Parking fines to benefit the public?
Parking fines to benefit the public?
Author
Discussion

KB_S1

Original Poster:

5,967 posts

260 months

Friday 7th March 2008
quotequote all
I find this story incredible.
Obviously it is impossible to know the full details of the circumstances but it is the decision of the council to 'end the appeal process' that I consider most disturbing.

ukwill

10,289 posts

238 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
KB_S1 said:
I find this story incredible.
Obviously it is impossible to know the full details of the circumstances but it is the decision of the council to 'end the appeal process' that I consider most disturbing.
Why do you find it incredible given the current state of affairs in this country?

tvrgit

8,490 posts

283 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
Does the sign say "Beware that our wardens might not be able to read upside-down like just about everybody else can"?

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
Surely by "end the appeal process" she mean't that the appeal was denied.

The ticket may not simply have been upside down, but in such a position that the date or time or whatever was not readable. I think there should be a reduced fine in cases where the driver had a valid ticket. It may be that the new rules allow this, since there are now different fines dependant on the infringement.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
By upside down does she mean Face Up but the writing USD or thatthe ticket was face down

ie its up side was down? confused

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
herewego said:
Surely by "end the appeal process" she mean't that the appeal was denied.

The ticket may not simply have been upside down, but in such a position that the date or time or whatever was not readable. I think there should be a reduced fine in cases where the driver had a valid ticket. It may be that the new rules allow this, since there are now different fines dependant on the infringement.
If, as you speculate, a critical part of the ticket actually was hidden from view, then the council might have a case.
If it was only a matter of the ticket's being upside down, then it is hard to see the validity of their argument. If a traffic warden is incapable of either reading upside down or twisting his head a bit, he is not qualified for the job.

Globulator

13,847 posts

262 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
herewego said:
I think there should be a reduced fine in cases where the driver had a valid ticket.
People with valid tickets should still be fined??

confused

Are you really advocating the punishment of people with valid tickets?????????
If you have a valid ticket, even if the warden misses it, you certainly should NOT be fined.

Why is authority so desparate to replicate Russia of the 1970s, when even they have left this trivial, petty, life quality reducing st behind them?

GKP

15,099 posts

272 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
I think the council should fix their ticket machine. It's obviously printing the tickets the wrong way up. rolleyes
silly

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
Globulator said:
herewego said:
I think there should be a reduced fine in cases where the driver had a valid ticket.
People with valid tickets should still be fined??

confused

Are you really advocating the punishment of people with valid tickets?????????
If you have a valid ticket, even if the warden misses it, you certainly should NOT be fined.
If the ticket was face down so it couldn't be read what should the authority do, assume it's valid? They have no choice but to issue a notice. If the offender later appeals and sends in a valid ticket that they may have bought at the time, then they could appear to be innocent and have the notice cancelled, but then some people take the piss don't they?

tvrgit

8,490 posts

283 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
Ah... I thought that "upside down" meant "face up but upside down" not "face down but right way up" - if the latter then fair enough - I think that it's obvious that you buy a ticket and display it to show that you have paid for the time that you have parked. If you put it face down so that they can't read it, then what are they supposed to do? Give you the benefit of the doubt?

What then if you buy the ticket and put it in your pocket so that they can't read it - when you return you say "no that parking fine's not valid because I bought a ticket but you just couldn't see it".

Must admit I got caught by this a couple of years ago - I don't stick tickets to the window because they usually leave adhesive on the glass, so I just leave them on the dashboard. This one time it slipped down between the dash and screen so you could see the time of expiry but not the date of issue, which was obscured by the black edge of the screen. So I got a parking ticket. I was pretty miffed about it at the time but what else were they supposed to do?

Globulator

13,847 posts

262 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
herewego said:
If the ticket was face down so it couldn't be read what should the authority do, assume it's valid?
If and when you get a notice, you should be able to easily cancel it on production of the correct time and date ticket. So you are entitled to be free and clear.

Because if you can produce the correct ticket it gives reasonable doubt of the offence. It's back to the plain vanilla, very boring, inconvenient, UK right of being innocent until proven guilty.

fluffnik

20,156 posts

258 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
If wardens can't read tickets upside down they're obviously too far down the food-chain for the job.

BertBert

21,345 posts

242 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
StirlingCouncilspokeswoman said:
The conditions of use of our car parks, clearly displayed at each car park entrance, indicate that a valid ticket must be displayed within the vehicle.
Doesn't define the legibility of all or part of the ticket. Says "displayed". Any good definitions of displayed?

What do the actual conditions say?

Bert

Hedders

24,460 posts

278 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
How is she supposed to even know she had a parking ticket? I can see a yellow thing thing under her windscreen wiper but can't read what it says cos it is not facing the right way.

Whats good for the goose...


ETA: with the new machines that make you enter your license plate info i don't see a need to deisplay a ticket all. The ticket nazi should be able to tell you have paid. That would be a good use of the technology though frown



Edited by Hedders on Sunday 9th March 10:56

KB_S1

Original Poster:

5,967 posts

260 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
The article is unfortunately not explicit in terms of the details. I do not know if the ticket was left/right, up/down, front/back.
The part that I find most annoying is the apparent dismissal of any appeal process by the council.
They know best and that is that.

bleesh

1,112 posts

285 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
IF, and it's a big IF, I ever park in a pay and display, I now
take a photo of the ticket in the dash, or on the window with my
phone..... laugh

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
fluffnik said:
If wardens can't read tickets upside down they're obviously too far down the food-chain for the job.
I thought a lowly position in the food-chain - somewhere below plankton - was a prerequisite - Streaky

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
Interesting quotes in the article:

[quote]A Stirling Council spokeswoman said: "The conditions of use of our car parks, clearly displayed at each car park entrance, indicate that a valid ticket must be displayed within the vehicle.

"In this case a ticket was displayed but it was not possible for the car park attendants to determine whether or not it was valid so an excess charge notice was correctly served.
[/quote]

So a valid ticket was displayed in the vehicle, but the 'car park attendants' (is that like toilet attendants, but much lower down the scale?) couldn't check it was valid.

OK so far. And the "not possible" suggests that it was face-down__, not __upside-down.

That the appeal process was "ended", may simple indicate that the Council has accepted that the ticket was valid.

I have no issues with the need to display a parking ticket. After-all, if I buy a railway ticket I do not expect the 'revenue enforcement officer' (what used to be called a ticket-collector ... or even a guard) to believe that I have a valid ticket if I either keep it in my pocket or show it to him upside-down.

Streaky