Mediation Day for Me
Author
Discussion

Alex_225

Original Poster:

7,910 posts

232 months

Yesterday (13:19)
quotequote all
Bit of background. I bought a 2014 Citroën C4 Grand Picasso for £5,900 as a commuter car. It had 103k miles, full service history and had supposedly been serviced and MOT’d two days before delivery.

Almost immediately it developed a fuel leak and within a week started completely cutting out at around 2,500rpm. The trader ignored my messages and calls, so I took it to two local garages (first one refused to do any work on it after inspection). They found the DPF/Adblue had been crudely removed and the second mechanic discovered the high pressure fuel pump was failing, contaminating the fuel system with oil. Both garages advised me to reject the car rather than repair it.

I formally rejected it on day 29 but the trader refused, saying I had driven 1,200 miles and that they “don’t run a lease service”. Their only solution was for me to return it for repair. Three hour drive with a failing fuel pump didn't seem reasonable regardless.

I took it to court and had mediation today. My claim is around £6,600 including my costs and I offered to settle for £6,000 just to get it over with. They refused. They claim they recorded the calls I did manage to have after rejection saying they offered to pick up the car and repair it but I refused.

Their offers were either to collect and repair the car or collect it, assess it themselves and then make me an offer. I would need to be nuts to accept the second option and the mediator said that is not a conventional route within the court system but if I was willing to accept that outside of court I could. No chance.

So mediation failed and we are now off to court, apparently in around 6–9 months. Very frustrating but with two independent garages backing up the faults and the emissions issue, I feel I have a strong case. Cannot believe the hassle and silly thing is if it does go my way, the garage will end up with a much larger cost than what I was willing to accept today to just get it done and dusted.

Bit of a vent to the PH masses so thanks for listening.

ExBoringVolvoDriver

12,128 posts

74 months

Yesterday (13:29)
quotequote all
I would imagine that they will have to provide the call records as late of their defence and if it were me, then I would the actual recordings rather than a transcript.

Make sure that you have everything fully documented for your pack of evidence along with all the paperwork. A well presented submission can make all the difference so that the judge can easily understand the issues.

The hearing will have to take place in a court near to your home and iirc, you may be unlikely to claim costs.

Good luck

PistonTim

767 posts

170 months

Yesterday (14:06)
quotequote all
You rejected it after 29 days and did 1,200 miles despite the issues becoming apparent 'almost immediately' and yet another 3 hour drive back to them for repair wasn't a risk you were prepared to take when you'd been commuting in it for almost a month.

I don't agree with the garage but I can see their point.

Alex_225

Original Poster:

7,910 posts

232 months

Yesterday (15:03)
quotequote all
ExBoringVolvoDriver said:
I would imagine that they will have to provide the call records as late of their defence and if it were me, then I would the actual recordings rather than a transcript.

Make sure that you have everything fully documented for your pack of evidence along with all the paperwork. A well presented submission can make all the difference so that the judge can easily understand the issues.

The hearing will have to take place in a court near to your home and iirc, you may be unlikely to claim costs.

Good luck
Assuming they put that forward as evidence although I'm not convinced they have recorded anything and I'm 99.9% sure they never offered to collect the car from me to repair it. The only offers I had was to return it to them and they would repair it or they offered to post me a fuel pump.

I have all my evidence logged and I have two garage reports, one mechanic willing to be witness.

PistonTim said:
You rejected it after 29 days and did 1,200 miles despite the issues becoming apparent 'almost immediately' and yet another 3 hour drive back to them for repair wasn't a risk you were prepared to take when you'd been commuting in it for almost a month.

I don't agree with the garage but I can see their point.
There is a bit more granular details to the issues.

- Fuel leak was noticed on first fill up, assumed possibly I'd overfilled it and fuel had spilled down the filler neck.
- The cutting out started intermittently, wasn't sure if it was electrical or fuel related.
- I continued to use the car for my commute - 450 miles per week for the first month as I was new to the role and had to be in five days initially
- Car cutting out became more apparent and could be consistently repeated - accelerate up to 50ish, accelerate firmly and engine cuts out completely
- Leak and cutting out reported in the first ten days by which I'd done 850-900 miles.
- In the four weeks before rejection, the vehicle spent 7 days with mechanics.

In looking for the leak, the garage spotted the illegally removed DPF/Adlu system and refused to work further on it.

Second garage took it in, confirmed the Adblue delete and that it hadn't been mapped out just chopped out. They also found the cause of the cutting out is the fuel pump.

