Poll.
Author
Discussion

Deltaf01

Original Poster:

1,512 posts

228 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
Should the police enforce against offences where there is NO victim?

Examples; Possession of cannabis for own use, speeding, warning other drivers of hidden traps?

Just put yes or no.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
laugh

Road Pest

3,123 posts

229 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
laugh
Is that a yes or a no, can't quite make it out.... getmecoat

soprano

1,613 posts

231 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
i don't think the examples you use are victimless, so in these circumstances yes.

FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
There is no victim needed in a riot. So yes, sweeping generalisations in a complex legal system are good.




Deltaf01

Original Poster:

1,512 posts

228 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
lol, trust you to try and subvert it.

The examples are what youre supposed to be basing the answer on......or was that too complex for you?
Yes or no, it dont get much simpler than that.

FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
They were examples, you didn't say they were exhaustive. Dangerous driving, driving whilst over the prescribed limit don't have victims.

Ok, so warning other people in the context of the other topic isn't an offence. Obstruct PC is. So you're saying obstruct PC shouldn't be a crime? In that case. No. I think obstruct PC should be a crime. As far as cannabis goes I'd happily legalise it.


P.S. How the fk do you PM on this forum? You may call me stupid for not being able to figure that out.

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
FishFace said:
P.S. How the fk do you PM on this forum? You may call me stupid for not being able to figure that out.
Click on User Name.
On user name's member page, on the right hand side is the "email me" thing to click.

It usually works...unless you come up against one of these:

Oops...

Sorry - the recipient doesn't permit emails.

Which a certain user named "FishFace" has on his member page. wink

FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
Neither do you tongue out

I assume that Emails people messages to their Email account? That's not what I mean by private message. So this forum doesn't have that facility?

miggy man 3

1,916 posts

227 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
If enforcement isn't taken then you start the spiral into anarchy. Think of the "broken windows" profile.

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
FishFace said:
Neither do you tongue out
Correct, although I wasn't asking how to send one to someone else. tongue outtongue out

FishFace said:
I assume that Emails people messages to their Email account? That's not what I mean by private message. So this forum doesn't have that facility?
I've never heard of it here, and a number of folks have mentioned that they couldn't get an email to me, for the reason you cited, so I presume that PH has none.

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
The Tuscan Rat said:
Not wearing a seat belt, only harms you in an accident, however this then costs the tax payer for your Ambulance, hospital treatment, the police time and resources to deal with the accident / aftermath etc etc...
What you say is factual.
If we are to run society on that basis, however, we'll have to ban scout hikes, cycling, windsurfing, gym workouts, horse riding, motorbiking, recreational flying, ballooning, sailing, running, boxing, rowing, and a thousand other activities that are perfectly reasonable but unnecessary, and which could result in cost to the taxpayer.
That would be at the same time that we start dictating people's diets - we can't have them eating the wrong things, requiring health care, and costing the taxpayer, can we?.

miggy man 3

1,916 posts

227 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
flemke said:
The Tuscan Rat said:
Not wearing a seat belt, only harms you in an accident, however this then costs the tax payer for your Ambulance, hospital treatment, the police time and resources to deal with the accident / aftermath etc etc...
What you say is factual.
If we are to run society on that basis, however, we'll have to ban scout hikes, cycling, windsurfing, gym workouts, horse riding, motorbiking, recreational flying, ballooning, sailing, running, boxing, rowing, and a thousand other activities that are perfectly reasonable but unnecessary, and which could result in cost to the taxpayer.
That would be at the same time that we start dictating people's diets - we can't have them eating the wrong things, requiring health care, and costing the taxpayer, can we?.
We're on about criminal offences rolleyes

FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
flemke said:
The Tuscan Rat said:
Not wearing a seat belt, only harms you in an accident, however this then costs the tax payer for your Ambulance, hospital treatment, the police time and resources to deal with the accident / aftermath etc etc...
What you say is factual.
If we are to run society on that basis, however, we'll have to ban scout hikes, cycling, windsurfing, gym workouts, horse riding, motorbiking, recreational flying, ballooning, sailing, running, boxing, rowing, and a thousand other activities that are perfectly reasonable but unnecessary, and which could result in cost to the taxpayer.
That would be at the same time that we start dictating people's diets - we can't have them eating the wrong things, requiring health care, and costing the taxpayer, can we?.
Not quite a like for like comparison to put it mildly. Even on and absurd economic comparison it falls apart. The sports and recreations contribute massively to the economy when pitted against the amount they cost through death / injury. On the other hand how does not wearing a seatbelt benefit the economy?

