ever done.

Is this really the future; speed limits changing every 2 - 3 minutes, gantry cameras there to catch you out??
In today's motoring miasma I would argue that we should be prepared for anything, and not be surprised. Variable speed limits occur on all roads, not only MW, with the average journey beset with different traffic configurations and varying speeds.

It was raining on your MW journey, so the hazard of spray at higher speeds would be relevant.

RedSwede

261 posts

223 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
HantsRat said:
It must be, mine recognises the limits by camera and self adjusts.
This all has a whiff of a dystopian future about it. An automated system sets up rules that are too difficult for a human to follow. So we must relinquish control to another automated system to control us. All the while the authorities tell us that this is a fine and proper way to live, as they gain more and more control.

It's just speed limits for now, but it's the thin end of the wedge I tell ya.

Fastchas

2,838 posts

150 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
ecksjay said:
Having attended a speed awareness course recently, I learned a lot about smart motorways that I wasnt already aware of. The speed changes are generally for traffic calming, slowing people behind down so you dont run into the back of those in front and end up stopping, causing a wave of traffic that seems to come out of nowhere. Everyones driven down the motorway only to stop without warning for a minute, then off you go again with no evidence of an accident etc. That's what the smart motorways iron out.

That and other things ofcourse but thats the main reason.
This +1.
I have noticed a distinct improvement in my neck of the woods - M6 north around Birmingham/Wolverhampton/Cannock
The conditions you mention above are exactly why it took me 7.5hrs to get home from Cornwall 3 years ago. Constant stop & go traffic with no accidents on the M5 northboundfrom Taunton to Wolves. Idiots charging off again as soon as there's a clear bit only to have to haul on the anchors half a mile further.
Sooner the better the whole M5 is managed for me.

xx99xx

3,006 posts

102 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
I go from M1 J14 to J8 every weekday morning (and back again in the afternoon!) And although it's stupidly busy, faster one minute slow/stationary the next, variable limits, cameras etc it's fairly relaxing if you stay out of the outermost overtaking lane, I.e. the bellend lane, and stick to lane 1 and 2. Same principle would apply to other motorways.

Pica-Pica

16,588 posts

113 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
NDA said:
HantsRat said:
Do you have cruise control? If so, set that and relax.
Does that help when speed limits are constantly changing?
Yes. See the gantry ahead and notch it down (or up) 10 or 20 mph. Easy. I don’t know how other CCs work, but I can notch mine up or down by a short move to give 1 mph, or if I overcome the detent it is 5 mph. Oh so simple.

andy_s

19,854 posts

288 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
davek_964 said:
Theory:

ecksjay said:
The speed changes are generally for traffic calming, slowing people behind down so you dont run into the back of those in front and end up stopping, causing a wave of traffic that seems to come out of nowhere. Everyones driven down the motorway only to stop without warning for a minute, then off you go again with no evidence of an accident etc. That's what the smart motorways iron out.
Reality:

AJB88 said:
I've driven from MK to Luton airport at 3am many times and seen it set to 60>50>40>70>60 and the road has been absolutely empty.
So it's, er, working then...

blueg33

46,435 posts

253 months

Tuesday 1st October 2019
quotequote all
M42 on tuesday last week at 5.30am virtually empty, all limits set at NSL apart from the one by the HADECS3 which was set to 40mph.

Call me cynical but..........................