So I used the car for just under three weeks before it was in the garage, I told the trader the issue and they ignored me up until day 29 when I formally rejected the vehicle.

I don't think I'm entirely unreasonable given that the potentially repairable problem of the leak was apparent from the off, the fuel pump (in my opinion) was failing from the beginning as it cut out first, 9 days into ownership which would have been ~600 miles into ownership. I thought it was a one off, it happened again so I let the garage know, they ignored me.

Was only when I had to get it looked at as driving it was becoming a hazard, for example moving to lane 2 of the M5 to pass a slow vehicle and the car dies completely. Not limp mode but nothing at all. So no, after a few weeks of trying to get them to respond I didn't feel it was safe to drive it 3 hours to them. Secondly, given the method of sale, I'm not obliged to either.

Then with the emissions systems being tampered with, which raises concerns over how legitimate the MOT they had put on it was, I'm not too sympathetic to the garage.

They only bothered starting to take it seriously when I rejected the car, which they refused having offered no help other than in week four for me to drive it to them to repair.

The point is I didn't want to reject the car based on not liking it, it's in great condition and is a nice drive. So the lateness of the rejection was based on me trying to do everything I could before feeling there was no other option.


Edited by Alex_225 on Wednesday 18th November 15:20

6pi

160 posts

179 months

Yesterday (16:19)
quotequote all
I'm not familiar with UK law, but isn't selling a car with a DPF delete illegal to start with ?

Alex_225

Original Poster:

7,910 posts

232 months

Yesterday (16:22)
quotequote all
6pi said:
I'm not familiar with UK law, but isn't selling a car with a DPF delete illegal to start with ?
You would be completely correct. So regardless of the actual faults, the DPF/Adblue delete is illegal.

I had mentioned this to the trader and their argument is, "we didn't do it, so it's not our fault". They seem to miss the fact that they freshly MOT'd it and given that both mechanics I used spotted it, the first point blank refused to do any more diagnostics on the car due to it. The trader feigning ignorance, I'm not sure will wash. It also raises questions about the MOT tester which I believe is one and the same place.

Wish

1,976 posts

280 months

Yesterday (17:05)
quotequote all
I think you might not be in a great position p. You have failed to let them rectify the issues.
I think they are have to have some chance to make good.

Not matter my thinking I wish you well with the rejection. Horrible situation to be in.

Alex_225

Original Poster:

7,910 posts

232 months

Yesterday (17:20)
quotequote all
Wish said:
I think you might not be in a great position p. You have failed to let them rectify the issues.
I think they are have to have some chance to make good.

Not matter my thinking I wish you well with the rejection. Horrible situation to be in.
Thanks mate. I took the advice of the Citizens Advice and no matter how trivial you do have a right to reject for a fault within 30 days of taking the car.

If they'd offered to fix the issue early on, collect the car and resolve the problem. I'd probably be none the wiser about the DPF, the car would be driving and if/when issues arise due to fuel contamination I'd be stuck with the car.

Thing is, by them failing to offer a solution and ignoring me, I've had to start getting the car looked at. I hoped I could get it repaired but a proper repair for these issues will be expensive.

- Leaking fuel (an MOT fail)
- Removed DPF/Adblue (MOT fail)
- Failing fuel pump and fuel contamination
- Coolant leak - not even looked into fully as was spotted as part of the investigation into the fuel pump issue.

Legally I can reject the vehicle within 30 days. It was either reject it before I couldn't or be stuck with a car and seemingly no support from the trader until the sh!t really hit the fan.

There's an interesting topic on here about High Peak Autos the Youtuber and how they had someone reject a car for an SRS error. They won in court by default as the trader didn't respond or claimed they had no paper work. If this was on fairly minor or easily rectified issue I'd still be using the car but altogether, the car is a total dog.

Panamax

10,130 posts

65 months

Yesterday (17:27)
quotequote all
So where is the car?

What have you been driving through this long drawn-out orocess?

VTC

2,405 posts

215 months

Yesterday (17:33)
quotequote all
Came expecting quiet calming music and story about centering oneself.

left disappointed

OutInTheShed

14,959 posts

57 months

Yesterday (18:12)
quotequote all
Driving it 1200 miles with an oil/fuel fault may not have done it any good.

IF you'd rejected it at the first sign of trouble, the dealer would have been pretty much where he started, but now he has a car that's been abused.
OTOH, it was clearly a wrong'un to start with.

At what point did the deaelr first offer to pick it up and assess it?

