Not sure who was driving.....Honestly!!!!
Not sure who was driving.....Honestly!!!!
Author
Discussion

flyinyam

Original Poster:

175 posts

231 months

Thursday 14th February 2008
quotequote all
Just been informed by work that a van allocated to my workmate (he signed for it), has recieved a NIP for 8th Jan, SP30.Speed indicated 36mph

Now we know one of us was driving, but genuinely can't say which of us it was.

We share the driving purely on a 'who can get in the passenger seat first' kind of way! So the driver can change hour by hour!

We are both prepared to put our names forward but not being 100% sure of who is the guilty tit...

Any advice would be helpful even if it's only to give my mate a kicking..

Cheers Fy

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Thursday 14th February 2008
quotequote all
Well, your mate will be liable (your company will declare so) so unless he convinces you to take the rap then he pays.

Maybe you could offer to pay all or part of the fine since he'll be getting the points.

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Thursday 14th February 2008
quotequote all
Your mate should call you as his witness to assist him when he can't say who was driving with any certainty. You'll have to admit that it could well have been you but that'll be ok. You have to make reasonable efforts to determine the driver so try to produce some documentation showing what jobs you were on the day etc and where you both went together. That should suffice.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Thursday 14th February 2008
quotequote all
This is a tricky one, the same defence used by the Hamiltons and often the police themselves to get off. They are as good as always successful.

Which then means, with typical British ruling class mentality, the laws were tightened to ensure everyone but the rich and the police would continue to get off scot free.

Failing to assist in naming the driver is now a far more serious offence than taking 3 and 60.

I think you are looking at double points and up to a grand, all at the magistrates whim. ( If you go down ) You will need to be calm and collected, and able to deal with immense stress and uncertainty to pull this one off.

The Hamiltons and police ensured many more of us tried this defence, and it pi**es them off - so you can't just turn up and say ' wasn't me, gov'. They will want credit card records, CCTV ( which is great if you can get it ) showing you at the local brothel at the time - in essence a paper trail as opposed to your word. That just doesn't wash unless...as said above..

It can be done, and if you are honest and cannot know the driver, you should indeed be able to win.

But it is all about convincing an establishment based on double standards.

( You can read lots about how people have done with your potential defence at....pepipoo.co uk or something like that...google ' speeding fine justice' otherwise!! )

flyinyam

Original Poster:

175 posts

231 months

Thursday 14th February 2008
quotequote all
Assuming he takes the rap and we find out at a later date i was driving, how would that sit legally?

Obviously we'd both prefer each other to be the guilty one, but can't say for sure.

Cheers Fy

spikeyhead

20,639 posts

228 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
flyinyam said:
Assuming he takes the rap and we find out at a later date i was driving, how would that sit legally?

Obviously we'd both prefer each other to be the guilty one, but can't say for sure.

Cheers Fy
If it was a forwards facing camera then ask for the photos. You can safely state on the NIP that it was one of you driving, just not sure who. If its a rear facing camera then its a lot less likely that the photo will show who was driving. At least that way you're being honest and up front about it from the start.

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
Hi smile

Assuming no pictures, if you go to court and both honestly say you don't know which was driving, I don't think they can find either of you guilty..

All the best Brett smile

doc3

483 posts

246 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
Similar situation occured recently within my company with a pool car. The company was unable to determine who was driving, so the court fined the company. I think it was £1000 (may have been more, i remember senior managers being very pissed off!). So might get you in a lot of trouble with your boss if both try and get away with it.

ETA: Just re-read your post. If your workmate signed for it, i think it would be fairly simple for the company to pass on all liability to him. I don't think the court will give him the benefit of the doubt either.

Edited by doc3 on Friday 15th February 01:28


Edited by doc3 on Friday 15th February 01:38

g_attrill

9,172 posts

277 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
doc3 said:
Similar situation occured recently within my company with a pool car. The company was unable to determine who was driving, so the caught fined the company. I think it was £1000 (may have been more, i remember senior managers being very pissed off!). So might get you in a lot of trouble with your boss if both try and get away with it.
The company should be clear in this case because it was signed out to an employee - that may well entirely shift the blame to that employee even if the company knows that they aren't the only person who might drive it.

