Discussion
This is a matter that was alluded to in another thread, but I think it needs some discussion.
Suppose you are driving at a perfectly legal and reasonable 28MPH when a car in a side turning pulls out in front of you. The occupants of the offending vehicle insist you were driving at 90 and you are charged with dangerous driving. It seems to me there are 2 possibilities.
If someone in the vehicle is badly hurt there is an investigation. Pictures are taken, skid marks are measured, damage is examined, and it becomes clear that you were doing a reasonable speed and it's the other guys fault for pulling out. Case probably dropped, or at worst you are acquitted.
If on the other hand nobody is hurt. There is no investigation so you can produce no evidence of your speed other than your word. So a severe risk of conviction. Do I understand this correctly?
Suppose you are driving at a perfectly legal and reasonable 28MPH when a car in a side turning pulls out in front of you. The occupants of the offending vehicle insist you were driving at 90 and you are charged with dangerous driving. It seems to me there are 2 possibilities.
If someone in the vehicle is badly hurt there is an investigation. Pictures are taken, skid marks are measured, damage is examined, and it becomes clear that you were doing a reasonable speed and it's the other guys fault for pulling out. Case probably dropped, or at worst you are acquitted.
If on the other hand nobody is hurt. There is no investigation so you can produce no evidence of your speed other than your word. So a severe risk of conviction. Do I understand this correctly?
Dr Jekyll said:
This is a matter that was alluded to in another thread, but I think it needs some discussion.
Suppose you are driving at a perfectly legal and reasonable 28MPH when a car in a side turning pulls out in front of you. The occupants of the offending vehicle insist you were driving at 90 and you are charged with dangerous driving. It seems to me there are 2 possibilities.
If someone in the vehicle is badly hurt there is an investigation. Pictures are taken, skid marks are measured, damage is examined, and it becomes clear that you were doing a reasonable speed and it's the other guys fault for pulling out. Case probably dropped, or at worst you are acquitted.
If on the other hand nobody is hurt. There is no investigation so you can produce no evidence of your speed other than your word. So a severe risk of conviction. Do I understand this correctly?
If nobody is hurt it is unlikely the police would attend.Suppose you are driving at a perfectly legal and reasonable 28MPH when a car in a side turning pulls out in front of you. The occupants of the offending vehicle insist you were driving at 90 and you are charged with dangerous driving. It seems to me there are 2 possibilities.
If someone in the vehicle is badly hurt there is an investigation. Pictures are taken, skid marks are measured, damage is examined, and it becomes clear that you were doing a reasonable speed and it's the other guys fault for pulling out. Case probably dropped, or at worst you are acquitted.
If on the other hand nobody is hurt. There is no investigation so you can produce no evidence of your speed other than your word. So a severe risk of conviction. Do I understand this correctly?
If they did then a glance at the damage would tell them you were not doing 90 MPH.
If there is no investigation you would not be reported.
The point is that a friend of mine has been charged with dangerous driving after an accident that damaged his car and some roadside furniture. His fault certainly, and he wouldn't argue with a 'without due care' charge. But he is accused of spinning into a barrier at well over 70 (despite stepping out of the wreck without a scratch), undertakng (which he denies and he is pretty anal about lane discipline, and moving across 2 lanes of traffic to overtake a middle lane crawler (which I thought was legal).
No investigation, just witness statements that both say he was driving dangerously but contradict each other about what he actually did.
It's pretty obvious they saw the crash, jumped to conclusions about how he was driving and claimed they witnessed various bits of strange driving in order to make a case.
He has an impeccable driving record up to this point so the CPS probably see him as a prime target.
No investigation, just witness statements that both say he was driving dangerously but contradict each other about what he actually did.
It's pretty obvious they saw the crash, jumped to conclusions about how he was driving and claimed they witnessed various bits of strange driving in order to make a case.
He has an impeccable driving record up to this point so the CPS probably see him as a prime target.