It seems like a lot to pay for an old Citroen anyway.

NAAHD

258 posts

56 months

Yesterday (18:24)
quotequote all
OutInTheShed said:
Driving it 1200 miles with an oil/fuel fault may not have done it any good.

IF you'd rejected it at the first sign of trouble, the dealer would have been pretty much where he started, but now he has a car that's been abused.
OTOH, it was clearly a wrong'un to start with.

At what point did the deaelr first offer to pick it up and assess it?

It seems like a lot to pay for an old Citroen anyway.
I rejected a car a number of years ago now and the dealer was very keen for me to drive it back to them. Didn’t seem to want to put that in writing though…

They weren’t happy about the 600 miles I’d done in it and given it had just gone past the 30 days I’d lost rights. Ended up taking a 15ish % loss for them to buy it back. Maybe being over cautious but I got the feeling if I had have driven it back and just topped the oil up every 10 minutes, I would’ve then been told I broke the car due to my negligence. I count myself very lucky on this one

Simpo Two

93,109 posts

296 months

Yesterday (18:25)
quotequote all
CRA 2015:

Your right to a repair or replacement
You can state your preference, but the retailer can normally choose whichever would be cheapest or easier for it to do.

If the attempt at a repair or replacement is unsuccessful, you can then claim a refund or a price reduction if you wish to keep the product.

Beyond the first 30 days of ownership you're entitled to a full or partial refund instead of a repair or replacement if any of the following are true:

an attempt at repair or replacement has failed
the cost of the repair or replacement is disproportionate to the value of the goods or digital content
a repair or replacement is impossible
a repair or replacement will cause you significant inconvenience
the repair or replacement will take an unreasonably long amount of time.
If a repair or replacement is not possible, or the attempt at repair fails, or the first replacement also turns out to be defective, you can reject the goods for a full refund.

From https://www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/regulation...

paul_c123

2,547 posts

24 months

Yesterday (18:55)
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
CRA 2015:

Your right to a repair or replacement
You can state your preference, but the retailer can normally choose whichever would be cheapest or easier for it to do.

If the attempt at a repair or replacement is unsuccessful, you can then claim a refund or a price reduction if you wish to keep the product.

Beyond the first 30 days of ownership you're entitled to a full or partial refund instead of a repair or replacement if any of the following are true:

an attempt at repair or replacement has failed
the cost of the repair or replacement is disproportionate to the value of the goods or digital content
a repair or replacement is impossible
a repair or replacement will cause you significant inconvenience
the repair or replacement will take an unreasonably long amount of time.
If a repair or replacement is not possible, or the attempt at repair fails, or the first replacement also turns out to be defective, you can reject the goods for a full refund.

From https://www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/regulation...
Notwithstanding the source, you've quoted a bit of the law but you've not looked at "short term right to reject" - which only needs there to be a fault, to entitle the consumer to reject a car.

Whilst the OP hasn't done things 100% right, they've done it more right than the garage and I think if the case is looked at in detail, stands a good chance of winning. It is always possible to get a judge who doesn't look at it properly and focuses on some of the issues presented above, diluting the win though.

Alex_225

Original Poster:

7,910 posts

232 months

Yesterday (19:03)
quotequote all
Panamax said:
So where is the car?

What have you been driving through this long drawn-out orocess?
The car us sat unused on my driveway, hasn't moved since the formal rejection. To be honest it was only driven about 20 miles in the week before that anyhow.

I need a commuter vehicle so bought a replacement car which has been much better.

OutInTheShed said:
Driving it 1200 miles with an oil/fuel fault may not have done it any good.

IF you'd rejected it at the first sign of trouble, the dealer would have been pretty much where he started, but now he has a car that's been abused.
OTOH, it was clearly a wrong'un to start with.

At what point did the deaelr first offer to pick it up and assess it?

It seems like a lot to pay for an old Citroen anyway.
I suspect the miles have exacerbated the issue but it was intermittent for the first couple of weeks so I was trying to get a solution from them. I didn't know the cause of the issue at the time so I was driving it, literally cruising up the M5 at 60mph anyway. Not abused but used consistently despite the fault.

The dealer has never offered to pick it up and assess it. His only offering was for me to return it to them to look at. They claim they offered collection but they haven't. They only offered to even look at it on week four after ignoring me for the first 2 and a bit weeks.

Simpo Two said:
CRA 2015:

Your right to a repair or replacement
You can state your preference, but the retailer can normally choose whichever would be cheapest or easier for it to do.