Either way, the person who signed should punt it back to the police and say the truth, that neither person can recall who was driving. Before doing this though you need to do some substantial research to see if you can determine this, because ultimately in court the prosecution is likely to ask many questions to see what research had taken place. For example, what job were you on, what reason was the vehicle being used for at the time, look for receipts that might shed some light or jog a memory, even ask people/customers at the job if they can remember, or if they have CCTV.

If you genuinely can't remember or determine who it was then you shouldn't falsely nominate either of you.



RtdRacer

1,274 posts

232 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
jondude said:
Failing to assist in naming the driver is now a far more serious offence than taking 3 and 60.

True
jondude said:
I think you are looking at double points and up to a grand, all at the magistrates whim.

Whim? Oh for heaven's sake - do you have no idea how being a JP works? Guidelines are 375 quid and 6 points and there's no reason to stray off that.
jondude said:
But it is all about convincing an establishment based on double standards.
I really do fail to see what those double standards are. Do you think we sit there going 'ooh, it's a copper/well known ex-MP/footballer - better pull out the other bench book with the different guideline sentencing.' Gaah.

A Section 172 offence (failure to provide details) is more serious indeed than speeding. If you do not provide full details then your friend will indeed be found guilty. His only chance is to be scrupulously honest, with your help, and provide both his and your full names and addresses, DOB, driver licence number, along with whatever material evidence there is about you both being there that day (job cards etc.). If you have any witnesses on who was driving when you left the depot, that would be good.

Basically, if the JP's think you really have tried to ascertain who the driver was, and it's simply not possible, then you will probably be acquitted. IT is possible the bench will think you're taking the piss and say your mate will cop the speeding, but personally, I would think that is unjust. It depends on how convincing you are on the day. Make sure you go to court as well, and be as honest, detailed and cooperative as you can be.

Note that if your mate decides to cop to the speeding, and pleads guilty (he will probably be charged with the section 39 speeding and the section 172, but the CPS will drop the speeding if they get a result with the 172) but stands there saying 'well, I'm just doing it for pragmatic reasons, because I really don't know it was me', the clerk will refuse to accept the guilty plea. You have to say it and mean it. Not many people know that. smile

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
Did you fill up with fuel on the trip in question; if so, who paid? Is there any point en route where CCTV might show that you were driving? Any delivery/stop-off points where staff would remember who was driving? If your mate signed for the vehicle and there is evidence that you (also) drove during the trip, then the defence is strengthened ... especially if witnesses A and D say you were driving, and witnesses B and C say your mate was driving- Streaky

BertBert

21,345 posts

242 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
Don't forget that neither of the potential drivers is the RK so they don't have to make diligent enquiries of the other. I assume this is all S172 in action. Also depends on what was actually signed for.

I don't even think that the reasonable diligence comes in. That's for the RK.

I agree that absolutely honest responses are required, but I am not convinced that scouring the coutryside for evidence is required.

If both don't know, then both should say that in response to the 172 enquiry. The guy currently down as driver has got to name the OP as potential other driver for that to happen of course.

If you both show successfully that you do not know, then they may decide not to proceed. Or they might go for you both or for your company as well!

Of course your company would be in the poo for not keeping a record.

What fun.

Bert

RtdRacer

1,274 posts

232 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
doc3 said:
Similar situation occured recently within my company with a pool car. The company was unable to determine who was driving, so the court fined the company. I think it was £1000 (may have been more, i remember senior managers being very pissed off!). So might get you in a lot of trouble with your boss if both try and get away with it.

ETA: Just re-read your post. If your workmate signed for it, i think it would be fairly simple for the company to pass on all liability to him. I don't think the court will give him the benefit of the doubt either.

Edited by doc3 on Friday 15th February 01:28


Edited by doc3 on Friday 15th February 01:38
The company can indeed pass liability on to him if they can show (which they can) he was the driver that day.

