RE: £1.5 million Speed Camera Blunder
RE: £1.5 million Speed Camera Blunder
Tuesday 4th March 2008

£1.5 million Speed Camera Blunder

For more than 10 years a speed camera in Dorset snapped drivers going over the speed limit - except, it turns out, they weren't.


Just a Cash Machine?
Just a Cash Machine?
Now the safety camera partnership concerned is facing up to paying back the £1.5million in fines it collected.

A paperwork blunder led to 25,000 motorists being given points and ordered to pay £60 fines.

But now the Dorset Safety Camera Partnership has been forced to admit a legal error which was spotted by a judge during a case involving lorry driver Alan Dawe last year.

She noticed that paperwork for the camera indicated a road used to mark out the 30mph zone on the A35 at Chideock, Dorset, didn't actually exist.

Instead of using the correct name Duck Street, it used Seatown Road.

It means every conviction issued by the camera towards Exeter since 1997 is void. The partnership admits other drivers might want to be reimbursed.

Author
Discussion

Daggerpie

Original Poster:

1,434 posts

232 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
So will they be writing to everyone that had a ticket through the letterbox....i very much doubt it!!

kmpowell

3,557 posts

259 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
Daggerpie said:
So will they be writing to everyone that had a ticket through the letterbox....i very much doubt it!!
More to the point what happens to people in this period who on the back of getting the points:
1. Have lost their license due to totting up
2. Have lost their job due to totting up
3. Seen their insurance increase due to the points

etc etc etc...

Jasandjules

72,684 posts

260 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
kmpowell said:
Daggerpie said:
So will they be writing to everyone that had a ticket through the letterbox....i very much doubt it!!
More to the point what happens to people in this period who on the back of getting the points:
1. Have lost their license due to totting up
2. Have lost their job due to totting up
3. Seen their insurance increase due to the points

etc etc etc...
They could, and SHOULD sue for consequential losses.

The more they have to pay out, the less likely they are to rely upon these things.

andyturner

120 posts

240 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
"For more than 10 years a speed camera in Dorset snapped drivers going over the speed limit - except, it turns out, they weren't"

Huh? Am I understanding the story wrong, but wasn't it simply a clerical problem and in fact they all *were* speeding?

Ean218

2,046 posts

281 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
andyturner said:
"For more than 10 years a speed camera in Dorset snapped drivers going over the speed limit - except, it turns out, they weren't"

Huh? Am I understanding the story wrong, but wasn't it simply a clerical problem and in fact they all *were* speeding?
They cannot break a speed limit which does not exist.

Misreading my speedo for 40 instead of 30 could also be described as a clerical error.

tigger1

8,484 posts

252 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
Story said:
The partnership admits other drivers might want to be reimbursed.
<tic>
Nah, I wouldn't have thought so, I mean, why would they? </tic>

It's an outrageous state of affairs when a mistake can be made like this and they can even consider not informing EVERY person involved, and offer them their money back plus any provable consequential costs. Plus interest.


JPKerr

109 posts

234 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
Is this not the same story as last week??? or is this another case? Once again I will state always question any speeding fine from a fixed camera. Never just pay the fine. Ask for a copy of the calibration certificate first the ask to see photographic evidence then if all else fails just tell then its not your car someone must be using false plates as you dont have any reason to use that road.

Edited by JPKerr on Tuesday 4th March 11:38

audidoody

8,598 posts

287 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
And some people call for capital punishment to be reinstated ...

("The Government has admitted that 459 people were mistakenly hanged between 2012 and 2018 because of a clerical error. The data disk that should have been labelled "marked for release" was mistakenly labelled "for the chop". The Home Office confirmed an unamed 18-year-old business experience youth with reading and writing difficulties in the Prisons Department had been suspended on full pay pending an investigation. We are truly sorry to have to tell taxpayers they will be funding the suspension pay. It is a tragedy of massive proportions."

JPKerr

109 posts

234 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
audidoody said:
And some people call for capital punishment to be reinstated ...

("The Government has admitted that 459 people were mistakenly hanged between 2012 and 2018 because of a clerical error. The data disk that should have been labelled "marked for release" was mistakenly labelled "for the chop". The Home Office confirmed an unamed 18-year-old business experience youth with reading and writing difficulties in the Prisons Department had been suspended on full pay pending an investigation. We are truly sorry to have to tell taxpayers they will be funding the suspension pay. It is a tragedy of massive proportions."
This could very well happen especial with the idiots that run this country

RB Will

10,909 posts

271 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
andyturner said:
"For more than 10 years a speed camera in Dorset snapped drivers going over the speed limit - except, it turns out, they weren't"

Huh? Am I understanding the story wrong, but wasn't it simply a clerical problem and in fact they all *were* speeding?
Im with you on this. I know it makes me sound bad but these people were speeding. Im not saying all for speed cameras etc but they saw the signs and the camera and still went past it above the posted limit. just cos the camera does not know where it is does not mean they were not speeding. unless the road it thought it was on was a 30mph limit and the road it was on was a 40mph so calibrated wrong but I dont think this is the case.

Tony*T3

20,911 posts

278 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
If this is a mere clerical error then the fines should stand. If the wrong road name was used, who really gives a flying fek?