If the attempt at a repair or replacement is unsuccessful, you can then claim a refund or a price reduction if you wish to keep the product.

Beyond the first 30 days of ownership you're entitled to a full or partial refund instead of a repair or replacement if any of the following are true:

an attempt at repair or replacement has failed
the cost of the repair or replacement is disproportionate to the value of the goods or digital content
a repair or replacement is impossible
a repair or replacement will cause you significant inconvenience
the repair or replacement will take an unreasonably long amount of time.
If a repair or replacement is not possible, or the attempt at repair fails, or the first replacement also turns out to be defective, you can reject the goods for a full refund.

From https://www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/regulation...
I have exercised my short term right to reject based on the vehicle being not as described/not fit for purpose. From the Motor Ombudsman:

"Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, you have a short term right to reject your car if it is of unsatisfactory quality, unfit for purpose or not as described. You can get a full refund. However, you should remember that this right is short-term and is only limited to 30 days from the date you bought your car."

Based on the faults and illegal modifications the vehicle is not of satisfactory quality, nor is it fit for purpose so I am within my rights to reject the vehicle and not accept an offer of repair.

Alex_225

Original Poster:

7,910 posts

232 months

Yesterday (19:05)
quotequote all
paul_c123 said:
Whilst the OP hasn't done things 100% right, they've done it more right than the garage and I think if the case is looked at in detail, stands a good chance of winning. It is always possible to get a judge who doesn't look at it properly and focuses on some of the issues presented above, diluting the win though.
Totally genuine question but which bit have I not done right?

I've given the garage information all along the process, they've ignored me throughout the first two weeks but I've needed the vehicle for work so had no choice but to keep using it.

It was only in the third to fourth week that I'd managed to get to the bottom of the issue after they had failed to offer any kind of support. They didn't offer to repair it until it was with the second garage, only if I returned it to them and they didn't offer to collect it and repair it despite claiming to the courts they offered that and I refused.

paul_c123

2,547 posts

24 months

Yesterday (19:16)
quotequote all
Alex_225 said:
Totally genuine question but which bit have I not done right?

I've given the garage information all along the process, they've ignored me throughout the first two weeks but I've needed the vehicle for work so had no choice but to keep using it.

It was only in the third to fourth week that I'd managed to get to the bottom of the issue after they had failed to offer any kind of support. They didn't offer to repair it until it was with the second garage, only if I returned it to them and they didn't offer to collect it and repair it despite claiming to the courts they offered that and I refused.
Its actually quite difficult to say, and so subtle I am not sure its actually right or wrong; but, did you continue to use the vehicle after you found it had a (possibly intermittent) fuel leak?

CoolHands

23,720 posts

226 months

Yesterday (19:17)
quotequote all
I always imagine these types of garages will just fold before they pay out (assuming they lose).

Alex_225

Original Poster:

7,910 posts

232 months

Yesterday (19:27)
quotequote all
paul_c123 said:
Its actually quite difficult to say, and so subtle I am not sure its actually right or wrong; but, did you continue to use the vehicle after you found it had a (possibly intermittent) fuel leak?
I did but I wasn't sure the cause of the leak until the 2nd garage had inspected it. Turns out it's leaking from the very top of the fuel tank. Initial issues and codes implied low fuel pressure which could have been a fuel pressure line, which turned out to be the fuel pump. What appeared to be related issues turned out to be two significant ones.

CoolHands said:
I always imagine these types of garages will just fold before they pay out (assuming they lose).
Given the amount of stock they have or appear to have, they seem fairly well established.

I'm sure if you live local and have an issue they just wheel it in to their own mechanic and fix it. How well they fix it remains to be seen but likely well enough that they get away with it.

For a garage to openly offer nationwide delivery and agree a long distance sale (which I have done before), I naively thought they would offer a matching service should an issue arise. I bought a car previously from only an hour away, they game me an opportunity to have it fixed locally and they covered the costs. Although that was an S Class it was actually only £1,500 more to buy at the time.

mr rusty

223 posts

123 months

Yesterday (19:40)
quotequote all
Personally, I would make the basis of your claim solely on the fact it was sold with an illegal dpf modification and hence a fraudulent MOT.

This is a fact that has nothing to do with usage. You could put a million miles on it and it wouldn't change the fact it was sold with illegal modifications and therefore isn't fit for purpose.

Everything else introduces subjectiveness, usage, etc. I'd ignore all these and focus on the one fact that is cast iron.