Dr Jekyll said:
The point is that a friend of mine has been charged with dangerous driving after an accident that damaged his car and some roadside furniture. His fault certainly, and he wouldn't argue with a 'without due care' charge. But he is accused of spinning into a barrier at well over 70 (despite stepping out of the wreck without a scratch), undertakng (which he denies and he is pretty anal about lane discipline, and moving across 2 lanes of traffic to overtake a middle lane crawler (which I thought was legal).
No investigation, just witness statements that both say he was driving dangerously but contradict each other about what he actually did.
It's pretty obvious they saw the crash, jumped to conclusions about how he was driving and claimed they witnessed various bits of strange driving in order to make a case.
He has an impeccable driving record up to this point so the CPS probably see him as a prime target.
The CPS obviously think that the witness testimony is sufficient to secure a conviction. I'd be surprised if they are charging him with an offence that can be elected to be heard at the Crown Court, if they honestly believe it's only really a DWDCA.No investigation, just witness statements that both say he was driving dangerously but contradict each other about what he actually did.
It's pretty obvious they saw the crash, jumped to conclusions about how he was driving and claimed they witnessed various bits of strange driving in order to make a case.
He has an impeccable driving record up to this point so the CPS probably see him as a prime target.
If he honestly believes that their testimony is conflicting pap, he should have no trouble or concerns defending the allegation.
Dr Jekyll said:
This is a matter that was alluded to in another thread, but I think it needs some discussion.
Suppose you are driving at a perfectly legal and reasonable 28MPH when a car in a side turning pulls out in front of you. The occupants of the offending vehicle insist you were driving at 90 and you are charged with dangerous driving. It seems to me there are 2 possibilities.
If someone in the vehicle is badly hurt there is an investigation. Pictures are taken, skid marks are measured, damage is examined, and it becomes clear that you were doing a reasonable speed and it's the other guys fault for pulling out. Case probably dropped, or at worst you are acquitted.
If on the other hand nobody is hurt. There is no investigation so you can produce no evidence of your speed other than your word. So a severe risk of conviction. Do I understand this correctly?
Their evidence would fall apart under cross examination.Suppose you are driving at a perfectly legal and reasonable 28MPH when a car in a side turning pulls out in front of you. The occupants of the offending vehicle insist you were driving at 90 and you are charged with dangerous driving. It seems to me there are 2 possibilities.
If someone in the vehicle is badly hurt there is an investigation. Pictures are taken, skid marks are measured, damage is examined, and it becomes clear that you were doing a reasonable speed and it's the other guys fault for pulling out. Case probably dropped, or at worst you are acquitted.
If on the other hand nobody is hurt. There is no investigation so you can produce no evidence of your speed other than your word. So a severe risk of conviction. Do I understand this correctly?
Either they viewed your car for long enough to make an estimation, or they didn't. Either they have the ability and knowledge to estimate accurately the speed of an incoming car, or they don't.
The independent evidence would show that you did not hit their car at anything like 90mph or there would be nothing left of it, or them.
That would then leave two factors which it would be difficult to trust their testimonies further. If they are arguing that they saw you driving long enough to make an assumption of your speed, why on earth did they then decide to pull out in front of you!?
Remembering a little bit about the other thread, I would say your friend must have a reasonable amount of evidence against him. It would certainly be a good time to get a solicitor on the case and get applying for it (though he shouldn't really expect it until right before the plea hearing, sadly).
As I probably said on the other thread, if your friend had not had an accident, the witnesses supporting dangerous driving would probably have thought he was driving badly and left it at that. The fact that a crash occurred gave them the opportunity to tell the Police what they thought. It's amazing how with hindsight, witnesses can suddenly describe 'an accident waiting to happen'.
As I probably said on the other thread, if your friend had not had an accident, the witnesses supporting dangerous driving would probably have thought he was driving badly and left it at that. The fact that a crash occurred gave them the opportunity to tell the Police what they thought. It's amazing how with hindsight, witnesses can suddenly describe 'an accident waiting to happen'.
