Parking Ticket - Falsifying a document!
Parking Ticket - Falsifying a document!
Author
Discussion

AdvocatusDiaboli

Original Poster:

2,278 posts

262 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
Yesterday, at 6.32 pm I parked my Suzuki SV650 on a single yellow line outside the Alfred Dunhill (bought a fantastic pair of driving gloves by the way...) shop at 48, Jermyn Street.

A traffic warden was standing right besides me as I parked, since it was close to 6.30 pm (crucial because you can park on a single yellow after 6.30 as you all know!) I specifically asked this warden what the time was by HIS watch. He confirmed it was 6.31pm. I then asked if it was fine to park where I was. He confirmed that it was. I duly parked, locked the bike, got off and walked into the shop.

I came back ten minutes later to find a f*cking ticket on my windscreen! I was incensed as you can well imagine. I could not beleive I had been given a ticket especially after I had ASKED!!

Luckily there was a BMW with a chaffeur parked right behind me who had been there when I had pulled up. I went to have a chat with him and to ask him what he had seen.

He told me that he saw me ask the first warden if I could park, saw the warden say it was fine, and then saw the warden walk away. He then saw ANOTHER warden come straight after the first one and proceed to take pictures of my bike with intent to ticket! The chaffeur told this walking piece of wank that I had already spoken to another warden and that it was after 6.30pm anyway, but the sodding **** proceeded to ticket the bike anyway.

I took down the chaffeur's name and address, he is happy to give evidence on my behalf. I will certainly use him.

The best part is that the ticket reads that the time was 6.25pm, when it was most certainly NOT that time. It was after 6.30pm. I can testify to that (which of course counts for funky all), as can my witness. The warden in his desire to get one final ticket falsified the time and therefore the document.

I am going to appeal and I am going to take this to the very last stage if necessary. I am sick and tired of crap like this. They assume people will avoid the hassle and just pay £50. These bastar*s are going down.

I was wondering if I might be able to secure CC TV footage that woudl show my talking to the warden and him walking away... That would certainly show the time and my conversation.

Apologies for the language, but I am very annoyed.

IT10

602 posts

246 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
Time also proved by the imprint on your receipt from the shop?
Although this would show the time you paid rather than arrived, with the other evidence it could well be persuasive.

Good luck!

ETA - God I cannot spell today!

Edited by IT10 on Friday 5th January 10:03

jezzaaa

1,951 posts

290 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
Sock it to 'em mate. Shame you didn't note down the other parking warden's name that you did speak to so you could use his statement in your defence!

havoc

33,523 posts

266 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
Thing is nothing will happen to the warden...even WITH eyewitness evidence, he'll still get away with what SHOULD be Attempting to Pervert the Course of Justice.

Hope you get it cancelled, and hopefully quickly and without grief.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
Surely you need to alert the media about this? They've declared war on the motorist so it's only fair to string them up.

SM

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
havoc said:
Thing is nothing will happen to the warden...even WITH eyewitness evidence, he'll still get away with what SHOULD be Attempting to Pervert the Course of Justice.

Hope you get it cancelled, and hopefully quickly and without grief.


He'll just say his watch was wrong.Haven't GNER given all their employees a "radio controlled" watch which means all of them will give the correct time?For a situation such as the OP gave then this might reduce tickets being given "at the death" as it were.

blackvanman

71 posts

245 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
The PCN will be cancelled but sadly I have to agree that the warden won't be punished. I'm now up to 7/7 successful appeals against Westminster, including one where a warden seriously falsified evidence by claiming that he had put the ticket on the vehicle.

All of my cancellation letters from Westminster contain a sentence like 'I am satisfied that the PCN was correctly issued, however taking your points into careful consideration I am cancelling the PCN on this occasion'.

This doesn't give me much confidence that the wardens get punished..

havoc

33,523 posts

266 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
blackvanman said:
This doesn't give me much confidence that the wardens get punished..

They've probably got targets (everyone else in 'public service' :spit: has now!!!), so their bosses turn a blind eye to this...no consideration for them serving us the public at all, eh?!?
banghead

meeja

8,290 posts

279 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
I was issued with a parking ticket in November last year for being "Not Parked Correctly Within the Markings of the Bay or Space"

My front wheel was literally on the edge of the double yellows next to the parking area.

I was furious when I got back to the car, but with no witnesses, no ability to take a photo (Phone battery was flat!) I thought I would have to stump up and live with it.

When I got home (still fuming!) I decided to send a cheque, along with this letter.

A few days later, I recieved this reply!

AdvocatusDiaboli

Original Poster:

2,278 posts

262 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
blackvanman said:
The PCN will be cancelled but sadly I have to agree that the warden won't be punished. I'm now up to 7/7 successful appeals against Westminster, including one where a warden seriously falsified evidence by claiming that he had put the ticket on the vehicle.

All of my cancellation letters from Westminster contain a sentence like 'I am satisfied that the PCN was correctly issued, however taking your points into careful consideration I am cancelling the PCN on this occasion'.

This doesn't give me much confidence that the wardens get punished..


