Taking points for somebody else?
Discussion
I think I know somebody who has taken points for somebody else - but I'm not 100% sure.
The person I *think* they've done it for has apparently paid people to do it in the past, but I don't know anything about him...only a rough location (county) and what sort of car (nothing unique).
The guy who *may* have taken points is somebody I know fairly well, and would sooner not see get into trouble...but I hate hearing about people paying their way out of trouble.
What would you do?
The person I *think* they've done it for has apparently paid people to do it in the past, but I don't know anything about him...only a rough location (county) and what sort of car (nothing unique).
The guy who *may* have taken points is somebody I know fairly well, and would sooner not see get into trouble...but I hate hearing about people paying their way out of trouble.
What would you do?
10 Pence Short said:
EU_Foreigner said:
Nothing - I know loads of people who had other people take their points. For a simple speeding ticket, there is 0% chance of anyone finding out.
Sure about that?There have been a few jailed for exactly that.
And you would have to be EXTREMELY stupid if you did get caught. So prob not 100% but 99%.
btw i know of two people who have admitted this offence to me.
FiveStar said:
What you have to ask yourself is how many people they have harmed in doing this action?
Nobody has to be harmed for an offence to take place. I know it's certainly perverting the course of justice, which is taken very seriously.Given I have no proof, I'm minded to do nothing, but keep my ears open. If I heard more...well, I don't know, it would depend on my conscience whether I felt the need to report my suspicions I guess.
The husband and wife thing you will never stop. I know of so many couples that work that way. You are both insured on the car, you both drive the car.
You can no longer use the defence "Don't know who was driving" as that costs 6 points. Could have been one or the other, so one will take the hit this time, the other the next. Even if the prosecution had the time to sue them, what can they say if you claim you did not know who was driving and you drive a car equal amounts?
You can no longer use the defence "Don't know who was driving" as that costs 6 points. Could have been one or the other, so one will take the hit this time, the other the next. Even if the prosecution had the time to sue them, what can they say if you claim you did not know who was driving and you drive a car equal amounts?
if its a friend of yours taking the points, then you do nothing.
do you really want to lose a friend because you grassed him up?
its doesn't harm you, your friend is not being forced into it, so mind your own business and keep your friend.
By all means, have a word with him, and try and make him see the wrong he is doing, but under no circumstances risk your friendship for it.
do you really want to lose a friend because you grassed him up?
its doesn't harm you, your friend is not being forced into it, so mind your own business and keep your friend.
By all means, have a word with him, and try and make him see the wrong he is doing, but under no circumstances risk your friendship for it.
EU_Foreigner said:
The husband and wife thing you will never stop. I know of so many couples that work that way. You are both insured on the car, you both drive the car.
You can no longer use the defence "Don't know who was driving" as that costs 6 points. Could have been one or the other, so one will take the hit this time, the other the next. Even if the prosecution had the time to sue them, what can they say if you claim you did not know who was driving and you drive a car equal amounts?
With TruVelo, Specs and some mobile traps you can be identified from the front. When you fraudulently take points for your wife, do you suggest you're also a part time crossdresser?You can no longer use the defence "Don't know who was driving" as that costs 6 points. Could have been one or the other, so one will take the hit this time, the other the next. Even if the prosecution had the time to sue them, what can they say if you claim you did not know who was driving and you drive a car equal amounts?
There were people ages ago (mostly students i think) who put their "license" on ebay so people could bid to put their points on the students license.
Obviously being a student it was a good way to make easy money, and as most of them wouldn't have a car at uni with them, it wouldn't affect their insurance and things, and by the time they came out of uni the points had probably dropped off!!
Quite clever really....Ebay, of course, put a quick stop to it!
Obviously being a student it was a good way to make easy money, and as most of them wouldn't have a car at uni with them, it wouldn't affect their insurance and things, and by the time they came out of uni the points had probably dropped off!!
Quite clever really....Ebay, of course, put a quick stop to it!
10 Pence Short said:
EU_Foreigner said:
The husband and wife thing you will never stop. I know of so many couples that work that way. You are both insured on the car, you both drive the car.
You can no longer use the defence "Don't know who was driving" as that costs 6 points. Could have been one or the other, so one will take the hit this time, the other the next. Even if the prosecution had the time to sue them, what can they say if you claim you did not know who was driving and you drive a car equal amounts?
With TruVelo, Specs and some mobile traps you can be identified from the front. When you fraudulently take points for your wife, do you suggest you're also a part time crossdresser?You can no longer use the defence "Don't know who was driving" as that costs 6 points. Could have been one or the other, so one will take the hit this time, the other the next. Even if the prosecution had the time to sue them, what can they say if you claim you did not know who was driving and you drive a car equal amounts?
If you do not request the photo's, then your choice of who will pick up the points is then based on your best knowledge. If someone wants to prosecute later one (why?), you can easily claim what I stated above without any risk to getting found guilty.
EU_Foreigner said:
That information is not available when you get your conditional offer. If you request it, then yes - you are buggered if it shows one person clearly. My understanding is that the vast majority of photographs do not identify the person as they always state that it is only to identify the car.
If you do not request the photo's, then your choice of who will pick up the points is then based on your best knowledge. If someone wants to prosecute later one (why?), you can easily claim what I stated above without any risk to getting found guilty.
There have been instances where the 172 has been filled in with the wrong person (ie. the photo shows it's obviously a women, yet it's a man being identified by the 172), and the officer dealing with the FP has sent the 172 back suggesting it gets changed to whoever really was driving.If you do not request the photo's, then your choice of who will pick up the points is then based on your best knowledge. If someone wants to prosecute later one (why?), you can easily claim what I stated above without any risk to getting found guilty.
Of course they could have just waited for the FP to be accepted with the false details then gone for PCoJ. I wouldn't want to take that risk!
But that photograph was not sent with the FP, so how could that person know? That couple could share the same car all day, for lots of trips etc.
It is very scarey to get a NIP as the language is very, very threatening in it. I can very well imagine that people will just fill in anything to get rid of the thing.
Your example is obviously a rare one as most pictures I have seen just shows a car from the rear.
It is very scarey to get a NIP as the language is very, very threatening in it. I can very well imagine that people will just fill in anything to get rid of the thing.
Your example is obviously a rare one as most pictures I have seen just shows a car from the rear.
EU_Foreigner said:
But that photograph was not sent with the FP, so how could that person know?
The partnership has the photograph- it's they who can potentially spot someone trying to lie about who was driving.The partnership have the photo cleraly showing a woman driving the car. They send out the 172 requesting the driver. The 172 comes back saying it's Bob Smith.
The partnership can either send something back suggesting it might not be Bob Smith, with a copy of the photo, or they could just proceed with the FP and upon completion of the FP report for PCoJ.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