I did suggest he tries to get it knocked down to careless in return for a guilty plea. But he reckons this would mean admitting undertaking, which he didn't do. His attitude right now is 'bring it on!'
Interestingly, it's the police who suggested his speed was well over 70, the witnesses agree that it wasn't.
Interestingly, it's the police who suggested his speed was well over 70, the witnesses agree that it wasn't.
He has seen the witness statements.
Apparently 2 of them were in the inside lane behind a lorry, they saw him pull across from the first the the third lane to overtake a mondeo which was in the middle lane, then pull back to the inside. According to one of these witnesses he undertook one vehicle when in the inside lane then pulled to the outside to overtake another car and span out of control before overtaking it. These movements taking place over about 1 mile. The other witness in the same car said Mick overtook and undertook so many times he lost count. The road was straight at this point so how much they could have seen from their position behind the lorry and the Mondeo is questionable.
Another witness in the outside lane said Mick overtook him on the inside before moving right to overtake the Mondeo, agrees he pulled back to the left then only moved right once more, but says he span after passing the second car, he also claims Mick undertook a vehicle in between.
MIcks story is that he pulled from lane 1 to 3 to overtake the Mondeo in lane 2, then returned to lane 1 because of faster traffic coming up behind, then repeated the overtake on a second vehicle, the accident happening shortly after passing the second one. He is adamant he didn't undertake. He could have passed both vehicles on the inside if he had wanted to, the inside lane being clear.
Apparently 2 of them were in the inside lane behind a lorry, they saw him pull across from the first the the third lane to overtake a mondeo which was in the middle lane, then pull back to the inside. According to one of these witnesses he undertook one vehicle when in the inside lane then pulled to the outside to overtake another car and span out of control before overtaking it. These movements taking place over about 1 mile. The other witness in the same car said Mick overtook and undertook so many times he lost count. The road was straight at this point so how much they could have seen from their position behind the lorry and the Mondeo is questionable.
Another witness in the outside lane said Mick overtook him on the inside before moving right to overtake the Mondeo, agrees he pulled back to the left then only moved right once more, but says he span after passing the second car, he also claims Mick undertook a vehicle in between.
MIcks story is that he pulled from lane 1 to 3 to overtake the Mondeo in lane 2, then returned to lane 1 because of faster traffic coming up behind, then repeated the overtake on a second vehicle, the accident happening shortly after passing the second one. He is adamant he didn't undertake. He could have passed both vehicles on the inside if he had wanted to, the inside lane being clear.
The problem you might have is the fact that the witnesses are describing a pattern of behaviour. Small individual discrepancies between the evidence might show up in court, but the prosecution will be looking at the picture as a whole.
If 3 or 4 different witnesses allege the same manner of driving immediately prior to him losing control and crashing, it's painting a picture of someone driving in a way that each witness will agree; in their opinion his driving was dangerous.
I spent hours pouring over witness statements in my case, pulling loads and loads of inconsistencies about details they'd put in their statements, even some pivotal parts which made the case much more serious. In the end it took my Barrister a couple of minutes to explain that those individual inconsistancies might be shown up in court, but at the end of the day, the jury would be hard pressed to disbelieve in entirety statements of the witnesses, which were all generally of the same nature.
We aren't in possesion of all the facts here, but with what you've said so far, I'd be looking to bargain it to Careless at the plea hearing and see what the CPS say. It's a good indication of how strong they see their case if they are willing to ignore a 100% chance of conviction to go for dangerous instead.
If they don't go for that and insist on dangerous, I'd opt straight for Crown Court (he'll be given a choice) as the chance of acquittal would be much better, according to the legal advice I was given last year.
If 3 or 4 different witnesses allege the same manner of driving immediately prior to him losing control and crashing, it's painting a picture of someone driving in a way that each witness will agree; in their opinion his driving was dangerous.
I spent hours pouring over witness statements in my case, pulling loads and loads of inconsistencies about details they'd put in their statements, even some pivotal parts which made the case much more serious. In the end it took my Barrister a couple of minutes to explain that those individual inconsistancies might be shown up in court, but at the end of the day, the jury would be hard pressed to disbelieve in entirety statements of the witnesses, which were all generally of the same nature.