The above have wide range of health and social benefits. I'm not sure not wearing a seatbelt has any outside of very exceptional circumstances (police expecting to run from car to chase someone etc).






flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
FishFace said:
flemke said:
The Tuscan Rat said:
Not wearing a seat belt, only harms you in an accident, however this then costs the tax payer for your Ambulance, hospital treatment, the police time and resources to deal with the accident / aftermath etc etc...
What you say is factual.
If we are to run society on that basis, however, we'll have to ban scout hikes, cycling, windsurfing, gym workouts, horse riding, motorbiking, recreational flying, ballooning, sailing, running, boxing, rowing, and a thousand other activities that are perfectly reasonable but unnecessary, and which could result in cost to the taxpayer.
That would be at the same time that we start dictating people's diets - we can't have them eating the wrong things, requiring health care, and costing the taxpayer, can we?.
Not quite a like for like comparison to put it mildly. Even on and absurd economic comparison it falls apart. The sports and recreations contribute massively to the economy when pitted against the amount they cost through death / injury. On the other hand how does not wearing a seatbelt benefit the economy?

The above have wide range of health and social benefits. I'm not sure not wearing a seatbelt has any outside of very exceptional circumstances (police expecting to run from car to chase someone etc).
Health and social benefits of recreational flying, windsurfing, motorbiking, sailing, horse riding, ballooning...??? They're self-indulgent hobbies no better or worse than most of the myriad other things than we humans get up to.

Look, I think it's daft to drive without a seatbelt. Apart from the safety benefit, the driver is much more stable in the seat, and can modulate and control his movements better. But it is OTT control-freakery to require an adult driving alone to wear a belt for his own good. Let him decide what is for his own good. It's his good, not yours, mine, or the Transport Minister's.
Should cigarettes be banned because they increase the risk to one's health? No.
Is the reason that cigarettes should not be banned that their production and sale benefits the the economy? Again, no.

Whether wearing a seatbelt when driving on one's own contirbutes to the economy is irrelevant. There are loads of things that are within an individual's right to do or not do that make no meaningful contribution to the economy. Whether something contributes to the economy is a red herring.

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
miggy man 3 said:
flemke said:
The Tuscan Rat said:
Not wearing a seat belt, only harms you in an accident, however this then costs the tax payer for your Ambulance, hospital treatment, the police time and resources to deal with the accident / aftermath etc etc...
What you say is factual.
If we are to run society on that basis, however, we'll have to ban scout hikes, cycling, windsurfing, gym workouts, horse riding, motorbiking, recreational flying, ballooning, sailing, running, boxing, rowing, and a thousand other activities that are perfectly reasonable but unnecessary, and which could result in cost to the taxpayer.
That would be at the same time that we start dictating people's diets - we can't have them eating the wrong things, requiring health care, and costing the taxpayer, can we?.
We're on about criminal offences rolleyes
Yes, we are.
The point was that, like windsurfing and ballooning, not wearing a seat belt should not be a criminal offence.rolleyesrolleyes

miggy man 3

1,916 posts

227 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
flemke said:
miggy man 3 said:
flemke said:
The Tuscan Rat said:
Not wearing a seat belt, only harms you in an accident, however this then costs the tax payer for your Ambulance, hospital treatment, the police time and resources to deal with the accident / aftermath etc etc...
What you say is factual.
If we are to run society on that basis, however, we'll have to ban scout hikes, cycling, windsurfing, gym workouts, horse riding, motorbiking, recreational flying, ballooning, sailing, running, boxing, rowing, and a thousand other activities that are perfectly reasonable but unnecessary, and which could result in cost to the taxpayer.
That would be at the same time that we start dictating people's diets - we can't have them eating the wrong things, requiring health care, and costing the taxpayer, can we?.
We're on about criminal offences rolleyes
Yes, we are.
The point was that, like windsurfing and ballooning, not wearing a seat belt should not be a criminal offence.rolleyesrolleyes
Why?

