Turning Right Across Junction

Turning Right Across Junction

Author
Discussion

c1223

Original Poster:

245 posts

150 months

Saturday 15th March
quotequote all
  • Obviously title should be turning right across junction
I think this is correct:



However most of the other cars do this:



By doing that, they block the free flow of traffic because inevitably there isn't a gap left, so the cars queue up and block each other.

Junction is here: https://www.google.com/maps/@51.3898607,-0.1885481...

Turning from Middleton Road into St Helier Avenue.

So which one is correct?

Edited by c1223 on Saturday 15th March 13:20

mmm-five

11,662 posts

297 months

Saturday 15th March
quotequote all
I think I was taught that it simply depends on the size of the junction and the space available.


Pica-Pica

15,018 posts

97 months

Saturday 15th March
quotequote all
Is this a statement or a question?

paddy1970

1,090 posts

122 months

Saturday 15th March
quotequote all
Picture 1 is the correct approach. The vehicles maintain proper lane discipline, allowing traffic to flow efficiently without unnecessary blockages. Right-turning vehicles position themselves in a way that does not obstruct oncoming traffic, reducing the risk of congestion and keeping the junction clear.

c1223

Original Poster:

245 posts

150 months

Saturday 15th March
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
I think I was taught that it simply depends on the size of the junction and the space available.

I did see this, but as you allude to, it doesn't really account for the size of the junction. The issue with this particular junction (and many others) is that more than 1 car can enter the junction and therefore block it.


InitialDave

12,966 posts

132 months

Saturday 15th March
quotequote all
In the OP's example, I think I would rather turn with my driver's side to the other car's driver's side, so the view to each of our lefts of the respective traffic streams we're each trying to join is less obstructed.

But it depends on the size of the junction, traffic light set up if any, what other cars are doing etc.

paul_c123

450 posts

6 months

Saturday 15th March
quotequote all
Replace the two cars with HGVs. Then, the junction suddenly becomes smaller, relatively, and you can see why the left side-left side approach now makes sense (for smaller junctions). Sure, if there's space, pass right-right.

Trif

769 posts

186 months

Saturday 15th March
quotequote all
It is safer to assume the junction is turn behind the car unless explicitly marked as turn in front.


The Gauge

4,339 posts

26 months

Saturday 15th March
quotequote all
The problem comes when you’re the first car entering the junction to turn right using option 1 above, but the oncoming car doing the same wants to do option 2

Alex Z

1,705 posts

89 months

Saturday 15th March
quotequote all
There was a really old episode of Top Gear where they did a segment on this, filmed at Oldswinford crossroads. Can’t find a clip of it though.

As the Highway Code says, it depends on the circumstances and layout of the junction. I find near side to near side is far more common.


eldrich

75 posts

91 months

Sunday 16th March
quotequote all
I always do turn behind unless the road markings indicate turn in front, in those cases I've noticed its usually a traffice lights controlled juctions with a turn right arrow.

Around our local area if you are both turning from a minor road to a more major one then I usually make eye contact with the opposite driver and indicate they should go first and I wait for them unless they are already indicating I should go first. Around there often often its easier for one to go than the other so if both ways are clear drivers usually let the one go first who has the least time to make the move.

whimsical ninja

218 posts

40 months

Sunday 16th March
quotequote all
Near side to near side is far more common in this country and generally confuses people less, even when it might be more appropriate to go off side to off side. I believe off side to off side is much more common in some other countries.

As per the highway code, really, whatever you think is best, although if there isn't much in it you'll probably get things flowing better going near side to near side just because that's what people mostly expect.

CanAm

10,789 posts

285 months

Sunday 16th March
quotequote all
Older members will remember that, many years ago, the Highway Code specifically stated that you should treat junctions as if there was an imaginary policeman on point duty in the middle of the junction and go around him (like a mini roundabout these days)

On the day of my driving test there was a huge power cut and no traffic lights were working. The examiner told me to turn right at a junction, and on point duty in the middle of the road was a policeman who signalled to me to turn in front of him rather than (as the HC stated) around him.

For the benefit of younger readers:-

fourthpedal

94 posts

17 months

Sunday 16th March
quotequote all
whimsical ninja said:
Near side to near side is far more common in this country and generally confuses people less, even when it might be more appropriate to go off side to off side. I believe off side to off side is much more common in some other countries.

As per the highway code, really, whatever you think is best, although if there isn't much in it you'll probably get things flowing better going near side to near side just because that's what people mostly expect.
Some countires require nearside to nearside - e.g. Switzerland or Germany (the latter apparently because of the 'mericans).

However the big risk is that you may not see following vehicles who have right of way - in particular cyclists or motorcycles. Offside to offside ensures a better view of oncoming traffic that you may obstruct or collide with (what the highway code already states).

On the rare occasion that I'm cycling, I'm doubly cautious when I see a car turning to its offside in front of me, because there's a significant risk of crossing traffic from the other direction not seeing me.

jondude

2,412 posts

230 months

Sunday 16th March
quotequote all
These kinds of junctions are always tough when you are a non local. Would be helpful if (as you do sometimes see to be fair) it was clearly marked on the road with nice lanes and arrows as to which way in and out you should turn.

Robertb

2,558 posts

251 months

Tuesday 18th March
quotequote all
Theres a cross-roads junction (like in the HC illustration) near me, quite tight and with a set of 3 way lights. When turning right, I like to turn in front of the oncoming cars who are turning to their right as this way I can move to the right a bit and allow others going straight on to pass.

I had a bloke the other day getting worked up, pointing at me like I should be passing behind him, which wouldn't work in any case as I'd have gone past the road.

mikecassie

643 posts

172 months

Thursday 20th March
quotequote all
O/S to O/S seems better in general, if you turn N/S to N/S there could be a driver deciding to zip past on the opposing cars N/S and you could be sticking your nose into their path. Who would be to blame there? But if sightlines are clear then do what feels safest is surely best.

Granadier

789 posts

40 months

Thursday 20th March
quotequote all
I was taught that passing offside to offside was correct and generally follow that unless the road markings dictate otherwise. Though on occasions, I have flashed an approaching vehicle to let them cross in front of me while I hang back, if my side of the road is clear and theirs isn't, for example.

Derek Smith

46,983 posts

261 months

Thursday 20th March
quotequote all
CanAm said:
Older members will remember that, many years ago, the Highway Code specifically stated that you should treat junctions as if there was an imaginary policeman on point duty in the middle of the junction and go around him (like a mini roundabout these days)

On the day of my driving test there was a huge power cut and no traffic lights were working. The examiner told me to turn right at a junction, and on point duty in the middle of the road was a policeman who signalled to me to turn in front of him rather than (as the HC stated) around him.

For the benefit of younger readers:-
I did point duty at Ludgate Circus in the 70s. Many drivers seemed to drive directly at me.

The probable reason for the officer indicating to the driver under test he should turn in front of him was to ensure he had sight of him all the time.