We aren't in possesion of all the facts here, but with what you've said so far, I'd be looking to bargain it to Careless at the plea hearing and see what the CPS say. It's a good indication of how strong they see their case if they are willing to ignore a 100% chance of conviction to go for dangerous instead.
If they don't go for that and insist on dangerous, I'd opt straight for Crown Court (he'll be given a choice) as the chance of acquittal would be much better, according to the legal advice I was given last year.
Edited by 10 Pence Short on Tuesday 11th March 13:53
10 Pence Short said:
The problem you might have is the fact that the witnesses are describing a pattern of behaviour. Small individual discrepancies between the evidence might show up in court, but the prosecution will be looking at the picture as a whole.
If 3 or 4 different witnesses alledge the same manner of driving immediately prior to him losing control and crashing, it's painting a picture of someone driving in a way that each witness will agree; in their opinion his driving was dangerous.
I spent hours pouring over witness statements in my case, pulling loads and loads of inconsistencies about details they'd put in their statements, even some pivotal parts which made the case much more serious. In the end it took my Barrister a couple of minutes to explain that those individual inconsistancies might be shown up in court, but at the end of the day, the jury would be hard pressed to disbelieve in entirety statements of the witnesses, which were all generally of the same nature.
We aren't in possesion of all the facts here, but with what you've said so far, I'd be looking to bargain it to Careless at the plea hearing and see what the CPS say. It's a good indication of how strong they see their case if they are willing to ignore a 100% chance of conviction to go for dangerous instead.
If they don't go for that and insist on dangerous, I'd opt straight for Crown Court (he'll be given a choice) as the chance of acquittal would be much better, according to the legal advice I was given last year.
I agree with all that. If 3 or 4 different witnesses alledge the same manner of driving immediately prior to him losing control and crashing, it's painting a picture of someone driving in a way that each witness will agree; in their opinion his driving was dangerous.
I spent hours pouring over witness statements in my case, pulling loads and loads of inconsistencies about details they'd put in their statements, even some pivotal parts which made the case much more serious. In the end it took my Barrister a couple of minutes to explain that those individual inconsistancies might be shown up in court, but at the end of the day, the jury would be hard pressed to disbelieve in entirety statements of the witnesses, which were all generally of the same nature.
We aren't in possesion of all the facts here, but with what you've said so far, I'd be looking to bargain it to Careless at the plea hearing and see what the CPS say. It's a good indication of how strong they see their case if they are willing to ignore a 100% chance of conviction to go for dangerous instead.
If they don't go for that and insist on dangerous, I'd opt straight for Crown Court (he'll be given a choice) as the chance of acquittal would be much better, according to the legal advice I was given last year.
Its going to be tough to say that all the people viewing the incident in all of the cars are wrong. Fundamentally they are going to try to prove the undertaking and link that to DD.
Dr Jekyll said:
But isn't undertaking normally regarded as careless rather than dangerous?
What you'll get is a case that says your friend was weaving in and out of traffic at high speed, and that he was driving so close to the edge of the cars and his performance whilst doing so that he lost control and crashed. It will be described as sheer luck that no other cars were involved and that there were no serious injuries.The Police officers from the scene will be wheeled out, their years of service described and they will say that they've seen thousands of post-collision cars in the line of duty. In their opinion the damage sustained will have indicated a very high speed impact etc etc.
I would imagine one of the sticking points for your friend's defence will be explaining why he lost control of the car in the first place. What has he told the Police?
But that is what is so ludicrous, he hit the central reservation either after or when just about to OVERtake a vehicle in the middle lane, depending on which witness you believe. Surely not even the CPS can argue that he was undertaking in the outside lane.
Moving to the outside lane twice in order to overtake, over the course of a mile, is hardly unreasonable.
Moving to the outside lane twice in order to overtake, over the course of a mile, is hardly unreasonable.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