But I disagree about the court giving him the benefit of the doubt. If he can show reasonable doubt on him being the driver, the court must acquit. For me, having a colleague saying 'it could've been me' and me believing him (key bit there!) might be enough. If it's obviously a scam, we'd find them guilty and recommend the CPS investigates for other offences - unlikely to be proven for sure, but necessary.

It's a very tall order to convince a bench that 'it could've been either of us, honest' - and it's risky. That's why it's not a loophole scrotes use. Two good honest people present a very different case than two 17 year old scrotes saying pretty much the same thing.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
RtdRacer said:
..he will probably be charged with the section 39 speeding and the section 172, but the CPS will drop the speeding if they get a result with the 172..
On what grounds would either of them be charged with speeding ? In the absence of a signed confession statement from the driver that they were driving, then there exists no admissible evidence of driver identity.


flyinyam

Original Poster:

175 posts

231 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
Just to clarify, van was signed out of garage (spare van), 4 days previously and we had it for around a week after too.

And as i stated, neither of us wishes to be the driver, so we do our damnest to get to the passenger seat first ( we do quite alot of miles!).

This can even mean when i pull up outside the newsagents and he dives in for milk, i could, and usually would, be sat in the passenger seat with door locked and big grin on my face! (Didn't say we weren't childish.).

We are both putting our names forward, and maybe need to implement some sort of shared driving (alternate days etc) but cannot actually say who it was.
Cheers Fy

marlinmunro

3,071 posts

236 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
You have some advice here boys, if you had beaten up an old lady for her pension it would be less serious by the look of it. Just shows what a cock up this camera stuff is. The main thing is they get the money and don't really care who was driving.

slow_poke

1,855 posts

265 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
www.pepipoo.com is your friend.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
RtdRacer said:
I really do fail to see what those double standards are. Do you think we sit there going 'ooh, it's a copper/well known ex-MP/footballer - better pull out the other bench book with the different guideline sentencing.' Gaah.

A Section 172 offence (failure to provide details) is more serious indeed than speeding. If you do not provide full details then your friend will indeed be found guilty. His only chance is to be scrupulously honest, with your help, and provide both his and your full names and addresses, DOB, driver licence number, along with whatever material evidence there is about you both being there that day (job cards etc.). If you have any witnesses on who was driving when you left the depot, that would be good.

Basically, if the JP's think you really have tried to ascertain who the driver was, and it's simply not possible, then you will probably be acquitted. IT is possible the bench will think you're taking the piss and say your mate will cop the speeding, but personally, I would think that is unjust. It depends on how convincing you are on the day. Make sure you go to court as well, and be as honest, detailed and cooperative as you can be.

Note that if your mate decides to cop to the speeding, and pleads guilty (he will probably be charged with the section 39 speeding and the section 172, but the CPS will drop the speeding if they get a result with the 172) but stands there saying 'well, I'm just doing it for pragmatic reasons, because I really don't know it was me', the clerk will refuse to accept the guilty plea. You have to say it and mean it. Not many people know that. smile
I'm very surprised (bearing in mind your position) by some of your comments.

This case is very similar to the one where Jeremy Clarkson was charged with a S172 offence: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/6982514.stm

I can well imagine that the OP's company would be charged, but to charge the OP's mate would surely be wrong? In the event he says he wasn't driving then recourse is back to the company.

Edited by Deva Link on Friday 15th February 12:49

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
Moral of the story - never sign for a works van as he who signs becomes liable for the thing then.

BertBert

21,345 posts

242 months

Friday 15th February 2008
quotequote all
In similar circs, I went through this process as RK with two other potential drivers. It couldn't have been me as I was away, but it could have been either of the other two and we genuinely couldn't be sure.

There isn't a not sure box on the 172 enquiry. So I followed advice, didn't sign the 172 and sent a letter with the details of the other two along with the insurance having them as named drivers. I stated we couldn't be sure whcih it was.

They got 172s and responded in the same way. I got the don't do it again letter along with the sage but incorrect advice that as RK, it was my responsibility to keep a written record.

It was the right outcome as we were scrupulously honest and genuinely didn't know.

Bert