I dont support speed cameras, but those caught speeding should suffer the consequences, not get a free 'get out of jail car' because someone wrote down the wrong road name. The name of the road is irrelevant, the speed limit on that road is relevant and the speed of the motorists is relevant, nothing else.

Taita

8,018 posts

234 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
They should phone EVERYONE, apologize, refund £100 each, remove the points. Sickening. Especially if its one where the motorist has to phone up and complain to get points removed.

Fetchez la vache

5,913 posts

245 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
They won't actively tell everyone they fked up. They didn't when the same thing happened on the M4 where a speed camera was placed outside the speed restriction, only nabbing a few tens of thousand...

If this thing has been wrong for 10 years.... rolleyes

Chrisgr31

14,297 posts

286 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
Tony*T3 said:
If this is a mere clerical error then the fines should stand. If the wrong road name was used, who really gives a flying fek?


I dont support speed cameras, but those caught speeding should suffer the consequences, not get a free 'get out of jail car' because someone wrote down the wrong road name. The name of the road is irrelevant, the speed limit on that road is relevant and the speed of the motorists is relevant, nothing else.
Ah but the procedure with speed cameras is flawed in the first place. They are suppossed to educate but plainly don't. They are suppossed to save lives but equally don't.

All those who were caught soeeding should get their fines back beciause it was a clerical error, and of course they will have learnt their lesson so won't be speeding.

cml

727 posts

293 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
That camera caught me! If it is the one in Chideock towards the bottom of the hill as you enter from the east.

I wrote a letter complaining about it because there was a sign saying '40', then a camera about 25 yards later and then a sign saying '30' another 25 yards after that! I was snapped at 38 between the signs. I got a letter back saying they were looking into it and then I heard nothing more. The next time I drove through the 40 sign had gone and the 30 sign moved in front of the camera.

Now it turns out it was all wrong anyway!

What goes through the minds of the people that actually install these things? If my experiences at large companies is anything to go by they were probabkly well aware of the problem but as 'little people' weren't listened to. A bit like the chaps who paint cycle lanes in London that are only ten feet long and take up a third of the width of a narrow road which has no room for both bike and car together. They know it is stupid, we know it is stupid but the tt at the council...




willcove

41 posts

245 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
andyturner said:
"For more than 10 years a speed camera in Dorset snapped drivers going over the speed limit - except, it turns out, they weren't"

Huh? Am I understanding the story wrong, but wasn't it simply a clerical problem and in fact they all *were* speeding?
Whether they were speeding in your eyes or not, they were not speeding in the eyes of the law and were wrongly punished. Dorset Safety(sic) Camera Partnership should 'fess up and notify every wrongly convicted motorist of the fact. Further those motorists should be entitled to proper compensation for any consequential losses - and the partnership (not the taxpayer) should pay from the profits they made on the speed tax. If that makes the partnership financially non-viable, then they should fold - the same as any business IMO.

No matter how you look at it, speeding is an absolute offence introduced from expediency to make it easier for the authorities to bring dangerous drivers to task. Used that way, speeding is very relevant to road safety.

However, it's very easy to enforce speeding and relatively difficult to enforce DWDCA etc. So, unfortunately, speeding has become the primary focus for road safety. It has become the be all and end all. So much so that the real factors of road safety have been sidelined or forgotten. We need to get away from this obsession with speed, and get more trafpols out looking for the real numpties. That can only happen in this bean-counter led administration if the scammers become a financial drain rather than a revenue generator. So, IMO, we need a system of automatic compensation to match the regime of automatic enforcement.

Daggerpie

Original Poster:

1,434 posts

232 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
[quote]

Im with you on this. I know it makes me sound bad but these people were speeding. Im not saying all for speed cameras etc but they saw the signs and the camera and still went past it above the posted limit. just cos the camera does not know where it is does not mean they were not speeding. unless the road it thought it was on was a 30mph limit and the road it was on was a 40mph so calibrated wrong but I dont think this is the case.
[/quote]

I know what your sayin but the simple fact is people have payed fines for being acused of speeding in a street they have never been down, in theory,this is a fraudulant fine. After all, these are apparantly "safety cameras" set up in apparant dangerous zones. What would happen if they were "accidently" set up NOT in safety zones but just in a position that coins in the ££££'s!! ohh, hold on....

Edited by Daggerpie on Tuesday 4th March 12:34

I WISH

874 posts

231 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
bounceclapbounceclapbounceclapbounceclapbounceclapbounceclap

Zumbruk

7,848 posts

291 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
RB Will said:
andyturner said:
"For more than 10 years a speed camera in Dorset snapped drivers going over the speed limit - except, it turns out, they weren't"

Huh? Am I understanding the story wrong, but wasn't it simply a clerical problem and in fact they all *were* speeding?
Im with you on this. I know it makes me sound bad but these people were speeding.
No they weren't. The law applies to everyone, and if the definition of the offense is invalid, there is no offense.

911hillclimber

486 posts

226 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
What a real waste and worry to all concerned!

The ££ is important, but the points are REALLY important.
Some may have lost their jobs etc.

Pull them all down except opposite schools and shopping centre crossings and think of something better!
Oh, can't do that as everyone will be sending cheques out and errasing points off licenses?