My priority is to get the fine cancelled. However, once that is done I am going after the warden himself.

7/7 is an impressive record! Any tips on how to phrase letter, who to write to, other tips?

jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
AdvocatusDiaboli said:

My priority is to get the fine cancelled. However, once that is done I am going after the warden himself.


Did you pay in the shop by Credit card? Wonder if you can get the time stamp from that?
As for getting the warden, I would ask the police to investigate, this sounds rather like an attempt to obtain a pecuniary advantage by deception to me, possible 7 years jail (though I am pretty sure the police won't do a thing). But if you are really keen, a private prosecution can follow.

Did you get the name/number of the 1st warden out of interest?

meeja

8,290 posts

279 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
jasandjules said:
Did you pay in the shop by Credit card? Wonder if you can get the time stamp from that?

Problem is, that only gives the time of the transaction, and an argument would be made for time spent "browsing" rolleyes

jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
meeja said:
jasandjules said:
Did you pay in the shop by Credit card? Wonder if you can get the time stamp from that?

Problem is, that only gives the time of the transaction, and an argument would be made for time spent "browsing" rolleyes


Good point.

Then the 1st warden is a damn good bet... At which point CCTV or just ask the council for the name of the first warden. Unless the council wish to attempt to pervert the course of justice as well of course.

jacko lah

3,297 posts

280 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
meeja said:
I was issued with a parking ticket in November last year for being "Not Parked Correctly Within the Markings of the Bay or Space"

My front wheel was literally on the edge of the double yellows next to the parking area.

I was furious when I got back to the car, but with no witnesses, no ability to take a photo (Phone battery was flat!) I thought I would have to stump up and live with it.

When I got home (still fuming!) I decided to send a cheque, along with this letter.

A few days later, I recieved this reply!


I'm Impressed !!

blackvanman

71 posts

245 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
AdvocatusDiaboli said:

My priority is to get the fine cancelled. However, once that is done I am going after the warden himself.

7/7 is an impressive record! Any tips on how to phrase letter, who to write to, other tips?


It's impressive but also quite depressing that Westminster has such problems with their attendants!

You should write to Parking Services, City of Westminster, PO Box 396, Warrington, WA55 1EL (should be the address on the back of the ticket). You can do it online but I prefer to write. Westminster have a 'view PCN images online' ( http://www3.westminster.gov.uk/pcnima ) tool which is worth looking at.

I'll dig out some of my old letters. Phrasing as you can imagine just needs to be clear and confident but you can (and should) sound really angry. You just need to state the facts and make it clear that you are quite happy to go all the way if necessary. I would also advise naming the witness and stating his occupation.

I would also mention that you expect disciplinary action to be taken against the warden. They won't do anything but it will help the appeal. Basically the more you sound like someone who is going to annoy them, the more likely they are to cancel the PCN.

Don't expect Westminster to reply quickly - they always seem to take several weeks..

Ben

fats25

6,260 posts

260 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
I believe the same thing has happened to me - falsified parking ticket, but I never even got the ticket.

Posted this thread previously - www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&f=10&t=330992 - and wrote a letter to Lewisham Parking - but had no response yet.

After the responses in the thread above - I checked and even though the car had not moved - they stated a different location of the vehicle on the ticket, even though their photos show the car is in the same location! Obviously included in my letter and still waiting response

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
Surely this should be reffered to the Police, and legal proceedings commenced?

Sod the disciplinary, does no good at all.

I'd be tempted top find said Warden and find out if you can still write false tickets out with your arms ripped off and shoved up your arse...?

XMG5

1,082 posts

258 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
If said warden cites an inaccurate time piece then surely that raises the question of the invalidation of the relevent times of offence on all tickets issued by him, at least for that day?? Maybe some publicity identifying said warden to alert other ticketed motorists of his that day might be a bargaining tool. Imagine all those potential appeals.........scratchchin

P.S. Wardens are assigned beats so they will have a record of who the 'witness' warden is likely to have been, especially if you can describe him. punch


Edited by XMG5 on Friday 5th January 14:03

knowley

145 posts

309 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
The original story in this thread is unbelievable, I would love to assume the warden in question had a very slow watch, and it was a geniune mistake but I fear I might be wrong and as someone else stated its all about targets/quotas.

I received a parking ticket in a council run leisure centre car park for failure to display properly. I have a membership at the leisure centre and members are provided with a LARGE blue card to use for parking. On this one occasion the card had slipped behind another parking permit I have to use for work, but for the most part it was visible - council logo and everything, the photo taken even showed this blue card clearly. It took 4 months, numerous letters from myself and two letters from the leisure centre to prove I was a member before they canceled the ticket. Its a real shame common sense seems to be extracted from the majority of traffic wardens during their training!

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Friday 5th January 2007
quotequote all
Old news I'm afraid. Parking fines are now a major source of revenue for local authorities and are actually factored into their annual budget calculations.

Nothing will happen to the warden, because he was doing the right thing and earning revenue for his employer. Sad, but true.

I would phone the shop up and speak to the manager. With any luck he/she will hate the mini-hitlers too, and write you a nice letter boosting your case.