How important are repeaters to speed prosecutions
How important are repeaters to speed prosecutions
Author
Discussion

BertBert

Original Poster:

21,353 posts

242 months

Yesterday (10:06)
quotequote all
I was on the M4 W bound yesterday. There are new roadworks the other side of Reading. They are a bit odd in as much as it's a 50 limit, down to 2 lanes and 50 repeaters. Average speed cams. Then the roadworks stop, back to 3 lanes, no repeaters. Everyone is a bit unsure so the traffic carries on at 50 then starts to speed up as I did. Eventually there is a small NSL sign perched on the hard shoulder.

I'll have to wait the prescribed amount of time to see if I cocked up. And yes we've discussed that a speed limit stays in place until something changes. Just made me muse over the importance of repeaters which are definitely there in the 2 lane section and definitely are not there after.

Alex_225

7,912 posts

232 months

Yesterday (11:56)
quotequote all
I have seen very similar and entirely likely the same section of the M4.

Road works vanish, no more 50 signs and then after a few minutes back to 50 and two lanes. You can tell where some people speed up but aren't sure, some just go back to normal driving. I would say they'd be raking in some money as most aren't sticking religiously to 50 at that point.

bergclimber34

4,609 posts

24 months

Yesterday (12:11)
quotequote all
Do we think it's deliberate?

Or just a mistake

I have geen convinced whoever runs the M6 starts does something fairly spurious one gantry 40 stuff to catch people out.

BertBert

Original Poster:

21,353 posts

242 months

Yesterday (12:21)
quotequote all
I don't think it's deliberate per se as in a Machiavellian plot to catch people out. Feels more like ineptitude than anything else. But if the av speed cams are active in the second bit that has no roadworks and no repeaters and I get a nasty letter, I'll feel unimpressed!

Mike Legerwood

226 posts

6 months

Yesterday (14:15)
quotequote all
BertBert said:
<snip>And yes we've discussed that a speed limit stays in place until something changes.<snip>
Isn't that your answer? Repeaters are therefore not necessary.

RazerSauber

2,952 posts

91 months

Yesterday (14:51)
quotequote all
M6 north last Saturday. Slip road had a sign saying 40. Great, here we go. Nothing after that. Numerous blank gantries, numerous cameras not going off (or not flashing at least), not a peep. Went from J23 at Haydock to J29 at the M65. Not another sign to be seen. I stayed at 40 a lot longer than other motorists did before getting up to 70.

Either the cameras are about to issue 50,000 fines or someone, somewhere had goofed on the signs.

Did see someone at J24 get flashed on the way back down in the dark so I assume the cameras were on and generating revenue functioning.

Countdown

49,589 posts

227 months

Yesterday (16:11)
quotequote all
This is one of the things that really gets my goat - the combination of constantly varying temporary speed limits (especially for "traffic management" purposes and the lack of clear signage on what the speed limit is. It's incredibly annoying, especially as it can be fairly easy to miss a change in the limit.

It would not be difficult to have whatever the speed limit is displayed on every overhead gantry rather than only when the limit changes.

BertBert

Original Poster:

21,353 posts

242 months

Yesterday (16:22)
quotequote all
Mike Legerwood said:
Isn't that your answer? Repeaters are therefore not necessary.
It's not the answer to my question really. My question is about the ability to prosecute. For example, the same situation in motorway variable limits. If the the gantry where the camera is is not displaying the lower limit then it is not enforced as there is no evidence. Not specifically the same situation, but an example where the limit is (probably) technically in place, but enforcement doesn't take place.

LastPoster

3,260 posts

214 months

Yesterday (16:30)
quotequote all
M4 by Swindon was the same on Monday. New roadworks, down to 2 lanes. 50 limit and average speed cameras. Where it returned to 3 lanes and the cones etc ended, no NSL signs and cameras continued with no ‘camera not in use sign’ I stayed at 50 for a bit but eventually sped up

By last night, an NSL sign appeared at the end of the cones

I’m going for cock-up rather than anything else

BertBert

Original Poster:

21,353 posts

242 months

Yesterday (16:34)
quotequote all
Thanks. Interesting. I assume there will be longer roadworks at some point as the av speed cams are in place.

WrekinCrew

5,746 posts

181 months

Yesterday (16:35)
quotequote all
If the overhead signs are blank, doesn't that mean the associated HADECS cameras will only trigger at NSL/70 (plus 10% +2 or whatever) even if technically the limit is lower because of an earlier uncancelled sign?

BertBert

Original Poster:

21,353 posts

242 months

Yesterday (16:37)
quotequote all
WrekinCrew said:
If the overhead signs are blank, doesn't that mean the associated HADECS cameras will only trigger at NSL/70 (plus 10% +2 or whatever) even if technically the limit is lower because of an earlier uncancelled sign?
Yes that's what happens I think.

paul_c123

2,549 posts

24 months

Yesterday (20:26)
quotequote all
Repeaters aren't needed to secure the prosecution.

But if they "forgot" to put the derestricted sign(s) up, ie the end of the 50mph limit, then the likelihood of them policing the zone which should have been derestricted as a 50 is slim. Also, there may not be the relevant underlying TRO in place to be able to enforce it.

I personally think road workers, or the planners/bosses/designers, or the people that set the variable speed limits (or design the systems that automate it) should get fined and points put on their licence if they mess up the signs! But that's another topic for another day....

BertBert

Original Poster:

21,353 posts

242 months

Yesterday (22:50)
quotequote all
Couldn't agree more!

fourthpedal

199 posts

35 months

I haven't been driving on UK motorways much recently, but elsewhere I find that I can often double-check the speed limit by looking at any signage at junctions/joining slip roads. You can't always see anything useful, but often enough there will be a visible sign which helps.

bergclimber34

4,609 posts

24 months

What it also shows is the lack of training and info surrounding gantrues and signage.

I dint think anyone who takes caredriving fully understand the law 100% if you leave a limited area and there are no NSA orrepeater signs.

Its just negligence from these supposedly vital workers who only even seem to be worried about speed, not finishing tge wirk they are doing quickly, efficiently and with less delay