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
miggy man 3 said:
flemke said:
miggy man 3 said:
flemke said:
The Tuscan Rat said:
Not wearing a seat belt, only harms you in an accident, however this then costs the tax payer for your Ambulance, hospital treatment, the police time and resources to deal with the accident / aftermath etc etc...
What you say is factual.
If we are to run society on that basis, however, we'll have to ban scout hikes, cycling, windsurfing, gym workouts, horse riding, motorbiking, recreational flying, ballooning, sailing, running, boxing, rowing, and a thousand other activities that are perfectly reasonable but unnecessary, and which could result in cost to the taxpayer.
That would be at the same time that we start dictating people's diets - we can't have them eating the wrong things, requiring health care, and costing the taxpayer, can we?.
We're on about criminal offences rolleyes
Yes, we are.
The point was that, like windsurfing and ballooning, not wearing a seat belt should not be a criminal offence.rolleyesrolleyes
Why?
We've had this debate here a number of times. It's always fun.
In one of those debates, vonhosen (if you've not met him yet, you most certainly will) justified the requirement for adult passengers all to wear seat belts on the basis that, in a crash, a human skull can become a deadly weapon bouncing around within the car's interior, and can inflict terrible damage on other passengers.
If one accepts that as being possible, even though it may not be terribly common, that still leaves us with the very common case of the lone driver, whose bouncing skull can harm nothing except his own body, which, if his skull is bouncing around, is probably not worth worrying about anyway and, if it were, is his problem for letting his skull bounce around.

That is to say, in choosing not to wear a seatbelt at least in the case of when on one's own, one is simply tipping the balance towards a form of suicide. However stupid it may be, there is no good reason why a person should not be allowed to do this. It is not the government's business, full stop.

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
Its not a yes or no answer. conflicting possibilities..
no for minor speeding yes for silly speeding
yes for drugs for own use

FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
flemke said:
FishFace said:
flemke said:
The Tuscan Rat said:
Not wearing a seat belt, only harms you in an accident, however this then costs the tax payer for your Ambulance, hospital treatment, the police time and resources to deal with the accident / aftermath etc etc...
What you say is factual.
If we are to run society on that basis, however, we'll have to ban scout hikes, cycling, windsurfing, gym workouts, horse riding, motorbiking, recreational flying, ballooning, sailing, running, boxing, rowing, and a thousand other activities that are perfectly reasonable but unnecessary, and which could result in cost to the taxpayer.
That would be at the same time that we start dictating people's diets - we can't have them eating the wrong things, requiring health care, and costing the taxpayer, can we?.
Not quite a like for like comparison to put it mildly. Even on and absurd economic comparison it falls apart. The sports and recreations contribute massively to the economy when pitted against the amount they cost through death / injury. On the other hand how does not wearing a seatbelt benefit the economy?

The above have wide range of health and social benefits. I'm not sure not wearing a seatbelt has any outside of very exceptional circumstances (police expecting to run from car to chase someone etc).
Health and social benefits of recreational flying, windsurfing, motorbiking, sailing, horse riding, ballooning...??? They're self-indulgent hobbies no better or worse than most of the myriad other things than we humans get up to.

Look, I think it's daft to drive without a seatbelt. Apart from the safety benefit, the driver is much more stable in the seat, and can modulate and control his movements better. But it is OTT control-freakery to require an adult driving alone to wear a belt for his own good. Let him decide what is for his own good. It's his good, not yours, mine, or the Transport Minister's.
Should cigarettes be banned because they increase the risk to one's health? No.
Is the reason that cigarettes should not be banned that their production and sale benefits the the economy? Again, no.

Whether wearing a seatbelt when driving on one's own contirbutes to the economy is irrelevant. There are loads of things that are within an individual's right to do or not do that make no meaningful contribution to the economy. Whether something contributes to the economy is a red herring.
It's simply selfish to drive without a seatbelt as it significantly increases the chance of death / serious injury a collision. This wipes out a huge amount of emergency services and other agencies (HATO etc) and can cost 10s of millions depending where is happens (think M25).

No health benefits to windsurfing? The old heart rate must stay down when conducting such a physical activity biggrin Horse riding not social? http://www.bhs.org.uk/Content/Default.asp

It's like saying let someone stand on top of their car when someone else is driving. Or stand in the back of a trailer being towed. How about motor bikers wearing helmets?