What's worse in the eyes of the law?
What's worse in the eyes of the law?
Author
Discussion

rumpelstiltskin

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

290 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
Knowingly selling a stolen motorcycle or unknowingly buying one?I've just run into an Ebay problem!

Derek Smith

50,021 posts

279 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
rumpelstiltskin said:
Knowingly selling a stolen motorcycle or unknowingly buying one?I've just run into an Ebay problem!
Both parties can be guilty of the same offence: handling stolen goods.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
I thought it could depend on the circumstances?

eg if you buy from a trader you could have inhereted good title to the goods.

If you bought it privately, at a silly price (where suspician should have been raised) you will be subject to a meeting without coffee at the cop shop




rumpelstiltskin

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

290 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
The suspicion being alerted due to funny prices wasn't an issue here.I'm just really trying to understand is the private seller knowingly selling stolen goods worse than the buyer unknowingly buying them if you know what i mean.It was a long distance transaction and the money paid was the going private value,maybe even slightly above!I really feel sorry for the buyer in this instance and i don't see why he or she would be held accountable at all really?

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
I think you are going to have to be more specific about your ebay problem TBH.

If either of you know then I suppose that you are guilty of receiving stolen goods.

Assuming the seller was not actually the tea leaf as well


rumpelstiltskin

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

290 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
Buyer bought bike blind on Ebay and it was delivered by courier.On collection of bike,frame number was missing but engine number was intact.

Kinky

39,946 posts

300 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
Did the buyer not do any reasonable check to check the validity of such?

Like a HPI check, etc, etc?

And how was it advertised?

K

ATG

23,863 posts

303 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
I've just re-read the originial post ... I wonder if others have misread it too,as I did first time round.

Is knowingly selling stolen goods more serious than unknowingly buying them? I'd have thought the answer was pretty obviously, yes, knowingly selling stolen goods is far more serious.

okgo

42,373 posts

229 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
If they prove you knew ( even though you didnt ) its worse than nicking it.

I knowingly bought a nicked Bike from a mate got busted by the guys whos bike it was in town. I got a three year warning. But I cant think if you didnt know and that stands up then you could be in any trouble especially with ebays way or working

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
If you suspect the goods to be stolen then now's the time to call bib.

okgo

42,373 posts

229 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
If its anything less than thousands of pounds or they literally catch you in the act while doing something else they dont seem to be that interested.. I had a mate report a few things and they said they would act and never did

rumpelstiltskin

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

290 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
ATG said:
I've just re-read the originial post ... I wonder if others have misread it too,as I did first time round.

Is knowingly selling stolen goods more serious than unknowingly buying them? I'd have thought the answer was pretty obviously, yes, knowingly selling stolen goods is far more serious.
I would think yes too but i've heard that possession is 9/10ths of the law.

wasted years

4,330 posts

240 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
If you know that the goods are stolen and you "handle" them then your are guilty. The law of England and Wales has handling as more serious than theft.

And posession is 9/10ths of the law is a load of rubbish. No such thing.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
rumpelstiltskin said:
ATG said:
I've just re-read the originial post ... I wonder if others have misread it too,as I did first time round.

Is knowingly selling stolen goods more serious than unknowingly buying them? I'd have thought the answer was pretty obviously, yes, knowingly selling stolen goods is far more serious.
I would think yes too but i've heard that possession is 9/10ths of the law.
I think you are confusing a couple of issues.

Knowingly selling stolen goods is a crime.
Unknowingly buying them isn't.

That's one thing dealt with but you also seem to be bringing lawful ownership into it.
You now have potentially two owners of the property though (which the courts may have to sort out). The buyer & the person they were stolen from.

ukvoyager.info

2,782 posts

253 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
If it is stolen goods and you bought it, the goods will be returned to their rightful owner (not you) and your money will still be with the seller. Lose / lose if you ask me.

Derek Smith

50,021 posts

279 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
rumpelstiltskin said:
Knowingly selling a stolen motorcycle or unknowingly buying one?I've just run into an Ebay problem!
Both parties can be guilty of the same offence: handling stolen goods.
Sorry, I misread the first post. I missed the unknowingly.

If you paid a reasonable price for the goods and bought them not knowing them to be stolen, then any later decision to keep them does not amount to theft. You cannot, however, sell them on.

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
If you paid a reasonable price for the goods and bought them not knowing them to be stolen, then any later decision to keep them does not amount to theft. You cannot, however, sell them on.
I'm puzzled by the implications of this Derek. You are implying that you would be entitled to keep the goods but not to sell them on?

I thought that if you didn't know and couldn't reasonably have been expected to know that they were stolen, you haven't committed an offence in buying them. However, even if you haven't committed an offence it doesn't mean that you get to keep them. If the seller didn't own them, your purchase didn't give you ownership and the goods aren't yours - they remain the property of the original owner.

Derek Smith

50,021 posts

279 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
Derek Smith said:
If you paid a reasonable price for the goods and bought them not knowing them to be stolen, then any later decision to keep them does not amount to theft. You cannot, however, sell them on.
I'm puzzled by the implications of this Derek. You are implying that you would be entitled to keep the goods but not to sell them on?

I thought that if you didn't know and couldn't reasonably have been expected to know that they were stolen, you haven't committed an offence in buying them. However, even if you haven't committed an offence it doesn't mean that you get to keep them. If the seller didn't own them, your purchase didn't give you ownership and the goods aren't yours - they remain the property of the original owner.
I too am unable to understand all the implications. However, what it means is that if you find you have bought stolen goods you commit no offence if you fail to tell the police or anyone with a claim on the goods. If you sell them on then, if memory of CID courses permit, you are guilty of deception because you purport to have full title, or at least the right to sell.

In keeping such goods you would not commit handling stolen goods because you did not receive the goods dishonestly, although there's an argument about retention but it is a very weak one. You would not commit theft either of course.

Number 7

4,113 posts

293 months

Saturday 8th March 2008
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
If the seller didn't own them, your purchase didn't give you ownership and the goods aren't yours - they remain the property of the original owner.
Exactly - you can't pass on title to something if the title isn't yours.

7.

Jasandjules

72,684 posts

260 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
rumpelstiltskin said:
Knowingly selling a stolen motorcycle or unknowingly buying one?I've just run into an Ebay problem!
If you didn't know that it was stolen then you have committed no offence in purchasing it as far as I can see. In fact, if the vehicle is stolen, you haven't bought it at all, as the seller does not have legal title, therefore he cannot pass legal title to you, under a principle called Nemo Dat IIRC.

So you are in possession of a stolen item, but not the owner of it...

You would then be looking to recover the cost of the item from the seller, as plod will likely impound it.